News

Cruella First Reviews: Emmas Stone and Thompson and Their Immaculate Costumes Light Up the Screen

Early reviews for the Disney villain's origin story say the punk-rock reimagining is creative, fun, and visually striking, even if it's a tad long.

by | May 26, 2021 | Comments

Who needs one hundred and one Dalmatians when you can have one-on-one Emmas? Disney’s latest live-action reimagining, Cruella, takes us back to the origin of its titular villain, now portrayed by Emma Stone as a newcomer in the fashion world clashing with an evil nemesis, played by Emma Thompson. The first reviews of the feature, which heads to theaters and Disney+ (for an extra charge) this weekend, mostly highlight the shared scene-chewing of the two Oscar-winning actresses as well as the costumes they parade on screen. Whether this One Hundred and One Dalmatians prequel is a great movie overall, however, is up for debate.

Here’s what critics are saying about Cruella:


Is Cruella a surprise success?

It just exceeded all of my expectations.
– Sharronda Williams, Pay or Wait

Cruella upends expectations to demonstrate that origin stories can be roundly entertaining.
– Peter Martin, ScreenAnarchy

Whatever movie you’re expecting from Cruella, you’d be wrong.
– Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

The biggest surprise of 2021… Craig Gillespie’s Cruella turns any preconceived notions on their head.
– Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com


Does it feel like other Disney fare?

The biggest compliment anyone could give Cruella is that it doesn’t have any feel or semblance of a Disney movie.
Nate Adams, The Only Critic

A bold departure for Disney that’s unlike anything we’ve ever seen from them before.
Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com

You have to remind yourself that you’re that you’re watching a Disney film.
Sharronda Williams, Pay or Wait

Parents of younger kids may be shocked that such a film carries the Disney imprint.
Peter Debruge, Variety

You get the feeling it’s geared as much towards Disney’s not insignificant adult fanbase as it is to a younger crowd.
Patrick Cremona, Radio Times

Whether its dark-but-Disney strangeness intrigues or repels, there’s often something to love and loathe in equal measure.
Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine

Slightly darker than your standard Disney fare…the film feels less like a satisfying character drama than a work of corporate rebranding.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush


Emma Stone in Cruella

(Photo by ©2021 Disney Enterprises Inc.)

How does it compare to the other live-action reimaginings?

What Cruella is not — to the immense relief of many, I’m sure — is another Maleficent… Cruella proves ingeniously creative in its reimagining of the underlying IP.
Peter Debruge, Variety

A movie that rivals the likes of Aladdin and The Jungle Book.
Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com

The studio just cannot crack the code in recapturing the magic that made the animated originals so endearing. Add Cruella, the newest revamp of their rogues gallery to the list of failures.
Kyle Pinion, ScreenRex


Will fans of the original film enjoy this?

There are several simple nods to the original story and 101 Dalmatians that will make most fans smile to themselves when they catch them.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Rather than shoehorning in a bunch of forced moments – “Oh, so that’s why she hates Dalmatians”… this take very much makes her a complex character in her own right.
Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com

Disney purists may be put off by the rewriting of canon.
Sean P. Means, The Movie Cricket

Any attempt to square the events of this film with the animated canon quickly falls apart… You’re better off just assuming that Cruella occurs in an alternate timeline.
Brent Hankins, The Lamplight Review

There’s no suggestion she’d ever consider such cruelty… As an actual prequel, it’s a tick-infested mutt of a movie.
Rob Hunter, Film School Rejects

The manner in which the script tries to bend itself away from and around Cruella’s specific Dalmatian-centric animal cruelty future requires some Cirque du Soleil-esque flexibility.
Douglas Davidson, Elements of Madness


Emma Stone in Cruella

(Photo by ©2021 Disney Enterprises Inc.)

How is the writing?

Incredibly good and sincerely humorous.
Peter Martin, ScreenAnarchy

Dana Fox and Tony McNamara’s Cruella screenplay plays with your expectations in clever, non-murderous ways.
Brian Truitt, USA Today

Writers Dana Fox and Tony McNamara boldly crafted a narrative that has the energy of shows like Revenge and Ugly Betty… I applaud it for actually taking risks in its story, adding dimension to this once simple, yet iconic, villain.
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

One of the joys of Cruella is how the screenplay escalates the public fashion battle between the established Baroness and the punk-minded Cruella.
Sean P. Means, The Movie Cricket

It’s a screenplay that’s tying itself in knots to create a brand new character that’s more Harley Quinn than Cruella De Vil.
Kyle Pinion, ScreenRex

Needlessly complicated and stuffed with too many supporting characters.
Brent Hankins, The Lamplight Review


How is Emma Stone?

Emma Stone delivers an unmissable performance that is every bit as Oscar-worthy as her work in La La Land.
Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com

Emma Stone absolutely crushes this role, so much so that it can be said she blows Glenn Close’s portrayal out of the water.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Stone is theatrical and clownish in the best way, wearing the over-the-top expressions that’ve sprinkled charm into her other roles like costume jewelry.
Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine


Emma Thompson in Cruella

(Photo by ©2021 Disney Enterprises)

What about Emma Thompson?

The definition of glorious, Thompson delivers a delightfully droll Baroness Von Hellman.
Hope Madden, MaddWolf

Thompson will most likely require some amount of reconstructive surgery on her jaw from the amount of scenery she chews throughout this movie.
Brian Lloyd, entertainment.ie

Thompson’s Baroness is the best thing — and only good thing — in the movie.
Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle


And when they’re on screen together?

Together, they are the highly strung dysfunctional double-act that post-lockdown cinema didn’t know it needed.
Peter Bradshaw, Guardian

Echoing the same energies as Anne Hathaway and Meryl Streep in The Devil Wears Prada, Stone and Thompson are a wealth of Oscar calibrated perfection.
Nate Adams, The Only Critic

Scenes between the Emmas elevate the entire project, allowing Thompson to radiate devastating narcissism and Stone to mine her character’s emotional and intellectual landscape.
Hope Madden, MaddWolf

There is no doubt that these are two of the greatest actresses of all time, and to see them working so incredibly together, is a treat.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Every time the two Emmas have a scene together, in which they must be drippingly arch and very British, Older Emma wipes Younger Emma right off the screen.
Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle

The two are a delight both apart and together.
Rob Hunter, Film School Rejects


Paul Walter Hauser, Emma Stone, and Joel Fry in Cruella

(Photo by ©2021 Disney Enterprises Inc.)

How is the rest of the cast?

Hauser and Fry are terrific as Estella/Cruella’s crew. They’re animated without being “cartoony,” giving their supporting characters multi-faceted internality and introspection.
Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

While the entire ensemble is delightful, Joel Fry is notable as the sensitive and loyal Jasper.
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

If there’s a weak link then it’s John McCrea, who delivers a somewhat wooden performance as vintage fashion shop owner Artie.
Patrick Cremona, Radio Times

Unfortunately, Mark Strong is wasted in a mostly forgettable role that could have been filled by any British actor.
Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com


We’ve been hearing about those costumes…

They are ingenious and artful in their presentation. They are complex and tell stories all on their own. They are provocative and challenging, yet enticing.
Douglas Davidson, Elements of Madness

The way the move, the way they standout in a crowd, and the way that either Emma wears them, is just a joy to look at.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

You don’t need to be a fashion connoisseur to appreciate the jaw-dropping design choices made throughout the movie.
Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com

The biggest mic drops of the film come from its jaw-dropping dresses: One moment featuring a garbage truck is a particularly extravagant bit of sartorial effectwork.
Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine

The costumes are spectacular — it’s just that they’re the only exciting thing onscreen for the middle hour of the film.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush


Cruella

(Photo by ©2021 Disney Enterprises Inc.)

Will the costumes get some awards love?

There’s not a world in which Jenny Beavan’s incredible costuming work doesn’t get award attention.
Nate Adams, The Only Critic

There’s no doubt that Jenny Beavan will score this film’s lone Oscar nomination and likely win.
Kyle Pinion, ScreenRex

Costume designer Jenny Beavan is more than likely on her way to at least another nomination for her work here.
Douglas Davidson, Elements of Madness

Jenny Beavan (Costume Designer), Nadia Stacey (Hair & Makeup), and their respective teams are hopefully already having their names etched into next year’s Academy Awards.
Josh Wilding, ComicBookMovie.com


How are the movie’s punk rock trappings?

The jukebox Cruella soundtrack, which includes hits from a number of ‘60s and ‘70s bands, is broadly excellent.
Patrick Cremona, Radio Times

It’s non-conformist with a bad attitude, badass music, and punk rock fits that would make Vivienne Westwood applaud.
Sherin Nicole, idobi.com

It makes the entire punk scene come to life with her signature black and white flair that matches her rebellious spirit and anarchist energy.
Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

Cruella often veers into that Disneyfied corporate mall-punk of The Nightmare Before Christmas Hot Topic apparel.
Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine

It’s hard to not roll your eyes at its attempt to sell you on the idea that this is a “punk/rebel” take on the character. Yeah, because there’s nothing more punk than market tested four quadrant cinema.
Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine


Cruella

(Photo by ©2021 Disney Enterprises Inc.)

Are there any issues?

My God does this movie need trimming. You will have aged noticeably by the time it’s over.
Hope Madden, MaddWolf

It is simply too long. Clocking in at nearly two hours and fifteen minutes is a bit ridiculous and feels unnecessary.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Cruella is rather weighed down by an overly baggy runtime and a few pacing issues, which means it sometimes threatens to turn from a fun romp into a bit of a slog.
Patrick Cremona, Radio Times

Were it 80 minutes, its sins could largely be seen as forgivable, but somehow it manages to be nearly an hour longer than that and it feels every moment of that running time.
Kyle Pinion, ScreenRex


Will we want more?

I wouldn’t be opposed to seeing what happens next.
Douglas Davidson, Elements of Madness

[It leaves] itself open for a sequel that, frankly, it doesn’t need or deserve.
Brian Lloyd, entertainment.ie


Cruella releases in theaters and streams on Disney+ with Premium Access on May 28, 2021.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

gangster Amazon Prime Video Columbia Pictures E! Apple Television Critics Association Interview Extras versus game of thrones Dark Horse Comics Netflix natural history 90s Turner WGN Comics on TV Tokyo Olympics true crime See It Skip It Shondaland spider-man zero dark thirty LGBT facebook TCA Awards USA screenings revenge Tags: Comedy medical drama toy story RT21 NYCC VOD Warner Bros. werewolf Arrowverse cults Disney based on movie Fall TV RT History screen actors guild superhero MGM teaser justice league all-time 2016 Best Director cooking Black Mirror leaderboard IFC news concert south america 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards foreign miniseries Character Guide Academy Awards South by Southwest Film Festival Marathons Starz films Amazon Prime spinoff Image Comics animated science fiction Sci-Fi TCA children's TV ITV Black History Month documentaries OWN ABC Family fresh legend razzies Fox News FOX Opinion Legendary VH1 CW Seed Valentine's Day ABC Signature sitcom critics cats Hulu Polls and Games television Best Actor new zealand franchise crossover reviews deadpool canceled TV shows Adult Swim Instagram Live mutant HBO Go Walt Disney Pictures Summer TCM CBS dramedy indiana jones Neflix PlayStation DC streaming service Film Festival MCU Focus Features Spike TV One Women's History Month stand-up comedy aapi strong female leads crime thriller Disney streaming service directors adenture Captain marvel free movies Nat Geo Emmys Comic Book wonder woman classics festivals renewed TV shows Broadway spy thriller FX on Hulu YouTube Premium Pacific Islander Musical Country psycho genre HBO Max series psychological thriller Tarantino NBA Trophy Talk 007 asian-american anthology comic book movies Acorn TV boxing dark Box Office art house summer TV preview Vudu supernatural feel good mission: impossible video on demand sequel Winners twilight 45 Family The Witch blockbuster king kong binge TV renewals Pirates OneApp vampires Cosplay First Look Lifetime Television Academy A24 zombie Brie Larson hidden camera Tumblr BET Awards Sundance Crunchyroll 4/20 Rocketman venice ratings obi wan 99% Freeform hispanic archives crime Fargo The Walking Dead DirecTV nbcuniversal TBS Paramount adaptation NBC Watching Series basketball best Exclusive Video Trailer parents Nickelodeon Lionsgate sports docudrama festival 21st Century Fox target theme song 71st Emmy Awards Sundance Now adventure Drama biopic Infographic joker game show Set visit Teen vs. Action ID broadcast comedies PaleyFest halloween tv SXSW 2022 sag awards spanish language romantic comedy Disney+ Disney Plus Universal Pictures Alien biography 20th Century Fox spider-verse 94th Oscars kids rt labs critics edition BBC One MTV streaming italian aliens Year in Review Discovery Channel comic Writers Guild of America police drama Photos royal family Music TNT Reality spain anime Tubi AMC Plus streaming movies child's play Ellie Kemper Holidays National Geographic Rom-Com disaster debate witnail name the review Universal Shudder Musicals chucky 2017 Mary Tyler Moore comic book movie football Stephen King Funimation toronto video Comic-Con@Home 2021 TIFF Elton John golden globe awards travel Avengers HFPA slashers Disney Plus Best Actress Logo cinemax movies GIFs Horror popular CNN YouTube Quiz singing competition Peacock dogs Oscar obituary cancelled nfl kong japan technology Turner Classic Movies Pet Sematary Mudbound crime drama dragons superman scorecard Marvel Studios hollywood Oscars young adult Western high school Mindy Kaling space hispanic heritage month comics slasher marvel comics The Arrangement comiccon Sneak Peek richard e. Grant batman Showtime 2019 mcc blaxploitation zombies SundanceTV rt labs heist movie CMT Anna Paquin Prime Video indie jamie lee curtis Creative Arts Emmys new york french pirates of the caribbean Food Network AMC hist what to watch stop motion Pop award winner Nominations jurassic park kaiju Netflix Christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con Podcast Schedule international mob TLC ghosts Britbox YouTube Red PBS diversity dexter Christmas Apple TV+ The Walt Disney Company Calendar rom-coms composers Emmy Nominations IFC Films blockbusters discovery prank telelvision live action VICE APB transformers Trivia cars Hollywood Foreign Press Association christmas movies Marvel 79th Golden Globes Awards Chernobyl IMDb TV Crackle doctor who Awards Tour Classic Film Comedy Spectrum Originals Paramount Network ABC fast and furious Endgame tv talk American Society of Cinematographers critic resources Amazon quibi Hallmark Awards The Purge Video Games Best and Worst trailers Superheroe Binge Guide period drama WarnerMedia spanish independent Spring TV Comedy Central Marvel Television harry potter talk show Lucasfilm X-Men Fantasy Apple TV Plus summer TV book adaptation rotten movies we love Hallmark Christmas movies LGBTQ die hard BBC America criterion Ovation scary movies 2018 Hear Us Out Best Picture GLAAD YA nature golden globes documentary Paramount Pictures unscripted Paramount Plus CBS All Access laika casting Biopics 2020 BBC serial killer cartoon El Rey stoner reboot thriller scene in color women suspense USA Network President know your critic DGA halloween ViacomCBS SXSW BAFTA dreamworks a nightmare on elm street 24 frames cancelled TV series black comedy E3 Countdown Film social media New York Comic Con saw 1990s king arthur TruTV Syfy GoT 72 Emmy Awards universal monsters Sundance TV rotten Masterpiece streamig The Academy latino 73rd Emmy Awards ESPN TV Land MSNBC TV HBO Mary poppins Mary Poppins Returns sequels Holiday new star wars movies canceled Winter TV book 2015 black remakes war BET breaking bad dc Animation politics The CW Martial Arts Travel Channel dceu TCA Winter 2020 Red Carpet TV movies boxoffice Mystery cancelled TV shows green book Reality Competition emmy awards sopranos movie godzilla Wes Anderson Election Lifetime Christmas movies political drama Song of Ice and Fire Certified Fresh 2021 comic books FX Kids & Family historical drama lord of the rings live event A&E Superheroes Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Star Wars Cannes posters olympics cancelled television Rock marvel cinematic universe First Reviews Premiere Dates Esquire worst movies Tomatazos elevated horror DC Comics monster movies Super Bowl robots Baby Yoda Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Grammys Cartoon Network Star Trek Fox Searchlight Pop TV Pride Month rt archives action-comedy Bravo History Thanksgiving cops Sony Pictures Pixar SDCC satire Amazon Studios Epix Rocky james bond worst mockumentary docuseries trophy japanese summer preview TCA 2017 FXX DC Universe scary 93rd Oscars australia Toys Disney Channel Heroines Ghostbusters finale romance