Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Cadillac Records Rocks, Punisher Hurts

Plus, Nobel Son doesn't take home the prize.

by | December 4, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got red-hot rhythm and blues (Cadillac Records, starring Adrien Brody and Beyonce Knowles), vigilante justice (Punisher: War Zone, starring Ray Stevenson and Dominic West), and a kidnapping caper (Nobel Son, starring Alan Rickman and Eliza Dushku). What do the critics have to say?

The influence of Chess Records’ output on popular music is impossible to overstate, and it’s difficult to imagine any film about its seminal roster — which included Muddy Waters, Howlin’ Wolf, Etta James, and Chuck Berry — doing it justice. The critics say while Cadillac Records falls a bit short of this noble goal, it’s still a well-acted, finely crafted piece of work. The movie stars Adrien Brody as Leonard Chess, a Polish immigrant whose enthusiasm for R&B and blues led him to record some of the best music of the 1950s and 1960s, an era during which the sounds of African American musicians began to reach the mainstream. Chess has a familial relationship with his artists, including James (Beyonce Knowles) and Waters (Jeffrey Wright), but their personal demons — and the huge success of Berry (Mos Def) — creates disharmony at the label. The pundits say much of Cadillac Records is the stuff of familiar biopics, and it tries to cover way too much ground. However, they also note the performances — particularly Mos Def and Wright — are outstanding, and the music is wild and powerful enough to overcome some of the bumpy spots. At 62 percent on the Tomatometer, Cadillac Records has got its mojo workin’ reasonably well. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down some of the most successful transitions by rappers to Hollywood.)

“It doesn’t work for me, Muddy. I gotta have more cowbell!”


Punisher: War Zone is the third cinematic try for the Marvel Comics vigilante; previous installments starring Dolph Lundgren and Thomas Jane failed to connect with audiences or critics. Nor is this one likely to, if the reviews are any indication. Ray Stevenson stars as Frank Castle (AKA The Punisher), a black-clad ex-marine turned one-man killing machine. He runs afoul of a mob boss, who adopts the nom de villain Jigsaw and sends an army of thugs to take the Punisher down. The pundits say War Zone is more brutal than most slasher flicks, but despite its hyperkinetic violence and flashes of sick humor, this is an over-the-top action flick with little of the emotional impact we’ve come to expect from comic book adaptations of late. At 19 percent on the Tomatometer, this one looks like punishment.

“I am not drinking any f—ing Merlot!”


It’s an intriguing premise: the son of a brilliant chemist is kidnapped on the eve of his father being awarded the Nobel Prize, but he hates the old man so much he agrees to go along with the scheme. Unfortunately, critics say Nobel Son, despite some sharp performances, doesn’t really work. Alan Rickman plays the father, a mean-spirited, pompous jerk who refuses to pay the ransom for Barkley (Bryan Greenberg), an aimless Ph.D student who just met a mysterious woman (Eliza Dushku). The pundits say Nobel Son is overplotted and too self-consciously weird to work, but the actors – particularly Rickman – are generally solid. At 27 percent on the Tomatometer, Nobel Son is no prize winner.

“That Noam Chomsky is such a cutup!”


Also opening this week in limited release:

  • A revival of Federico Fellini‘s Amarcord, in which the master director takes a fond look back at his youth and his hometown, is at 100 percent.
  • The Aussie import The Black Balloon, a coming-of-age tale about an autistic teen who finds love, is at 100 percent.
  • Hunger, based on the true story of IRA member Bobby Sands’ hunger strike in prison, is at 93 percent.
  • Ron Howard‘s Frost/Nixon, about the former president’s series of interviews with an Australian television personality, is at 88 percent.
  • Dust, a documentary about the ever-present substance, is at 80 percent.

Recent Mos Def Movies:

Tag Cloud

PaleyFest diversity Alien Paramount Plus Rock classics animated summer TV preview Year in Review Broadway Super Bowl Reality Competition halloween tv adaptation Kids & Family Rocky Holiday wonder woman Baby Yoda Tokyo Olympics psychological thriller Emmys Pop TV Trivia Certified Fresh twilight Shudder christmas movies blockbusters Dark Horse Comics finale Comics on TV Hollywood Foreign Press Association screenings Winners TCA Winter 2020 Universal Pictures Sneak Peek HBO joker doctor who space talk show Apple IFC Films politics docudrama vs. AMC Plus Sci-Fi 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Starz TBS Thanksgiving batman ABC Family revenge Mystery MSNBC spanish language Apple TV Plus AMC spider-man CW Seed hidden camera Awards game show live action Brie Larson CNN remakes PBS godzilla ITV Focus Features Cartoon Network supernatural indie jurassic park Columbia Pictures Exclusive Video First Look Captain marvel Lucasfilm Funimation video on demand nfl suspense romantic comedy NYCC french elevated horror Image Comics Elton John Musicals hispanic heritage month Toys Horror composers IMDb TV black comedy Food Network American Society of Cinematographers Television Critics Association Disney+ Disney Plus Bravo mcc harry potter transformers Biopics documentaries Prime Video San Diego Comic-Con streaming movies USA Musical 45 tv talk cars GoT jamie lee curtis rt labs critics edition anime versus marvel comics 20th Century Fox romance stand-up comedy summer TV comiccon natural history fast and furious renewed TV shows Syfy TV FXX cartoon adventure adenture WGN Christmas Paramount Pictures thriller Star Trek Photos cancelled TV series 007 The Witch CMT strong female leads Discovery Channel movies justice league saw festival Opinion Awards Tour witnail Character Guide Disney concert science fiction Oscars game of thrones ViacomCBS 4/20 Best Actress unscripted award winner LGBT television directors Amazon Prime Amazon dark docuseries Academy Awards genre Freeform Sundance dceu Holidays chucky VOD streaming Western reviews cancelled TV shows Universal BET Awards mutant Tarantino book X-Men Lifetime scary Nat Geo Paramount Network cooking Logo DGA indiana jones Sundance TV 2017 Film obituary cancelled television Turner Classic Movies Winter TV dramedy casting The CW new york werewolf halloween PlayStation Extras crime quibi richard e. Grant Shondaland best die hard Legendary ABC Writers Guild of America Tubi Paramount medical drama Rom-Com japan Amazon Prime Video Travel Channel Comedy FX on Hulu series USA Network cats kong Calendar james bond football australia boxoffice rom-coms BBC America dogs high school CBS All Access YouTube Red Spectrum Originals 2021 discovery Esquire 79th Golden Globes Awards Polls and Games robots TCA comic books NBC rt archives scene in color Trophy Talk Anna Paquin TLC binge leaderboard anthology prank aapi video Oscar Nominations art house IFC ABC Signature book adaptation green book Grammys Amazon Studios war breaking bad pirates of the caribbean 71st Emmy Awards biography scorecard sopranos cults Watching Series news SundanceTV Crackle biopic worst Valentine's Day mockumentary Britbox aliens Fall TV TV One Nickelodeon toy story Warner Bros. legend Chilling Adventures of Sabrina movie streamig OneApp scene in color film series Masterpiece stoner scary movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt mob debate deadpool Summer Chernobyl dreamworks The Walking Dead Best Picture italian TruTV travel Pacific Islander Mudbound SXSW Native Interview Acorn TV MTV Hallmark archives dexter 2020 BBC asian-american kids 2019 Film Festival Teen Cosplay MGM 2018 Crunchyroll Television Academy Best and Worst Peacock Drama Disney streaming service Binge Guide spinoff singing competition scene in color series child's play Infographic mission: impossible new star wars movies screen actors guild teaser canceled TV shows crossover target New York Comic Con Showtime Best Actor Adult Swim cops National Geographic satire Sony DirecTV Hear Us Out international Neflix superman vampires serial killer franchise disaster target scene in color RT History action-comedy comics critic resources trophy Comic-Con@Home 2021 feel good Premiere Dates TCM lord of the rings First Reviews Martial Arts Netflix Christmas movies 2015 NBA Endgame SXSW 2022 telelvision Star Wars slashers women See It Skip It worst movies rt labs The Walt Disney Company HBO Max south america Mindy Kaling king kong ghosts TV renewals canceled ESPN hollywood BBC One FOX documentary A&E 72 Emmy Awards sequels Song of Ice and Fire Marvel Studios Fargo Netflix young adult foreign ID parents DC Comics Emmy Nominations Quiz Lifetime Christmas movies Pop President TV Land Set visit all-time historical drama posters El Rey APB Schedule Lionsgate Comedy Central comedies Reality Vudu 1990s true crime Classic Film Instagram Live hist Tags: Comedy YouTube TCA Awards Action Sony Pictures BAFTA venice marvel cinematic universe criterion police drama blaxploitation YA slasher a nightmare on elm street Geeked Week Country OWN nbcuniversal Fox News E3 HFPA Family heist movie The Academy Pride Month interviews Indigenous BET MCU Black History Month political drama Music 21st Century Fox gangster Hulu period drama what to watch films critics Box Office cinemax know your critic dc The Purge Star Wars Celebration independent TV movies hispanic Mary Poppins Returns razzies black Marathons TNT Comic Book comic book movie Best Director History DC Universe zombies sports VH1 psycho Animation GIFs Women's History Month E! new zealand Black Mirror Ghostbusters Fox Searchlight stop motion Marvel 93rd Oscars A24 theme song YouTube Premium free movies monster movies Turner 94th Oscars TIFF Superheroes Arrowverse TCA 2017 99% VICE Avengers comic 90s Creative Arts Emmys broadcast FX crime thriller 24 frames kaiju DC streaming service blockbuster WarnerMedia CBS Stephen King sitcom Rocketman sag awards 73rd Emmy Awards olympics Sundance Now Spike Tumblr children's TV laika nature SDCC Walt Disney Pictures Cannes spanish Ellie Kemper GLAAD ratings Election Podcast Fantasy South by Southwest Film Festival rotten Superheroe zombie social media Mary Tyler Moore live event Marvel Television Hallmark Christmas movies latino RT21 name the review Video Games basketball superhero festivals Apple TV+ Red Carpet comic book movies HBO Go fresh Tomatazos spy thriller king arthur technology Pirates miniseries summer preview crime drama spider-verse zero dark thirty Mary poppins Heroines reboot Pet Sematary Wes Anderson Trailer 2016 emmy awards royal family boxing facebook The Arrangement golden globes rotten movies we love LGBTQ toronto japanese spain popular obi wan Disney Plus Countdown universal monsters Spring TV Epix dragons golden globe awards cancelled Pixar Ovation based on movie Disney Channel trailers sequel