Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Captain Phillips is Certified Fresh

Plus, Machete Kills doesn't cut that deep.

by | October 10, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a hostage situation (Captain Phillips, starring Tom Hanks and Catherine Keener), and a deadly mission (Machete Kills, starring Danny Trejo and Michelle Rodriguez). What do the critics have to say?

Captain Phillips

93%

Director Paul Greengrass (United 93, Bloody Sunday) is an expert at adapting true stories to the big screen with a sense of you-are-there immediacy. Tom Hanks is great at portraying relatable people operating under extraordinary duress. Together, they make Captain Phillips a tense, endlessly involving thriller that entertains even as it raises intriguing questions. Hanks plays Phillips, the captain of a cargo ship that?s hijacked by Somali pirates; as the situation becomes more grim by the minute, it?s up to the captain to maintain composure and keep his crew safe. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Captain Phillips is potent, powerful stuff, with terrific performances and a script that gives multiple dimensions to all parties involved. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Hanks’ best-reviewed films.)

Machete Kills

29%

There’s a thin line separating trashy fun and plain ol’ trash, and unfortunately, critics say Machete Kills is too often on the wrong side of the divide; despite its emphasis on gleefully over-the-top violence and campy laughs, the movie is too slackly paced and overlong to fully register as a guilty pleasure. This time out, the president enlists our blade-wielding hero (played by Danny Trejo) to stop a billionaire arms trader bent on inciting chaos across the globe. The pundits say Machete Kills is like its predecessor in many ways, just less so; it’s got some clever cameos and delightfully tasteless action, but there’s less energy on display this time out. (Take a look through our gallery of the ladies of the Machete movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

AMC Fall TV japanese biography ESPN binge vampires monster movies Tarantino Film Festival YouTube joker foreign The Academy 2017 The Purge Cartoon Network Alien concert GIFs See It Skip It Fox Searchlight suspense Academy Awards rom-coms obi wan hollywood legend The Walt Disney Company docuseries latino NBA prank WGN Disney streaming service Indigenous Drama First Reviews blockbusters movie disaster FXX breaking bad HFPA Amazon Studios popular Marathons USA Network godzilla 72 Emmy Awards scene in color film series discovery TV renewals Ellie Kemper stop motion halloween Nickelodeon Star Wars nbcuniversal Summer golden globe awards dexter basketball summer TV Mindy Kaling LGBTQ Esquire boxoffice 2016 Trophy Talk know your critic doctor who ID game of thrones Sundance diversity Oscars TCA Freeform IFC Films video on demand 4/20 Image Comics 94th Oscars cooking justice league Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Teen screenings nature twilight transformers Character Guide summer preview Animation A24 Tubi Walt Disney Pictures FX on Hulu Action teaser spider-man adaptation chucky police drama Hear Us Out sequels President crossover VICE Podcast Hulu archives Spectrum Originals SXSW Netflix worst movies Columbia Pictures football Britbox versus Quiz obituary hist scene in color Best Actor Amazon Prime fast and furious royal family kids free movies worst Fantasy TCA Winter 2020 action-comedy comics AMC Plus genre superhero Marvel Studios james bond BBC America 79th Golden Globes Awards crime thriller new star wars movies Masterpiece high school indiana jones Superheroes Paramount Plus OneApp E! Writers Guild of America scary HBO Max ViacomCBS Countdown Rocky Bravo Legendary El Rey Instagram Live summer TV preview historical drama Lifetime Christmas movies japan GLAAD book adaptation thriller werewolf American Society of Cinematographers christmas movies true crime Rocketman spanish language Apple TV+ golden globes Disney Channel jamie lee curtis die hard theme song CW Seed elevated horror zero dark thirty Certified Fresh Calendar child's play Martial Arts Universal TLC stoner independent YA comedies razzies LGBT cinemax Rock aliens green book anime scary movies casting Paramount Network crime Endgame Hallmark National Geographic documentaries Pop TV Kids & Family Shudder VOD The Witch dc Avengers criterion Horror MSNBC PBS vs. streamig Elton John BBC sitcom TruTV children's TV BET Ghostbusters Amazon Prime Video Opinion X-Men comiccon Travel Channel Stephen King Netflix Christmas movies DirecTV NBC Baby Yoda Wes Anderson Crunchyroll Creative Arts Emmys stand-up comedy RT21 FOX Comics on TV comic books remakes Heroines dceu Best and Worst Peacock New York Comic Con TV One harry potter 007 Pride Month debate Disney+ Disney Plus OWN The Walking Dead superman olympics Syfy TCA 2017 classics hidden camera SDCC Spring TV venice 2015 Vudu zombie Disney Plus comic book movies Best Director Pop witnail robots MTV WarnerMedia Lionsgate Reality Christmas heist movie 45 ABC Family finale natural history reboot Broadway Women's History Month adenture Fargo hispanic heritage month A&E Mudbound Polls and Games Dark Horse Comics australia romantic comedy TV Pacific Islander Turner Ovation medical drama Mystery canceled TV shows BBC One documentary Awards Set visit indie YouTube Premium sopranos SundanceTV Captain marvel Oscar Rom-Com San Diego Comic-Con singing competition Cosplay rt labs lord of the rings comic 90s deadpool name the review Holiday USA Comedy Central BET Awards Food Network Country scene in color series fresh political drama cops Grammys Funimation Photos critics Watching Series Tokyo Olympics Winners Crackle Mary Tyler Moore ABC black marvel comics DC Comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina interviews 2018 cars Sony Pictures Super Bowl gangster HBO Go Tomatazos posters animated asian-american boxing trophy Hallmark Christmas movies TV Land scorecard toy story PaleyFest all-time universal monsters period drama Sneak Peek social media facebook YouTube Red Paramount Pictures spy thriller cults MCU MGM travel war sag awards VH1 Marvel Year in Review films Comic-Con@Home 2021 2020 DC streaming service parents South by Southwest Film Festival marvel cinematic universe science fiction trailers emmy awards Infographic History FX saw what to watch Television Academy Election quibi dragons rotten telelvision anthology 93rd Oscars aapi IFC Extras Superheroe blockbuster Nat Geo streaming Musicals black comedy Schedule tv talk nfl slasher book comic book movie Apple Musical young adult Anna Paquin richard e. Grant cats 71st Emmy Awards news BAFTA Fox News spanish streaming movies composers south america television TCA Awards Thanksgiving NYCC 20th Century Fox Star Wars Celebration series game show Family Trivia Film The CW CMT Binge Guide Cannes TIFF Brie Larson Music critic resources DGA DC Universe hispanic rt labs critics edition target scene in color 99% Starz cancelled television miniseries Amazon jurassic park TV movies Biopics cancelled TV series Arrowverse E3 Prime Video unscripted Acorn TV Reality Competition live action TNT Emmys award winner halloween tv best adventure Television Critics Association franchise SXSW 2022 a nightmare on elm street docudrama mcc king arthur dogs new zealand Song of Ice and Fire Universal Pictures TBS Turner Classic Movies Chernobyl zombies crime drama First Look mission: impossible Winter TV directors Apple TV Plus movies mob RT History 24 frames HBO international festivals king kong Warner Bros. Focus Features Black History Month french sports Neflix wonder woman Nominations Mary poppins Toys Spike CBS All Access spider-verse Sundance Now batman romance Classic Film dark festival psycho 2019 psychological thriller technology screen actors guild satire Sci-Fi pirates of the caribbean Emmy Nominations reviews slashers Epix Geeked Week toronto Comic Book biopic Showtime Black Mirror Premiere Dates GoT Trailer TCM women Lucasfilm Best Picture rotten movies we love APB italian sequel Tags: Comedy Interview ABC Signature space laika ITV based on movie 1990s Pirates 21st Century Fox kong Star Trek blaxploitation strong female leads live event ghosts dreamworks Paramount target serial killer dramedy spinoff ratings Lifetime Pet Sematary Disney talk show Tumblr Marvel Television Western Awards Tour Video Games IMDb TV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards revenge PlayStation spain Sundance TV Discovery Channel new york canceled Best Actress mutant art house kaiju Red Carpet renewed TV shows Mary Poppins Returns Sony Box Office 2021 rt archives Holidays video cartoon Hollywood Foreign Press Association Native supernatural Exclusive Video Logo Comedy CNN The Arrangement Adult Swim cancelled TV shows leaderboard cancelled Shondaland broadcast mockumentary Pixar CBS politics feel good 73rd Emmy Awards Valentine's Day