Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Frozen is Certified Fresh

Plus, Black Nativity is heartfelt but uneven; Homefront is mostly generic; and Oldboy is intriguing but not quite successful.

by | November 27, 2013 | Comments

Happy Thanksgiving! This week at the movies, we’ve got a frigid fairy tale (Frozen, featuring voice performances by Kristen Bell and Idina Menzel); a small-town drug war (Homefront, starring Jason Statham and James Franco); a holiday musical (Black Nativity, starring Forest Whitaker and Angela Bassett); a quest for vengeance (Oldboy, starring Josh Brolin and Elizabeth Olsen); a mother’s search (Philomena, starring Judi Dench and Steve Coogan); and a troubled childhood (The Book Thief, starring Geoffrey Rush and Emily Watson). What do the critics have to say?



Any film released under the banner of Walt Disney Animation has a lot to live up to. Happily, critics say Frozen acquits itself quite well: it’s got toe-tapping tunes, crisp visuals, and a sensibility that’s at once classic and au courant. Like a blustery King Midas, Elsa (Idina Menzel) is cursed with the power to turn everything she touches to ice. She’s forced into exile after plunging the kingdom into a deep freeze; it’s up to her sister Anna (Kristen Bell) and some newfound friends to rescue her. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Frozen is beautifully animated, consistently inventive, and intelligently written — in other words, it’s a solid entry into the Disney pantheon.



Homefront boasts an intriguing pedigree: it’s an action flick starring Jason Statham and James Franco (as a bad guy!) with a screenplay by Sylvester Stallone. Unfortunately, critics say the end result is pretty generic, with a few decent thrills and a whole lotta clichés. Statham stars as an ex-DEA agent who has relocated to a small rural community in order to put the past behind him. Soon, however, he’s pulled into a conflict with a local meth kingpin (Franco) and must defend his home against an army of thugs. The pundits say Homefront offers the dependable sight of Statham cleaning house, but it’s essentially a thin genre exercise with a better-than-average-cast.

Black Nativity


em>Black Nativity would seem to have everything needed for uplifting holiday entertainment, including an all-star cast, powerful music, and warm messages about faith and family. And while some critics think it’s a winning formula, others feel the film is weighted down by sappiness and heavy-handed sermonizing. A loose adaptation of Langston Hughes’ play, Black Nativity is the story of a teenager (Jacob Latimore) who is sent by his mother to spend Christmas with grandparents he’s never met; while he initially chafes under their austere morality, he eventually learns a thing or two about life and love from the people he meets on his travels. The pundits say Black Nativity is undeniably warm-hearted and well-acted, but it’s hamstrung by its preachiness and contrived plot.



Spike Lee has never been one to play things safe, which is why critics are all the more surprised that his remake of Chan-wook Park?s cult classic Oldboy is disappointingly straightforward — a competent, occasionally stylish thriller that fails to replicate the gonzo panache or moral weightiness of its predecessor. Josh Brolin stars as a man who’s abducted and confined for 20 years — until he’s mysteriously released, at which point he goes on a mission to enact revenge against his captors. The pundits say Oldboy is sufficiently grim and violent, but it lacks the freshness that made the original such a punch to the gut.



Based on a remarkable true story, Philomena won raves in limited release last week; now, this Certified Fresh drama goes wide, and critics say it’s witty, deeply moving, and terrifically acted. Judi Dench stars as a woman who was forced to give up her son for adoption years ago after getting pregnant out of wedlock. In order to find her child, she enlists the aid of an investigative reporter (Steve Coogan). The pundits say Philomena is a bittersweet, inspiring tear-jerker that benefits from Dench’s typically outstanding work.

The Book Thief


The Book Thief expands into wide release this week, and critics say it’s a handsome and well-acted drama that’s a bit too facile and syrupy to fully convince. Based on Markus Zusak’s bestselling novel, the film stars Sophie Nelisse as a girl who learns to read while living with foster parents (played by Geoffrey Rush and Emily Watson) in a German town on the cusp of World War II. The pundits say the film is well-intentioned and occasionally touching, but it tiptoes around its incendiary setting.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

festival Ghostbusters Toys action-comedy worst movies Spectrum Originals CNN chucky Fox Searchlight jamie lee curtis Netflix best trophy Lifetime 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards BBC TCA 2017 king kong BBC America Rom-Com hist satire Marvel Studios VOD popular MCU comic book movie series critics richard e. Grant target archives nature HBO SundanceTV hollywood 2018 vs. E3 asian-american Hallmark Christmas movies Crunchyroll green book Certified Fresh Star Trek Chilling Adventures of Sabrina classics IFC Logo directors YouTube Red Reality south america TV renewals E! young adult APB zombies Spike Creative Arts Emmys reboot cancelled TV series blaxploitation TruTV scorecard IFC Films TV movies live event black comedy Film canceled TV shows USA name the review HBO Max biography remakes suspense feel good Tags: Comedy christmas movies Sundance GLAAD 4/20 Masterpiece ghosts Apple TV+ composers Disney Channel Netflix Christmas movies LGBTQ 24 frames ID foreign Heroines television Polls and Games DGA Country American Society of Cinematographers Opinion CBS All Access doctor who Britbox scary Biopics streaming RT21 strong female leads obituary Instagram Live dc TCA cooking zero dark thirty Funimation rotten movies we love Quiz stand-up comedy BET Awards new zealand Lifetime Christmas movies boxing Countdown TV Drama halloween Starz unscripted marvel cinematic universe Kids & Family Walt Disney Pictures National Geographic Fargo San Diego Comic-Con 20th Century Fox Black History Month X-Men Emmy Nominations comic book movies dark romantic comedy The Walking Dead GIFs Paramount Plus YA teaser werewolf FX Cosplay spy thriller OWN war movies revenge mob casting The Walt Disney Company Broadway kaiju Freeform ratings boxoffice Holiday New York Comic Con versus 007 high school streaming movies basketball Podcast The CW WarnerMedia Oscars dceu Pirates Warner Bros. Sony Pictures game show spider-man Academy Awards Turner Classic Movies Food Network screen actors guild finale hispanic heritage month sequel Peacock independent CMT Trivia films Hulu Pop See It Skip It sopranos Stephen King Wes Anderson emmy awards YouTube Premium miniseries Writers Guild of America Elton John Bravo Winners space mockumentary Mary poppins ESPN reviews Anna Paquin dogs Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Legendary mission: impossible MSNBC Sundance Now transformers posters Film Festival Animation OneApp PaleyFest Mary Tyler Moore Hollywood Foreign Press Association king arthur Prime Video psycho 79th Golden Globes Awards telelvision Apple Trophy Talk The Witch RT History animated Disney robots TCA Winter 2020 cops Shudder spanish justice league Action rt archives Avengers Fox News Lucasfilm Rocketman GoT Exclusive Video Marathons Mary Poppins Returns Universal Pictures ABC Family Spring TV marvel comics binge Ellie Kemper Pet Sematary The Academy First Look 2019 mcc DC Comics rt labs critics edition concert rotten game of thrones VH1 breaking bad Sundance TV Sneak Peek 2016 Binge Guide cults Pop TV fast and furious Travel Channel Baby Yoda harry potter cancelled new york FX on Hulu wonder woman VICE all-time Dark Horse Comics TNT Crackle sag awards YouTube Election new star wars movies rom-coms gangster Chernobyl Thanksgiving lord of the rings Comic-Con@Home 2021 Tokyo Olympics DirecTV screenings Amazon Prime Video canceled Paramount indiana jones Endgame Photos sports Nickelodeon Hallmark El Rey hispanic Holidays Teen award winner BAFTA slashers Universal DC Universe olympics President biopic Showtime BET Tubi golden globes scene in color Amazon Prime book adaptation adenture anime Trailer The Arrangement Awards Tour Comics on TV TCA Awards 21st Century Fox slasher Nominations parents what to watch renewed TV shows 1990s Star Wars royal family black psychological thriller Women's History Month australia tv talk Turner Television Academy TIFF razzies joker supernatural zombie IMDb TV medical drama Watching Series Black Mirror Tomatazos Character Guide Brie Larson adaptation news cinemax know your critic stop motion Fall TV PBS halloween tv Mudbound 2015 aliens CBS movie dramedy Infographic toronto children's TV LGBT sequels Western politics deadpool Fantasy A24 Awards spider-verse free movies superhero Marvel genre criterion spinoff Martial Arts Television Critics Association legend Musicals Comic Book Year in Review TBS comiccon kids french Set visit crime thriller critic resources social media Emmys ABC Signature Family witnail jurassic park leaderboard stoner child's play Reality Competition FXX rt labs BBC One Grammys Cartoon Network Superheroe serial killer trailers 99% Shondaland Esquire saw Cannes Marvel Television godzilla Paramount Network PlayStation ABC WGN Box Office Premiere Dates thriller 72 Emmy Awards 90s Apple TV Plus universal monsters USA Network Pride Month romance indie video on demand Horror Nat Geo video dreamworks NBC kong superman Comedy comedies sitcom Hear Us Out die hard AMC TV Land Rocky laika 93rd Oscars cancelled television singing competition Disney+ Disney Plus james bond 2021 Superheroes franchise monster movies 2020 elevated horror Comedy Central CW Seed Arrowverse MTV Epix debate Acorn TV science fiction dexter Disney Plus NYCC cats Super Bowl Rock Disney streaming service TLC Syfy Christmas mutant Calendar Pacific Islander anthology disaster Tumblr police drama facebook worst football festivals Discovery Channel NBA discovery Amazon ITV nbcuniversal batman aapi Amazon Studios blockbuster Video Games comics Classic Film spain HFPA Red Carpet SDCC docuseries 71st Emmy Awards venice comic pirates of the caribbean Lionsgate TCM crossover book Mystery dragons nfl blockbusters Captain marvel TV One Valentine's Day adventure women international hidden camera latino docudrama twilight live action Best and Worst Schedule prank toy story First Reviews 73rd Emmy Awards SXSW DC streaming service Image Comics japanese diversity FOX heist movie Pixar quibi natural history vampires AMC Plus HBO Go spanish language Winter TV fresh golden globe awards technology travel The Purge Columbia Pictures Neflix italian A&E ViacomCBS documentaries cartoon art house 45 Ovation Sci-Fi Music based on movie crime drama crime talk show a nightmare on elm street Adult Swim Summer 2017 theme song Extras Song of Ice and Fire scary movies Alien true crime Tarantino historical drama documentary Vudu History period drama Mindy Kaling cars Musical japan political drama comic books Interview cancelled TV shows