Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Captain America: The First Avenger is Good Old-Fashioned Fun

Plus, Friends with Benefits' stars have great chemistry.

by | July 21, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a shield-wielding superhero (Captain America: The First Avenger, starring Chris Evans and Hayley Atwell) and a commitment-free couple (Friends With Benefits, starring Justin Timberlake and Mila Kunis). What do the critics have to say?

Captain America: The First Avenger


Good ol’ Captain America. He’s one of Marvel’s oldest heroes. But how does he fare in the 21st Century? Not badly at all, say critics; if Captain America: The First Avenger is a cut below Marvel’s other 2011 blockbusters (Thor and X-Men: First Class, both Certified Fresh), it’s still a rousing, proudly old-fashioned superhero flick with tons of visual flash and an exceptional lead performance from Chris Evans. Steve Rogers (Evans) is a super patriotic lad who’s rejected by the draft board as physically unable to serve. However, he’s enlisted by an expat scientist who’s working on an experiment to create super soldiers, and soon, he’s battling HYDRA, a terrorist organization led by a former Nazi called Red Skull. The pundits say Captain America is a scrappy crowd pleaser that compensates for its lack of originality with strong acting and sense of innocent nostalgia that’s refreshing in our irony-soaked era. (Check out Marvel Movie Madness, in which the RT staff memebers share our thoughts on all of the Marvel movie.)

Friends with Benefits


Will Gluck scored big with Easy A, a teen comedy that brought smarts and freshness to a shopworn subgenre. Can he do the same with a grown up romantic comedy? It appears the answer is “for the most part;” critics say Friends With Benefits has moments of sharp humor and a pair of attractive, lively leads, but too often it veers into predictable territory. Justin Timberlake and Mila Kunis star as, yes, friends with benefits: two busy, career-driven pals who agree to share physical intimacy while avoiding the potentially painful trappings of a committed relationship. But what if one starts to actually fall for the other? The pundits say Friends With Benefits gets a major boost from the stars’ easy chemistry and often witty banter, but the movie never fully avoids the clichés it’s attempting to skewer. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Woody Harrelson’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Life in a Day, a synthesis of YouTube videos uploaded by users around the globe in a single day, is at 100 percent.
  • The Woman With The 5 Elephants, a doc about the life and times of a great Russian literature translator, is at 100 percent.
  • World on a Wire, Rainer Werner Fassbinder‘s newly rediscovered 1973 dystopian sci-fi epic, is at 100 percent.
  • Fire in Babylon, a doc about the glory days of West Indian cricket squads in the post-colonial 1970s, is at 89 percent.
  • The Myth Of The American Sleepover, an indie coming-of-age dramedy about a group of teens’ late summer exploits before the beginning of a new school year, is at 83 percent.
  • Sarah’s Key, starring Kristin Scott Thomas in a drama about a journalist who uncovers a dark secret about a family dispossessed by the Nazis, is at 74 percent.
  • Another Earth, an indie sci-fi romance about a pair of damaged souls who attempt to start anew on an exact replica of our planet, is at 64 percent.
  • A Little Help, starring Jenna Fischer and Chris O’Donnell in a dramedy about a suburban woman who suffers a mental breakdown after 9/11, is at 39 percent.

Tag Cloud

ghosts worst Awards Tour mission: impossible Rock boxing Holiday what to watch romance 73rd Emmy Awards lord of the rings Shudder comics finale ID 79th Golden Globes Awards Musical docuseries anthology Disney+ Disney Plus festivals unscripted television Horror TCA Awards Cannes Quiz Paramount Plus technology Instagram Live Comedy Central wonder woman comiccon Country space USA FX on Hulu Columbia Pictures Awards Animation asian-american DGA disaster Freeform CMT medical drama adaptation rotten movies we love book adaptation documentaries FX 93rd Oscars werewolf halloween tv cancelled TV series USA Network OneApp justice league prank Fall TV IMDb TV golden globes El Rey genre talk show rt labs godzilla series boxoffice mcc Infographic ABC Tumblr TCA Winter 2020 movies spy thriller Comic Book renewed TV shows Cosplay Exclusive Video Video Games Kids & Family die hard based on movie 2019 YA natural history robots Pacific Islander Netflix Writers Guild of America Trailer crossover BBC TV TV One football CNN AMC Plus canceled TV shows strong female leads toy story PaleyFest leaderboard harry potter sitcom BBC One Stephen King cinemax Hollywood Foreign Press Association emmy awards 2018 adventure RT21 Arrowverse dark 90s Pop TV rt archives marvel comics Nickelodeon FXX Creative Arts Emmys chucky king arthur live action Dark Horse Comics Disney cats australia Fantasy PBS blockbusters twilight SundanceTV vampires art house Sundance Now The Witch Acorn TV TLC Cartoon Network Musicals kong comedies scary movies Tokyo Olympics Universal Marathons Hallmark Broadway 2021 serial killer Chilling Adventures of Sabrina italian Lifetime Set visit best jurassic park gangster Paramount Network Year in Review pirates of the caribbean Holidays critic resources Captain marvel Academy Awards crime Netflix Christmas movies Endgame Mudbound festival richard e. Grant Pirates Apple TV Plus women jamie lee curtis Star Wars french Oscars The Walking Dead toronto psychological thriller GLAAD Starz parents Biopics docudrama target composers Countdown hist popular award winner japanese Western Rom-Com versus period drama Baby Yoda stoner Turner Classic Movies MTV spanish language james bond hispanic heritage month VICE Tomatazos cancelled television name the review Hulu animated foreign Lucasfilm Summer Spike Hear Us Out TV movies Best and Worst slashers Esquire superman Lifetime Christmas movies 4/20 universal monsters YouTube Amazon travel Extras DirecTV The Walt Disney Company new zealand Comic-Con@Home 2021 TCM MSNBC Rocketman Superheroes facebook casting A24 cancelled TV shows Martial Arts The Arrangement 20th Century Fox SDCC basketball screen actors guild directors Comics on TV LGBTQ zombies indiana jones E! Teen Women's History Month documentary laika black debate Syfy cartoon live event ITV Disney Plus aapi Reality TBS know your critic miniseries Prime Video spanish rt labs critics edition WarnerMedia X-Men game show Tarantino Neflix Vudu CBS Valentine's Day New York Comic Con AMC Showtime Mary Poppins Returns mutant sopranos psycho Super Bowl APB Sci-Fi classics Elton John quibi cars Marvel Studios Superheroe sports 2017 Crunchyroll new star wars movies olympics DC Universe Britbox HFPA war Marvel Television Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt slasher Emmys Hallmark Christmas movies See It Skip It streaming rotten History royal family Funimation trailers Travel Channel TNT Television Critics Association Polls and Games hollywood golden globe awards book dexter Pixar NBC ViacomCBS true crime Sundance TV marvel cinematic universe science fiction suspense reviews Nominations deadpool 1990s vs. BET TruTV BAFTA President Thanksgiving TCA 2017 comic Walt Disney Pictures San Diego Comic-Con anime movie worst movies mockumentary feel good films dreamworks streaming movies BBC America Tubi king kong indie screenings Marvel 24 frames supernatural TV Land thriller witnail new york Box Office theme song The Academy E3 YouTube Premium Interview archives Heroines biopic Watching Series 007 Pet Sematary trophy singing competition historical drama video on demand fresh Calendar blaxploitation saw crime drama elevated horror independent Adult Swim BET Awards Turner Food Network Trivia adenture dc sequel Amazon Prime Video critics political drama Trophy Talk Black History Month comic book movie Discovery Channel HBO Film Festival Image Comics Certified Fresh Schedule TIFF kids Crackle NYCC child's play venice Family nature concert halloween discovery Masterpiece zero dark thirty DC Comics Chernobyl GIFs spinoff Bravo Warner Bros. young adult dramedy mob IFC Films 71st Emmy Awards sag awards Winter TV all-time news satire stop motion south america heist movie Ellie Kemper children's TV Sneak Peek Ovation Mary poppins SXSW black comedy social media NBA comic books GoT joker ESPN rom-coms VH1 obituary hispanic Fox News OWN ratings Black Mirror franchise Legendary canceled Mindy Kaling Premiere Dates HBO Max green book Wes Anderson First Look The CW telelvision ABC Signature Emmy Nominations blockbuster Sony Pictures cooking 2015 tv talk Rocky VOD Song of Ice and Fire dragons scene in color MCU biography Brie Larson CW Seed criterion superhero spain A&E remakes Television Academy Reality Competition transformers WGN Drama 21st Century Fox teaser posters Tags: Comedy Action Nat Geo monster movies Election LGBT comic book movies a nightmare on elm street international Mystery Logo Ghostbusters The Purge stand-up comedy 72 Emmy Awards Disney Channel CBS All Access 2016 HBO Go First Reviews binge romantic comedy Red Carpet Character Guide spider-man breaking bad cancelled free movies Fox Searchlight Paramount razzies Amazon Studios Epix American Society of Cinematographers nfl 45 police drama revenge fast and furious Lionsgate latino kaiju japan Peacock YouTube Red Apple aliens reboot 2020 Pride Month National Geographic Podcast nbcuniversal Spectrum Originals Toys high school sequels crime thriller cops scorecard Shondaland Apple TV+ Avengers game of thrones Photos batman Disney streaming service spider-verse Music Christmas politics dogs Spring TV DC streaming service diversity 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards doctor who Mary Tyler Moore PlayStation Grammys Classic Film legend Binge Guide Alien IFC Comedy TV renewals video TCA dceu ABC Family RT History Star Trek scary Opinion Universal Pictures christmas movies Sundance 99% cults zombie Film Fargo FOX Amazon Prime Pop hidden camera Winners Anna Paquin action-comedy