Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Inglourious Basterds is Certified Fresh!

Plus, Shorts, Post Grad, and X Games 3D: The Movie come up short.

by | August 20, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Nazi killers (Quentin Tarantino‘s Inglourious Basterds, starring Brad Pitt), a magic rock (Shorts, starring William H. Macy and Leslie Mann), unemployment blues (Post Grad, starring Alexis Bledel and Michael Keaton), and extreme sports (X Games 3D: The Movie. What do the critics have to say?


Inglourious Basterds

Historians may have plenty of quibbles with Quentin Tarantino’s wild and wooly take on World War II. However, critics have fewer reservations on Inglourious Basterds, calling it an audacious, bravura piece of pulpy pop filmmaking. Brad Pitt stars as the leader of a group of Jewish soldiers who terrorize the Nazis and plot a brilliant plan to put an end to the Third Reich. Meanwhile, a German officer (Christopher Waltz) is hot on the Basterds’ trail. The pundits say Basterds may not be Tarantino at his peak, but it’s perhaps his most loving tribute to cinephilia yet, as well as a bracing, tense exercise in over-the-top action. Like most of Tarantino’s directorial efforts, Inglourious Basterds is Certified Fresh.



Director Robert Rodriguez has seamlessly moved between the worlds of violent adult-themed film (Sin City, From Dusk Till Dawn, Desperado) and more family-oriented fare (the Spy Kids franchise). After working with Quentin Tarantino on 2007’s B-movie tribute Grindhouse, Rodriguez returns this week with another whimsical children’s film, Shorts. In Shorts, an 11-year-old boy named Toe Thompson happens upon a magical rainbow-colored rock that grants wishes to anyone that holds it, and after it falls into the hands of the neighborhood grown-ups, Toe and his friends must band together to save the town from chaos. So far, while some critics have noted the film’s hyperkinetic pace and imaginative premise as strengths, others fail to see any underlying charm and feel the director’s enthusiasm is wasted. (Be sure to check out our interview with Rodriguez from Comic-Con, in which he talks about his own son’s involvement in the project.)


Post Grad

At a time when college graduates are having a tough time finding work, Post Grad seemingly benefits from timeliness. Unfortunately, critics say the film is less about our current economic situation and more about shopworn romantic comedy conventions. Alexis Bledel stars as a grad that has been beaten out of her dream job by her college rival, so she moves back in with her parents — and finds herself torn between two dudes. The pundits say Post Grad is listless and dull, squandering a solid cast that includes Jane Lynch, Michael Keaton, and Carol Burnett on a script that lacks much insight into the heady days of post-collegiate life, and worse, one that is woefully short on laughs.


X-Games 3D: The Movie

When the X Games held its first annual competition nearly 15 years ago, some dismissed it as a novelty act, while others clearly foresaw its potential to explode worldwide. Now a legitimate sporting event, the extreme sports exhibition has spawned several similar competitions and garnered coverage from the likes of ESPN and ABC Sports, so it’s only natural that the next step would be a feature-length documentary in 3D. X-Games 3D: The Movie mashes together a string of impossible stunts from the various events, sound bites from the biggest names, and a narrative voiceover by Emile Hirsch, but early critical response has been negative overall. Most are saying the film plays out like an extended commercial for the event, offering little beyond what one might find in a typical broadcast of the X-Games besides the novelty of 3D, and its appeal may extend no further than its built-in fans.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Certified Fresh art house DC streaming service remakes CNN canceled TV shows GLAAD Funimation Marvel Studios cartoon FX slasher Marvel Television The Witch versus BBC One game of thrones Trailer Disney streaming service Amazon Prime spy thriller spanish language psycho comic books Disney+ Disney Plus war cancelled television Sundance rom-coms singing competition tv talk what to watch YA TV Land reboot TCM Adult Swim 79th Golden Globes Awards godzilla Song of Ice and Fire HFPA Trophy Talk young adult blockbusters Legendary 93rd Oscars twilight Columbia Pictures Paramount Plus Film south america Bravo a nightmare on elm street historical drama mob Ellie Kemper Western concert films CMT trophy Premiere Dates HBO Go medical drama boxoffice critics zombie ABC Trivia Kids & Family MTV Star Trek 45 Esquire 21st Century Fox canceled Tags: Comedy LGBT parents Wes Anderson miniseries revenge Logo Rock chucky christmas movies crime thriller IFC Prime Video boxing IMDb TV universal monsters Baby Yoda Endgame video on demand USA Network National Geographic Mary Tyler Moore Calendar sequels comiccon technology dc BAFTA heist movie TCA 2017 Amazon Studios Paramount Network marvel comics rt labs critics edition new york HBO indie PBS OWN period drama sitcom Tumblr science fiction Photos Super Bowl justice league Showtime Lionsgate 2015 BET Awards E! 2018 Fox News toronto japan YouTube Premium game show First Reviews mcc Lifetime Oscars indiana jones 99% blaxploitation Superheroe target live event stand-up comedy ABC Signature RT21 werewolf Pirates Drama superhero saw The Walt Disney Company dark Britbox nbcuniversal serial killer renewed TV shows Emmy Nominations docudrama Mindy Kaling FX on Hulu social media hispanic heritage month scary movies telelvision royal family classics Binge Guide comic fast and furious rt archives The Academy Amazon Prime Video Creative Arts Emmys Family hidden camera Mudbound adaptation Brie Larson archives Country Crackle dogs MCU Cannes biopic nature talk show MSNBC Sundance Now children's TV Interview NYCC doctor who Turner Nominations hispanic ratings golden globes Chilling Adventures of Sabrina monster movies Valentine's Day diversity Apple new zealand Masterpiece mockumentary Awards Tour Nat Geo Pet Sematary 72 Emmy Awards Watching Series joker slashers Lifetime Christmas movies Hallmark Christmas movies TV One Food Network TIFF casting action-comedy GoT razzies series Classic Film Sony Pictures Warner Bros. Teen prank kids italian know your critic adventure TV movies RT History women crime Cosplay TCA Winter 2020 biography disaster king kong The CW cancelled GIFs WGN Fall TV franchise VICE sopranos El Rey rotten Countdown Sneak Peek Spring TV X-Men cinemax WarnerMedia politics spider-man Starz Tubi venice VH1 anthology natural history sag awards Discovery Channel crossover Instagram Live Avengers Opinion aliens black Mystery Video Games criterion TNT dramedy robots comic book movie Emmys spanish Dark Horse Comics Awards NBC deadpool Fargo fresh SDCC Tomatazos Heroines streaming movies cults Fox Searchlight latino BBC America mutant Syfy DirecTV asian-american TBS Red Carpet screenings Comic Book Comic-Con@Home 2021 Marvel dragons Exclusive Video DGA Travel Channel San Diego Comic-Con FXX Peacock Shudder teaser Universal Pictures Alien HBO Max Television Academy aapi Television Critics Association 24 frames sequel jurassic park Box Office docuseries cats Year in Review high school wonder woman Shondaland cops 20th Century Fox toy story spider-verse worst movies AMC Plus based on movie emmy awards police drama finale Animation Mary Poppins Returns marvel cinematic universe australia History DC Comics Holiday obituary award winner directors Music Black History Month TCA Hear Us Out Podcast Comics on TV political drama Sci-Fi stop motion Sundance TV scene in color First Look 1990s Crunchyroll discovery FOX festival BET leaderboard Pop TV Toys Reality Netflix Cartoon Network elevated horror The Purge gangster name the review scorecard Film Festival Star Wars documentary green book facebook vampires screen actors guild Netflix Christmas movies Rocketman comic book movies Marathons Chernobyl japanese 2017 Image Comics halloween tv book satire cancelled TV series Comedy Central nfl Comedy 2019 Arrowverse Mary poppins cancelled TV shows cars die hard 2020 Freeform Quiz best TLC Pixar Academy Awards worst lord of the rings television reviews Horror thriller SXSW hist BBC Ghostbusters DC Universe unscripted live action Summer Hollywood Foreign Press Association TV renewals Martial Arts The Walking Dead PaleyFest Biopics A&E binge zero dark thirty LGBTQ 2021 Disney Channel space free movies OneApp dexter mission: impossible football Elton John A24 Walt Disney Pictures pirates of the caribbean Paramount Holidays french 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Writers Guild of America See It Skip It 73rd Emmy Awards Acorn TV Stephen King Captain marvel zombies laika The Arrangement CBS All Access American Society of Cinematographers dceu Apple TV+ movies VOD anime movie comedies spain romance Pacific Islander Neflix Lucasfilm new star wars movies Women's History Month news independent Ovation critic resources Musical 007 streaming Hulu Schedule Hallmark Musicals Turner Classic Movies hollywood Disney Plus NBA sports E3 composers stoner Christmas foreign halloween crime drama Vudu child's play Apple TV Plus IFC Films kong ghosts ESPN suspense all-time YouTube Red blockbuster trailers 90s Winter TV PlayStation TruTV Extras cooking documentaries book adaptation theme song richard e. Grant king arthur Action Anna Paquin Election travel psychological thriller ViacomCBS Character Guide Best and Worst Black Mirror 2016 black comedy james bond Set visit kaiju batman legend Reality Competition Infographic international APB AMC rotten movies we love Tokyo Olympics Tarantino Amazon Thanksgiving witnail Pop olympics romantic comedy Rom-Com popular video vs. YouTube feel good Fantasy strong female leads Nickelodeon Epix rt labs harry potter Spectrum Originals CBS Pride Month jamie lee curtis comics USA genre CW Seed quibi Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt superman scary basketball supernatural Polls and Games Winners Spike spinoff festivals animated dreamworks 4/20 Disney true crime 71st Emmy Awards Universal breaking bad ITV Grammys TV ABC Family Broadway adenture debate President Superheroes New York Comic Con posters TCA Awards golden globe awards ID Rocky transformers SundanceTV