Comics On TV

5 Reasons To Give Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. Another Shot

Strong performances, reinvention, and worthy adversaries are just a few of the reasons the ABC series deserves a second (third or even fourth) look.

by | December 7, 2017 | Comments


When it debuted on ABC five years ago, Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. began with a very rocky start. The first episode was dull, the second revealed a number of budget limitations, and while it was trying its best to get the audiences invested in the characters, its momentum was hampered by a critical connection to Captain America: The Winter Soldier. Around the time of the film’s debut – and definitely after – S.H.I.E.L.D. finally found a voice and an interesting hook: Coulson (Clark Gregg) and his team became the last good agents in the face of Hydra’s infiltration of the organization.

Over the subsequent seasons, the characters charmed a dedicated group of fans who remained loyal in the face of long hiatuses and shifting schedules. Unfortunately, the appreciative fans (and a 95% on the Tomatometer) never turned the series into a ratings winner for ABC, In fact, the current season exists only because of a reported request by high-level Disney executives. Nonetheless, it is definitely a show worth watching, particularly if you walked away before.

Here are just five of the many reasons to give S.H.I.E.L.D. another chance.

1. It Reinvents Itself

While the show generally maintains the visual style of a mid-budget spy or crime series, S.H.I.E.L.D. consistently reinvents its narrative drive with each season. This year’s change moves the team to space, which, as it happens, also brings a change to the visual grammar of the program. (See our article, “10 Things We Learned on the Set of Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. Season 5”) Now it looks like a mid-budget sci-fi series. It is definitely a good thing.

As revealed in the two-part season premiere, Agent Coulson and his team have been transported to a time when the remnant of mankind is under the heel of the Kree Empire (the blue people from Guardians of the Galaxy). Their mission: save the human race.

The realigned premise allows newcomers to hop onto the show without much of its previous stories getting in the way. At the same time, it definitely rewards loyal viewers with references to previous antagonists, old aliens, and simmering tensions, but like a comic book taking a bold new direction, the “Agents in Space” premise is definitely something the comic industry would call “new reader friendly.” And if you happen to be a fan of, say, Dark Matter, the new season may take a little of the sting off of that series’s recent cancellation.

2. It Made Ghost Rider Work

Ghost Rider - Marvel's Agents of SHIELD screencap (ABC)

Last season, the show adopted a storytelling method it called “pods.” Like a story arc in a comic book series, the “pod” system allowed the show to focus intensely on one idea for five or six episodes and then move to a new story while maintaining one key thematic tie between them. Last year, it was a mystical book known as The Darkhold – apparently one of the missing texts from Wong’s library in Doctor Strange — and with it came the Ghost Rider.

Utilizing the version created by Felipe Smith, Robbie Reyes (Gabriel Luna), and some great East L.A. locations, the series managed to tell the only worthwhile live action Ghost Rider story to date. It even featured a kick-ass cameo by original Ghost Rider Johnny Blaze. Though only appearing in seven episodes, he made quite the impression. So much so, the season 5 premiere teased unfinished business between Robbie and Coulson. When the Ghost Rider story ended, The Darkhold fell into the hands of an experimental android – or “Life Model Decoy” – named AIDA. In reading its pages, she found a purpose which fuels the next two story pods.

The pod system, besides giving the show a great structure, also gave the series a way to utilize a number of Marvel Comics ideas which cannot support television shows or feature films on their own. In fact, the show introduced Inhumans far more successfully than the recent Marvel’s Inhumans on ABC.

Considering the company’s staggering amount of cosmic characters, it easy to imagine S.H.I.E.L.D. will find a breakout character like Ghost Rider among the stars.

(Photo by ABC/Kurt Iswarienkio)

3. It Gave The World Mack…

Seriously, Mack (Henry Simmons) is one of the key reasons to watch the show. Joining S.H.I.E.L.D. in its second season, Alphonso Mackenzie was introduced as one of the few loyal S.H.I.E.L.D. agents left after Hydra revealed itself. He was soon part of a new version of S.H.I.E.L.D. led by Robert Gonzalez (Edward James Olmos) and sent to spy on Coulson’s team. Once the two groups merged into a single S.H.I.E.L.D., he quickly became an indispensable member of Coulson’s team.

Physically strong, good with a shotgun, and quick with the quip, he also became a good friend to Fitz (Iain De Caestaecker) as he recovered from brain damage after nearly drowning the previous season. Since then, he’s been Coulson’s go-to guy for almost everything, including serving as acting director, despite Mack’s well-voiced concerns about his methods.

He is also very much the team’s everyman in the face of extranormal threats. Demon drag racers, advanced androids, and Inhumans come as a surprise to Mack, who would love for the ground to just be solid for once. But his shock always gives way to a clever retort and a new understanding of reality. He even faced a demonic possession with grace and aplomb.

As the fifth season opens, he is left trying to convince Coulson that they’re in an Aliens situation and not a Star Wars one. Mack is the hero we need and deserve.

4 … And Melinda May


From almost her first scene, Ming-Na Wen has been kicking ass on the show as Agent Melinda May; often literally. As the team’s fiercest fighter and best pilot, the show often goes to great lengths to get her off the battlefield for the sake of tension. Nonetheless, she grew into a sympathetic character with a rich past, intense parents, and one grievous sin which led to her taking on a stoic demeanor and Hydra taking over a digital simulation of the world.

Despite her stoicism, she is fearlessly loyal to her team and Coulson in particular. They have a lot of history together and many of her warmer moments in earlier seasons center on their camaraderie.

The show even dabbled in a romantic tension between May and Coulson, giving the fans a fake-out kiss between the former S.H.I.E.L.D. director and a Life Model Decoy of May last season. It is unclear how much time the series will have to return to this idea, but watching May fight aliens and instantly learn to fly spaceships is definitely a more compelling focus.

But considering she still feels terrible about Bahrain and what she did in the digital world, giving her a reason to smile would be a great turn as well.

5. It Is Using the Kree as Season 5 Antagonists


While the Kree Empire maintained a treaty with the Nova Corps of Xandar throughout Guardians of the Galaxy, S.H.I.E.L.D. has always presented them as a fairly hostile alien race. In season 2, a Kree named Vin-Tak (Eddie McClintock) infiltrated the team’s base in hopes of learning about the emerging Inhuman situation – a project they themselves undertook thousands of years ago. He discovered Daisy Johnson (Chloe Bennet) was herself Inhuman and tried to murder her, labeling her “an abomination.” It led to a tense fight between Vin-Tak and Bobbi Morse (Adrianne Palicki) with Morse winning only because she used Vin-Tak’s amnesia ray on him. Luckily, Lady Sif (Jaimie Alexander) was at the base and helped escort Vin-Tak off the planet.

But even in the first season, Kree science led to Coulson’s miraculous recovery from his apparent demise in Marvel’s The Avengers and he later used the same technique to save a key member of the S.H.I.E.L.D. cast.

As the fifth season begins, we see the Kree maintaining an occupying force on an asteroid humanity calls “The Lighthouse.” The humans there live in fear of them, but a select few are chosen to live in luxury with Kasius (Dominic Rains), the military governor who is both fascinated and repulsed by humans.

He definitely put the fear into Simmons (Elizabeth Henstridge) upon their first encounter. The character represents the first real long-form look at the Kree on the series, who seems more like Ronan the Accuser (Lee Pace) than either would like to admit.

Come to think of it, the status of the Kree/Nova treaty has to be fairly shaky at this point, right?

The Kree continue to have a presence in the Guardians of the Galaxy films and will definitely play a key role in Captain Marvel. And getting to know all about background details in the features was once the S.H.I.E.L.D. mission statement.

Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. season 5 (ABC/Matthias Clamer)

But these are just some of the big hooks the show uses to become a fun weekly dose of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Of the course of the last few seasons, direct ties to films have waned in favor of thematic ties, like last year’s dip into the mystic arts. The results were compelling and, hopefully, S.H.I.E.L.D.’s trip to space will prove as rewarding.

Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. airs Fridays at 9/8C on ABC.

Tag Cloud

BAFTA WarnerMedia Spike Television Critics Association nbcuniversal Hallmark Trophy Talk ESPN RT21 romantic comedy Tags: Comedy serial killer mcc thriller TV renewals rt labs critics edition blockbusters Music dreamworks Thanksgiving Drama biography crime Sony Pictures Comedy comic book movies harry potter ABC natural history what to watch period drama WGN Tomatazos suspense BET Awards PaleyFest robots TV movies Trivia TBS anthology disaster The Arrangement ITV Year in Review USA Disney streaming service Comic-Con@Home 2021 foreign 2015 Oscars sequel Pop Best Actress cats dceu documentaries Disney dragons hispanic heritage month facebook marvel cinematic universe Binge Guide kaiju Awards new york adenture cinemax concert marvel comics TCA Awards Reality Competition series critic resources Heroines Mindy Kaling transformers Elton John obituary festivals PlayStation Podcast satire cancelled TV shows Alien Song of Ice and Fire Shudder IFC Films 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 79th Golden Globes Awards green book 45 Marvel Television Watching Series The Walking Dead diversity PBS comedies book indiana jones Superheroes Amazon Prime spider-man psychological thriller Martial Arts MGM golden globe awards Disney Plus black comedy comics venice Mary poppins APB HBO Go 4/20 anime Television Academy 2019 social media Toys Prime Video 2021 canceled boxoffice Netflix Christmas movies DGA chucky Chilling Adventures of Sabrina trophy IFC hispanic Hear Us Out Amazon crime drama Disney+ Disney Plus Rom-Com canceled TV shows technology miniseries emmy awards Rocketman spy thriller slasher American Society of Cinematographers reboot Epix trailers fast and furious 24 frames blaxploitation crime thriller Women's History Month Comedy Central pirates of the caribbean travel based on movie vs. rom-coms cartoon AMC Plus Image Comics Quiz FX heist movie GoT Discovery Channel Nominations reviews HBO fresh Kids & Family TLC 71st Emmy Awards NBA NYCC Tubi Creative Arts Emmys dogs National Geographic Arrowverse Oscar movies Legendary zombies worst movies HFPA toronto new zealand TruTV TCM Photos Reality Endgame mutant OneApp See It Skip It richard e. Grant El Rey game show X-Men Pride Month Paramount Plus Black History Month scene in color streamig prank Spring TV deadpool unscripted joker screenings Star Wars children's TV zero dark thirty TV DC Universe Premiere Dates adaptation Polls and Games Summer YouTube Red films Winter TV kong Countdown cancelled TV series cops Nat Geo The CW theme song TV Land teaser 94th Oscars Superheroe Film Pixar Lionsgate Sundance TV E3 cancelled television international Opinion Comics on TV docuseries CBS All Access archives SXSW Baby Yoda saw wonder woman Academy Awards Valentine's Day live action Masterpiece Walt Disney Pictures Warner Bros. Funimation Marathons GIFs Mystery Logo twilight boxing summer TV sag awards ViacomCBS superhero Pirates best Columbia Pictures 72 Emmy Awards olympics Marvel finale Cosplay CNN french 90s Lifetime Christmas movies Instagram Live Ghostbusters BBC 73rd Emmy Awards FOX ratings revenge Pet Sematary 93rd Oscars breaking bad Infographic Film Festival cults SXSW 2022 Amazon Prime Video Exclusive Video summer preview christmas movies Comic Book Paramount slashers Country Hulu Mary Tyler Moore streaming movies Holidays The Walt Disney Company SundanceTV Stephen King Fall TV Esquire adventure New York Comic Con cancelled australia Action south america Emmys TV One sports 2018 History Biopics documentary dc blockbuster Shondaland spinoff Paramount Network gangster Fantasy nature independent VH1 sitcom indie Anna Paquin BET Writers Guild of America CBS FX on Hulu scary movies true crime rt labs Crunchyroll ghosts TCA 2017 latino basketball game of thrones godzilla comiccon know your critic IMDb TV obi wan 2016 Lucasfilm The Purge laika Sci-Fi cooking child's play king kong Sneak Peek debate Starz Dark Horse Comics Character Guide Neflix feel good Certified Fresh book adaptation tv talk SDCC critics quibi justice league ABC Signature young adult Peacock italian telelvision Cannes kids scorecard Universal Pictures ABC Family witnail Rock First Reviews television Avengers renewed TV shows Trailer posters hidden camera Cartoon Network Focus Features scary MSNBC Sundance Now Best and Worst CW Seed Amazon Studios Teen Vudu 2020 leaderboard Wes Anderson Captain marvel news razzies jamie lee curtis art house E! dramedy spider-verse 99% Marvel Studios lord of the rings San Diego Comic-Con dexter screen actors guild TCA Winter 2020 Grammys science fiction Interview Fox Searchlight Horror First Look Family Freeform rt archives Showtime Best Director stoner new star wars movies Rocky summer TV preview political drama LGBTQ free movies BBC America comic books YA Universal Ovation die hard talk show remakes Star Trek Tarantino ID spanish language supernatural vampires halloween tv VICE jurassic park criterion Apple TV+ genre Sundance Holiday name the review cars worst FXX Food Network stop motion Turner Britbox Tokyo Olympics comic historical drama war Mudbound video Musicals Pacific Islander CMT Super Bowl Best Picture MTV medical drama doctor who Ellie Kemper Calendar Hallmark Christmas movies USA Network VOD President Nickelodeon singing competition Western elevated horror football comic book movie mission: impossible japan Turner Classic Movies Musical Pop TV Paramount Pictures Mary Poppins Returns Black Mirror A&E versus legend toy story aliens Netflix biopic Bravo werewolf Travel Channel broadcast Lifetime batman golden globes hist animated LGBT 20th Century Fox sequels YouTube Premium Set visit TNT YouTube all-time The Academy Fargo stand-up comedy zombie halloween DirecTV Classic Film OWN discovery Syfy Box Office sopranos spanish video on demand james bond Best Actor nfl superman award winner politics movie The Witch GLAAD target NBC live event AMC TIFF docudrama police drama binge Apple TV Plus composers black Election rotten romance Emmy Nominations universal monsters streaming mockumentary DC Comics classics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 007 DC streaming service Video Games Fox News festival RT History popular Winners dark spain royal family Animation crossover Brie Larson casting Schedule Disney Channel mob South by Southwest Film Festival strong female leads Broadway hollywood a nightmare on elm street Extras Tumblr action-comedy Christmas Apple directors rotten movies we love king arthur psycho Chernobyl asian-american Red Carpet parents MCU 2017 Hollywood Foreign Press Association Acorn TV women HBO Max space franchise Crackle aapi Adult Swim 21st Century Fox high school TCA japanese A24 BBC One 1990s monster movies Spectrum Originals Awards Tour