Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Rush and Don Jon Certified Fresh

Plus, Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 is silly fun, and Baggage Claim isn't worth the trip.

by | September 27, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got racing rivals (Rush, starring Chris Hemsworth and Daniel Brühl); ravenous food (Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2, with voice performances from Bill Hader and Anna Faris); a lovestruck lothario (Don Jon, starring Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Scarlett Johansson); and a desperate flight attendant (Baggage Claim, starring Paula Patton and Djimon Hounsou). What do the critics have to say?

Rush

89%

The best sports movies are about more than winning or losing — they’re about the inner workings of the people that play the games. Critics say director Ron Howard‘s Rush excels both on and off the track — the racing scenes are incredibly tense, but it’s the human drama and outstanding performances that push this film into the winner’s circle. James Hunt (Chris Hemsworth) and Niki Lauda (Daniel Brühl) are rival drivers with markedly different personalities and a shared history. As they battle it out for the 1976 Formula One championship, both drivers deal with personal traumas — and find a measure of mutual respect. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Rush is full of visual fireworks, but its nuanced portrait of two fierce competitors is what ultimately resonates. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Howard’s best-reviewed films.)

Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2

71%

Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs was a funny, exuberant surprise, so Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 was probably inevitable. Still, the critics say that while this sequel lacks the freshness of the original, it’s an energetic, visually inventive family movie. After dealing with torrents of raining food in the first film, the residents of Swallow Falls now have a mess of leftovers to clean up. But Flint Lockwood (voiced by Bill Hader), Sam Sparks (Anna Faris), and the rest of the town have bigger concerns than spoilage when a veritable army of food/animal hybrids start wreaking havoc. The pundits say Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 should please the little ones, and their parents will be reasonably satisfied as well. (Watch our video interviews with the cast, and click through our gallery of the worst movie meals.)

Don Jon

80%

It’s an old adage that what every actor really wants to do is direct. However, critics say that few thespians have the natural talent behind the camera that Joseph Gordon-Levitt displays in Don Jon, a funny, insightful romantic comedy that handles tricky material with aplomb. Gordon-Levitt stars as Jon, a skilled pickup artist who falls head over heels for Barbara, a beautiful woman with more traditional views on romance. Soon, however, Jon’s porn addiction threatens to derail his real-life relationship. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Don Jon is a strong debut for Gordon-Levitt — his film is witty, visually stylish, and well acted.

Baggage Claim

15%

Some material is so flimsy that even the most experienced actors prove unable to bring it to life. Unfortunately, critics say that’s the case with Baggage Claim, a romantic comedy that’s too contrived and clichéd to make much of an impression. Paula Patton stars as a flight attendant who wants to find Mr. Right before her sister ties the knot, so she hatches a plan to use her job to meet up with her exes and determine if they’re marriage material. The pundits say Baggage Claim hits the same notes as a number of successful romantic comedies without establishing much personality of its own.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • On the Job, a thriller about a pair of prison inmates who are enlisted to commit contract killings in exchange for reduced sentences, is at 100 percent.

  • Muscle Shoals, a rockumentary about the legendary Alabama recording studio, is at 100 percent.

  • Inequality For All, a documentary about the gap in income between the rich and poor, is at 96 percent.

  • Metallica Through the Never, starring Dane DeHaan in a thriller about a young roadie who encounters a variety of strange situations and people while on a mission for the band, is at 90 percent.

  • We Are What We Are, a horror film about a family with a controlling patriarch and a dark secret, is at 88 percent.

  • Shepard & Dark, a doc about the friendship between playwright Sam Shepard and bohemian Johnny Dark, is at 71 percent.

  • Out in the Dark, a drama about a love affair between a Palestinian student and an Israeli lawyer, is at 69 percent.

  • Dark Touch, a horror film about an 11-year-old outcast with telekinetic powers, is at 60 percent.

  • Morning, starring Leland Orser and Jeanne Tripplehorn in a drama about a couple who have just experienced the death of their child, is at 50 percent.

  • As I Lay Dying, starring James Franco and Danny McBride in an adaptation of William Faulkner’s novel about a family traveling through Mississippi to bury its recently deceased matriarch, is at 42 percent.

Tag Cloud

Netflix toy story space young adult franchise Winter TV richard e. Grant stop motion comic book movies independent Polls and Games Sundance Now boxing Disney Plus teaser quibi Pixar vs. Pet Sematary target scene in color news Paramount Network king arthur directors docuseries CBS All Access telelvision Dark Horse Comics video chucky debate 1990s robots 2015 cults Premiere Dates TLC spanish thriller Ghostbusters MTV 94th Oscars CW Seed Nat Geo Infographic Holiday See It Skip It classics Best Actor strong female leads Sundance TV Starz television Mindy Kaling Lionsgate period drama Elton John Best Actress Cosplay Tarantino monster movies action-comedy Hallmark Christmas movies scary Marathons marvel comics cancelled Universal Pictures Year in Review canceled TV shows Marvel Television a nightmare on elm street Pop TV transformers all-time Rom-Com series screenings feel good Sony Pictures documentaries TBS comics Valentine's Day Television Critics Association comiccon Set visit Musicals ratings GoT rt labs critics edition YouTube Premium adaptation Sony award winner Lifetime Christmas movies foreign Endgame reboot live action DGA Classic Film olympics WGN nfl Red Carpet AMC Plus italian HBO 99% Pacific Islander Travel Channel 2019 Teen Instagram Live toronto sequel jamie lee curtis Cartoon Network dexter 93rd Oscars dceu Comedy Central slashers dark Netflix Christmas movies wonder woman YouTube Black Mirror composers hidden camera Amazon LGBT blockbuster spider-man hispanic RT21 werewolf DC Universe YA HBO Max USA Fargo 2017 finale Creative Arts Emmys Apple TV+ golden globe awards Shondaland hispanic heritage month Reality Competition cars deadpool historical drama Emmy Nominations Black History Month superhero Music basketball 72 Emmy Awards casting 2016 90s natural history football Crunchyroll FX on Hulu 2020 DC streaming service PaleyFest TV Land summer TV Alien Marvel Studios Biopics FXX jurassic park concert docudrama TV sopranos screen actors guild Rock critic resources cops SXSW 2022 TNT Video Games Mary poppins Ovation Hollywood Foreign Press Association breaking bad video on demand archives art house Native Chernobyl spain miniseries adenture WarnerMedia Disney documentary romance justice league lord of the rings Arrowverse films Women's History Month versus Broadway Martial Arts name the review Turner cancelled TV shows Exclusive Video aliens 4/20 IFC Films Trophy Talk streaming movies Cannes Lucasfilm Interview APB Warner Bros. 79th Golden Globes Awards Grammys TV renewals Family parents war scary movies slasher cooking Writers Guild of America Hulu Amazon Studios crossover President free movies die hard Sundance E! Tokyo Olympics Crackle halloween marvel cinematic universe laika mob Geeked Week mutant Oscar FX Image Comics Super Bowl Sci-Fi Comic Book 2018 Schedule Film Festival Reality Vudu 2021 Oscars renewed TV shows TCA Awards scene in color series TV One batman canceled Columbia Pictures leaderboard American Society of Cinematographers Fox Searchlight scene in color Superheroes The Walking Dead Watching Series Tomatazos twilight Wes Anderson james bond Nominations Rocky gangster PBS disaster TIFF worst TCA 2017 science fiction cats legend live event politics dreamworks Winners Rocketman Holidays latino Adult Swim stand-up comedy South by Southwest Film Festival Showtime HFPA Musical Nickelodeon TCA Winter 2020 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Emmys VICE Western dc know your critic Election Trailer Certified Fresh cancelled television based on movie Comics on TV Extras Spring TV Legendary dragons zero dark thirty Britbox comedies Indigenous Brie Larson prank Christmas A24 summer TV preview Countdown Heroines broadcast scene in color film series vampires Disney streaming service Spectrum Originals comic SDCC Acorn TV Masterpiece Binge Guide Pride Month Discovery Channel NBA Esquire binge New York Comic Con Walt Disney Pictures book adaptation 20th Century Fox christmas movies Shudder new york witnail festival universal monsters Stephen King Character Guide black Disney+ Disney Plus PlayStation boxoffice zombies blockbusters San Diego Comic-Con Tumblr saw popular australia Box Office spanish language Universal The Academy Star Wars Celebration Neflix Baby Yoda best book talk show indie hollywood VH1 criterion Comic-Con@Home 2021 Peacock OneApp dogs SundanceTV Podcast children's TV Food Network Funimation MSNBC USA Network DirecTV doctor who Logo rotten movies we love interviews AMC movies unscripted Marvel Photos royal family HBO Go Drama History biopic ghosts Captain marvel Tags: Comedy game show Fox News revenge Toys Best Director obituary Fall TV emmy awards hist genre posters IMDb TV Apple TV Plus Amazon Prime Video The Witch Paramount Pictures sag awards travel Awards Tour E3 Paramount pirates of the caribbean Mystery anime BAFTA ViacomCBS Opinion TV movies Bravo Mary Poppins Returns political drama venice trophy crime drama ABC Song of Ice and Fire godzilla heist movie asian-american Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt japan worst movies Paramount Plus Action Summer Superheroe zombie Best Picture target DC Comics Focus Features technology sequels CMT international Turner Classic Movies The Arrangement The CW indiana jones elevated horror mockumentary X-Men Thanksgiving halloween tv 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards remakes Prime Video discovery nature rt labs BBC One comic books Star Trek FOX Syfy south america Spike psychological thriller Apple Ellie Kemper Country sports 73rd Emmy Awards Pirates true crime ESPN kids CBS dramedy rotten ABC Family 007 crime Best and Worst festivals kong Trivia social media Lifetime First Reviews comic book movie Epix medical drama Tubi aapi spider-verse Horror Freeform El Rey Amazon Prime 71st Emmy Awards BET superman blaxploitation 45 A&E obi wan child's play YouTube Red Television Academy harry potter psycho high school spinoff Disney Channel 21st Century Fox romantic comedy theme song ID police drama streamig fast and furious ABC Signature Hallmark Comedy supernatural rt archives what to watch National Geographic facebook spy thriller TruTV black comedy cancelled TV series serial killer mcc anthology rom-coms SXSW First Look OWN Quiz stoner Anna Paquin scorecard animated fresh The Purge joker kaiju Sneak Peek japanese Kids & Family satire critics golden globes LGBTQ Animation adventure tv talk Fantasy ITV king kong 24 frames Film women NYCC new zealand suspense trailers streaming crime thriller cartoon NBC nbcuniversal BBC green book TCA VOD MGM reviews RT History CNN game of thrones Pop BBC America singing competition Avengers summer preview GIFs Star Wars TCM MCU IFC Academy Awards sitcom new star wars movies movie Mudbound cinemax french mission: impossible razzies GLAAD diversity The Walt Disney Company Mary Tyler Moore Hear Us Out Calendar BET Awards biography