Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Project Almanac is Fun but Uneven

Plus, Black or White is well-meaning but contrived, and The Americans is Certified Fresh.

by | January 29, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got time-traveling teens (Project Almanac, starring Jonny Weston and Sofia Black D’Elia), squabbling families (Black or White, starring Kevin Costner and Octavia Spencer), and philandering friends (The Loft, starring James Marsden and Karl Urban). What do the critics have to say?

Project Almanac


Project Almanac is unlikely to replace Back to the Future or Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure in the popular imagination. Still, critics say this time-travel thriller is stylish and smart, even if it eventually runs out of steam and the found-footage gimmick doesn’t quite work. David (Jonny Weston) is a high school science wiz who builds a time machine based on a model developed by his late father. But when he and his friends journey into the past, they end up messing up the present in unforeseen ways. The pundits say Project Almanac is reasonably fun, but the film never quite lives up to its intriguing premise. (Watch our video interview with the stars.)

Black or White


Heartfelt intentions and great actors do not a successful film make. Case in point: Black or White, which critics say saddles its stellar cast with a contrived story that only touches on the weightiness to which it aspires. Kevin Costner plays Elliot, a hard drinking attorney who finds himself caring for his orphaned granddaughter after his wife dies. But Rowena (Octavia Spencer), her paternal grandmother, thinks he’s not up to the task, and soon she and Elliot are involved in an emotional custody battle. The pundits say Black or White is a noble attempt to address issues of race and family, but the contrived plot undercuts both the film’s lofty aims and its nuanced performances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Costner’s best-reviewed movies.)

The Loft


It’s been nearly four years since The Loft was filmed, and now it hits theaters without being screened for critics. Neither of those facts are encouraging. It’s the story of five married guys who rent an apartment for extracurricular activities. When they discover a dead woman in the loft, each of them is a suspect. Guess the Tomatometer!

What’s Hot On TV:

Critics say that tamily-driven drama and psychological themes propel The Americans (Certified Fresh at 100 percent) which will dispence thrills of a different ilk this season.

The critics say the action and sex in Sons of Liberty (58 percent) is certainly titillating, but not enough to compensate for the show’s bland, historically inaccurate story.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Hard to be a God, an epic Russian sci-fi film about a scientist sent to planet whose inhabitants have regressed into the dark ages, is at 100 percent.
  • Timbuktu, a drama about everyday life in the famed Malian city after its takeover by religious fundamentalists, is at 97 percent.
  • Girlhood, a drama about a teenager with a troubled home life who finds solace with a group of street kids, is at 82 percent.
  • Above and Beyond, a documentary about a group of American pilots who fought in the Israeli War of Independence, is at 80 percent.
  • Amira & Sam, a romantic dramedy about the relationship between an American soldier and an Iraqi woman, is at 75 percent. (Also, check out Martin Starr’s Five Favorite Films.)
  • Suburban Gothic, starring Kat Dennings and Matthew Gray Gubler in a horror comedy about a misfit who must protect his community from a vengeful spirit, is at 43 percent.
  • Wild Card, starring Jason Statham and Sofía Vergara in an action thriller about a bodyguard who goes after the thug who attacked his friend, is at 15 percent.
  • Alien Outpost, a mockumentary about a group of soldiers fighting extraterrestrials in the deserts of Pakistan, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

TCA rom-coms Action space sequels Endgame docuseries VH1 The Walking Dead joker medical drama Crunchyroll festivals zombie BBC America WarnerMedia monster movies Film Festival cops know your critic Arrowverse disaster Anna Paquin die hard GIFs Extras spider-man Podcast FX nature black comedy Freeform Summer award winner biography Paramount reboot TruTV women Opinion satire Pirates jamie lee curtis godzilla remakes WGN TIFF anime facebook Trivia Netflix Christmas movies archives Horror razzies CNN tv talk Women's History Month aliens gangster scene in color Tarantino japan Elton John Warner Bros. Broadway Television Academy Schedule kids Sony Pictures stand-up comedy Instagram Live parents USA Network Sundance TV james bond Spectrum Originals mob Kids & Family movies 2015 Song of Ice and Fire APB YA emmy awards rt labs The CW Video Games werewolf australia Spring TV Peacock Disney Channel Mary Tyler Moore Brie Larson BBC HFPA festival series Disney streaming service Rocketman Logo Superheroe cinemax what to watch Avengers dark CW Seed all-time Polls and Games Disney+ Disney Plus comic book movies Nickelodeon anthology Amazon Studios NBC American Society of Cinematographers Ghostbusters LGBT PlayStation Black Mirror saw Britbox GLAAD book adaptation spinoff jurassic park Classic Film MTV Character Guide Drama trophy supernatural Paramount Network See It Skip It The Witch Biopics 45 PBS comic book movie Fox News Photos Binge Guide Rom-Com Marvel Television docudrama pirates of the caribbean History ViacomCBS sports genre Pacific Islander Esquire sag awards cancelled TV shows aapi Food Network politics X-Men social media blaxploitation quibi Apple TV+ cartoon comedies police drama 4/20 critics Black History Month indiana jones king kong superman Country BBC One Fargo Marvel Studios wonder woman composers Television Critics Association twilight sequel Exclusive Video Hallmark Star Trek HBO Go spy thriller Watching Series Mudbound adenture Sci-Fi Election book franchise posters Calendar crime spider-verse boxoffice Super Bowl 72 Emmy Awards Valentine's Day kaiju south america japanese CMT CBS TLC Star Wars El Rey richard e. Grant 2017 ABC RT21 science fiction Teen Tumblr 2020 Legendary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Starz Reality dogs best MCU Grammys political drama mutant President zombies fast and furious a nightmare on elm street marvel comics dceu Sneak Peek Lifetime batman Music breaking bad Tokyo Olympics boxing Shondaland Red Carpet ratings Prime Video HBO Max animated Turner screen actors guild Paramount Plus cats Pop TV 73rd Emmy Awards E! laika italian Best and Worst Holiday hollywood FX on Hulu marvel cinematic universe golden globe awards war Sundance scary movies singing competition versus Hear Us Out Alien San Diego Comic-Con Superheroes scorecard dexter Chernobyl Family TCM witnail Set visit cars critic resources mission: impossible slasher toy story Pet Sematary 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards technology DC Universe Mystery DGA rotten movies we love crossover news Shudder Awards Tour cooking children's TV Nat Geo Syfy art house FOX TV One Universal Pictures hist concert GoT Crackle elevated horror classics stoner Rocky comic heist movie adaptation streaming Winners young adult Interview thriller ESPN Oscars nfl Chilling Adventures of Sabrina slashers documentaries live action romantic comedy worst unscripted 99% new york Comedy Central A&E 21st Century Fox TCA 2017 Cartoon Network Thanksgiving BET Awards Writers Guild of America halloween harry potter asian-american telelvision Pop Awards ID rotten Premiere Dates Marathons comics travel Nominations indie prank DC streaming service obituary halloween tv Western Columbia Pictures First Reviews comic books USA name the review superhero TCA Winter 2020 DirecTV christmas movies TV leaderboard scary SXSW Neflix toronto new star wars movies Amazon TV movies Disney spain biopic football Turner Classic Movies YouTube Premium hidden camera TBS Animation Apple TV Plus hispanic heritage month zero dark thirty child's play diversity Emmy Nominations venice video ABC Signature Travel Channel HBO television Ellie Kemper 2019 VICE Comic-Con@Home 2021 Marvel Vudu BET french dc Comic Book IMDb TV Musicals Disney Plus foreign Funimation SDCC adventure justice league basketball rt labs critics edition romance dramedy Mindy Kaling TV Land historical drama Trailer New York Comic Con Christmas royal family comiccon TCA Awards Captain marvel Trophy Talk nbcuniversal ITV Holidays based on movie TV renewals Sundance Now canceled TV shows sopranos 79th Golden Globes Awards BAFTA Film kong 20th Century Fox Image Comics period drama Ovation Spike reviews strong female leads Mary Poppins Returns films renewed TV shows Tomatazos deadpool Year in Review chucky target The Arrangement RT History Adult Swim YouTube Red spanish streaming movies A24 free movies cancelled television Pixar Acorn TV Reality Competition Heroines 93rd Oscars finale AMC Plus Stephen King documentary E3 Hulu Cannes Musical olympics theme song Baby Yoda ghosts Creative Arts Emmys AMC universal monsters high school hispanic trailers Box Office crime thriller screenings Countdown casting directors The Walt Disney Company popular cults action-comedy teaser MSNBC criterion vampires NBA Winter TV video on demand Cosplay Discovery Channel serial killer Comedy canceled 71st Emmy Awards discovery live event new zealand independent IFC Films doctor who Fantasy mcc black Amazon Prime Video Amazon Prime debate spanish language Apple psychological thriller First Look game show Fox Searchlight SundanceTV 90s Dark Horse Comics crime drama mockumentary golden globes ABC Family Lionsgate binge legend vs. Tubi Netflix blockbuster YouTube green book transformers The Purge rt archives Masterpiece Emmys Infographic 24 frames PaleyFest The Academy 1990s blockbusters fresh Wes Anderson cancelled TV series National Geographic international 2018 game of thrones Fall TV Mary poppins 2016 Tags: Comedy 007 Quiz Comics on TV stop motion FXX Rock IFC movie Bravo VOD lord of the rings dragons DC Comics Certified Fresh Universal true crime Epix LGBTQ OneApp worst movies talk show Hollywood Foreign Press Association Showtime TNT miniseries suspense Toys feel good robots Lifetime Christmas movies king arthur Pride Month Academy Awards psycho Lucasfilm dreamworks NYCC cancelled Walt Disney Pictures CBS All Access latino revenge Hallmark Christmas movies Martial Arts natural history 2021 OWN sitcom