Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Cinderella is Certified Fresh

Plus, Run All Night is hit and miss, and Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt is Certified Fresh.

by | March 12, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fairy tale princess (Cinderella, starring Lily James and Cate Blanchett) and a regretful hit man (Run All Night, starring Liam Neeson and Ed Harris). What do the critics have to say?



Revisionist fairy tales are all the rage these days, so it’s a bit surprising that director Kenneth Branagh has taken the opposite tack with his mostly-straightforward version of Cinderella. Not that that’s a bad thing; critics say this is charming, visually striking family entertainment with more than a touch of the old Disney magic. You probably know the story by heart, but here goes: after her aristocratic father’s tragic death, Cinderella (Lily James) is left in the care of her wicked stepmother (Cate Blanchett) and her cruel stepsisters. But with the help of a fairy godmother (Helena Bonham Carter), our heroine wins the heart of a prince. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Cinderella doesn’t bring many new twists to the classic tale, but it’s so exquisitely crafted and energetically acted that it hardly matters. (Watch our video interview with Branagh, James, and Blanchett, and click through our gallery of the most important shoes in the movies.)

Run All Night


Another week, another movie in which Liam Neeson is out for blood. Critics say Run All Night is a so-so entry in this budding subgenre, one that’s better than Taken 3 but a notch or two below A Walk Among the Tombstones. Neeson plays Jimmy, a broken-down mob assassin with a long personal and professional history with crime boss Shawn (Ed Harris). But when Jimmy kills Shawn’s kid in order to save his son’s life, he finds his old buddy gunning for him. The pundits say the main reason to watch Run All Night is Neeson and the strong cast, but otherwise, the plot is too convoluted and the execution is too workmanlike. (Check out Harris’ best-reviewed films here.)

What’s On TV:

Critics say that Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt (Certified Fresh at 95 percent) is as odd as it is hilarious, thanks in part to a spot-on performance from Ellie Kemper.

The pundits say season three of Bates Motel (90 percent) further blurs the lines around TV’s creepiest taboo mother/son relationship, uncomfortably darkening its already fascinating tone.

Critics say that while The Returned (64 percent) is overshadowed by its superior source material, the US version retains enough of the creep factor and character drama to appease fans of the genre.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Of Horses and Men, an Icelandic dramedy featuring a series of interlocking stories about disparate people and their equine companions, is at 100 percent.
  • Seymour: An Introduction, a documentary profile of concert pianist and teacher Seymour Bernstein directed by Ethan Hawke, is at 100 percent.
  • It Follows, an indie horror film about a malevolent force that preys on teens in a Michigan suburb, is Certified Fresh at 95 percent.
  • The Wrecking Crew, a doc about the legendary L.A. session musicians who backed up everyone from Frank Sinatra to the Beach Boys, is at 93 percent.
  • 3 Hearts, starring Charlotte Gainsbourg and Catherine Deneuve in a romantic drama about two sisters who fall for the same man, is at 82 percent.
  • Champs, a documentary in which legendary pugilists Mike Tyson and Evander Holyfield discuss their lives in and outside the ring, is at 60 percent.
  • Walter, a dramedy about a movie theater employee who believes he’s the son of God, is at 57 percent.
  • Treading Water, starring Douglas Smith and Zoë Kravitz in a dramedy about a lonely teenager with a rare medical condition that makes him smell like a fish, is at 50 percent.
  • Cymbeline, starring Ethan Hawke and Ed Harris in a modern-day retelling of Shakespeare’s tragedy featuring warring bikers and cops, is at 33 percent.
  • The Cobbler, starring Adam Sandler and Steve Buscemi in a comic fantasy about a shoe repairman who discovers a machine magical properties, is at 11 percent (check out co-star Method Man’s Five Favorite Films here).
  • Home Sweet Hell, starring Katherine Heigl and Patrick Wilson in a drama based on the true story of the brazen kidnapping of a brewery heir, is at eight percent.

Tag Cloud

Superheroes blockbusters adaptation Lifetime 2016 Fantasy Red Carpet Cosplay italian Star Trek parents critics Character Guide teaser summer TV preview Native Oscars Tomatazos Syfy obituary MCU summer preview Music Food Network cancelled TV shows cancelled Apple zombie blaxploitation Grammys dogs Television Academy ID anime Discovery Channel Baby Yoda latino Podcast broadcast Black Mirror FX true crime Best Director Toys hollywood medical drama PlayStation kids james bond romantic comedy Extras football Broadway action-comedy cooking Women's History Month emmy awards chucky Interview Apple TV+ MTV Marvel ABC Family 72 Emmy Awards VH1 jurassic park docudrama 24 frames children's TV WarnerMedia First Look Election game show See It Skip It Photos Marathons cops Animation The Walt Disney Company Song of Ice and Fire Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comic book movie 71st Emmy Awards Disney Channel aapi Mudbound crime batman spanish language LGBT 21st Century Fox Christmas kong marvel comics Best Actor comic Hollywood Foreign Press Association 2017 dc TCA Winter 2020 live event christmas movies ABC rom-coms Disney+ Disney Plus Fall TV Legendary genre Calendar robots streaming TV movies international FXX 20th Century Fox foreign Focus Features BET spider-man 45 Quiz Opinion sequel SXSW NYCC OWN Hulu Lionsgate concert Warner Bros. crossover The CW comedies AMC indie target scene in color Anna Paquin Comic Book Instagram Live HFPA stoner trophy Watching Series Cannes Turner revenge golden globe awards MGM spy thriller cinemax Vudu VICE SXSW 2022 Superheroe rt labs game of thrones biography Drama binge Hear Us Out Trophy Talk Hallmark Christmas movies DC Comics dexter name the review Video Games best canceled TV shows breaking bad Western indiana jones Avengers TV renewals stop motion elevated horror TV Land The Witch political drama nature Rock basketball die hard HBO Go cartoon justice league Sneak Peek Star Wars leaderboard Comedy Central documentaries toy story TIFF A&E slashers deadpool BAFTA king kong Paramount Plus Travel Channel Chernobyl VOD Freeform diversity Set visit dceu Spike Spring TV hist mutant monster movies heist movie criterion History debate child's play new zealand miniseries art house reboot unscripted GLAAD telelvision Amazon Prime Video Reality OneApp CNN Musical The Purge superman scary Certified Fresh renewed TV shows 2019 E! cars Dark Horse Comics award winner Acorn TV Britbox japanese Polls and Games Film Festival Heroines TCA slasher RT21 japan 99% films spanish ratings Sci-Fi Best Actress hispanic heritage month Schedule Exclusive Video 2018 mission: impossible classics HBO 4/20 Film free movies politics Lifetime Christmas movies Martial Arts suspense DGA BBC One vampires DC streaming service Tumblr YA popular Mystery BBC America women Geeked Week Creative Arts Emmys black jamie lee curtis book adaptation series adventure Sundance Now CW Seed Columbia Pictures book Netflix Christmas movies Wes Anderson Trivia YouTube Premium President Tags: Comedy Shondaland Nickelodeon Awards strong female leads obi wan SDCC reviews witnail trailers target YouTube BBC psychological thriller Funimation scary movies sequels police drama 2021 Brie Larson feel good south america royal family crime drama Holiday television social media Epix kaiju black comedy Country Disney RT History new star wars movies Adult Swim vs. cats casting remakes Indigenous Binge Guide Holidays American Society of Cinematographers Turner Classic Movies Emmys news olympics doctor who Winter TV technology Bravo Biopics Sundance Family young adult Crackle historical drama Cartoon Network 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards harry potter twilight Academy Awards Alien IMDb TV richard e. Grant sopranos posters 2015 Marvel Studios LGBTQ ABC Signature blockbuster 007 high school The Walking Dead aliens new york Action First Reviews Year in Review spider-verse Writers Guild of America biopic razzies singing competition South by Southwest Film Festival boxoffice versus crime thriller werewolf Mary Tyler Moore Mindy Kaling Paramount interviews TNT Universal scene in color USA GIFs sports dark sag awards Sony Tarantino Mary Poppins Returns YouTube Red Oscar mockumentary Classic Film Rocketman fast and furious Pop TV Image Comics Pirates know your critic worst movies Spectrum Originals transformers serial killer animated CMT dragons Disney streaming service TV IFC lord of the rings canceled Paramount Pictures Disney Plus festivals Lucasfilm Emmy Nominations war Rocky Infographic thriller venice Summer IFC Films golden globes adenture TBS Amazon Studios screenings summer TV spinoff 1990s directors nfl rotten movies we love Comics on TV mcc cancelled television hidden camera marvel cinematic universe Comedy Starz pirates of the caribbean Pride Month comic book movies Box Office 94th Oscars MSNBC satire 93rd Oscars FX on Hulu gangster joker Countdown godzilla critic resources Sony Pictures Stephen King DC Universe Fargo Rom-Com fresh Winners a nightmare on elm street supernatural docuseries rt labs critics edition Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comic books nbcuniversal NBC Awards Tour dramedy cults The Arrangement hispanic Star Wars Celebration Nat Geo scene in color series ghosts Reality Competition HBO Max Sundance TV Pet Sematary worst halloween A24 rt archives 79th Golden Globes Awards romance Teen Best Picture Comic-Con@Home 2021 dreamworks natural history Pixar rotten what to watch sitcom quibi movies comics Amazon Hallmark video on demand Valentine's Day TV One king arthur Peacock facebook australia Apple TV Plus Paramount Network talk show Arrowverse Kids & Family GoT Masterpiece comiccon wonder woman Amazon Prime San Diego Comic-Con Netflix NBA legend psycho Walt Disney Pictures Tubi stand-up comedy all-time Esquire franchise E3 anthology 73rd Emmy Awards Black History Month ESPN Trailer spain scorecard travel Elton John toronto halloween tv Neflix FOX ITV ViacomCBS space asian-american Prime Video based on movie superhero TCA 2017 DirecTV CBS Fox Searchlight Premiere Dates Thanksgiving green book Ovation Showtime X-Men streamig 90s Musicals El Rey Pop period drama TCM streaming movies Shudder boxing zero dark thirty cancelled TV series movie laika New York Comic Con independent Logo SundanceTV Television Critics Association live action Universal Pictures screen actors guild Fox News PBS Best and Worst TCA Awards Crunchyroll PaleyFest TruTV Tokyo Olympics Marvel Television scene in color film series Endgame documentary The Academy Captain marvel Super Bowl saw Ghostbusters Pacific Islander zombies mob video archives National Geographic finale 2020 AMC Plus Ellie Kemper french theme song TLC WGN APB composers discovery Nominations festival Horror USA Network universal monsters BET Awards science fiction CBS All Access disaster Mary poppins prank tv talk