Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Prisoners is Certified Fresh

Plus, Battle of the Year has two left feet.

by | September 19, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a frantic search (Prisoners, starring Hugh Jackman and Jake Gyllenhaal) and an international dance-off (Battle of the Year, starring Josh Holloway and Laz Alonso). What do the critics have to say?



A dark, grim police procedural, Prisoners isn’t exactly feel-good cinema. However, critics say it’s a suspenseful, gripping thriller, thanks to an outstanding ensemble cast and a mystery that remains ambiguous to the end. Keller Dover (Hugh Jackman) is the father of a six-year-old girl who goes missing, along with her best friend. A suspect is arrested, but released for lack of evidence; fearing the worst for his child, Dover decides to take the law into his own hands. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Prisoners is haunting, tense, and disturbing, with a weighty sense of moral complexity. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Jake Gyllenhaal’s best-reviewed movies

Battle of the Year


Nobody goes to a dance movie expecting high art, but critics say Battle of the Year is flimsy even by the standards of the genre, spending too much time on its hackneyed story and not enough on the dancefloor. With an international dance competition only months away, a down-on-his-luck basketball coach (Josh Holloway) is recruited to coax a squad of 12 street dancers into fighting shape. Will this ragtag band of breakers bring home the title — and will their coach find a measure of personal redemption in the process? The pundits say Battle of the Year delivers a few slick dance moves, but its plot is hopelessly hokey and the dialogue is unintentionally hilarious.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Wizard of Oz: An IMAX 3D Experience, starring Judy Garland in a timeless classic about a girl who isn’t in Kansas anymore, is Certified Fresh at 99 percent.

  • Enough Said, starring Julia Louis-Dreyfus and James Gandolfini in a drama about a divorced woman who meets a man who seems perfect until she finds out a little more about him, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.

  • After Tiller, a documentary that profiles doctors that perform late-term abortions, is at 85 percent.

  • Generation Iron, a doc about the world of professional bodybuilders, is at 80 percent.

  • The Short Game, a doc about the highly competitive world of junior golf, is at 78 percent.

  • C.O.G., a dramedy based on a David Sedaris story about a man who ditches his modern devices and works as an apple picker in Oregon, is at 74 percent.

  • Haute Cuisine, a comedy about a little-known provincial chef who becomes the French president’s personal cook, is at 71 percent.

  • Thanks For Sharing, starring Mark Ruffalo and Gwyneth Paltrow in a dramedy about the lives of an interconnected group of recovering sex addicts, is at 57 percent.

  • Ip Man: The Final Fight, an action drama about the legendary martial arts master in the twilight of his life, is at 58 percent.

  • A Single Shot, starring Sam Rockwell and Jeffrey Wright in a thriller about a hunter who inadvertently kills a woman and tries to cover it up, is at 52 percent.

  • Men at Lunch, a documentary about the famous photograph Lunch atop a Skyscraper, is at 50 percent.

  • Newlyweeds, a comedy about a young couple that smokes an awful lot of marijuana, is at 44 percent.

  • My Lucky Star, starring Zhang Ziyi in a spy spoof about a cartoonist who gets involved in a plot to obtain a valuable diamond, is at 44 percent.

  • Zaytoun, starring Stephen Dorff in a drama about an Israeli pilot who travels with a Palestinian orphan to see the kid’s family’s hometown, is at 39 percent.

  • Weekender, a dramedy about a pair of friends who organize warehouse raves in the early 1990s, is at nine percent.

  • The Colony, starring Laurence Fishburne and Bill Paxton in a sci-fi thriller set in a post-apocalyptic ice age, is at six percent.

  • Jewtopia, starring Jennifer Love Hewitt and Jamie-Lynn Sigler in a romantic comedy about a guy who pretends to be Jewish in order to win the heart of a rabbi’s daughter, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

rom-coms joker Paramount Pictures TruTV Pixar 1990s dc interviews dragons rt labs critics edition Nominations WGN Comedy Central Year in Review Funimation YouTube witnail VOD war foreign Paramount rotten movies we love El Rey comics Avengers Apple TV Plus Reality Competition Disney streaming service canceled TV shows revenge Oscar The CW Cartoon Network royal family ViacomCBS blockbusters Adult Swim Lucasfilm streaming MSNBC BAFTA HBO Max teaser Reality Comic Book The Witch DirecTV reboot prank chucky comedies Lionsgate Disney Channel Quiz USA Network unscripted broadcast pirates of the caribbean cartoon Indigenous adaptation DC Universe dexter PlayStation Character Guide Trailer Mindy Kaling IFC Films SundanceTV Animation spain Cosplay HBO Go Food Network Trivia Mary poppins talk show Exclusive Video Shudder halloween tv superhero Academy Awards festivals black television Superheroe A24 medical drama sports south america History OWN crossover Video Games crime spy thriller leaderboard Rom-Com movies nfl christmas movies Certified Fresh Nickelodeon king arthur BBC Red Carpet international Tubi australia basketball women MTV cancelled telelvision debate Premiere Dates Fall TV cats transformers Shondaland Pop TV obi wan Infographic cops Dark Horse Comics 2016 all-time king kong classics football live event boxing independent SXSW 2022 feel good RT21 Box Office American Society of Cinematographers cars Spring TV ratings Television Academy Election IMDb TV Emmy Nominations biopic Lifetime Christmas movies Amazon Prime WarnerMedia jurassic park The Walt Disney Company trophy lord of the rings TV Land Mary Poppins Returns a nightmare on elm street Netflix Christmas movies See It Skip It Ovation Hulu Instagram Live ITV Chernobyl robots sopranos art house Paramount Network 2018 VICE new star wars movies richard e. Grant Logo crime drama stoner Best Director comiccon vs. emmy awards Rocky renewed TV shows spider-man Mary Tyler Moore news true crime slashers DC Comics GIFs Set visit 2017 japan docudrama crime thriller Holiday video on demand marvel comics Best Actor indie Showtime biography batman VH1 Sneak Peek deadpool Watching Series sag awards Elton John Summer Best and Worst jamie lee curtis Best Picture singing competition TCA Marvel Film Festival 93rd Oscars Sundance rt archives action-comedy ABC Countdown japanese Turner films AMC Best Actress Western politics award winner spanish SXSW Anna Paquin Song of Ice and Fire game show The Academy Discovery Channel Wes Anderson E! period drama zero dark thirty Legendary target quibi fresh fast and furious ESPN Pride Month Extras 90s what to watch black comedy facebook young adult video YouTube Red Arrowverse Image Comics Stephen King directors Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FOX satire Geeked Week french cancelled television Peacock 2021 saw doctor who tv talk ABC Family Baby Yoda Nat Geo olympics Polls and Games X-Men universal monsters 2020 screen actors guild CBS DGA Britbox free movies indiana jones blaxploitation PBS 2015 Disney Plus Sony 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards based on movie science fiction Syfy hidden camera A&E LGBTQ TCA Awards Sony Pictures hispanic Ghostbusters Musicals Women's History Month hispanic heritage month FX on Hulu mcc CBS All Access screenings TNT Creative Arts Emmys YouTube Premium Pirates target scene in color critics AMC Plus NYCC romance Apple dramedy E3 National Geographic best spanish language aapi 007 Trophy Talk festival posters HBO supernatural twilight CNN space Marvel Studios Heroines Photos Musical stop motion Horror Disney+ Disney Plus Walt Disney Pictures BET kong heist movie First Look know your critic cults gangster Amazon nbcuniversal critic resources Tokyo Olympics Winter TV Drama Tarantino CMT Black History Month TV movies ID scorecard toronto breaking bad aliens YA Disney TCA Winter 2020 summer TV canceled Action worst movies documentary streaming movies live action Interview Masterpiece BBC One Freeform popular elevated horror thriller 79th Golden Globes Awards Rock Rocketman discovery scene in color film series Podcast children's TV Crackle adenture BET Awards Marvel Television reviews legend Star Wars Television Critics Association Valentine's Day Tomatazos animated Paramount Plus political drama Marathons zombies mission: impossible laika dark PaleyFest Classic Film TV romantic comedy Star Wars Celebration Warner Bros. Acorn TV high school Hallmark Endgame series Universal ghosts Amazon Prime Video LGBT Family hollywood anthology Pet Sematary 94th Oscars Fox News police drama razzies Epix Focus Features adventure criterion venice Broadway spider-verse HFPA Universal Pictures Film Schedule Esquire comic dreamworks book travel trailers book adaptation rotten strong female leads franchise The Walking Dead Awards 2019 The Purge OneApp Alien Sci-Fi Opinion cooking 20th Century Fox Black Mirror Amazon Studios Hear Us Out Toys Music natural history new zealand Apple TV+ ABC Signature miniseries BBC America nature Spike genre FX Kids & Family San Diego Comic-Con zombie parents concert Fargo TBS Captain marvel comic books name the review scene in color golden globe awards kaiju Pop worst Lifetime Comics on TV Spectrum Originals latino The Arrangement GoT godzilla Prime Video 73rd Emmy Awards Christmas Netflix summer TV preview First Reviews scene in color series Oscars mockumentary NBC Comedy summer preview Crunchyroll versus Sundance TV 45 Superheroes sequel psychological thriller cinemax psycho disaster 99% mob IFC CW Seed italian suspense Star Trek Tumblr harry potter documentaries Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Vudu monster movies Thanksgiving Hollywood Foreign Press Association hist RT History comic book movies 71st Emmy Awards Martial Arts golden globes Sundance Now Brie Larson TCA 2017 archives TLC GLAAD mutant 72 Emmy Awards Super Bowl Ellie Kemper halloween rt labs obituary theme song stand-up comedy TV renewals sitcom Country Awards Tour cancelled TV series new york die hard SDCC TCM binge Native Fantasy Binge Guide Neflix toy story finale social media boxoffice kids APB asian-american scary streamig Mystery docuseries justice league composers Tags: Comedy superman Biopics Holidays dceu historical drama serial killer TV One Travel Channel Comic-Con@Home 2021 24 frames Teen sequels Starz South by Southwest Film Festival President NBA Pacific Islander marvel cinematic universe movie james bond technology Writers Guild of America spinoff 4/20 Fox Searchlight wonder woman remakes diversity cancelled TV shows New York Comic Con green book vampires Mudbound USA anime comic book movie slasher MGM Turner Classic Movies Calendar TIFF blockbuster Grammys Hallmark Christmas movies 21st Century Fox MCU Winners werewolf Bravo casting scary movies FXX DC streaming service game of thrones dogs Cannes Columbia Pictures child's play Emmys