Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2 Is Criminally Unfunny

Plus, Unfriended offers solid thrills, Monkey Kingdom shines, and Game of Thrones is Certified Fresh.

by | April 16, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a silly security guard (Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2, starring Kevin James and Raini Rodriguez), tech-savvy teens (Unfriended, starring Shelley Hennig and Renee Olstead), and parental primates (the Disneynature documentary Monkey Kingdom). What do the critics have to say?

Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2


Despite a lukewarm reception from critics, Paul Blart: Mall Cop was a sizeable box office hit. So naturally, we’re treated to Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2, which critics say lacks even the modest charms of its predecessor — it’s indifferently performed, tonally jumbled, and almost entirely bereft of laughs. Kevin James returns as the self-important Blart, who’s been invited to a security guard convention in Vegas. Will our hero overcome gluttony and boorishness to thwart a brazen art heist and rescue his kidnapped daughter? The pundits say Paul Blart: Mall Cop 2 is a startlingly empty experience, one that James’ inherent likability does little to enliven. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most critically-panned second installments.)



At first blush, Unfriended sounds pretty gimmicky: it’s a horror movie that consists entirely of footage from its teenage characters’ computer screens. However, critics say the result is smart and deeply unsettling, a clever thriller that has a thing or two to say about teen angst and modern communication. The plot: on the anniversary of a classmate’s death, a group of high schoolers are being hunted — via Skype — by her malevolent spirit. The pundits say Unfriended is an intelligent blend of form and content that feels utterly contemporary. (Watch our video interview with the cast here.)

Monkey Kingdom


Who doesn’t love monkeys? Critics say Monkey Kingdom might be Disneynature’s best film to date, and its breathtaking footage of primates in the wild makes for action-packed viewing. Narrated by Tina Fey, the film follows a group of toque macaques who live in the Sri Lankan jungle near an abandoned temple, with special attention paid to a single mother and her child who are trying to fit in with their new community. The pundits say Monkey Kingdom‘s stars are a playful, colorful bunch, and if the film sometimes anthropomorphizes them, they’re still likely to please animal lovers of all ages.

What’s On TV:

Bloody action and extreme power plays return full throttle, as Game of Thrones (Certified Fresh at 97 percent) enjoys a new-found liberation from the world of the source material, resulting in more unexpected thrills.

With tight adherence to its source material’s history, high production quality, and a no-nonsense dramatic flair, Marvel’s Daredevil (Certified Fresh at 97 percent) excels as an effective superhero origin story, a gritty procedural, and an exciting action adventure.

Beautifully filmed and brilliantly acted, Wolf Hall (Certified Fresh at 100 percent) masterfully brings Hilary Mantel’s award-winning novels to life.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Alex of Venice, starring Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Chris Messina in a drama about a woman who reinvents herself after her divorce, is at 82 percent.
  • The Oscar-nominated anti-war drama Tangerines, about two immigrant farmers who refuse to abandon their crops even with war on the horizon, is at 75 percent.
  • Felix & Meira, a drama about the tentative romance between a middle-aged atheist and a married Hasidic woman, is at 73 percent.
  • The Dead Lands, an adventure film about a Maori warrior who seeks to avenge his father’s murder and stave off an attack from a rival tribe, is at 60 percent.
  • True Story, a drama about a journalist working on a story about an accused killer who used the reporter’s name as an alias, is at 50 percent (check out our interview with stars Jonah Hill and James Franco).
  • Beyond The Reach, starring Michael Douglas in a thriller about a billionaire hunter who frames his guide for murder after accidentally shooting a man, is at 35 percent.
  • Child 44, starring Tom Hardy and Noomi Rapace in a period drama about a Soviet secret police agent on the trail of a serial killer, is at 23 percent.
  • Monsters: Dark Continent, a sci-fi action film about a platoon of American soldiers who must fight off an alien attack, is at 22 percent.
  • The Squeeze, starring Jeremy Sumpter and Christopher McDonald in a dramedy about three troubled young people who escape an institution and go on a road trip, is at 14 percent.
  • The Road Within, starring Dev Patel and Zöe Kravitz in a dramedy about three troubled young people who escape an institution and go on a road trip, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

teaser Warner Bros. VICE Trivia 72 Emmy Awards sopranos FOX Holidays Pixar streaming spinoff crossover reboot Writers Guild of America ID Nickelodeon MCU razzies Super Bowl independent superman Winter TV scene in color series jurassic park dark Tarantino Cosplay Sundance 21st Century Fox Spring TV war WGN PBS New York Comic Con Tumblr 79th Golden Globes Awards Endgame talk show prank mcc NBC all-time Year in Review Awards 94th Oscars kids disaster golden globe awards dexter See It Skip It DirecTV strong female leads 2016 emmy awards Action Star Trek asian-american BBC One Geeked Week Spectrum Originals Pacific Islander ESPN social media OWN Starz PlayStation IMDb TV werewolf summer TV Amazon Studios Music supernatural spider-man APB period drama VH1 Apple TV Plus christmas movies latino Ellie Kemper BBC America HBO ratings Arrowverse anthology History fast and furious 2021 cancelled TV series broadcast LGBTQ directors Tags: Comedy Elton John Sony Pride Month toronto comedies A24 sag awards Superheroe interviews godzilla USA Network superhero Captain marvel festivals crime Broadway First Reviews Amazon Prime Video Nat Geo Thanksgiving Sundance TV pirates of the caribbean rt archives renewed TV shows technology Film Festival 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Chernobyl wonder woman Turner Classic Movies Trailer new york Anna Paquin BET Awards obituary First Look Esquire Adult Swim Brie Larson Stephen King TIFF cartoon Paramount Plus justice league The Witch trophy witnail Marvel Studios romance politics Women's History Month critic resources monster movies dceu E3 Polls and Games comic book movies DGA The Walking Dead Classic Film live event Sci-Fi Video Games hidden camera sitcom Britbox National Geographic diversity NBA 4/20 cancelled TV shows Christmas batman rt labs Tomatazos satire El Rey TV One Acorn TV television Biopics Amazon 73rd Emmy Awards Oscar nfl comic feel good sequel australia Fall TV Turner jamie lee curtis TCA Winter 2020 20th Century Fox Kids & Family children's TV PaleyFest new star wars movies true crime BAFTA screen actors guild psycho Vudu cancelled television slashers facebook Native Best Director Marathons Fox Searchlight harry potter docuseries posters leaderboard Animation dragons scene in color film series Universal Pictures venice criterion zombie Fargo Ghostbusters Mary poppins Tokyo Olympics gangster YA theme song Netflix Family documentary parents 2019 italian FX on Hulu rotten Shudder travel DC streaming service 93rd Oscars target worst movies Spike trailers Discovery Channel Mystery Food Network ViacomCBS Mudbound composers HBO Go binge Best Actor Star Wars crime thriller adenture YouTube TCA 2017 black comedy Funimation Grammys concert BET scary transformers green book SDCC Crackle new zealand Academy Awards south america comics hist Box Office Marvel Television Election high school Image Comics Heroines Reality Competition Disney streaming service TNT deadpool Summer CMT twilight WarnerMedia french ABC Family Crunchyroll AMC Plus Hulu know your critic king arthur news Lucasfilm USA SXSW slasher spanish robots Ovation japanese fresh vs. zero dark thirty Fox News cancelled die hard The Walt Disney Company action-comedy rom-coms classics Pop halloween cults Lifetime Christmas movies Legendary Red Carpet festival TruTV 007 comic book movie Bravo free movies Mary Tyler Moore screenings royal family worst Valentine's Day telelvision what to watch Song of Ice and Fire saw book adaptation movies football Epix stand-up comedy streamig Countdown Baby Yoda aapi Horror San Diego Comic-Con basketball LGBT TLC Mindy Kaling canceled cooking cars 1990s YouTube Premium Sony Pictures Columbia Pictures sequels Paramount dramedy black TCM japan Best and Worst Film TCA Awards Hear Us Out police drama marvel cinematic universe BBC ABC Cannes young adult Avengers laika genre Disney+ Disney Plus marvel comics CBS IFC Certified Fresh Best Picture kong Comedy Central Amazon Prime Universal a nightmare on elm street animated Sneak Peek Instagram Live Shondaland Western summer TV preview Emmy Nominations boxoffice 2015 child's play Paramount Network FXX Prime Video Comedy Toys revenge 99% dreamworks olympics game show rotten movies we love singing competition game of thrones Oscars 71st Emmy Awards Quiz Comics on TV spider-verse Awards Tour ghosts kaiju Martial Arts richard e. Grant cinemax MGM crime drama lord of the rings space 24 frames Black History Month canceled TV shows toy story Trophy Talk 2020 Interview natural history Peacock Apple art house SundanceTV Disney RT21 E! GIFs Drama indie The Arrangement indiana jones dc king kong TV movies streaming movies Lifetime AMC Calendar critics series Disney Channel Creative Arts Emmys CW Seed Watching Series james bond Rom-Com Tubi international GLAAD FX aliens sports Masterpiece Indigenous TBS nature target scene in color Photos Freeform book medical drama psychological thriller mutant Podcast OneApp Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VOD Pirates cops cats Walt Disney Pictures archives Television Critics Association versus scorecard nbcuniversal breaking bad Paramount Pictures Hollywood Foreign Press Association Dark Horse Comics Cartoon Network Syfy hispanic spain Reality Exclusive Video stop motion CNN docudrama Winners Travel Channel women based on movie chucky X-Men 45 Apple TV+ rt labs critics edition Country HBO Max boxing biopic MTV documentaries adventure thriller Extras debate Opinion universal monsters Neflix award winner Schedule reviews mob Netflix Christmas movies serial killer halloween tv miniseries A&E Musicals Wes Anderson Comic Book blaxploitation remakes 2017 dogs Alien biography Showtime Best Actress Infographic Star Wars Celebration Focus Features anime quibi hispanic heritage month Pop TV adaptation RT History Pet Sematary obi wan mission: impossible Black Mirror Lionsgate discovery spanish language Logo vampires comic books Character Guide ABC Signature Fantasy scene in color Emmys summer preview DC Comics SXSW 2022 YouTube Red American Society of Cinematographers 2018 movie Holiday TCA tv talk NYCC finale Chilling Adventures of Sabrina President TV Land Superheroes romantic comedy DC Universe hollywood TV renewals doctor who Musical MSNBC Teen legend Mary Poppins Returns comiccon Television Academy science fiction Rocketman heist movie 90s ITV popular Binge Guide IFC Films video historical drama Sundance Now joker elevated horror blockbuster films Premiere Dates Rocky video on demand spy thriller Hallmark Christmas movies live action scary movies political drama zombies Marvel Rock Comic-Con@Home 2021 blockbusters Disney Plus best golden globes The CW Set visit name the review GoT The Purge South by Southwest Film Festival mockumentary foreign franchise stoner CBS All Access suspense unscripted Hallmark casting Nominations TV HFPA The Academy