Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Captain America: The First Avenger is Good Old-Fashioned Fun

Plus, Friends with Benefits' stars have great chemistry.

by | July 21, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a shield-wielding superhero (Captain America: The First Avenger, starring Chris Evans and Hayley Atwell) and a commitment-free couple (Friends With Benefits, starring Justin Timberlake and Mila Kunis). What do the critics have to say?

Captain America: The First Avenger


Good ol’ Captain America. He’s one of Marvel’s oldest heroes. But how does he fare in the 21st Century? Not badly at all, say critics; if Captain America: The First Avenger is a cut below Marvel’s other 2011 blockbusters (Thor and X-Men: First Class, both Certified Fresh), it’s still a rousing, proudly old-fashioned superhero flick with tons of visual flash and an exceptional lead performance from Chris Evans. Steve Rogers (Evans) is a super patriotic lad who’s rejected by the draft board as physically unable to serve. However, he’s enlisted by an expat scientist who’s working on an experiment to create super soldiers, and soon, he’s battling HYDRA, a terrorist organization led by a former Nazi called Red Skull. The pundits say Captain America is a scrappy crowd pleaser that compensates for its lack of originality with strong acting and sense of innocent nostalgia that’s refreshing in our irony-soaked era. (Check out Marvel Movie Madness, in which the RT staff memebers share our thoughts on all of the Marvel movie.)

Friends with Benefits


Will Gluck scored big with Easy A, a teen comedy that brought smarts and freshness to a shopworn subgenre. Can he do the same with a grown up romantic comedy? It appears the answer is “for the most part;” critics say Friends With Benefits has moments of sharp humor and a pair of attractive, lively leads, but too often it veers into predictable territory. Justin Timberlake and Mila Kunis star as, yes, friends with benefits: two busy, career-driven pals who agree to share physical intimacy while avoiding the potentially painful trappings of a committed relationship. But what if one starts to actually fall for the other? The pundits say Friends With Benefits gets a major boost from the stars’ easy chemistry and often witty banter, but the movie never fully avoids the clichés it’s attempting to skewer. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Woody Harrelson’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Life in a Day, a synthesis of YouTube videos uploaded by users around the globe in a single day, is at 100 percent.

  • The Woman With The 5 Elephants, a doc about the life and times of a great Russian literature translator, is at 100 percent.

  • World on a Wire, Rainer Werner Fassbinder‘s newly rediscovered 1973 dystopian sci-fi epic, is at 100 percent.

  • Fire in Babylon, a doc about the glory days of West Indian cricket squads in the post-colonial 1970s, is at 89 percent.

  • The Myth Of The American Sleepover, an indie coming-of-age dramedy about a group of teens’ late summer exploits before the beginning of a new school year, is at 83 percent.

  • Sarah’s Key, starring Kristin Scott Thomas in a drama about a journalist who uncovers a dark secret about a family dispossessed by the Nazis, is at 74 percent.

  • Another Earth, an indie sci-fi romance about a pair of damaged souls who attempt to start anew on an exact replica of our planet, is at 64 percent.

  • A Little Help, starring Jenna Fischer and Chris O’Donnell in a dramedy about a suburban woman who suffers a mental breakdown after 9/11, is at 39 percent.

Tag Cloud

sequel movie vampires casting legend adventure comic books Opinion franchise wonder woman streamig Discovery Channel toronto rt archives 007 politics Nat Geo richard e. Grant Super Bowl posters TV movies lord of the rings art house cancelled TV series emmy awards Comedy reboot basketball Tags: Comedy TBS HBO The Witch psycho science fiction Sony Pictures diversity Sony TV One Reality Competition halloween tv children's TV award winner screen actors guild Lifetime Disney Plus Infographic Vudu strong female leads Trophy Talk breaking bad independent chucky Adult Swim See It Skip It mockumentary obituary E3 boxoffice spy thriller Neflix Hear Us Out Crackle Black Mirror Family streaming movies canceled TV shows 2015 dexter leaderboard CNN superman 93rd Oscars technology Cartoon Network slashers Pacific Islander mcc french Logo tv talk Binge Guide mob comic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Chernobyl Comic-Con@Home 2021 dc Shondaland Apple TV+ Sci-Fi Star Wars Celebration composers rom-coms Travel Channel international Wes Anderson feel good GIFs GLAAD thriller heist movie Prime Video zero dark thirty target scene in color Anna Paquin docuseries Apple Food Network Awards Tour Marathons summer TV vs. New York Comic Con Comics on TV theme song rt labs critics edition 72 Emmy Awards 2018 book adaptation FX on Hulu Masterpiece asian-american scorecard medical drama ESPN Heroines justice league crime thriller Tarantino SXSW 2022 Britbox crossover finale Captain marvel best joker based on movie werewolf comics ID live action Oscars Country godzilla TLC action-comedy comedies transformers MCU boxing Showtime Amazon Studios Video Games Fall TV Hallmark Christmas movies YouTube Red sequels remakes CW Seed scene in color series Rom-Com interviews Hallmark Reality Martial Arts game show 94th Oscars 45 South by Southwest Film Festival crime Nickelodeon Mary poppins travel Image Comics Countdown Election universal monsters worst slasher CBS criterion CMT Turner Classic Movies scary movies OneApp cancelled TV shows TCM IFC batman scary DirecTV directors Lionsgate blaxploitation cults Cosplay Instagram Live video on demand sports nfl Musical Columbia Pictures TV Land Esquire A&E TV renewals Marvel Television Warner Bros. Pop TV Alien Ovation YA south america disaster Best and Worst canceled Hulu golden globes war cancelled television renewed TV shows IMDb TV HBO Max Baby Yoda mutant italian free movies Tokyo Olympics Mystery OWN USA cartoon Box Office worst movies latino docudrama Music 2016 dragons video spider-verse football SXSW Watching Series halloween child's play Fantasy Certified Fresh TCA Winter 2020 spanish cancelled YouTube Premium king arthur Western Year in Review reviews unscripted Paramount king kong die hard BAFTA DGA Podcast superhero Netflix First Reviews comic book movies streaming know your critic 71st Emmy Awards stop motion 20th Century Fox doctor who Marvel Amazon Prime Biopics LGBTQ Musicals FX E! Classic Film Focus Features Exclusive Video sopranos stand-up comedy PlayStation Nominations SundanceTV BET Awards ITV parents The Academy Emmys Ellie Kemper Peacock BBC cars 90s Best Picture japan hispanic heritage month Schedule BET Sundance Now Tubi natural history anime biopic green book Fox News television facebook dark serial killer Fox Searchlight 2020 series Christmas Paramount Plus History gangster target dogs Action VICE Spring TV golden globe awards hispanic Epix MSNBC spain spider-man Television Academy cooking The Walking Dead Walt Disney Pictures X-Men comic book movie versus hidden camera USA Network marvel comics zombies Legendary Sneak Peek Film Festival 79th Golden Globes Awards young adult Winners summer TV preview 2021 genre singing competition 2019 Geeked Week Netflix Christmas movies australia TruTV Universal Oscar royal family San Diego Comic-Con Indigenous news twilight WGN DC Comics dreamworks Star Wars Mary Tyler Moore pirates of the caribbean screenings robots Red Carpet psychological thriller women Superheroe popular Black History Month ABC Family rt labs Premiere Dates debate HFPA documentaries period drama festival Dark Horse Comics The Arrangement Turner Thanksgiving The Purge obi wan NBC Trivia Holidays Universal Pictures MGM 1990s teaser Sundance TV RT21 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Interview Marvel Studios Best Actress The CW Rock broadcast anthology satire Calendar FOX Rocky American Society of Cinematographers marvel cinematic universe kaiju deadpool Hollywood Foreign Press Association TCA mission: impossible social media cinemax VH1 Fargo blockbuster BBC One spanish language PBS Animation what to watch Avengers Star Trek GoT dramedy Funimation Disney streaming service RT History sag awards historical drama Emmy Nominations Song of Ice and Fire book movies National Geographic a nightmare on elm street concert harry potter elevated horror Shudder Disney Channel Women's History Month true crime saw Mudbound Valentine's Day TCA 2017 Holiday laika LGBT SDCC Television Critics Association prank Bravo Stephen King hollywood films IFC Films talk show 2017 black comedy AMC Plus ghosts ratings binge Pride Month razzies olympics CBS All Access ABC Signature revenge scene in color game of thrones Extras romantic comedy new zealand sitcom El Rey documentary rotten Horror monster movies Best Director Native dceu aliens spinoff Comic Book Pop Rocketman stoner Creative Arts Emmys critics Apple TV Plus all-time Teen Lucasfilm aapi TV jamie lee curtis venice Writers Guild of America 21st Century Fox fresh WarnerMedia kids Superheroes Disney Drama HBO Go Amazon Prime Video TNT TIFF Paramount Network First Look Tumblr hist nbcuniversal indiana jones DC streaming service ViacomCBS classics archives YouTube trophy PaleyFest Elton John Arrowverse Mindy Kaling Brie Larson 24 frames ABC critic resources animated Set visit Pirates supernatural Pixar political drama blockbusters BBC America VOD high school festivals Grammys Spectrum Originals Broadway fast and furious Academy Awards Polls and Games Syfy MTV Freeform Lifetime Christmas movies foreign Film FXX name the review Crunchyroll nature new star wars movies cats comiccon Trailer Quiz 4/20 AMC quibi james bond scene in color film series DC Universe telelvision Toys 73rd Emmy Awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina NBA Amazon discovery Paramount Pictures indie japanese Photos police drama TCA Awards Winter TV Awards President biography witnail Endgame Acorn TV APB Starz The Walt Disney Company Cannes A24 jurassic park 99% NYCC christmas movies black kong Summer Ghostbusters Tomatazos crime drama miniseries Best Actor Comedy Central trailers new york live event Kids & Family adenture Character Guide rotten movies we love space Sundance adaptation romance suspense Spike zombie Mary Poppins Returns toy story cops Pet Sematary Disney+ Disney Plus summer preview