Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Gone Girl is Certified Fresh

Plus, Annabelle, Left Behind, and new TV.

by | October 2, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a mysterious disappearance (Gone Girl, starring Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike), a spooky doll (Annabelle, starring Annabelle Wallis and Ward Horton), and the end of the world (Left Behind, starring Nicolas Cage and Lea Thompson). What do the critics have to say?

Gone Girl


As the old promotional tagline goes, “You’ve read the book — now see the movie!” In the case of David Fincher‘s Gone Girl (adapted from Gillian Flynn‘s page-turning bestseller), critics say that’s sage advice, for the film is a psychologically penetrating thriller that’s chilling and darkly funny — and it features a performance from Rosamund Pike that’s likely to catapult her to the big-time. Nick (Ben Affleck) and Amy (Pike) are a seemly idyllic couple. However, when Amy goes missing, and the media descends on their small Midwestern town, Nick looks increasingly suspicious. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Gone Girl is well-acted, intelligent, and deeply unsettling — in short, what we’ve come to expect from Fincher. (Watch our video interview with the cast and crew here.)



That creepy doll Annabelle cut such a striking presence in The Conjuring that she got her own movie. Unfortunately, the critics say it’s too bad she couldn’t get a better one; despite a few undeniably effective scares, Annabelle is by and large a compendium of horror movie cliches. A young couple with a baby on the way witnesses the shocking murder of their neighbors by a satanic cult. Soon, our heroes experience sinister goings-on throughout their house ; could that weird vintage doll the husband purchased be the cause? The pundits say Annabelle is a pretty generic haunted house flick, though it’s spooky enough on occasion to wish it were more.

Left Behind


Nicolas Cage plus the Book of Revelations should equal apocalyptic excitement, right? Apparently not. Critics are less than — ahem — enraptured by Left Behind; they say it’s a limp, clumsily crafted potboiler with cheesy special effects and minimal character development. Based upon the bestselling novels by Jerry B. Jenkins and Tim LaHaye, the film stars Cage as Rayford Steele, a disaffected airline pilot who witnesses several passengers and crew members vanish in mid-flight. Steele must safely land the plane while chaos reigns on the ground. The pundits say Left Behind is mostly amateurish and largely bereft of thrills.

Fresh on TV this week:

This Amazon Prime dramedy is winning high praise for its honest, empathetic, and funny depiction of a dysfunctional family; critics say Transparent (98 percent) features top-notch performances from the likes of Jeffrey Tambor, Judith Light, Gaby Hoffmann, and many more.

Gracepoint (73 percent) is an American adaptation of the critically-adored British detective series Broadchurch, both of which star David Tennant. And while critics say it’s not quite as sharp as its predecessor, it’s sophisticated and stylish, and features a strong lead performance from Anna Gunn.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Nas: Time Is Illmatic, a documentary about the making of one of hip hop’s greatest albums, is at 100 percent.
  • Last Hijack, a documentary about the life of a Somali pirate, is at 100 percent.
  • The Blue Room, a thriller about a man whose adulterous affairs lead to serious trouble, is at 90 percent.
  • For Those In Peril, a drama about a man who survives a mysterious fishing boat accident off the coast of Scotland, is at 89 percent.
  • The Good Lie, starring Reese Witherspoon in a drama about a group of Sudanese refugees who attempt to make new lives for themselves in the United States, is at 85 percent (check out our interview with the cast here).
  • Copenhagen, a drama about a man who befriends a teenage girl while searching for his grandfather in Denmark, is at 83 percent.
  • Harmontown, a documentary portrait of Community creator Dan Harmon, is at 60 percent.
  • The Decent One, a documentary about how Nazi leader Heinrich Himmler thought about his actions, is at 50 percent.
  • Men, Women & Children, starring Jennifer Garner and Adam Sandler in a dramedy about the ways that technology has changed the way that parents and teens communicate, is at 40 percent.
  • Inner Demons, a horror film about reality show subject who appears to be a drug addict but may be suffering from something even scarier, is at 40 percent.
  • A Good Marriage, starring Joan Allen and Anthony LaPaglia in a thriller about a woman who makes a shocking discovery about her husband, is at 38 percent.
  • The Liberator, a biopic of Simón Bolívar and his fight for Latin American independence from Spain, is at 27 percent.
  • The Hero of Color City, an animated adventure about anthropomophic crayons featuring voice performances by Christina Ricci and Craig Ferguson, is at 20 percent.
  • Drive Hard, starring John Cusack and Thomas Jane in a thriller about a racecar driver who’s enlisted to drive the getaway car as part of daring heist, is at eight percent.

Tag Cloud

Action NBC indiana jones Super Bowl President Tags: Comedy sag awards anime Pet Sematary new york Lucasfilm GLAAD DirecTV Exclusive Video Trailer Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pirates deadpool stoner biography Endgame Horror quibi mission: impossible A24 Disney streaming service twilight WGN Election godzilla blaxploitation vs. Polls and Games DGA Family GIFs Song of Ice and Fire dragons binge Mary poppins Chernobyl witnail Emmy Nominations NYCC cats 72 Emmy Awards 4/20 Brie Larson TCA Awards Fargo psychological thriller based on movie talk show trophy Arrowverse Esquire Hallmark video Mary Poppins Returns Alien Lifetime rt labs critics edition Writers Guild of America PBS Television Academy medical drama Pacific Islander TV movies game of thrones crime crime thriller genre Schedule National Geographic stop motion dark dc monster movies Fox Searchlight Hollywood Foreign Press Association comics mutant Image Comics TIFF posters Discovery Channel foreign Comic Book Disney Plus Year in Review BAFTA Tarantino cancelled TV series The Academy CBS chucky Rocketman elevated horror comic books scary comedies Quiz 45 richard e. Grant BET Awards cancelled television New York Comic Con Walt Disney Pictures The Arrangement superhero Certified Fresh screenings IMDb TV Hear Us Out Christmas ID Disney Star Trek zombie Dark Horse Comics Comics on TV Musicals LGBTQ Premiere Dates YouTube Red Set visit rom-coms nbcuniversal anthology ratings 71st Emmy Awards comic book movies dexter transformers asian-american BBC America Spring TV Awards Winter TV docuseries sequel blockbusters serial killer venice feel good 2017 universal monsters saw hispanic heritage month First Reviews slashers video on demand sequels social media breaking bad biopic History The CW hist Epix YouTube Premium hispanic composers Trophy Talk Adult Swim Sundance TV E! suspense aapi die hard TCA Winter 2020 Film Festival jurassic park spain streaming telelvision Pop Vudu 007 24 frames Marvel Television archives critics christmas movies Marathons remakes 1990s E3 Britbox franchise rotten movies we love live event boxoffice Interview technology HBO Max documentary spanish IFC Films vampires 2019 USA Network royal family Comic-Con@Home 2021 movies TLC Universal Pictures news adaptation wonder woman Baby Yoda HBO Go films toy story dogs reboot Spike theme song romantic comedy independent Best and Worst black Food Network Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FX on Hulu Sneak Peek art house FXX RT21 YA razzies all-time singing competition joker Opinion Kids & Family harry potter festivals Mystery Masterpiece TV renewals sopranos Ellie Kemper basketball trailers Amazon Prime Video SundanceTV unscripted supernatural Amazon Paramount cops Academy Awards Classic Film kids discovery Calendar 2015 LGBT Acorn TV Paramount Plus fast and furious diversity DC Universe Warner Bros. classics Nominations SDCC king arthur Biopics golden globes Paramount Network BBC Film mcc 2018 Musical Oscars Disney+ Disney Plus french Photos comic book movie Thanksgiving Box Office DC Comics cartoon The Witch First Look Cannes Netflix Christmas movies scorecard cancelled TV shows Television Critics Association Black Mirror BET Animation Fox News marvel cinematic universe war king kong superman Rom-Com APB australia Wes Anderson Martial Arts cars dreamworks Mudbound FOX spinoff Ghostbusters book disaster Turner Universal documentaries ABC Family Marvel book adaptation PaleyFest Neflix cinemax Summer AMC Plus werewolf versus Countdown dramedy Mindy Kaling police drama batman new zealand popular what to watch Freeform reviews Superheroe young adult Winners japan mockumentary Nickelodeon PlayStation Prime Video politics worst movies travel The Walt Disney Company zero dark thirty Amazon Studios aliens mob MSNBC DC streaming service YouTube CMT Elton John ITV strong female leads emmy awards hollywood concert Netflix ghosts TV teaser MTV Bravo high school Shondaland sitcom children's TV 2016 marvel comics nfl action-comedy animated Heroines Crackle golden globe awards Anna Paquin olympics Apple Black History Month Avengers psycho Nat Geo Western latino OWN japanese rt labs Reality Pride Month free movies canceled TV shows Syfy south america ABC Signature Star Wars VH1 Tokyo Olympics Teen halloween a nightmare on elm street sports ViacomCBS 2020 Captain marvel Marvel Studios Awards Tour award winner adenture doctor who live action jamie lee curtis space Sundance series Trivia TV Land Stephen King black comedy italian GoT Lifetime Christmas movies VICE Holidays best Comedy obituary indie festival thriller CNN SXSW Valentine's Day dceu Tubi 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards crime drama lord of the rings Watching Series critic resources romance Sony Pictures TruTV RT History TCM scene in color blockbuster toronto American Society of Cinematographers 90s VOD Country docudrama 93rd Oscars Character Guide worst Ovation IFC true crime Rocky stand-up comedy See It Skip It nature laika Hulu Toys canceled Video Games Tumblr Emmys Lionsgate Music 79th Golden Globes Awards Funimation name the review Holiday USA Instagram Live new star wars movies finale Infographic Logo scary movies international Apple TV Plus renewed TV shows legend cooking revenge adventure Travel Channel MCU CW Seed spy thriller Shudder El Rey Women's History Month Podcast tv talk Sci-Fi Amazon Prime directors ABC Reality Competition TNT Grammys X-Men Fall TV fresh Legendary Cartoon Network crossover 2021 green book Sundance Now target know your critic HBO debate Tomatazos Turner Classic Movies casting spanish language heist movie women The Purge BBC One Crunchyroll A&E justice league science fiction Pop TV rotten screen actors guild period drama Spectrum Originals kaiju cancelled 73rd Emmy Awards Creative Arts Emmys cults Drama Broadway spider-verse television OneApp game show leaderboard Extras historical drama slasher Showtime Peacock kong natural history Disney Channel halloween tv WarnerMedia The Walking Dead Red Carpet facebook Starz Mary Tyler Moore rt archives AMC spider-man TV One Hallmark Christmas movies movie TCA 2017 Comedy Central robots boxing hidden camera zombies TBS criterion Cosplay 20th Century Fox satire comic San Diego Comic-Con FX CBS All Access TCA HFPA political drama james bond parents Apple TV+ Binge Guide miniseries Pixar Columbia Pictures streaming movies 99% Superheroes comiccon gangster pirates of the caribbean Rock prank NBA ESPN 21st Century Fox child's play Fantasy football