Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Superman" And "Devil" Are Certified Fresh

by | June 29, 2006 | Comments

This week’s wide releases both involve publishing. In "The Devil Wears Prada," the setting is a fashion magazine, and in "Superman Returns," it’s The Daily Planet. So maybe that’s why the critics like both these movies so much…

While there has been some debate over the quality of Lauren Weisberger’s novel "The Devil Wears Prada," there’s less divergence over the movie adaptation, particularly because of the presence of Meryl Streep in the titular role. Anne Hathaway plays an earnest small-town girl who hopes to write high-minded stuff for the New Yorker, but is little match for the Cruella De Ville-esque Miranda Priestly (Streep). The scribes say the film ultimately works because of Streep’s excellent performance, but "The Devil Wears Prada" is also an incisive examination of workplace politics. At 76 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Devil" wears a Certified Fresh badge.

After a long, arduous trial, Meryl Streep was acquitted by the fashion police, but convicted by the sunglass police.

You may have heard that there’s a new Superman movie out. It’s called "Superman Returns," and it stars a relative unknown as the Man of Steel (Brandon Routh), an actress who was in that Bobby Darin movie (Kate Bosworth), and the guy who played Bobby Darin himself in that same movie, this time playing Lex Luthor (Kevin Spacey). (Dude, he was probably Keyzer Soze as well) The critics say "Superman Returns" is able to pull off the neat trick of sticking closely to the age-old particulars of the Superman myth, while making them fresh. "Superman Returns" is at 76 percent on the Tomatometer, and it’s Certified Fresh.

"I’ll have a root beer float, hold the kryptonite."

This is a week of well-reviewed releases in general. Also opening, albeit in limited release: "Who Killed the Electric Car," a documentary about the short-lived EV1, is at 87 percent; "The Motel," a coming-of-age tale set in a fleabag motel, is at 82 percent; "The Blood of My Brother," a documentary about death in Iraq, is at 67 percent; and the big-screen adaptation of the cult TV hit "Strangers With Candy" is at 57 percent.

Recent Meryl Streep Movies:
80% — A Prairie Home Companion (2006)
50% — Prime (2005)
81% — The Manchurian Candidate (2004)
71% — Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events (2004)
62% — Stuck On You (2003)

Recent Bryan Singer Movies:
87% — X2: X-Men United (2003)
80% — X-Men (2000)
53% — Apt Pupil (1998)
90% — The Usual Suspects (1995)
50% — Public Access (1993)

Tag Cloud

Mary Poppins Returns scary movies LGBTQ Turner Classic Movies worst movies Creative Arts Emmys Mystery 99% deadpool talk show 4/20 ghosts nature rt labs critics edition Epix Podcast wonder woman mockumentary vampires french Elton John adventure Paramount Network BBC hidden camera revenge NBC Musicals Western ABC Signature award winner young adult indie GoT Starz Awards Video Games toronto scene in color SDCC TCA political drama 72 Emmy Awards boxoffice RT21 Hollywood Foreign Press Association Film Festival black crime thriller Walt Disney Pictures leaderboard aapi Anna Paquin TCA Awards Set visit Winners hollywood strong female leads dc witnail Prime Video Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sopranos Horror Lucasfilm Disney streaming service TV movies jamie lee curtis OWN sitcom cancelled television The Purge Countdown feel good Cosplay MTV Television Critics Association GLAAD AMC DC Universe halloween tv art house Food Network blockbusters FX spanish dramedy spinoff obituary NYCC dexter 45 diversity ITV canceled TV shows spider-verse olympics DC Comics zombies BET animated prank Valentine's Day Crunchyroll hispanic heritage month comics Rocketman 2020 dreamworks El Rey streaming movies true crime Columbia Pictures Black Mirror adaptation werewolf Superheroes monster movies Pride Month SXSW cooking fresh satire Fox News spain scary Star Trek WGN doctor who black comedy casting Rocky Disney Channel miniseries festivals Comedy international universal monsters DGA Reality Competition king arthur zero dark thirty 007 debate indiana jones Fall TV rt labs Nat Geo HBO Endgame south america Heroines tv talk pirates of the caribbean historical drama joker medical drama biography Cartoon Network Music mission: impossible Black History Month cinemax BBC One Cannes Premiere Dates blockbuster hist mutant Marvel Studios Alien movies period drama Freeform Infographic Comedy Central Wes Anderson Drama National Geographic toy story Ghostbusters golden globe awards MCU mob Vudu Schedule DirecTV DC streaming service anthology free movies The Walt Disney Company classics spider-man TBS BET Awards cancelled TV series YA docuseries Lifetime spanish language rom-coms cats new york Film PBS Oscars Academy Awards Fargo Pet Sematary harry potter Red Carpet comedies psycho television Pirates Apple TV Plus versus emmy awards latino Grammys women A24 documentaries Baby Yoda Sundance Now screen actors guild cops Instagram Live cults live action Adult Swim razzies batman news renewed TV shows 2016 docudrama vs. Watching Series Hallmark Christmas movies First Reviews comic TV renewals christmas movies Writers Guild of America Warner Bros. YouTube Premium USA independent IFC X-Men Teen Women's History Month 1990s elevated horror critic resources natural history Nickelodeon composers king kong jurassic park Tags: Comedy basketball Peacock Marvel Television technology biopic Tomatazos IFC Films science fiction Winter TV ABC Family Tumblr USA Network comiccon President ViacomCBS Syfy Avengers IMDb TV reboot RT History A&E TV disaster The Walking Dead directors Thanksgiving Crackle breaking bad Awards Tour 73rd Emmy Awards 2018 comic book movie History marvel comics TruTV stop motion japan AMC Plus Mary Tyler Moore Animation live event Mindy Kaling Comic-Con@Home 2021 Box Office E3 20th Century Fox cartoon Stephen King Discovery Channel Apple TV+ finale The Arrangement popular 71st Emmy Awards The Witch criterion green book Emmys legend Nominations Summer saw LGBT discovery Superheroe Paramount WarnerMedia hispanic Extras franchise Binge Guide rt archives Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt slashers kaiju The CW halloween laika sag awards golden globes Photos 2017 psychological thriller Disney+ Disney Plus Holiday james bond Captain marvel Pop Netflix Christmas movies dogs all-time remakes trophy what to watch politics YouTube Red screenings 93rd Oscars series concert CBS Fantasy Trivia BBC America best dragons movie parents 2015 Shondaland anime slasher Year in Review based on movie nfl CBS All Access nbcuniversal OneApp scorecard video comic book movies CW Seed NBA Apple Broadway ESPN chucky travel Star Wars Dark Horse Comics video on demand E! TCA Winter 2020 New York Comic Con Best and Worst Spring TV Chernobyl kong critics kids war theme song Biopics Lionsgate Song of Ice and Fire thriller 79th Golden Globes Awards a nightmare on elm street Neflix new zealand Funimation facebook HBO Max Netflix Comic Book Trailer supernatural Masterpiece The Academy films Travel Channel football MSNBC Bravo sequels cancelled TV shows archives First Look 2021 crossover TLC singing competition Amazon Prime Video VOD serial killer 21st Century Fox Turner target superhero YouTube spy thriller crime Character Guide Rom-Com gangster FOX Quiz Legendary dark quibi Tokyo Olympics Toys sports know your critic Ovation boxing CMT high school Holidays PlayStation new star wars movies book adaptation Paramount Plus godzilla VH1 90s Trophy Talk Certified Fresh heist movie Country marvel cinematic universe Fox Searchlight documentary Amazon Prime romance Hallmark 2019 Television Academy blaxploitation 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards TV Land Arrowverse genre Sci-Fi cancelled children's TV Christmas Rock Spectrum Originals Mudbound game of thrones venice ID Opinion FXX See It Skip It foreign Pacific Islander Sneak Peek HFPA CNN PaleyFest TCA 2017 crime drama FX on Hulu Super Bowl Family space italian Lifetime Christmas movies Mary poppins ratings Hulu trailers Election Hear Us Out reviews Sundance TV Musical justice league zombie Showtime richard e. Grant Acorn TV japanese Universal Pictures SundanceTV worst aliens action-comedy stand-up comedy suspense Universal binge royal family telelvision Disney Classic Film robots San Diego Comic-Con Amazon dceu Spike festival posters asian-american police drama APB game show rotten Reality stoner rotten movies we love Sony Pictures 24 frames Disney Plus romantic comedy cars sequel Sundance social media Esquire Logo Polls and Games Britbox lord of the rings streaming BAFTA Marvel Pixar transformers Action Kids & Family Comics on TV twilight child's play Calendar book HBO Go canceled Ellie Kemper Brie Larson American Society of Cinematographers TNT superman mcc Exclusive Video Emmy Nominations Shudder teaser fast and furious Pop TV Tarantino die hard Martial Arts adenture VICE Image Comics Amazon Studios ABC unscripted Interview GIFs Tubi TCM australia TIFF name the review comic books Marathons TV One