Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Killing Them Softly Is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Collection improves a bit on its predecessor.

by | November 29, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an efficient enforcer (Killing Them Softly, starring Brad Pitt and Richard Jenkins) and a methodical madman (The Collection starring Emma Fitzpatrick and Josh Stewart). What do the critics have to say?

Killing Them Softly


The economic collapse of 2008 didn’t just deep six Wall Street — it put the squeeze on the underground economy as well. That’s the theme of Killing Them Softly, a twisty crime thriller that critics say is sharply written and visually striking, though it occasionally pushes its big ideas too hard. After a couple of incompetent crooks steal from a mafia-sanctioned poker game, the family sends Jackie Cogan (Brad Pitt) to rub them out. However, the mafia’s corporation-like structure makes Jackie’s task more complicated at nearly every turn. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Killing Them Softly doesn’t always match its outsized ambitions, but it’s still a thoughtful, visceral foray into gangland built around Pitt’s magnetic performance. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Pitt’s best-reviewed movies.)

The Collection


The Collection is a sequel to the 2009 frightfest The Collector, and critics say it’s an improvement — it’s a sleek, twisted, and well acted, though it intermittently gets bogged down in predictability and gratuitous bloodiness. Thinking she’s going to a party, Elena (Emma Fitzpatrick) is taken to a mysterious location, only to wind up in the clutches of the murderous Collector. In order to retrieve her, a rescue squad turns to Arkin (Josh Stewart), the only one to ever escape the Collector’s clutches. The pundits say The Collection will please gorehounds with its grisly inventiveness, but others are likely to blanch at its over-the-top violence.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Funimation FOX canceled TV shows Star Trek Rock Disney+ Disney Plus australia GIFs documentaries black comedy SXSW nbcuniversal prank FXX Paramount Logo RT History docudrama Black History Month Lionsgate parents toy story Peacock political drama supernatural Captain marvel Holidays Image Comics ViacomCBS Warner Bros. Awards Tour Hulu spider-man ratings new york cancelled television comic book movies Infographic target Endgame DC Comics legend President TBS diversity jamie lee curtis crime drama revenge italian Disney book Election Hallmark tv talk FX Columbia Pictures Baby Yoda Nominations reboot Mary Poppins Returns Lifetime TCA Netflix Christmas movies 99% king arthur dceu animated superhero heist movie scary movies trophy Marvel Television christmas movies Box Office Amazon Studios nfl pirates of the caribbean Set visit Emmys Heroines 20th Century Fox BET dexter docuseries blockbuster 2020 godzilla critic resources Marvel Studios ITV medical drama BBC biography Exclusive Video TCA 2017 wonder woman werewolf royal family Christmas YA First Look marvel cinematic universe Kids & Family Music Countdown Showtime DC streaming service slashers Amazon Prime Video game of thrones mission: impossible comedies Comedy Central doctor who 2016 cats movie Awards Trivia Instagram Live AMC Plus TV Apple TV+ Emmy Nominations rotten superman SundanceTV crime thriller comiccon TV renewals criterion Tubi ABC Signature miniseries Thanksgiving Drama Opinion news 21st Century Fox international Neflix Syfy Action based on movie FX on Hulu sitcom DC Universe Epix Tumblr genre Reality crime biopic robots south america kong MSNBC Cannes historical drama 2019 Film Festival screen actors guild dc hollywood Sundance Now facebook Podcast Hollywood Foreign Press Association video NYCC Avengers cancelled E! Marvel boxoffice witnail natural history Dark Horse Comics harry potter Photos thriller Tarantino TCA Awards WarnerMedia Family black El Rey documentary sequel fresh stoner Binge Guide Universal Grammys 24 frames Nickelodeon Sundance TV Travel Channel all-time Rom-Com rt labs critics edition spinoff Tags: Comedy 73rd Emmy Awards Britbox 1990s strong female leads directors A24 Bravo comics Academy Awards BBC One zombie scorecard PaleyFest ABC fast and furious 2021 Comic Book know your critic rt labs Disney Channel cancelled TV shows Creative Arts Emmys The Purge YouTube feel good blockbusters free movies Superheroe dragons indiana jones Turner Vudu Winter TV french Tokyo Olympics Shondaland asian-american psycho Red Carpet Pop Television Critics Association dreamworks Interview rotten movies we love stop motion Acorn TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sequels cinemax Polls and Games Biopics basketball Mystery mob suspense rom-coms Spectrum Originals dogs football History adventure vampires comic disaster festivals psychological thriller Freeform talk show mcc Toys APB kaiju satire 007 batman Super Bowl Horror Starz scary ID X-Men American Society of Cinematographers golden globe awards Superheroes TruTV 2017 Shudder lord of the rings The Walking Dead Apple TV Plus quibi Pet Sematary Alien independent emmy awards Mudbound women Oscars period drama BET Awards Premiere Dates Lucasfilm IMDb TV cults 72 Emmy Awards Martial Arts BAFTA art house television Masterpiece Comics on TV cartoon leaderboard The Academy DGA Best and Worst discovery best sag awards Star Wars hist San Diego Comic-Con Marathons marvel comics romantic comedy romance nature Song of Ice and Fire Ghostbusters versus TV One Calendar YouTube Premium OWN child's play indie blaxploitation anthology Nat Geo aapi crossover IFC trailers japan adaptation spanish language travel transformers sopranos Disney Plus adenture Amazon Universal Pictures HFPA Watching Series spider-verse mockumentary A&E children's TV serial killer Crackle Sundance Winners Pirates singing competition halloween tv theme song Mary Tyler Moore Sneak Peek Valentine's Day teaser Brie Larson Chernobyl kids cooking 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards social media Pixar casting GoT zombies Video Games sports what to watch OneApp Legendary Paramount Network The Arrangement Fox News VH1 Amazon Prime war Pride Month scene in color canceled DirecTV Pacific Islander 2018 Spring TV TIFF cars foreign 2015 Tomatazos concert USA Fargo Hallmark Christmas movies young adult rt archives high school TLC saw toronto Turner Classic Movies movies Reality Competition TCA Winter 2020 laika technology AMC hidden camera VICE comic book movie japanese Paramount Plus festival gangster Netflix spy thriller new star wars movies jurassic park PBS National Geographic Black Mirror TV Land Mary poppins razzies a nightmare on elm street popular USA Network worst movies obituary james bond latino Pop TV Crunchyroll NBC Comic-Con@Home 2021 book adaptation mutant Television Academy IFC Films hispanic heritage month 90s TCM Summer Fall TV renewed TV shows First Reviews 4/20 deadpool die hard franchise Wes Anderson breaking bad green book screenings Food Network Schedule golden globes richard e. Grant science fiction space CMT SDCC Ellie Kemper game show WGN Writers Guild of America new zealand Lifetime Christmas movies live event dramedy Hear Us Out VOD Elton John Women's History Month New York Comic Con anime LGBT archives unscripted Sony Pictures Anna Paquin 79th Golden Globes Awards streaming video on demand telelvision Western YouTube Red politics The Walt Disney Company award winner RT21 HBO vs. Rocketman Musicals PlayStation streaming movies true crime series Mindy Kaling Rocky films TNT Teen monster movies 93rd Oscars NBA Animation Fox Searchlight chucky Arrowverse ghosts cops Certified Fresh Disney streaming service Cosplay justice league reviews GLAAD posters Holiday MTV Musical venice E3 Walt Disney Pictures TV movies Spike Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt composers 45 Film slasher king kong debate CBS All Access Extras MCU olympics Country Broadway Fantasy 71st Emmy Awards Quiz Trophy Talk hispanic CBS worst Apple Year in Review The Witch dark comic books HBO Max elevated horror spanish zero dark thirty Sci-Fi name the review Character Guide aliens joker Trailer finale Prime Video LGBTQ critics Esquire ABC Family BBC America See It Skip It HBO Go CNN Adult Swim Ovation police drama live action Stephen King Discovery Channel ESPN cancelled TV series spain twilight remakes universal monsters boxing classics stand-up comedy Classic Film action-comedy Cartoon Network The CW Comedy halloween CW Seed binge