Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Nightcrawler is Certified Fresh

Plus, Before I Go to Sleep is well-crafted but too slack; Saw gets a 10th anniversary rerelease; and we tell you what's Fresh on TV.

by | October 30, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a crime reporter (Nightcrawler, starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Rene Russo), a troubled amnesiac (Before I Go to Sleep, starring Nicole Kidman and Colin Firth), and a sadistic killer (the 10th anniversary rerelease of Saw, starring Cary Elwes and Danny Glover). What do the critics have to say?. What do the critics have to say?



A creepy, tense thriller about a nocturnal obsessive or a satire of the 24-hour news cycle? Critics say Nightcrawler is a terrific blend of both, with a live-wire performance from Jake Gyllenhaal and an evocative, sinister sense of place. Gyllenhaal stars as Lou Bloom, a freelance TV journalist who sells lurid crime footage to a local station. But as his career progresses, and his scoops become ever more explosive, Bloom’s shaky ethics threaten to overwhelm him. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Nightcrawler is so taut, atmospheric, and well-acted, you might not even notice the leaps in narrative logic.

Before I Go to Sleep


Before I Go to Sleep boasts an intriguing premise, a top-notch cast, and slick, sleek production values. So how could it miss? The answer, say critics, is that the film’s fine performances are in service to a plot that starts strong but strains credulity as it goes along. Nicole Kidman stars as a woman who wakes up every day with no memory of her past — the tragic result of an accident. But when she makes a shocking discovery, our heroine delves into the secrets of her past while trying to determine who she can trust. The pundits say Before I Go to Sleep often gets by on chilly atmosphere and the strength of Kidman’s performance, but it doesn’t quite achieve the chilly heights it’s aiming for.



Ten years ago, before the term “torture porn” had even been invented, Saw hit theaters awash in Sundance buzz and comparisons to Se7en. The critics were split: some found it to be brutal and clever, while others simply found it depraved. Half a dozen sequels followed, but none could approach the original Saw in terms of novelty or (moderate) critical acclaim. If you’ve ever wanted to enter the twisted world of diabolical killer Jigsaw in a darkened roomful of screaming strangers, now’s your chance: Saw is hitting theaters to celebrate its 10th anniversary.

What’s Fresh on TV:

Critics are still mixed on Gotham‘s overall tone, but most found “The Spirit of the Goat” (67 percent) to be a step in the right direction, thanks in part to much-needed character details about Oswald Cobblepot and Detective Bullock.

Creepy atmosphere, high-stakes action, and splendid special effects combine with a welcome touch of humor to overcome narrative flaws and present a version of Constantine (69 percent) that’s close to his comics counterpart.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Revenge of the Mekons, a rockumentary about the cultishly adored British indie band, is at 100 percent.

  • Jean-Luc Godard‘s Goodbye to Language 3D, an atmospheric meditation on the nature of communication, is at 89 percent.

  • The Great Invisible, a documentary about the explosion of the Deepwater Horizon oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico, is at 84 percent.

  • Point and Shoot, a documentary about a Baltimore man whose five-year tour of the Middle East included a stint in the Libyan Revolution, is at 71 percent.

  • ABCs of Death 2, a 26-chapter anthology horror film that takes another crack at alphabetical terror, is at 68 percent.

  • Private Peaceful, a period drama about two brothers whose loyalties are tested amidst the fog of World War I, is at 65 percent.

  • Magical Universe, a documentary about an eccentric octogenarian outsider artist, is at 60 percent.

  • Horns, starring Daniel Radcliffe and Juno Temple in a fantasy thriller about a man who’s been accused of a crime and finds horns with astonishing powers growing out of his head, is at 48 percent.

  • Missionary, a thriller about a woman who tries to break off her extramarital affair with a missionionary when she reunites with her estranged husband, is at 38 percent.

  • Hit By Lightning, starring Jon Cryer and Will Sasso in a comedy about a guy who meets the perfect woman only to discover she wants to kill her husband, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

CNN Focus Features psycho marvel comics Exclusive Video olympics satire rt labs critics edition target scene in color Dark Horse Comics 2020 Black History Month VOD comics rt archives Mindy Kaling Television Academy TBS book movie spider-verse NBC RT History PlayStation nbcuniversal 45 elevated horror Nickelodeon Epix archives Sony franchise worst movies 1990s BBC Best Actor HBO Best Director Mudbound free movies versus Amazon Prime Video mutant marvel cinematic universe CBS Pop TV debate obituary Oscar Amazon Studios Emmy Nominations Paramount Network HBO Max cancelled TV series south america Music GoT latino adaptation TV movies Country video on demand Acorn TV MSNBC slashers concert Logo new york Binge Guide vampires Film political drama AMC Plus E3 20th Century Fox Baby Yoda saw halloween tv Thanksgiving space tv talk spanish thriller 4/20 Vudu 007 YouTube Premium facebook Superheroe king arthur boxoffice Rocky dragons halloween adventure Television Critics Association Kids & Family Lionsgate screenings Family Sundance Now Disney streaming service justice league aliens popular Warner Bros. deadpool LGBT Ellie Kemper gangster YouTube Red zero dark thirty universal monsters Fox Searchlight binge heist movie Hallmark First Look independent Lifetime interviews jamie lee curtis Sneak Peek Opinion Disney Plus reboot South by Southwest Film Festival Spectrum Originals Turner Classic Movies ITV critic resources batman Video Games Chilling Adventures of Sabrina theme song Shondaland Comics on TV comic book movies Tomatazos natural history Britbox Freeform A&E See It Skip It Legendary golden globe awards 2019 trailers telelvision Paramount Pictures Hollywood Foreign Press Association razzies screen actors guild reviews sequels composers dc GLAAD stand-up comedy Hulu Columbia Pictures BET Awards sequel summer preview Tarantino summer TV preview Box Office breaking bad biography Masterpiece Rom-Com Marvel Television Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt king kong anime NYCC suspense Infographic cars DC Universe singing competition TV emmy awards scene in color Awards Arrowverse IMDb TV sitcom dreamworks Musical spider-man Trivia crime thriller superhero BBC One streaming Pacific Islander children's TV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards comedies witnail spanish language Polls and Games Holidays Writers Guild of America crime drama Turner slasher comiccon Summer Song of Ice and Fire BBC America Mystery New York Comic Con Netflix Christmas movies Holiday Travel Channel Lucasfilm mockumentary vs. hist SXSW 2022 24 frames rt labs directors medical drama 71st Emmy Awards nature Horror CMT Sci-Fi Grammys YouTube zombie 94th Oscars 2016 italian Election 2021 Comic-Con@Home 2021 2017 FX on Hulu cinemax discovery Academy Awards all-time sopranos Indigenous Super Bowl venice Rocketman Hallmark Christmas movies Fox News werewolf TCM Adult Swim live event mission: impossible know your critic 72 Emmy Awards Best Picture indie video harry potter BET Native Trailer Nominations Women's History Month Marathons kaiju sports Wes Anderson scorecard cults green book Peacock spinoff DGA WGN MTV posters Rock technology fresh SundanceTV dexter nfl scene in color series Classic Film Winter TV art house Brie Larson The Witch VICE TCA Winter 2020 hispanic National Geographic Apple TV Plus cats RT21 The Arrangement what to watch Paramount Plus Sony Pictures The Academy Reality APB 2015 Comic Book Tags: Comedy Netflix war Reality Competition worst superman broadcast docuseries twilight MCU Fantasy The CW science fiction El Rey comic cartoon Comedy Central Character Guide Awards Tour talk show kong rotten dceu crime FOX disaster football aapi Avengers cancelled TV shows Crunchyroll australia TCA 2017 young adult blockbuster Photos best toy story Image Comics Tubi Spring TV Chernobyl streamig Amazon 73rd Emmy Awards based on movie OWN police drama joker finale Stephen King Star Wars boxing adenture summer TV 79th Golden Globes Awards Year in Review a nightmare on elm street chucky Film Festival Black Mirror ghosts Disney Channel game of thrones revenge indiana jones romantic comedy lord of the rings miniseries criterion TLC international quibi TNT remakes movies Cartoon Network wonder woman LGBTQ OneApp hidden camera ID target french TIFF films scary book adaptation monster movies BAFTA Drama Set visit Watching Series Hear Us Out PBS Apple anthology Emmys blockbusters Spike Funimation Endgame Star Trek Neflix Pet Sematary Captain marvel Valentine's Day Western TCA Awards television TV Land HFPA comic books action-comedy spain Tokyo Olympics HBO Go Cosplay travel Ghostbusters USA Network SDCC rom-coms Biopics FXX Sundance Walt Disney Pictures scary movies Comedy The Purge obi wan Teen zombies historical drama animated child's play Showtime YA First Reviews feel good SXSW Best and Worst Mary Poppins Returns legend Disney dramedy 99% name the review DC Comics Premiere Dates IFC Films History President royal family Nat Geo Winners CW Seed ratings jurassic park WarnerMedia ABC PaleyFest Geeked Week E! casting hollywood TCA laika ABC Signature biopic Paramount critics NBA robots golden globes FX festivals Trophy Talk scene in color film series die hard Anna Paquin Bravo japanese new zealand canceled TruTV Disney+ Disney Plus Interview ESPN Superheroes series Universal Pictures Heroines Oscars American Society of Cinematographers CBS All Access Certified Fresh genre politics Shudder prank 21st Century Fox Universal Action fast and furious black comedy game show stoner serial killer diversity A24 Esquire docudrama Prime Video Mary poppins psychological thriller japan The Walking Dead GIFs mcc Broadway Pride Month asian-american Discovery Channel Countdown comic book movie romance Musicals sag awards Calendar rotten movies we love new star wars movies live action trophy IFC documentary festival Fall TV Pixar mob Creative Arts Emmys james bond Marvel richard e. Grant period drama Elton John Lifetime Christmas movies toronto Extras Martial Arts Quiz unscripted news blaxploitation cops X-Men teaser ABC Family crossover pirates of the caribbean Toys TV One Pop streaming movies Christmas DirecTV renewed TV shows christmas movies Marvel Studios AMC cancelled television godzilla canceled TV shows Cannes MGM classics Pirates The Walt Disney Company supernatural doctor who Fargo 2018 Animation true crime Food Network social media Mary Tyler Moore Syfy cooking cancelled DC streaming service dark kids Red Carpet Apple TV+ VH1 90s Instagram Live transformers Alien hispanic heritage month 93rd Oscars Star Wars Celebration strong female leads TV renewals Starz documentaries women ViacomCBS Best Actress parents spy thriller Crackle dogs high school Sundance TV black basketball Podcast Schedule award winner USA Amazon Prime Tumblr Ovation leaderboard foreign stop motion San Diego Comic-Con