Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Shrek's Final Chapter Is So-So

Plus, MacGruber's early Tomatometer is impressive!

by | May 21, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fairy tale finale (Shrek Forever After, starring the voices of Mike Myers and Cameron Diaz) and a clueless commando (MacGruber, starring Will Forte and Kristen Wiig). What do the critics have to say?


Shrek Forever After

Everyone’s favorite ogre returns this week in the fourth (and reportedly final) installment of the Shrek franchise, but is there enough fairy tale magic left after Shrek the Third? Unfortunately, the critics don’t all seem to think so. Presented in 3D (a franchise first), Shrek Forever After finds its titular hero longing for the good old days, when he was still a regular ogre. When the conniving Rumpelstiltskin tricks Shrek into giving up a day from his past in exchange for a day as a regular ogre, Shrek unwittingly signs away the day of his birth, effectively rewriting the history of Far Far Away… as if he never existed. Though critics say Forever After has its share of moments, and it’s a step up from the third installment, most also felt that the film felt entirely too familiar and formulaic.



While Saturday Night Live has produced some of America’s best comedic talents over the past few decades, its track record on film is hardly as impressive. Most films based on SNL sketches have done poorly, with a few rare exceptions like The Blues Brothers and the Wayne’s World films. This week, Will Forte’s bumbling action hero, MacGruber, finds himself thrust into an international espionage comedy on the big screen, and it’s up to him to save the world from the dastardly Dieter Von Cunth (Val Kilmer) and his nuclear warhead. So far, only a handful of critics have chimed in, but most of them have been pleasantly surprised by what they felt was a relatively effective and enjoyable sendup of 80s action movies. Continue to check back as more reviews roll in. (Also, check this week’s Total Recall to see a ranked list of films based on SNL sketches.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

docudrama rt archives Cosplay Ellie Kemper Chernobyl comic all-time 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards blockbuster 79th Golden Globes Awards BBC One pirates of the caribbean Comic Book basketball Extras E! TCM medical drama Trailer FOX obituary screen actors guild Comedy heist movie Apple TV+ blaxploitation sports Lifetime Christmas movies FX on Hulu 1990s finale teaser Neflix Superheroes ESPN Country Sci-Fi mutant 4/20 Adult Swim science fiction kids 94th Oscars based on movie El Rey scary movies comic book movies anthology worst screenings legend 71st Emmy Awards Elton John YouTube Premium social media new york HBO book art house romance marvel comics Western batman boxoffice 2016 concert documentaries toronto The Academy Creative Arts Emmys National Geographic E3 Pirates Hallmark Christmas movies lord of the rings 20th Century Fox award winner broadcast casting Rocketman Mary Poppins Returns dark game show dragons scary summer preview Binge Guide Turner ABC prank Best Actress Amazon Studios mob renewed TV shows comic books Logo cancelled TV shows asian-american Endgame movie diversity best scorecard OWN Masterpiece Crackle CMT rt labs critics edition spain Walt Disney Pictures Song of Ice and Fire period drama Television Critics Association crossover Tomatazos American Society of Cinematographers IFC Universal Ghostbusters The CW VOD TV One Toys Amazon Prime Video 24 frames dreamworks Cannes saw TV DGA spanish language dceu Esquire franchise miniseries space Funimation psychological thriller series superman Tokyo Olympics Fall TV WarnerMedia Reality Podcast nfl Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt MTV Disney+ Disney Plus Amazon Prime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina technology Star Trek FXX Watching Series hispanic stand-up comedy archives hist Disney APB toy story Premiere Dates DC Comics live event indiana jones X-Men The Walt Disney Company Cartoon Network tv talk Shudder ABC Signature WGN Super Bowl king arthur GoT BBC America supernatural halloween tv Valentine's Day comics The Witch festivals Winter TV Opinion elevated horror streaming movies cinemax Certified Fresh mcc feel good Acorn TV TBS 007 Spectrum Originals Superheroe Epix boxing Star Wars Celebration psycho adaptation Lucasfilm DC streaming service Paramount HBO Go Rom-Com CBS All Access joker children's TV Star Wars 21st Century Fox Shondaland worst movies dexter Thanksgiving VICE comiccon aliens Tarantino biopic animated Arrowverse Tumblr blockbusters cars breaking bad Alien BET reviews cartoon spy thriller posters Spring TV Dark Horse Comics independent Comedy Central target green book scene in color name the review true crime Oscar NBC Emmy Nominations ViacomCBS Britbox spider-man black australia japanese rotten Film Festival cops harry potter New York Comic Con zero dark thirty war natural history Paramount Plus Christmas Polls and Games canceled twilight debate universal monsters summer TV preview criterion DirecTV romantic comedy dramedy 2015 free movies DC Universe Action Fox News telelvision historical drama Calendar Musical transformers facebook streamig Apple remakes BAFTA international MSNBC Sundance TV 99% Sneak Peek Vudu Showtime suspense NYCC richard e. Grant Countdown Teen TCA Winter 2020 dogs mockumentary Hulu Ovation Election Summer SDCC japan comic book movie MCU movies Nickelodeon Mary poppins crime drama quibi witnail razzies Set visit Mary Tyler Moore Nominations young adult thriller Grammys jurassic park A&E VH1 MGM composers talk show President Family black comedy HFPA 2021 Holidays Reality Competition chucky politics Classic Film disaster Fantasy GLAAD halloween Pride Month biography versus streaming Best and Worst LGBT Sundance Now Nat Geo 2017 Awards Tour Exclusive Video History fast and furious sequel CBS cults Writers Guild of America Travel Channel TCA Awards PaleyFest Rock Turner Classic Movies sopranos golden globes PlayStation Tubi Year in Review Anna Paquin Tags: Comedy IFC Films ABC Family Holiday Sony rotten movies we love hidden camera Discovery Channel die hard Winners child's play nbcuniversal godzilla know your critic ITV Trivia comedies TV movies Fargo Hollywood Foreign Press Association Netflix Christmas movies Image Comics Marvel Television discovery crime Television Academy Disney Plus video OneApp stop motion police drama marvel cinematic universe First Reviews TV Land werewolf Oscars Quiz SXSW 2022 fresh The Walking Dead Geeked Week Character Guide a nightmare on elm street Comic-Con@Home 2021 popular Black Mirror Crunchyroll Schedule monster movies serial killer NBA Sundance spider-verse AMC Lifetime indie South by Southwest Film Festival Columbia Pictures cats golden globe awards YA political drama italian jamie lee curtis Disney streaming service IMDb TV spanish emmy awards GIFs Captain marvel Pixar kong video on demand rom-coms satire target scene in color dc interviews cancelled television unscripted new star wars movies anime Biopics San Diego Comic-Con Freeform TruTV Wes Anderson ghosts Avengers SXSW LGBTQ Mystery TIFF TCA strong female leads directors hollywood trophy obi wan First Look Heroines scene in color film series FX theme song sitcom venice HBO Max mission: impossible zombie festival Fox Searchlight laika Starz king kong adenture Marvel what to watch Marathons 73rd Emmy Awards Pacific Islander docuseries Sony Pictures 2018 TCA 2017 cancelled USA Network Animation Broadway french TNT reboot rt labs Emmys football critics Best Actor new zealand nature 2019 Infographic crime thriller travel Stephen King Red Carpet The Arrangement Comics on TV CNN singing competition Hallmark Video Games ratings women binge Hear Us Out USA Black History Month sequels cooking Focus Features The Purge revenge Box Office superhero RT History YouTube book adaptation aapi Paramount Network latino summer TV television scene in color series 72 Emmy Awards Horror vampires Music Film Mindy Kaling Bravo adventure Universal Pictures gangster Pop robots PBS Academy Awards Spike Netflix CW Seed films kaiju genre Marvel Studios Rocky cancelled TV series Paramount Pictures royal family Warner Bros. documentary sag awards Amazon TLC hispanic heritage month Martial Arts james bond game of thrones A24 Lionsgate Indigenous deadpool doctor who justice league Apple TV Plus Kids & Family See It Skip It Best Picture south america ID BET Awards canceled TV shows Mudbound Pet Sematary 2020 stoner Native slashers Drama news 90s 45 93rd Oscars parents zombies wonder woman Brie Larson high school Legendary BBC christmas movies RT21 Food Network spinoff Prime Video Best Director leaderboard trailers Interview live action Peacock TV renewals Pop TV Baby Yoda SundanceTV Trophy Talk foreign Photos Syfy Awards Musicals YouTube Red olympics AMC Plus slasher action-comedy Disney Channel Women's History Month critic resources Instagram Live vs. classics