Counterpart Star J.K. Simmons and Series Creators Reveal Crazy Kismet Behind Sci-Fi Spy Thriller

A chance run-in between The Jungle Book screenwriter Justin Marks and La La Land producer Jordan Horowitz could have gone horribly wrong.

by | December 7, 2017 | Comments

In another world, similar to ours, the new Starz series Counterpart does not exist. The reason: Justin Marks did not try to beat a streetlight a few years back.

“If I hadn’t tried to jaywalk in Beverly Hills this show wouldn’t exist,” Marks told Rotten Tomatoes.

The Jungle Book screenwriter had a dentist appointment, but parked in a structure that was a half-mile from the dentist’s office.

“I’m already late. And I’m trying to get through a crosswalk before the light changes and a car is also trying to get through the light before it changes. And I end up stopping right in front of [the car], against the passenger side window. And I’m looking and I’m like, ‘Jordan?’”

Inside the car was La La Land producer Jordan Horowitz. The pair grew up together and were even both in the same band back in the day. But as college loomed, they lost touch. Marks eventually moved to Los Angeles to begin a screenwriting career, while Horowitz entered the New York independent film scene.

“He gave me a ride to the dentist office that then reconnected us,” Marks said.

Had either man not tried to beat the light, they would have missed each other, and Counterpart, which debuts with a special preview of the pilot episode this weekend, might not exist.

(Photo by Starz)

Academy Award winner J.K. Simmons (Whiplash) stars as Howard Silk, a low-level agent at a strange government agency in Berlin who discovers his world is connected to a divergent reality — a world like Howard’s own, but built on billions of subtle differences, the accumulation of alternative choices. That world, dubbed “The Other Side” by Marks and Horowitz, offers characters like Howard and his wife Emily (Olivia Williams) the unique opportunity to learn what might have happened had they turned right instead of left. It also presents something Simmons calls “a great ethical and moral dilemma” as Howard and other characters face the temptation to discover what their lives could have been like if things had been different.

“[It’s] like a time-travel scenario,” Simmons added. “I mean, you can’t go back and fix it, but maybe you can go over where it’s already been fixed.”

The actor recalled a seemingly insignificant choice in his own life that might have led to a very different life: a summer in college when he chose to try theater instead of painting houses. Simmons theorized he might still be painting houses if not for that choice, but was unsure if he wanted to really know what that life would be like.

Howard, meanwhile, confronts what changed circumstances would mean for himself when he meets the Howard Silk of the divergent reality.

J.K. Simmons in Counterpart (Starz)

While the series’ premise had an immediate “What if?” sci-fi hook to it, Simmons first found himself taken with the character of Howard, a timid man hoping for a promotion when viewers meet him.

“It was just good writing and a character that I felt like I could really identify with,” he said. “A lot of scripts I was getting in the wake of Whiplash were these abusive alpha males. And when I first started reading Howard, the first Howard we meet, he was definitely a departure from that. [It was] just something that was intelligent and looked like fun.”

Then he discovered the other Howard – referred to as “Howard Prime” in the script – and found a second character to identify with, though he admitted, “I still sort of viewed the world from our first Howard’s point of view, and really, I think, continued to throughout a lot of the shooting.”

J.K. Simmons in Counterpart (Starz)

The first Howard, ostensibly from the world closest to our own, spends his days before the series begins collecting information from the Other Side through a very elaborate system of codes and passwords. It is a low-level job requiring he only write down the coded phrases.

Howard Prime, meanwhile, is more of a traditional Cold War spy character. He is accustomed to wetwork and the higher levels of the agency’s equivalent in the other reality. And according to Simmons, it may not be entirely clear who the hero of the series really is.

“I’m interested to see [how] audiences respond to it,” he said, “and who’s the protagonist [in their view], because there’s a lot of answers to that question. There are a lot of possible answers.”

Nicholas Pinnock, J.K. Simmons in Counterpart (Starz)

That ambiguity and level of Cold War–era suspicion was a key element in developing the series.

“When we first started talking about it, we were talking about the classic Cold War spy thriller tradition and also a little bit of science fiction too,” Horowitz explained.

He used the example of John Le Carré novels like The Spy Who Came In From The Cold, which are filled with that political tension, but allow the characters to remain at the forefront.

The result, combined with the divergent reality is something Horowitz called a “very character-forward science fiction thing that sort of lived in that spy thriller genre.”

Marks added that the premise began as a spy thriller with the science fiction element “sprinkled over the top.”

“Sci-fi could be anything and so what we’re doing with sci-fi here is we’re taking the elements of a parallel world and sprinkling it over all of the conventions that you would find in a traditional Cold War espionage thriller,” he explained. “But you know you could be telling a time-travel sci-fi story, you could be telling a futurist sci-fi story, a parallel-world sci-fi story. All of those have different conventions in and of themselves, so we felt our strongest foot was to be landing firmly in the place of espionage and then adding the science fiction over the top of it.”

J.K. Simmons in Counterpart (Starz)

For Simmons, becoming a spy hero – at least when he is playing Howard Prime – was a special opportunity to “go back to being a little nine year old and you get to do a baseball movie or a cowboy movie, or you get to be the super spy shooting guns at the bad guy.” He definitely enjoyed playing what he called “that guy who actually is competent in that scenario and knows how to handle himself,” but also enjoyed playing Howard for the opposite reasons.

Then there came the day when Howard and Howard Prime interacted with one another.

“We experimented with a few different ways of how to technically accomplish it, some of which involved having a recording in your ear of your own dialogue from a previous take, and looking at a blank spot and pretending that you’re looking at yourself, or looking at a tennis ball on a stand,” Simmons recalled.

Ultimately, the method which worked best was for Simmons to play the scenes opposite his stand-in, John Funk.

“We were able to just make it very organic like a usual day on a film set,” he said.

While it took a little time to get the technique worked out, it eventually meant scenes could be blocked and performed quickly. Then, as Simmons put it, “the technical wizards” merged his two performances into one take.

Nicholas Pinnock, Olivia Williams, J.K. Simmons in Counterpart (Starz)

Another technical consideration for the producers was the look of the Other Side. After toying with concepts like tinting the footage, switching to black and white or using title cards, they realized the best answer was not an “underlying aesthetic” for the Other Side at all.

Instead, they tried to “let the aesthetics serve as a different underlying narrative between the two worlds,” as Marks put it. The result became the presence of subtle differences in a visually similar setting; the Other Side uses more LED lighting, for example. But as the series continues, the accumulation of differences will create a visual grammar that will allow the viewer to know which world they are in almost imperceptibly, according to Marks and Horowitz.

But in making the choice to let the Other Side’s visual aesthetic grow from the narrative, Marks, Horowitz and the rest of the writers’ room went down a “rabbit hole” of “game theory” about various aspects of the Other Side.

“What does it mean for cell phone technology? What does it mean for automobiles? What does it mean for building construction or medical equipment?” Marks asked.

“The Other Side has a very meticulously built out narrative that’s only being alluded to,” he added. “You get the sense that there’s some resentment built up between the sides.”

“Maybe world events that maybe happened on the Other Side that didn’t happen on ours,” Marks continued. “And, by the way, there are some major world events that probably happened on our side that didn’t happen on theirs.”

Harry Lloyd in Counterpart (Starz)

The suppositions led to a compelling backdrop for characters like Howard, Howard Prime and his contact on our side, Peter Quayle, played by Game of Thrones’ dastardly Brother of Dragons actor Harry Loyd.

“Quayle is in his own black comedy,” Marks said. “And Harry plays it so brilliantly. There’s a dark satire to what it is because I think that there’s a manifestation in Quayle of a certain version of privilege.”

While the nature of his predicament will be revealed in subsequent episodes, Howard Prime pretty much has his number from their first scene together.

Marks also added, “It’s less about like it is with [Howard], where it’s a man that’s lived with mileage and gone a different path. I think in the case of Peter Quayle, it’s a lot more about his inability to cope with the very, very dangerous high-stake situation he’s been thrust into the middle of, unwillingly.”

It all leads to a character who is “trying to write himself out of the show in every single scene.”

J.K. Simmons and Harry Lloyd in Counterpart (Starz)

Writing Quail gave Marks and Horowitz a particular pleasure, but Simmons added that working on Counterpart day-to-day was also a pleasure.

“I’m sure it will continue to be,” he added. “And it ain’t going to get boring. It’s going to continue to present good challenges and hopefully boggle minds.”

Considering the alternatives, Marks said he would not be a very different person in that world where Counterpart never came to be, but noted that “over time, things start to impact your sense of identity as formed in a certain way by constructs around you.

“Power over that and the powerlessness that we all possess in the face of that,” he said, is key to the questions the series poses.

Counterpart episode 1 airs as a sneak peek on Sunday, December 10 at 9 p.m. ET/PT on Starz after the season 3 finale of Outlander; the series officially premieres January 21, 2018.

Tag Cloud

Photos Teen HBO Max Pacific Islander Academy Awards Holidays die hard name the review ABC Signature anthology Shudder boxoffice critics basketball blaxploitation Rom-Com Showtime toronto comiccon Winners DC Universe Binge Guide sag awards docudrama finale Country Universal japan concert game of thrones Warner Bros. Hallmark BBC 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards slasher Marvel Tomatazos documentaries crime Election OneApp PaleyFest NBC See It Skip It revenge kaiju comic book movie king arthur series Spectrum Originals cars archives black DirecTV halloween FXX gangster PBS sports Polls and Games what to watch FX wonder woman Film Dark Horse Comics mcc know your critic halloween tv DGA Extras disaster war Disney Pop TV child's play Sneak Peek CMT A&E discovery Nat Geo HBO Go ESPN medical drama Adult Swim tv talk Horror Podcast Wes Anderson 2018 Ghostbusters directors Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pixar science fiction Writers Guild of America docuseries boxing cults YouTube Red The Walt Disney Company critic resources Legendary period drama cancelled television SundanceTV Ellie Kemper superhero cancelled TV series worst movies Netflix zombies Exclusive Video Baby Yoda RT History adventure Martial Arts all-time Travel Channel richard e. Grant Masterpiece Comics on TV Columbia Pictures 007 prank technology Spring TV stand-up comedy movies Pride Month mutant Bravo TV One Apple cooking APB Tarantino Turner Classic Movies 2016 remakes Fall TV Pirates Year in Review criterion scary movies The CW rotten movies we love 2019 romance TV travel doctor who Marvel Studios kids Hear Us Out American Society of Cinematographers WGN Creative Arts Emmys Kids & Family Thanksgiving Lifetime Christmas movies based on movie History NYCC SXSW Watching Series Sundance mockumentary festival YouTube dark Music Mindy Kaling Apple TV Plus unscripted Sundance TV CW Seed monster movies Star Wars Mary Tyler Moore target Film Festival space documentary anime Countdown zero dark thirty TV Land FOX Musical Song of Ice and Fire Vudu biopic Premiere Dates Emmys social media First Reviews crossover 73rd Emmy Awards National Geographic Musicals 99% 2015 45 king kong spain comic books ABC Superheroe Lucasfilm supernatural witnail superman children's TV IFC Netflix Christmas movies screenings slashers Broadway french thriller posters christmas movies New York Comic Con ViacomCBS Trailer 2017 USA dogs high school PlayStation cancelled Oscars MSNBC transformers feel good book adaptation Starz sequels heist movie rt labs critics edition spider-man cops Mary Poppins Returns TCA 2017 Heroines TCA sitcom 21st Century Fox cinemax south america dc Fox News Tumblr diversity facebook Fox Searchlight screen actors guild political drama VOD suspense Opinion biography rt archives Interview aliens hist Star Trek Food Network Black Mirror werewolf The Academy psychological thriller Nickelodeon cats GLAAD game show E3 Marathons spinoff worst Winter TV book 71st Emmy Awards Red Carpet best HBO 2020 Classic Film romantic comedy spanish Summer Women's History Month Grammys razzies sequel Comedy Central Ovation politics animated TCM Spike E! strong female leads scene in color emmy awards young adult new zealand joker Peacock Paramount latino Action Cosplay Lionsgate rom-coms 24 frames independent scorecard jurassic park Super Bowl reviews The Arrangement live action hollywood Fantasy Rocky Superheroes Shondaland quibi legend CBS Reality Competition classics movie CBS All Access james bond Calendar Arrowverse international debate television binge venice robots comics CNN a nightmare on elm street lord of the rings Character Guide trailers Sony Pictures Family theme song jamie lee curtis RT21 Captain marvel Christmas justice league dramedy Apple TV+ hidden camera women ID comic Discovery Channel batman nbcuniversal X-Men asian-american foreign LGBT San Diego Comic-Con IFC Films satire Amazon Studios Paramount Plus Tokyo Olympics Best and Worst YA crime thriller talk show laika Certified Fresh Comedy Cannes teaser Epix Disney+ Disney Plus Sci-Fi Funimation Pet Sematary football 1990s comic book movies TV movies rt labs Sundance Now dceu 4/20 MTV video fast and furious cancelled TV shows Trophy Talk TV renewals Logo Endgame kong Set visit stop motion Mystery action-comedy spy thriller Trivia Crunchyroll TIFF Amazon Prime Video USA Network historical drama Animation 90s TLC BET Awards crime drama Disney streaming service toy story Stephen King El Rey Marvel Television Crackle casting Black History Month miniseries 72 Emmy Awards Amazon harry potter BBC America adenture Disney Plus dexter Freeform royal family composers Hulu stoner award winner Box Office streaming rotten elevated horror Emmy Nominations Rocketman Holiday comedies twilight Comic-Con@Home 2021 universal monsters Nominations Drama mission: impossible serial killer The Purge new york MCU Toys godzilla vampires Rock TCA Winter 2020 First Look DC streaming service Awards Tour hispanic heritage month true crime ratings breaking bad Alien Britbox A24 hispanic parents Brie Larson spanish language canceled TV shows chucky natural history TCA Awards obituary italian festivals singing competition nature versus video on demand marvel comics canceled Tubi nfl zombie indie ghosts DC Comics Amazon Prime deadpool reboot blockbusters Cartoon Network Reality AMC popular 93rd Oscars free movies psycho aapi 2021 Lifetime Paramount Network Acorn TV Pop saw Anna Paquin australia Chernobyl 20th Century Fox telelvision Mary poppins Hallmark Christmas movies Esquire green book Walt Disney Pictures Video Games franchise blockbuster Television Critics Association VICE TruTV LGBTQ Elton John GoT golden globes cartoon The Witch NBA BAFTA BET Valentine's Day Image Comics Quiz Television Academy streaming movies japanese YouTube Premium dragons news Mudbound Turner Infographic golden globe awards indiana jones police drama GIFs Disney Channel new star wars movies fresh WarnerMedia FX on Hulu marvel cinematic universe Syfy TNT TBS VH1 The Walking Dead renewed TV shows Western Awards pirates of the caribbean olympics OWN President Avengers Comic Book ITV SDCC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ABC Family adaptation Schedule films BBC One Biopics