Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Moneyball is Certified Fresh

Plus, Dolphin Tale inspires, Killer Elite wanders, and Abduction sags.

by | September 23, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got baseball nerds (Moneyball, starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill), aquatic rehab (Dolphin Tale, starring Harry Connick Jr. and Morgan Freeman), an assassin-dodging teen (Abduction, starring Taylor Lautner and Lily Collins), and a tough-guy showdown (Killer Elite, starring Jason Statham and Clive Owen). What do the critics have to say?



Do you love The Natural, but wish the movie had found time to take a closer look at Roy Hobbs’s OPS and weighted on base average? Well then, Moneyball is the movie for you, and critics say it’s a moving, witty underdog tale that somehow manages to find drama in baseball stat geekdom. Oakland Athletics General Manager Billy Beane (Brad Pitt) is tasked with fielding a competitive team on a small-market budget. His solution is to ignore traditional scouting methods and focus almost exclusively on obscure statistics that measure players’ abilities in ways that have been overlooked by other teams. Will Beane’s feather-ruffling approach be accepted in the staid world of Major League Baseball — and more importantly, will it yield results on the field? The pundits say the Certified Fresh Moneyball is a smart dramedy with excellent performances and a razor-sharp script that is likely to appeal to folks who don’t know the first thing about our national pastime. (Check out our countdown of the best baseball movies here.)

Dolphin Tale


In these cynical times, we could use some good old fashioned inspirational family entertainment at the multiplex. And critics say the pleasant, uplifting Dolphin Tale fits the bill, thanks to solid acting and a script that manages to avoid schmaltz and still jerk tears. Based upon a true story, Dolphin Tale is the story of an injured seafaring mammal who damages her tail in a crab trap. A team of specialists and a lonely youngster band together to help our aquatic heroine — now sporting a prosthetic tail — to swim again. The pundits say Dolphin Tale deftly avoids the corniness that could have weighed it down, and the result is a heartwarming film that will please both kids and adults.



Given his high-profile gig in the Twilight franchise, it was inevitable that Taylor Lautner would get his own starring vehicle. Unfortunately, critics say he could have chosen a better one than Abduction, a predictable, mediocre thriller that never slows down long enough to make sense. Launter plays Nathan Harper, who learns that the family he’s living with is not his own. Soon, he’s on the run from an elite group of assassins, and he tries to piece together his mysterious past while staying one step ahead of his pursuers. The pundits say Abduction is Bourne-lite, with unintentionally funny dialogue and an absurdly complicated plot that strands a talented cast. (Check out Lautner’s Five Favorite Films here.)

Killer Elite


Killer Elite is a globe-trotting action flick with a top-notch cast and more on its mind than your typical thriller. Unfortunately, critics say those intriguing pieces don’t add up to a satisfying whole, and Killer Elite is ultimately a formulaic adrenaline-fest with a plot that wanders all over the place. Jason Statham plays Danny Bryce, a hired gun on the edge of retirement who’s lured back into action when his mentor Hunter (Robert De Niro) is taken hostage. Our hero must finish the job Hunter was contracted to do, but soon he’s run afoul with a rogue group of soldiers lead by Spike (Clive Owen), who’s now gunning for Danny. The pundits say Killer Elite has macho attitude to spare, but its execution is off, and the result is an overlong and confusing film that raises interesting moral questions without answering them. (Check this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Statham’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Weekend, a romantic drama about two men who meet and share their lives over the course of 48 hours, is at 100 percent.

  • Thunder Soul, a documentary about Houston’s astonishingly funky Kashmere High School Stage Band, is at 100 percent.

  • Pearl Jam Twenty, Cameron Crowe‘s documentary portrait of the grunge superstars, is at 71 percent.

  • Limelight, a doc about the rise and fall of New York nightclub impresario Peter Gatien, is at 71 percent.

  • The Whale, a doc about a killer whale who befriends some residents of Vancouver Island after being separated from his family, is at 67 percent.

  • Puncture, starring Chris Evans in a drama about a drug addicted lawyer who investigates a health care and pharmaceutical industry conspiracy, is at 57 percent.

  • Archie’s Final Project, dramedy about a high school filmmaker who announces he’s going to kill himself on camera, is at 40 percent.

  • Machine Gun Preacher, starring Gerard Butler in a drama about a former biker and born-again Christian who goes to Sudan to save as many children as he can, is at 29 percent.

Tag Cloud

OWN SundanceTV universal monsters vampires BET AMC Plus DC streaming service Amazon Studios sag awards Comedy Central BBC french unscripted Pirates zombie black comedy DGA transformers Stephen King Drama Warner Bros. adventure Year in Review TLC Alien HBO Go Best Actor stoner Rocky Geeked Week saw Indigenous CBS quibi news 94th Oscars Nominations 99% Syfy Pixar hidden camera trailers 2019 Amazon Prime Video talk show cancelled reboot what to watch natural history Premiere Dates robots aapi 21st Century Fox basketball critic resources children's TV blaxploitation Baby Yoda movies ViacomCBS ESPN 2016 Avengers Family indie YouTube Premium telelvision Holiday witnail marvel cinematic universe pirates of the caribbean sitcom space series festival Rocketman Marathons Fall TV psycho cats chucky vs. nbcuniversal Starz TCM true crime Song of Ice and Fire archives video biopic war tv talk TNT Paramount Pictures Set visit cartoon TCA 2017 Hollywood Foreign Press Association Awards Tour Crunchyroll Rock Disney CW Seed A&E New York Comic Con concert king kong American Society of Cinematographers Pop TV TCA Winter 2020 supernatural Epix The CW MGM popular Fantasy Winter TV summer preview Character Guide live action interviews leaderboard Black History Month Countdown classics politics new zealand Neflix anthology Shudder comedies rom-coms YouTube Red E! Cosplay Box Office teaser TV renewals Horror X-Men OneApp Star Trek stop motion romantic comedy Musical ABC RT21 game show TBS stand-up comedy The Walt Disney Company Bravo 72 Emmy Awards historical drama art house australia Best Actress DC Comics Tumblr discovery Sneak Peek Tomatazos japan Rom-Com child's play Tokyo Olympics cults criterion Fox News Disney Plus broadcast Lifetime Christmas movies 2015 The Walking Dead Polls and Games olympics Best Picture worst Mary poppins halloween tv docudrama Crackle king arthur USA scary movies Sundance Quiz a nightmare on elm street CMT award winner Prime Video summer TV Podcast scary joker finale Native Amazon Prime posters Sundance TV rotten Paramount Network television Discovery Channel CBS All Access Election Video Games Spike NBA animated know your critic WGN twilight 71st Emmy Awards sequels nature streaming movies new york Nat Geo 2018 Funimation Cartoon Network Hear Us Out Film Festival Thanksgiving spy thriller crime 2020 MTV franchise Hulu mockumentary breaking bad wonder woman obituary movie prank documentaries rt labs critics edition game of thrones IFC Films all-time National Geographic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 79th Golden Globes Awards documentary rt archives comic book movies Mystery elevated horror scene in color film series science fiction cancelled TV series TIFF History NYCC italian justice league PBS miniseries SXSW 2022 toronto Nickelodeon emmy awards diversity TV movies social media APB spider-verse boxing Ovation PaleyFest Shondaland marvel comics TV One Ellie Kemper international 73rd Emmy Awards dogs scene in color series Music Comedy RT History Holidays godzilla werewolf travel Tags: Comedy fast and furious biography Television Critics Association Britbox Writers Guild of America Paramount VICE Winners GoT Image Comics Tubi anime Mary Poppins Returns golden globe awards nfl Comic Book Comics on TV Pacific Islander Disney+ Disney Plus 20th Century Fox Anna Paquin Schedule police drama Reality trophy Legendary MCU Cannes ABC Signature singing competition Binge Guide feel good adaptation A24 Turner Red Carpet Arrowverse zero dark thirty canceled TV shows Action foreign dceu satire comic 007 The Witch Western YouTube Captain marvel Mudbound streamig Amazon Disney Channel Fox Searchlight Summer worst movies action-comedy Pet Sematary Apple Classic Film TV Land Sci-Fi Biopics deadpool high school Endgame theme song monster movies suspense Apple TV Plus cinemax Food Network debate rt labs Broadway jurassic park VH1 venice crime drama name the review Interview book adaptation Mindy Kaling Sony Pictures scene in color SXSW Trophy Talk Peacock parents HBO Max IMDb TV Spectrum Originals ratings 90s Wes Anderson Lionsgate political drama Watching Series Film versus target Superheroes Martial Arts Star Wars doctor who ITV Apple TV+ BET Awards GIFs Heroines Fargo MSNBC Logo sequel Chernobyl ID FXX YA TCA blockbuster Exclusive Video Best and Worst Hallmark Reality Competition TCA Awards mutant films slasher The Arrangement 24 frames BBC One kong Freeform hollywood canceled Christmas critics Star Wars Celebration summer TV preview Oscar Columbia Pictures Creative Arts Emmys dc book batman Marvel Studios south america Kids & Family james bond mcc See It Skip It Sony First Look screen actors guild crime thriller Hallmark Christmas movies fresh cancelled TV shows lord of the rings Spring TV kaiju LGBT superman harry potter black facebook Tarantino TruTV Instagram Live Netflix Christmas movies free movies cops disaster HBO Superheroe FX GLAAD PlayStation superhero Best Director rotten movies we love 1990s Grammys renewed TV shows Focus Features target scene in color South by Southwest Film Festival streaming latino asian-american golden globes Mary Tyler Moore Valentine's Day Calendar 2021 technology sports mission: impossible binge Marvel Television medical drama scorecard The Purge composers obi wan slashers Extras comics gangster remakes football spanish revenge 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards legend boxoffice Brie Larson Walt Disney Pictures Opinion Disney streaming service based on movie Adult Swim dramedy sopranos Academy Awards green book LGBTQ Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Universal Pictures El Rey Elton John Photos best aliens Emmy Nominations psychological thriller strong female leads HFPA thriller NBC zombies romance cancelled television IFC Trivia hispanic heritage month Acorn TV Trailer Sundance Now President casting live event razzies toy story hispanic spanish language adenture jamie lee curtis laika independent BBC America spinoff Teen Awards 93rd Oscars comic book movie VOD Turner Classic Movies richard e. Grant kids young adult halloween Women's History Month comic books spain crossover women CNN Esquire Universal screenings Netflix blockbusters Black Mirror Marvel Oscars BAFTA SDCC genre serial killer heist movie E3 DC Universe festivals The Academy 45 die hard royal family video on demand Pop San Diego Comic-Con Pride Month TV ABC Family Lucasfilm Infographic indiana jones FOX Vudu directors new star wars movies reviews Television Academy Animation Certified Fresh comiccon Travel Channel Dark Horse Comics dark hist ghosts dragons First Reviews period drama 4/20 Comic-Con@Home 2021 Toys japanese FX on Hulu cooking Emmys DirecTV USA Network AMC Super Bowl WarnerMedia docuseries 2017 Lifetime mob Musicals Masterpiece spider-man Ghostbusters christmas movies Country Showtime cars dreamworks dexter Paramount Plus