Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: American Sniper Hits the Target, Paddington Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Blackhat does not compute, and The Wedding Ringer is short on laughs.

by | January 15, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fallen soldier (American Sniper, starring Bradley Cooper and Sienna Miller), a marmalade-loving bear (Paddington, starring Hugh Bonneville and Sally Hawkins), an ex-con hacker (Blackhat, starring Chris Hemsworth and Viola Davis), and a best man for hire (The Wedding Ringer, starring Kevin Hart and Josh Gad). What do the critics have to say?

American Sniper


As a director, Clint Eastwood is one of cinema’s greatest chroniclers of troubled tough guys. Critics say American Sniper is a tense, kinetic drama that has much to say about the emotional toll of war — even if it fudges some of the facts about its real-life subject. Bradley Cooper stars as Chris Kyle, a Navy SEAL sniper who achieved near-legendary status for his fearlessness and shooting accuracy. But when he left the service, Kyle’s place in the world became less certain. The pundits say American Sniper avoids some of the more controversial aspects of Kyle’s life, but it’s still a bracing, tense, powerfully acted portrait of a supremely talented soldier at war with himself.



The bear from darkest Peru is one of the brightest lights of the young movie year. Critics say Paddington is the best kind of family film — it’s funny, thoughtful, deeply heartfelt, and filled with strong characters. After stowing away on a boat, the titular bear arrives in London and is discovered by the Brown family, who bring him into their home. Paddington is a stranger in a strange land, but he does his best to adjust to city life; unfortunately, he also draws the attention of a devious taxidermist. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Paddington maintains the cheer and whimsy of Michael Bond’s books, while teaching children a gentle lesson in tolerance. (Check out star Hugh Bonneville’s Five Favorite Films, as well as our interviews with the cast and crew.)



It’s tough to make computing look cool on the big screen. Critics say even a talented director like Michael Mann can only add so much to something like Blackhat, a cyberthriller that’s long on visual razzle-dazzle but short on tension and believability. Chris Hemsworth stars as Nick Hathaway, a brilliant hacker who’s serving prison time. However, when U.S. intelligence agents team up with the Chinese government to investigate a devastating act of cyberterrorism, they spring Hathaway from the joint to help solve the case. The pundits say Blackhat squanders its timely premise on a silly plotting and dialogue, though it does have a sense of visual panache.

The Wedding Ringer


Kevin Hart is one of the funniest men on the planet, but critics say his comic exuberance can’t save The Wedding Ringer, a thoroughly so-so bromance with a few good gags but a whole lot of dead spots. Hart stars as Jimmy, who provides an unusual service: he serves as the best man for socially awkward, soon-to-be-wedded guys. While giving Doug (Josh Gad) instructions on how to act cool, Jimmy stars to actually like the big galoot. The pundits say Hart tries his best, but the pace is slack and too many of the jokes are of the gross-out variety. (Check out our interviews with Kevin Hart, Josh Gad, and Kaley Cuoco.)

What’s Hot On TV:

Critics say Togetherness (Certified Fresh at 94 percent) is a delightful surprise that interweaves day-to-day life with moving, dramatic characters who have an affinity for deprecating, squirmy humor.

The critics say Man Seeking Woman (92 percent) is easy to fall for, taking a ridiculously funny approach to a common theme with amusingly surreality and enjoyable oddness.

The pundits say Girls (Certified Fresh at 86 percent) is familiar after four seasons, but its convoluted-yet-comical depiction of young women dealing with the real world still manages to impress.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Interview Sundance Now documentaries 93rd Oscars crossover 21st Century Fox binge Hear Us Out worst movies Disney Native target scene in color reboot godzilla romance fresh transformers science fiction Watching Series Bravo Fox News Disney+ Disney Plus NBA TLC The Walking Dead RT History Trivia Pet Sematary concert Lifetime historical drama APB Comics on TV PaleyFest Fall TV critics Animation Reality The Arrangement Syfy fast and furious directors Chernobyl Spectrum Originals Shudder Marvel politics Best Director Warner Bros. Focus Features streamig Certified Fresh Ovation nature Lifetime Christmas movies DC Universe BET Awards scorecard A&E prank rotten Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 2020 rt labs critics edition trophy spinoff Mary Tyler Moore monster movies comic sopranos Stephen King SXSW 2022 Rocketman MCU Fox Searchlight spider-man Neflix political drama Turner vampires new star wars movies summer TV preview Lionsgate Toys Premiere Dates Arrowverse BBC TBS royal family travel nbcuniversal scene in color Sundance TV Country kaiju Academy Awards facebook toronto supernatural genre GLAAD dark Winners jamie lee curtis anime Election LGBT revenge Walt Disney Pictures casting Star Wars art house 2016 mutant true crime HBO Go archives Awards technology 2021 blockbuster DC streaming service breaking bad American Society of Cinematographers renewed TV shows Thanksgiving japanese Grammys Hallmark Christmas movies YA 24 frames cancelled cooking gangster free movies ID Esquire cancelled TV series twilight TCA Awards ESPN heist movie TCA versus young adult Tomatazos Lucasfilm Rom-Com Film Geeked Week canceled TV shows 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards halloween Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt E3 TCM blockbusters Britbox movie South by Southwest Film Festival Mary poppins james bond Action Best and Worst Super Bowl Mystery Marathons 71st Emmy Awards cats ABC spanish language FOX boxoffice DirecTV Video Games Infographic aapi 007 trailers 90s Tumblr Pride Month broadcast Extras war Food Network Ghostbusters Exclusive Video Reality Competition HBO Star Wars Celebration RT21 dogs justice league adventure vs. Disney streaming service Spike dragons slashers book dexter Pacific Islander TV movies MSNBC BBC America Holidays dramedy Teen universal monsters cinemax Photos Turner Classic Movies christmas movies hispanic heritage month kong know your critic werewolf scene in color film series stand-up comedy SundanceTV screen actors guild 2019 MTV 94th Oscars TCA Winter 2020 Pop TV zombies harry potter slasher TV elevated horror black Instagram Live king kong 2018 theme song asian-american obituary remakes Crunchyroll Pirates VICE TNT Dark Horse Comics Sci-Fi Horror Funimation animated finale what to watch PBS Peacock Best Picture classics pirates of the caribbean OWN dceu Hollywood Foreign Press Association rt labs HFPA kids comic book movies First Reviews quibi razzies high school Winter TV spy thriller SXSW telelvision toy story news dreamworks king arthur Pixar Comic-Con@Home 2021 Rock CBS series LGBTQ HBO Max Endgame a nightmare on elm street golden globes nfl interviews olympics aliens blaxploitation disaster television 99% docuseries ratings 79th Golden Globes Awards Marvel Television legend child's play Heroines summer preview Crackle Polls and Games MGM cartoon IFC festivals X-Men OneApp Tags: Comedy jurassic park The Witch singing competition canceled TV Land zombie Marvel Studios Trailer IMDb TV social media wonder woman golden globe awards halloween tv sports Acorn TV Paramount Plus Paramount Network sequel ITV YouTube San Diego Comic-Con Sneak Peek Broadway mockumentary lord of the rings Classic Film Box Office TV One Tubi TruTV Comedy Central indiana jones See It Skip It Paramount Pictures Creative Arts Emmys Cartoon Network Holiday psycho satire cancelled television Best Actress zero dark thirty hollywood IFC Films Western Sony Pictures stoner Christmas Epix Tokyo Olympics mob 2017 Podcast comic books discovery basketball new zealand hist batman book adaptation The Purge Amazon stop motion Comedy south america New York Comic Con 72 Emmy Awards President BAFTA scary movies foreign video Netflix Christmas movies Sony WGN USA Network Character Guide leaderboard CMT cars deadpool children's TV women Alien CBS All Access marvel comics Nominations rotten movies we love Song of Ice and Fire Television Academy target marvel cinematic universe The Academy Women's History Month reviews 20th Century Fox CNN El Rey YouTube Premium Schedule Star Trek Valentine's Day Drama Writers Guild of America name the review festival AMC Plus ABC Family Summer streaming hidden camera worst NBC Mindy Kaling Legendary popular Mary Poppins Returns psychological thriller rom-coms TV renewals cops Shondaland venice live action game show dc movies Red Carpet robots ViacomCBS Black Mirror romantic comedy tv talk Martial Arts parents critic resources Anna Paquin scary saw franchise National Geographic streaming movies Tarantino Musicals Awards Tour based on movie independent criterion Pop Hulu VOD Elton John spain doctor who die hard scene in color series Brie Larson The Walt Disney Company screenings chucky diversity Mudbound comic book movie Emmys debate Set visit Countdown DGA NYCC Musical comedies PlayStation Baby Yoda A24 boxing indie GIFs Discovery Channel Calendar USA talk show black comedy Best Actor emmy awards comics crime thriller Showtime YouTube Red Quiz ABC Signature Adult Swim Masterpiece Apple TV+ AMC Fargo Television Critics Association crime drama adaptation Oscar space FX on Hulu Year in Review teaser summer TV posters 2015 Cosplay police drama GoT Biopics Opinion Apple TV Plus biopic biography TIFF spanish crime Music Universal Pictures docudrama witnail strong female leads DC Comics superman latino Starz medical drama First Look unscripted Image Comics Superheroe football all-time Disney Channel action-comedy 1990s feel good rt archives australia suspense Nickelodeon Avengers period drama Paramount sequels Film Festival VH1 Ellie Kemper The CW FXX Prime Video richard e. Grant natural history international video on demand Captain marvel composers new york Nat Geo laika mission: impossible obi wan Superheroes Disney Plus spider-verse Spring TV miniseries Amazon Studios Comic Book Emmy Nominations Indigenous 4/20 french Family superhero Vudu WarnerMedia Fantasy Sundance japan mcc Freeform Binge Guide BET CW Seed Hallmark serial killer green book cancelled TV shows Netflix Travel Channel award winner ghosts Amazon Prime Video Kids & Family History italian joker sitcom game of thrones best cults sag awards thriller Universal FX films Amazon Prime BBC One hispanic Trophy Talk 45 Columbia Pictures E! Apple Oscars comiccon anthology 73rd Emmy Awards Black History Month Rocky Wes Anderson Cannes TCA 2017 adenture documentary SDCC Logo live event