Showdowns

Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher: Who Makes Better Mindbending Blockbusters?

Is it the director who gave us Fight Club, The Game, Seven, and Zodiac? Or the one who gave us Memento, Inception, Interstellar, and the upcoming Tenet?

by | July 9, 2020 | Comments

OK, fanboys, we’re getting ready to dodge and duck and block your furious comments as we pit favorites Christopher Nolan and David Fincher against each other in our second director-focused episode of VS. Who is the better mind-bending auteur: The man who delivered the big WTFs with Memento and redefined the superhero movie with the Dark Knight Trilogy? Or the man who laid Mark Zuckerberg out on the table in one of the smartest and most enjoyable dramas of the last 20 years – and also gave us the iconic Fight Club? We’re comparing their performance on the Tomatometer and at the box office, and looking at their characters and biggest moments to decide who comes out on top of the modern directors’ heap.

Of course, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Thumbnail images by ©20th Century Fox Film Corp., Stephen Vaughan/©Warner Bros courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Rock The Walt Disney Company robots Star Wars TLC Lifetime pirates of the caribbean Nominations emmy awards slashers popular thriller spy thriller The Walking Dead 007 Paramount psycho YouTube Premium monster movies PBS sports Tumblr Trailer cats TV Fall TV television Thanksgiving stoner Pop TV ESPN DGA festivals dexter Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Television Critics Association romance live event Marvel El Rey Western Dark Horse Comics harry potter versus Brie Larson all-time Apple TV+ cancelled parents Biopics Opinion Sci-Fi jamie lee curtis chucky BBC America debate Funimation IFC Films critic resources Binge Guide Britbox japanese suspense 20th Century Fox directors Awards Fantasy mcc dramedy independent Mary poppins new star wars movies 72 Emmy Awards golden globe awards CNN 2016 halloween Instagram Live Summer boxoffice singing competition obituary FXX blockbuster sitcom spanish language revenge Nat Geo remakes kaiju President Amazon basketball Comic Book batman reviews Red Carpet spinoff HBO Black Mirror Spring TV TCA Awards genre superhero Hulu ratings criterion Watching Series 99% trailers comic book movies SXSW RT21 Endgame quibi Sony Pictures justice league Hallmark universal monsters 4/20 Universal Legendary scorecard Certified Fresh action-comedy MTV Cannes 1990s Tubi cars ABC Signature composers politics Stephen King Reality Competition Apple TV Plus Chernobyl Paramount Plus 2017 marvel comics Image Comics biography National Geographic The CW WGN Avengers Shudder target Reality Schedule Mary Poppins Returns anthology FOX comedies CMT know your critic Hallmark Christmas movies cops scary Turner Classic Movies Mindy Kaling james bond movie war Toys Amazon Studios lord of the rings FX on Hulu Ghostbusters dragons tv talk young adult PlayStation prank AMC Paramount Network TV renewals Year in Review Sundance richard e. Grant spanish cooking Shondaland The Arrangement Character Guide biopic Black History Month canceled olympics Tomatazos spider-man facebook Baby Yoda The Purge marvel cinematic universe Comics on TV hist comic books The Academy black crime drama Winter TV DC streaming service game show Marathons video sequels renewed TV shows slasher Netflix Christmas movies classics Academy Awards DC Universe art house aliens best Hear Us Out game of thrones king arthur Sneak Peek Masterpiece teaser VICE technology free movies TV movies nfl Amazon Prime Musical Emmy Nominations GLAAD concert TBS latino Ovation canceled TV shows adaptation medical drama razzies casting TCA Winter 2020 diversity king kong screen actors guild Spike critics comics Universal Pictures spider-verse Teen hidden camera rt archives supernatural foreign mission: impossible 90s asian-american MSNBC crossover children's TV worst movies Mystery comiccon rt labs critics edition Photos rom-coms die hard witnail child's play zero dark thirty 2015 Television Academy Logo Disney+ Disney Plus Crackle OneApp psychological thriller laika green book Fox News transformers what to watch mockumentary dogs Superheroes hispanic Sundance TV GIFs australia Marvel Television BET vampires scary movies San Diego Comic-Con films dark movies werewolf TV One DirecTV based on movie TV Land TCA Winners nbcuniversal news Bravo space Marvel Studios adventure fast and furious golden globes binge TruTV Disney Channel japan DC Comics video on demand documentaries animated E3 Writers Guild of America sag awards 71st Emmy Awards south america blaxploitation Disney streaming service Extras Countdown ABC Family Infographic X-Men jurassic park Lionsgate Superheroe streaming Animation disaster docuseries TNT Action Women's History Month Family Grammys NBA heist movie posters cancelled TV shows Walt Disney Pictures CBS Interview Pirates Horror Adult Swim Calendar wonder woman cancelled TV series Crunchyroll stand-up comedy talk show comic IMDb TV Kids & Family WarnerMedia Heroines Turner Lifetime Christmas movies cartoon Emmys CW Seed Arrowverse breaking bad Trophy Talk Film Festival godzilla Cartoon Network First Reviews feel good Valentine's Day Rocketman stop motion NYCC Captain marvel kids twilight FX Sundance Now saw AMC Plus streaming movies high school Columbia Pictures theme song adenture USA Network 21st Century Fox NBC christmas movies joker VH1 Video Games telelvision Christmas TCA 2017 kong archives Elton John Box Office 45 true crime Comic-Con@Home 2021 APB zombie TCM comic book movie 2018 football Election Musicals LGBTQ Anna Paquin Peacock Super Bowl IFC YouTube Red Fargo gangster Rocky HBO Go docudrama mob rotten book adaptation elevated horror franchise Discovery Channel ABC sequel travel Set visit boxing serial killer romantic comedy cinemax Alien dc Pixar TIFF Pet Sematary LGBT Podcast Country Netflix hollywood discovery hispanic heritage month Trivia Pride Month political drama vs. international Apple scene in color women American Society of Cinematographers 2020 BBC One Polls and Games Starz ITV reboot sopranos cults CBS All Access miniseries BAFTA Food Network 2019 doctor who OWN 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Warner Bros. screenings Premiere Dates Epix SundanceTV Oscars ViacomCBS Tarantino Vudu nature Mary Tyler Moore toy story Creative Arts Emmys dceu blockbusters Showtime dreamworks indiana jones mutant Syfy MCU Ellie Kemper BET Awards Martial Arts historical drama GoT a nightmare on elm street legend Best and Worst Drama new york The Witch new zealand Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Nickelodeon PaleyFest Pacific Islander toronto crime thriller Neflix Tokyo Olympics Holiday ghosts Film First Look Holidays italian royal family Acorn TV documentary satire social media Classic Film Broadway VOD A24 YA zombies french Esquire Rom-Com See It Skip It 73rd Emmy Awards police drama award winner aapi anime HBO Max festival superman deadpool Freeform Pop period drama science fiction venice series natural history strong female leads 24 frames rotten movies we love name the review USA YouTube Disney fresh RT History Comedy Central History Music SDCC New York Comic Con Mudbound Spectrum Originals Wes Anderson Awards Tour ID Travel Channel Lucasfilm crime Cosplay halloween tv BBC Quiz A&E Song of Ice and Fire book E! unscripted Disney Plus cancelled television Star Trek 93rd Oscars Fox Searchlight Amazon Prime Video Comedy live action rt labs 2021 Exclusive Video worst spain finale indie black comedy