Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Amazing Spider-Man Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Savages is uneven, pulpy fun, and Katy Perry: Part of Me is Certified Fresh.

by | July 5, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a legendary web-slinger (The Amazing Spider-Man, starring Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone), a deadly cartel (Savages, starring Taylor Kitsch and Salma Hayek), and a teenage dream (the 3D concert documentary Katy Perry: Part of Me). What do the critics have to say?



The Amazing Spider-Man

72%

The Spider-Man franchise might have set a record for the quickest reboot, though critics say The Amazing Spider-Man is still entertaining, gritty, action-packed stuff — even if we’ve seen it all before. It’s the story of how Peter Parker (Andrew Garfield) gets bitten by a radioactive spider, becomes a superhero, develops a relationship with Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone), and battles a supervillain named the Lizard. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Amazing Spider-Man covers some pretty well-trodden ground, but Garfield and Stone are excellent and the action sequences pack a wallop. (Check out 24 Frames for a pictorial rundown of Marvel characters on the big screen.)



Savages

50%

Oliver Stone may have mellowed in recent years, but critics say Savages is a return to the disreputable Stone films of old — one that’s messy, but often queasily compelling. A couple of friends (Taylor Kitsch and Aaron Johnson) run a profitable marijuana-dealing business, but a fearsome Mexican drug cartel led by the ruthless Elana (Salma Hayek) insists on a partnership – with severe consequences if they refuse. The pundits say Savages is tonally uneven and a bit overlong, but it’s also exuberantly pulpy and features fine supporting turns from Benicio Del Toro and John Travolta. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Stone’s best-reviewed movies.)



Katy Perry: Part of Me

76%

At first glance, Katy Perry: Part of Me looks like a tricked-out infomercial, but critics say it’s a rousing and brightly-colored concert documentary that gives some insight into the star’s offstage life. The film follows Perry on her “California Dreams” world tour, capturing her eye-popping stage show as well as archival footage of her younger days and glimpses of backstage drama. The pundits say that even if the Certified Fresh Katy Perry: Part of Me doesn’t delve too deeply, it’s still a revealing portrait of a likeable pop star dealing with the rigors of life on the road.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

2019 Trophy Talk Marathons diversity Tarantino TCA Awards latino San Diego Comic-Con 71st Emmy Awards Paramount nature halloween tv ESPN art house Acorn TV Musicals werewolf revenge The Arrangement Best and Worst toy story ID new zealand independent trailers streaming movies Thanksgiving Horror witnail TLC dc natural history 24 frames biopic know your critic Sci-Fi dogs DGA Pop TV canceled parents Pride Month sports Cannes comics romance AMC Comic Book TV spy thriller TCA 2017 game of thrones Drama Food Network OneApp Lionsgate cancelled TV shows Lifetime christmas movies mockumentary Cosplay movie Kids & Family Disney adenture cats razzies slasher Amazon Prime Country Shondaland Awards Tour Spring TV ghosts cults cinemax A&E Binge Guide Amazon Prime Video twilight Hollywood Foreign Press Association Esquire Winners crime GIFs Freeform 72 Emmy Awards slashers politics Vudu WGN TV One BET free movies CBS All Access dark die hard emmy awards LGBT Mudbound sag awards 2016 First Reviews X-Men fresh telelvision richard e. Grant Tubi Sundance TV Superheroes Mystery Captain marvel 90s Peacock video Pop GoT posters AMC Plus Disney streaming service 1990s Mary Poppins Returns Netflix Christmas movies Sundance Logo Rock Musical Certified Fresh screenings strong female leads Brie Larson casting dexter APB First Look Comic-Con@Home 2021 war President Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comedy elevated horror french italian VOD live action suspense Alien Marvel Television Watching Series Tokyo Olympics scary movies miniseries Tags: Comedy Writers Guild of America popular zombies discovery rt labs hist Instagram Live marvel comics Lucasfilm finale black leaderboard Legendary The Academy science fiction Polls and Games talk show American Society of Cinematographers Shudder YA Pirates new star wars movies blaxploitation Schedule Super Bowl gangster spanish deadpool high school period drama MTV stand-up comedy TBS Film E3 HBO black comedy wonder woman anthology festival Pacific Islander directors NBA obituary ABC Signature reboot DC Comics cars feel good Nat Geo Baby Yoda scene in color Nominations PlayStation sitcom cooking Holidays Universal travel Comics on TV saw cops golden globes remakes Calendar Film Festival BBC royal family Infographic ABC Music Animation Fox Searchlight japan FX sequel The Walt Disney Company Song of Ice and Fire crime thriller Hear Us Out series Television Critics Association Christmas jamie lee curtis dreamworks Broadway fast and furious Star Trek 73rd Emmy Awards Spectrum Originals facebook TNT The CW docuseries Oscars satire Interview children's TV Amazon doctor who 99% comic Sundance Now indie mission: impossible critic resources critics Chernobyl Ghostbusters 2021 PBS worst 2020 singing competition spain 2018 Women's History Month social media Apple TV+ thriller Starz international universal monsters police drama Lifetime Christmas movies transformers MSNBC comic books TCA Winter 2020 Summer cartoon genre psychological thriller Columbia Pictures kaiju trophy Opinion A24 Neflix TCM CNN stop motion Hallmark Christmas movies Toys young adult BBC One screen actors guild Adult Swim Dark Horse Comics Black Mirror rotten medical drama dramedy comic book movie serial killer king arthur classics godzilla Warner Bros. golden globe awards comic book movies romantic comedy Ovation football book archives Endgame joker Rocketman TIFF Video Games Marvel Studios films Black History Month Syfy sequels award winner History Comedy Central TV movies Showtime Masterpiece legend comedies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pet Sematary Family streaming Apple documentaries debate El Rey CBS DirecTV Paramount Plus Hulu technology venice MCU ratings action-comedy Character Guide a nightmare on elm street Year in Review what to watch LGBTQ Prime Video ABC Family GLAAD SundanceTV crossover boxing Disney+ Disney Plus adventure 20th Century Fox vampires name the review Podcast Anna Paquin spider-man Universal Pictures japanese Martial Arts VICE scary Trailer Sony Pictures Countdown PaleyFest documentary See It Skip It National Geographic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TCA 21st Century Fox Turner Classic Movies rom-coms live event CW Seed Quiz 2015 reviews Pixar WarnerMedia festivals target TruTV IMDb TV dragons green book 4/20 robots stoner Set visit Emmy Nominations cancelled Turner Awards Epix TV Land Rocky Fox News CMT 45 women BET Awards Crunchyroll FX on Hulu foreign indiana jones SDCC aapi USA aliens toronto RT21 Sneak Peek Marvel jurassic park lord of the rings Spike New York Comic Con based on movie tv talk BBC America blockbusters hidden camera Western 007 biography best Superheroe VH1 Bravo E! rt labs critics edition harry potter justice league Tumblr Winter TV Grammys news hispanic heritage month Television Academy DC streaming service scorecard nbcuniversal Reality zombie Netflix south america all-time canceled TV shows Red Carpet supernatural Mary poppins Travel Channel 2017 nfl Disney Channel Box Office OWN psycho spider-verse criterion anime HFPA superhero versus zero dark thirty boxoffice mutant composers olympics rt archives Trivia Premiere Dates rotten movies we love dceu television disaster NYCC adaptation Britbox comiccon Valentine's Day ViacomCBS Academy Awards renewed TV shows chucky worst movies Star Wars Holiday Reality Competition crime drama HBO Max Ellie Kemper DC Universe Creative Arts Emmys FXX Classic Film vs. IFC theme song teaser Crackle franchise sopranos kids binge Disney Plus marvel cinematic universe The Purge IFC Films Fall TV spanish language child's play Heroines superman political drama unscripted halloween king kong hollywood Extras Mary Tyler Moore Tomatazos Walt Disney Pictures Avengers Discovery Channel The Walking Dead Fantasy Amazon Studios quibi Election pirates of the caribbean james bond Stephen King 79th Golden Globes Awards Arrowverse cancelled television concert mob Fargo heist movie docudrama australia TV renewals game show animated Wes Anderson historical drama mcc true crime monster movies Biopics FOX hispanic YouTube Premium YouTube Red Teen book adaptation spinoff basketball space Mindy Kaling video on demand YouTube asian-american NBC 93rd Oscars Photos Image Comics Emmys cancelled TV series Apple TV Plus batman laika breaking bad SXSW BAFTA Paramount Network Cartoon Network kong Elton John USA Network Exclusive Video Funimation Action new york blockbuster movies Rom-Com ITV HBO Go RT History Hallmark Nickelodeon The Witch prank