Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Shrek's Final Chapter Is So-So

Plus, MacGruber's early Tomatometer is impressive!

by | May 21, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fairy tale finale (Shrek Forever After, starring the voices of Mike Myers and Cameron Diaz) and a clueless commando (MacGruber, starring Will Forte and Kristen Wiig). What do the critics have to say?


Shrek Forever After

Everyone’s favorite ogre returns this week in the fourth (and reportedly final) installment of the Shrek franchise, but is there enough fairy tale magic left after Shrek the Third? Unfortunately, the critics don’t all seem to think so. Presented in 3D (a franchise first), Shrek Forever After finds its titular hero longing for the good old days, when he was still a regular ogre. When the conniving Rumpelstiltskin tricks Shrek into giving up a day from his past in exchange for a day as a regular ogre, Shrek unwittingly signs away the day of his birth, effectively rewriting the history of Far Far Away… as if he never existed. Though critics say Forever After has its share of moments, and it’s a step up from the third installment, most also felt that the film felt entirely too familiar and formulaic.



While Saturday Night Live has produced some of America’s best comedic talents over the past few decades, its track record on film is hardly as impressive. Most films based on SNL sketches have done poorly, with a few rare exceptions like The Blues Brothers and the Wayne’s World films. This week, Will Forte’s bumbling action hero, MacGruber, finds himself thrust into an international espionage comedy on the big screen, and it’s up to him to save the world from the dastardly Dieter Von Cunth (Val Kilmer) and his nuclear warhead. So far, only a handful of critics have chimed in, but most of them have been pleasantly surprised by what they felt was a relatively effective and enjoyable sendup of 80s action movies. Continue to check back as more reviews roll in. (Also, check this week’s Total Recall to see a ranked list of films based on SNL sketches.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

mob Lucasfilm DC streaming service anime Starz First Look Winners independent A24 crime drama Infographic sitcom social media HFPA biopic 1990s Women's History Month Photos scorecard twilight Exclusive Video critics ESPN HBO video finale stoner 2016 medical drama Certified Fresh historical drama YouTube Premium 2021 Black History Month Esquire VH1 Disney Channel spinoff genre Fox News theme song OneApp PaleyFest Pop Chernobyl CNN SundanceTV gangster high school vs. Binge Guide spy thriller Mindy Kaling Television Critics Association kids NYCC Arrowverse 24 frames parents golden globe awards live event Holiday zombies dexter TCA 2017 Hear Us Out Martial Arts dc 99% Horror docuseries marvel comics classics TCA Winter 2020 Podcast TCM The Academy Captain marvel discovery GLAAD feel good comic books Extras Quiz Disney+ Disney Plus USA Network ID black comedy worst movies sequel The Walt Disney Company 79th Golden Globes Awards Mudbound quibi Film basketball series hidden camera canceled TV shows sequels Discovery Channel Rocketman Mary Tyler Moore Reality singing competition doctor who renewed TV shows saw Ellie Kemper Peacock Trailer mcc Rocky robots concert HBO Max First Reviews green book TIFF halloween Set visit Turner Classic Movies biography Amazon Mary Poppins Returns slashers prank blockbuster Stephen King unscripted Paramount Plus MSNBC rt labs dreamworks cinemax Comedy posters children's TV Family GoT Comic-Con@Home 2021 franchise blaxploitation Pacific Islander joker 20th Century Fox YA Marvel Television Funimation GIFs rotten all-time TV The Purge australia spanish Summer National Geographic international news obituary Year in Review asian-american Ovation Travel Channel dramedy RT21 adaptation PBS werewolf richard e. Grant binge BBC One Pop TV game of thrones IFC Films films name the review Freeform WarnerMedia Christmas BBC cars LGBTQ Tumblr screenings sports Prime Video book television Kids & Family cops suspense lord of the rings 4/20 justice league ABC Family Anna Paquin Food Network Pet Sematary adenture romance japanese Red Carpet BET Awards Instagram Live Bravo universal monsters See It Skip It rt labs critics edition scene in color vampires DC Comics marvel cinematic universe MTV SXSW Crackle spain FOX festival Hallmark Christmas movies Trivia king kong Comics on TV hist young adult screen actors guild cults diversity Legendary venice Tags: Comedy E! Neflix aapi spider-verse Universal Pictures hispanic CMT french Pirates Holidays psychological thriller travel emmy awards Netflix San Diego Comic-Con Cartoon Network 007 romantic comedy Tarantino Heroines Mystery mutant james bond ratings cancelled psycho Star Trek streaming based on movie Creative Arts Emmys Lionsgate black king arthur Wes Anderson hispanic heritage month ITV spider-man Disney streaming service toronto Walt Disney Pictures comic crossover VICE WGN godzilla cancelled TV shows Epix 90s Amazon Prime Video kong remakes FX comics leaderboard FX on Hulu MCU President tv talk indiana jones 73rd Emmy Awards best Columbia Pictures FXX Lifetime Christmas movies Teen Apple TV+ The CW Hollywood Foreign Press Association Fall TV kaiju Best and Worst E3 Comedy Central The Witch talk show TV Land Dark Horse Comics sopranos Calendar live action Amazon Studios Black Mirror crime thriller YouTube boxoffice streaming movies legend American Society of Cinematographers stand-up comedy Fargo Britbox dark Fox Searchlight jurassic park A&E TCA Awards Election Image Comics stop motion 2019 Interview Crunchyroll Endgame what to watch heist movie Television Academy Sony Pictures animated Disney Plus Valentine's Day Action X-Men Vudu Western Grammys DirecTV hollywood Ghostbusters Acorn TV slasher Disney Cannes Comic Book 2020 Marathons Music TCA Avengers 21st Century Fox directors aliens Netflix Christmas movies AMC Plus TNT festivals movie Toys facebook halloween tv Spring TV Oscars El Rey dogs Turner 2017 golden globes action-comedy Sneak Peek Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt composers popular superhero Shudder TLC Pixar olympics Video Games new zealand TruTV 45 Sci-Fi trailers movies miniseries Alien cats mockumentary Shondaland Super Bowl Awards ABC game show thriller Film Festival cartoon Musicals dceu Sundance TV true crime natural history adventure DC Universe Pride Month Warner Bros. Reality Competition TV One award winner chucky Hulu teaser Superheroe dragons war Mary poppins batman Academy Awards Polls and Games Fantasy witnail SDCC Apple TV Plus Brie Larson 72 Emmy Awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Universal cancelled television indie nature Tokyo Olympics USA scary movies video on demand nfl latino deadpool comic book movie superman debate Song of Ice and Fire disaster comiccon fast and furious Hallmark Tomatazos criterion CBS All Access football trophy TV renewals jamie lee curtis anthology AMC worst Elton John reviews Emmys nbcuniversal a nightmare on elm street zombie CW Seed New York Comic Con BET zero dark thirty Awards Tour japan Character Guide new york canceled documentaries Country RT History Box Office serial killer sag awards Countdown LGBT monster movies Writers Guild of America YouTube Red Apple Nickelodeon Sundance razzies child's play transformers OWN History documentary period drama Logo NBC foreign cancelled TV series Cosplay Opinion blockbusters wonder woman Showtime IFC Masterpiece spanish language boxing Superheroes toy story fresh scary cooking critic resources ViacomCBS christmas movies comedies italian ghosts technology Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount Watching Series archives IMDb TV TV movies harry potter Animation ABC Signature 93rd Oscars women art house versus strong female leads rotten movies we love Broadway DGA VOD royal family die hard Tubi police drama Adult Swim Spectrum Originals Syfy BAFTA casting The Arrangement Trophy Talk revenge APB breaking bad Sundance Now reboot HBO Go Premiere Dates south america 2015 politics Thanksgiving Classic Film crime pirates of the caribbean rt archives space PlayStation 2018 Emmy Nominations Marvel 71st Emmy Awards science fiction Star Wars NBA Schedule laika Spike satire CBS telelvision rom-coms Nat Geo political drama Marvel Studios new star wars movies TBS Baby Yoda Winter TV know your critic comic book movies free movies Musical Nominations target docudrama BBC America Amazon Prime mission: impossible Lifetime The Walking Dead supernatural Rock Paramount Network elevated horror Biopics Drama book adaptation Rom-Com