Chucky vs. Annabelle: Who Wins the Ultimate Murder Doll Showdown?

We crunch the numbers to see who emerges victorious when these toys of terror face off.

by | June 20, 2019 | Comments

Earlier this month we compared two cinematic titans in our Godzilla vs. King Kong showdown; this week we’re looking at two smaller-scale destroyers, Chucky and Annabelle. Both are returning to screens this month: First up, Chucky arrives rebooted – and with the voice of Mark Hamill – in the new Child’s Play; then the Conjuring Universe’s mischief-making little cutie returns in Annabelle Comes HomeBut which doll is the most terrifying? Our host Mark Ellis pits them against each other in a special episode of Vs., comparing the two dolls and their film histories by Tomatometer, box office, kills, and in one special bonus round. Check out who gets top shelf position above.

Child’s Play is in theaters June 21 | Annabelle Comes Home is in theaters June 26

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

theme song Discovery Channel Fox News TCA Awards X-Men Premiere Dates Reality Competition NBC 21st Century Fox Acorn TV sequel Extras Character Guide Hallmark Christmas movies Cosplay casting cancelled Watching Series batman unscripted composers films superhero FXX Best and Worst RT History indie Paramount BBC binge Apple TV+ dceu nature Walt Disney Pictures toy story Sony Pictures DC Universe A&E anthology jamie lee curtis rotten movies we love adventure 007 dc cars El Rey Vudu Quiz Grammys Television Critics Association Amazon Prime Video psycho Esquire Logo Writers Guild of America Anna Paquin finale Hulu documentary PlayStation ABC elevated horror CNN FOX 45 Set visit Masterpiece Musical AMC Freeform Apple President Travel Channel dark Marvel Television Valentine's Day supernatural crime all-time richard e. Grant Trailer book San Diego Comic-Con Turner aliens HBO Max Emmy Nominations YouTube Premium foreign a nightmare on elm street 2018 adaptation Amazon versus asian-american nbcuniversal Brie Larson comics mockumentary History zombies USA Sundance APB CW Seed Stephen King OWN Nominations Star Trek National Geographic Food Network DirecTV period drama comedies Sundance TV Rocketman tv talk Starz CMT sitcom Drama reviews Syfy Holiday anime GoT TV renewals Crunchyroll ratings Epix directors Avengers Emmys stand-up comedy romantic comedy VOD hispanic Tubi movies Turner Classic Movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Fall TV talk show Shondaland VICE Countdown fast and furious BBC America Mary poppins Elton John Disney streaming service Paramount Network First Reviews festivals Podcast sequels Marathons TCA 2017 emmy awards Marvel Studios Sundance Now criterion Tumblr hist Winter TV police drama romance 72 Emmy Awards zombie Super Bowl YouTube Red festival parents based on movie Lifetime American Society of Cinematographers Nat Geo Rom-Com Polls and Games BET scary movies south america Netflix Christmas movies NYCC Spike Christmas HBO MTV witnail werewolf Cartoon Network universal monsters Classic Film Amazon Prime 2020 Lionsgate critics Ellie Kemper laika Infographic Ovation Lucasfilm Bravo disaster Lifetime Christmas movies Spring TV Martial Arts zero dark thirty obituary screen actors guild TIFF breaking bad Captain marvel Video Games worst slashers teaser game show documentaries Superheroes game of thrones Oscars Warner Bros. classics television cooking Television Academy TCM satire animated Comics on TV Musicals series Disney Plus Columbia Pictures Baby Yoda First Look ghosts true crime twilight Spectrum Originals 2017 Women's History Month Disney+ Disney Plus streaming Peacock Comedy Central Summer Tarantino christmas movies Adult Swim SXSW cancelled television cults TLC ESPN TV Land The Witch dogs LGBTQ SDCC Mary Poppins Returns GLAAD Horror Holidays VH1 worst movies LGBT Red Carpet Toys spanish language Black Mirror technology Arrowverse what to watch war Reality chucky Sneak Peek Box Office cancelled TV shows cartoon dragons MCU die hard YouTube FX Pop harry potter Britbox New York Comic Con renewed TV shows social media TNT Action Biopics green book YA transformers Election football canceled TV shows stop motion Calendar Academy Awards natural history venice WGN kids Photos 71st Emmy Awards vampires Superheroe Creative Arts Emmys Animation child's play Family USA Network crime thriller Sci-Fi Marvel HBO Go halloween franchise Western facebook Comedy SundanceTV Trivia spy thriller revenge best indiana jones diversity The CW Rocky 2015 scorecard crossover Awards comic free movies concert canceled spider-man serial killer toronto Disney Channel BBC One doctor who FX on Hulu TV independent video on demand Country quibi Netflix cats Funimation Winners Hallmark Universal The Walking Dead ABC Family TCA Awards Tour Kids & Family Nickelodeon spinoff Heroines DC streaming service thriller Star Wars remakes cancelled TV series Fantasy award winner 24 frames 2019 Film TBS justice league Comic Book 2016 joker politics Music Mindy Kaling WarnerMedia E3 discovery cinemax movie Amazon Studios CBS All Access A24 Binge Guide 20th Century Fox GIFs TruTV IFC Films 4/20 Film Festival Certified Fresh Interview biography crime drama OneApp BAFTA Mudbound E! screenings TCA Winter 2020 miniseries Song of Ice and Fire space blaxploitation Mystery Rock singing competition Cannes Dark Horse Comics science fiction See It Skip It Apple TV Plus BET Awards Trophy Talk The Arrangement video Showtime IFC stoner dramedy ITV nfl reboot RT21 Crackle Pet Sematary Mary Tyler Moore medical drama Ghostbusters Schedule psychological thriller political drama Opinion PBS Pirates DGA Pride Month robots latino news travel Chernobyl boxoffice Black History Month sag awards MSNBC Year in Review Teen blockbuster Thanksgiving rotten hollywood name the review Hear Us Out mutant Tomatazos Pixar cops docudrama Disney Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spain historical drama PaleyFest golden globes DC Comics Pop TV Shudder Endgame CBS mission: impossible children's TV comiccon strong female leads The Purge sports