Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Divergent Disappoints

Plus, Muppets Most Wanted is Certified Fresh.

by | March 21, 2014 | Comments


This week at the movies, we’ve got individuality under attack (Divergent, starring Shailene Woodley and Kate Winslet) and Kermit under lock and key (Muppets Most Wanted, starring Ricky Gervais and Tina Fey). What do the critics have to say?



Based on a series of popular young adult novels, Divergent is a sci-fi allegory about the dangers of conformity. Ironically, critics say the biggest problem with the film is that it borrows too heavily from the likes of The Hunger Games and Harry Potter, leaving its terrific cast stranded in a sea of exposition. In a dystopian future, teenagers are forced to chose one of five factions with which they’ll associate for life. However, Beatrice Prior (Shailene Woodley) doesn’t fit neatly into any one group, and her independent streak makes her a target when two rival tribes prepare for war. The pundits say Woodley gives a star-making performance, and her supporting cast is top-notch, but Divergent is too grim and jumbled to fully resonate. (Check out our gallery of co-star Kate Winslet in some of her most memorable roles.)

Muppets Most Wanted


“Everybody knows that the sequel’s never quite as good,” sing Kermit and Fozzie in the opening scene of Muppets Most Wanted. The operative word here is “quite,” for the critics say that while this caper comedy lacks the breezy charm of The Muppets, it’s got enough laughs and catchy tunes to entertain in its own right. Hot off their successful reunion show, the Muppets decide to take their act on the road, but things quickly go amiss when they sign up with a fast-talking booking agent (Ricky Gervais) who’s in league with a wanted criminal mastermind — and who looks exactly like Kermit the Frog. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Muppets Most Wanted maintains the anarchic spirit of the Muppets, and if the story isn’t as strong this time out, the rapid-fire gags are reliably witty and inventive. (Check out our video interviews with the cast, as well as our rundown of the best films from the Jim Henson Company.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Vicente Torres and Nat Brautigam for coming the closest to guessing The Single Moms Club‘s 17 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

festivals Warner Bros. Marvel Television Television Critics Association 007 Showtime hispanic heritage month TCA Awards Trophy Talk royal family high school docuseries Pet Sematary TIFF justice league olympics Comedy USA Network Television Academy Box Office Marvel reboot legend halloween tv zombie 2019 Podcast 90s FX supernatural Infographic politics Winter TV IFC Films war Chernobyl Amazon Prime Video Video Games American Society of Cinematographers mob scorecard book strong female leads renewed TV shows FOX Star Wars Comedy Central DC Universe 45 PaleyFest HBO Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt kaiju superhero CW Seed GIFs animated National Geographic fresh indie MSNBC boxing technology Rom-Com cars binge Horror ID hidden camera rt archives Schedule Classic Film Academy Awards films TNT Turner stop motion biopic golden globe awards canceled Christmas Nominations ITV WGN Nickelodeon blaxploitation Pride Month Rocketman Freeform comedies Masterpiece richard e. Grant Thanksgiving 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards kids BBC America theme song TCM Spectrum Originals Paramount Network spinoff rt labs Best and Worst SXSW Star Trek 2021 CBS YouTube Premium venice Marvel Studios Funimation international mission: impossible worst movies ghosts FXX Hallmark doctor who posters Pacific Islander heist movie comic book movie spanish asian-american genre Reality docudrama Brie Larson green book Winners NYCC space The Walking Dead disaster Watching Series Adult Swim Stephen King crime drama Opinion comic 99% nbcuniversal hist sopranos 2016 APB The Walt Disney Company LGBTQ cooking Shudder Amazon tv talk diversity VOD Broadway vs. screenings unscripted ViacomCBS franchise BET free movies Black Mirror First Look Tokyo Olympics hispanic DC streaming service anthology Rocky Disney+ Disney Plus elevated horror marvel cinematic universe prank james bond Oscars Mudbound The Purge Cosplay Netflix Lionsgate Pop TV chucky Comics on TV Endgame comiccon Baby Yoda spy thriller TCA Logo DirecTV Drama Country teaser natural history festival Superheroes Crunchyroll Food Network robots Pop saw name the review 21st Century Fox facebook DGA die hard TV movies Martial Arts Columbia Pictures Comic Book History Paramount Plus sequels spanish language reviews razzies See It Skip It documentary BBC obituary adenture aliens Travel Channel Holiday psycho Disney Channel MTV Tumblr Valentine's Day YouTube Super Bowl black comedy The Academy Rock Discovery Channel documentaries Tarantino superman Hulu The CW italian A24 what to watch Trailer game of thrones adventure universal monsters Hollywood Foreign Press Association PBS Summer satire latino Apple TV Plus dragons laika Alien Universal Pictures godzilla Vudu know your critic YA TV One comics Fox Searchlight Dark Horse Comics Action cinemax nfl Starz art house VH1 historical drama directors trophy 24 frames new star wars movies new york jamie lee curtis Musicals Sundance TV rt labs critics edition wonder woman independent sports 72 Emmy Awards Instagram Live Quiz young adult Music Netflix Christmas movies Elton John SundanceTV TLC Awards Tour GoT 73rd Emmy Awards PlayStation 2017 Set visit pirates of the caribbean Walt Disney Pictures video on demand Spring TV Neflix crime thriller breaking bad Apple TV+ Black History Month Cannes Bravo biography 4/20 El Rey halloween football Nat Geo kong Photos Polls and Games Wes Anderson target canceled TV shows Awards TV Land cancelled remakes period drama sag awards lord of the rings parents black screen actors guild The Arrangement batman Tomatazos Film science fiction talk show cancelled TV series best ratings The Witch stand-up comedy dreamworks streaming movies anime Grammys Ellie Kemper First Reviews Musical gangster dogs singing competition Mystery Sony Pictures australia leaderboard all-time award winner crossover A&E Crackle MCU Legendary Britbox Women's History Month social media sequel TruTV child's play Emmy Nominations Universal toy story mutant Heroines Anna Paquin zombies BAFTA Peacock new zealand cats President Amazon Studios movies Comic-Con@Home 2021 FX on Hulu south america Paramount BBC One king arthur Tubi monster movies video Sneak Peek romantic comedy Toys HBO Go Extras telelvision Film Festival nature scary movies X-Men spider-verse christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns Fox News Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Fantasy live event cancelled TV shows Captain marvel sitcom rotten movies we love book adaptation rom-coms Lifetime Christmas movies Turner Classic Movies Ghostbusters dexter rotten dark VICE Marathons ABC Family TCA 2017 E3 Red Carpet ESPN Teen scary Apple IMDb TV witnail Ovation joker TBS miniseries NBC CBS All Access travel Emmys Mindy Kaling New York Comic Con indiana jones marvel comics LGBT Lucasfilm CNN streaming Family dramedy Interview composers blockbusters political drama Year in Review Disney Plus worst comic book movies vampires Pixar police drama Exclusive Video Hallmark Christmas movies feel good hollywood mockumentary Biopics scene in color Countdown Hear Us Out women NBA TV renewals critics debate fast and furious dceu OWN television toronto Sci-Fi E! action-comedy thriller 2020 jurassic park Lifetime criterion Image Comics psychological thriller basketball foreign Disney 71st Emmy Awards AMC Plus DC Comics based on movie cults Mary Tyler Moore RT21 romance a nightmare on elm street mcc serial killer Kids & Family TCA Winter 2020 concert trailers CMT Pirates quibi true crime Holidays Arrowverse Esquire Calendar dc Certified Fresh king kong spider-man Epix slasher Binge Guide japan Mary poppins Fall TV RT History twilight SDCC french Avengers casting movie IFC crime Cartoon Network golden globes 79th Golden Globes Awards Sundance cops BET Awards Fargo archives blockbuster critic resources WarnerMedia 93rd Oscars Disney streaming service werewolf San Diego Comic-Con zero dark thirty Western adaptation popular OneApp 2015 slashers 2018 Amazon Prime GLAAD stoner ABC Signature AMC comic books aapi series Superheroe HBO Max deadpool harry potter cancelled television boxoffice children's TV emmy awards Tags: Comedy Syfy live action Spike revenge spain suspense medical drama USA Election cartoon finale Acorn TV Prime Video ABC YouTube Red Creative Arts Emmys 1990s Writers Guild of America Premiere Dates Character Guide Trivia Song of Ice and Fire Sundance Now versus game show TV news Shondaland classics HFPA Animation Reality Competition discovery japanese transformers 20th Century Fox