Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Prisoners is Certified Fresh

Plus, Battle of the Year has two left feet.

by | September 19, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a frantic search (Prisoners, starring Hugh Jackman and Jake Gyllenhaal) and an international dance-off (Battle of the Year, starring Josh Holloway and Laz Alonso). What do the critics have to say?



A dark, grim police procedural, Prisoners isn’t exactly feel-good cinema. However, critics say it’s a suspenseful, gripping thriller, thanks to an outstanding ensemble cast and a mystery that remains ambiguous to the end. Keller Dover (Hugh Jackman) is the father of a six-year-old girl who goes missing, along with her best friend. A suspect is arrested, but released for lack of evidence; fearing the worst for his child, Dover decides to take the law into his own hands. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Prisoners is haunting, tense, and disturbing, with a weighty sense of moral complexity. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Jake Gyllenhaal’s best-reviewed movies

Battle of the Year


Nobody goes to a dance movie expecting high art, but critics say Battle of the Year is flimsy even by the standards of the genre, spending too much time on its hackneyed story and not enough on the dancefloor. With an international dance competition only months away, a down-on-his-luck basketball coach (Josh Holloway) is recruited to coax a squad of 12 street dancers into fighting shape. Will this ragtag band of breakers bring home the title — and will their coach find a measure of personal redemption in the process? The pundits say Battle of the Year delivers a few slick dance moves, but its plot is hopelessly hokey and the dialogue is unintentionally hilarious.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Wizard of Oz: An IMAX 3D Experience, starring Judy Garland in a timeless classic about a girl who isn’t in Kansas anymore, is Certified Fresh at 99 percent.
  • Enough Said, starring Julia Louis-Dreyfus and James Gandolfini in a drama about a divorced woman who meets a man who seems perfect until she finds out a little more about him, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • After Tiller, a documentary that profiles doctors that perform late-term abortions, is at 85 percent.
  • Generation Iron, a doc about the world of professional bodybuilders, is at 80 percent.
  • The Short Game, a doc about the highly competitive world of junior golf, is at 78 percent.
  • C.O.G., a dramedy based on a David Sedaris story about a man who ditches his modern devices and works as an apple picker in Oregon, is at 74 percent.
  • Haute Cuisine, a comedy about a little-known provincial chef who becomes the French president’s personal cook, is at 71 percent.
  • Thanks For Sharing, starring Mark Ruffalo and Gwyneth Paltrow in a dramedy about the lives of an interconnected group of recovering sex addicts, is at 57 percent.
  • Ip Man: The Final Fight, an action drama about the legendary martial arts master in the twilight of his life, is at 58 percent.
  • A Single Shot, starring Sam Rockwell and Jeffrey Wright in a thriller about a hunter who inadvertently kills a woman and tries to cover it up, is at 52 percent.
  • Men at Lunch, a documentary about the famous photograph Lunch atop a Skyscraper, is at 50 percent.
  • Newlyweeds, a comedy about a young couple that smokes an awful lot of marijuana, is at 44 percent.
  • My Lucky Star, starring Zhang Ziyi in a spy spoof about a cartoonist who gets involved in a plot to obtain a valuable diamond, is at 44 percent.
  • Zaytoun, starring Stephen Dorff in a drama about an Israeli pilot who travels with a Palestinian orphan to see the kid’s family’s hometown, is at 39 percent.
  • Weekender, a dramedy about a pair of friends who organize warehouse raves in the early 1990s, is at nine percent.
  • The Colony, starring Laurence Fishburne and Bill Paxton in a sci-fi thriller set in a post-apocalyptic ice age, is at six percent.
  • Jewtopia, starring Jennifer Love Hewitt and Jamie-Lynn Sigler in a romantic comedy about a guy who pretends to be Jewish in order to win the heart of a rabbi’s daughter, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Reality Competition TCA 2017 ESPN Film Character Guide Oscars slashers Fox Searchlight dogs miniseries Amazon Prime Video critics serial killer 45 SXSW lord of the rings Hear Us Out werewolf vs. razzies scary 93rd Oscars Britbox Black History Month Marvel Studios Logo indie disaster blockbusters ID action-comedy Rom-Com women Arrowverse best Horror History Animation christmas movies Wes Anderson sports PaleyFest parents Grammys Shudder BET Awards mockumentary dark rt labs science fiction trophy Showtime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DirecTV GLAAD zero dark thirty Emmy Nominations blockbuster marvel comics rt labs critics edition festival toronto all-time news Avengers Premiere Dates Elton John ABC Signature LGBT Marvel Television teaser Spike Comedy cancelled Esquire 20th Century Fox composers Reality Superheroes Polls and Games renewed TV shows Ellie Kemper justice league zombies Shondaland Mary Tyler Moore comic Stephen King Sneak Peek golden globes Certified Fresh TCM Tomatazos Disney+ Disney Plus series adenture Western Heroines foreign The Witch X-Men spanish language OWN Food Network Bravo USA unscripted Mystery SundanceTV Pixar Disney spinoff natural history witnail heist movie Countdown true crime The CW TCA Winter 2020 free movies NYCC richard e. Grant transformers psychological thriller war Schedule halloween tv Trophy Talk cults nature comiccon breaking bad social media Baby Yoda television ratings Ovation YA new star wars movies President genre historical drama Pacific Islander Sundance Now superhero indiana jones films WarnerMedia CMT sequel Comic Book franchise Sundance Syfy cats Hollywood Foreign Press Association National Geographic Television Critics Association spain video worst movies 79th Golden Globes Awards reboot Pop TV 1990s universal monsters cartoon WGN adventure SDCC kaiju TV renewals Infographic Turner Classic Movies diversity Box Office scary movies crime drama A&E Red Carpet romantic comedy rom-coms Biopics Neflix rotten Teen blaxploitation independent australia comics HBO TV movies TV psycho 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards asian-american joker hispanic japan Apple TV+ Crackle Song of Ice and Fire deadpool biopic french young adult Exclusive Video Mindy Kaling hist MTV E3 Toys screen actors guild LGBTQ know your critic theme song Disney Plus police drama superman Music YouTube name the review cancelled television Best and Worst AMC Pop Fox News book adaptation Instagram Live TLC Country spider-verse Election DGA Paramount Plus Black Mirror political drama facebook FX on Hulu CW Seed latino Chernobyl award winner Epix streaming USA Network trailers 2019 Marvel pirates of the caribbean dramedy movies Musical Interview TBS Amazon Studios sopranos halloween versus Comic-Con@Home 2021 strong female leads TIFF IFC TCA Awards Turner harry potter RT21 72 Emmy Awards Anna Paquin FX gangster robots TV Land obituary Lifetime Christmas movies hidden camera classics stoner kids NBC Image Comics Comics on TV 21st Century Fox cars Nominations basketball Walt Disney Pictures OneApp DC Universe live event Lionsgate Tubi doctor who quibi Awards American Society of Cinematographers venice 73rd Emmy Awards Creative Arts Emmys ITV Writers Guild of America Holidays Ghostbusters Dark Horse Comics kong game of thrones Mary Poppins Returns crime The Walking Dead anthology leaderboard debate nfl fast and furious TCA 4/20 Captain marvel RT History VICE Fargo Disney streaming service Chilling Adventures of Sabrina VH1 Cannes laika Adult Swim E! A24 video on demand Spring TV PBS Opinion Summer japanese First Look live action ABC Family 007 godzilla cancelled TV shows Alien Apple TV Plus critic resources ghosts See It Skip It 2017 canceled TV shows Rocketman comic books mission: impossible technology Fantasy movie Drama dc Superheroe Watching Series Pirates target Christmas Year in Review First Reviews TNT telelvision Brie Larson Universal Pictures chucky football MSNBC Super Bowl jurassic park MCU royal family Columbia Pictures Mary poppins cooking boxoffice vampires olympics IFC Films Warner Bros. GIFs Hulu elevated horror Television Academy sitcom wonder woman sequels Masterpiece Cartoon Network 2016 twilight italian directors Star Trek crime thriller child's play Rocky die hard spy thriller Prime Video Legendary 71st Emmy Awards casting Endgame Action CBS All Access VOD criterion Mudbound finale Travel Channel Set visit Academy Awards Trailer king kong Trivia posters Apple based on movie 2021 Women's History Month documentary dceu fresh new york comic book movies Thanksgiving revenge discovery hollywood remakes black Cosplay Video Games Musicals marvel cinematic universe Pride Month documentaries stand-up comedy DC streaming service new zealand dexter 2018 New York Comic Con TV One travel concert 2015 archives ViacomCBS Lucasfilm animated Sci-Fi adaptation international game show Amazon Freeform scorecard Awards Tour king arthur saw Acorn TV romance anime Marathons jamie lee curtis Netflix CBS biography tv talk IMDb TV stop motion GoT Fall TV streaming movies mcc satire YouTube Premium binge FOX APB Calendar Nickelodeon DC Comics crossover 90s Amazon Prime medical drama Winter TV Family BBC One children's TV The Purge slasher Peacock book Holiday aapi Spectrum Originals Disney Channel Tokyo Olympics ABC Extras Paramount Funimation PlayStation suspense dreamworks The Academy The Arrangement period drama prank rotten movies we love BBC America spider-man San Diego Comic-Con docudrama Netflix Christmas movies sag awards Quiz Discovery Channel YouTube Red comic book movie screenings Vudu Podcast CNN El Rey AMC Plus worst scene in color Pet Sematary Star Wars Winners Nat Geo nbcuniversal aliens toy story Universal 2020 Starz Sony Pictures politics Comedy Central The Walt Disney Company legend reviews cops HFPA cancelled TV series space golden globe awards cinemax Hallmark Rock dragons rt archives Valentine's Day Tarantino what to watch popular thriller canceled mob 24 frames supernatural BAFTA high school monster movies james bond a nightmare on elm street BET docuseries zombie art house hispanic heritage month feel good NBA TruTV boxing south america emmy awards mutant Crunchyroll Tumblr batman Film Festival comedies BBC Sundance TV talk show Kids & Family Classic Film Martial Arts HBO Go Hallmark Christmas movies singing competition Tags: Comedy green book Paramount Network Broadway HBO Max black comedy FXX spanish Lifetime festivals Emmys Binge Guide Photos 99%