Showdowns

Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher: Who Makes Better Mindbending Blockbusters?

Is it the director who gave us Fight Club, The Game, Seven, and Zodiac? Or the one who gave us Memento, Inception, Interstellar, and the upcoming Tenet?

by | July 9, 2020 | Comments

OK, fanboys, we’re getting ready to dodge and duck and block your furious comments as we pit favorites Christopher Nolan and David Fincher against each other in our second director-focused episode of VS. Who is the better mind-bending auteur: The man who delivered the big WTFs with Memento and redefined the superhero movie with the Dark Knight Trilogy? Or the man who laid Mark Zuckerberg out on the table in one of the smartest and most enjoyable dramas of the last 20 years – and also gave us the iconic Fight Club? We’re comparing their performance on the Tomatometer and at the box office, and looking at their characters and biggest moments to decide who comes out on top of the modern directors’ heap.

Of course, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Thumbnail images by ©20th Century Fox Film Corp., Stephen Vaughan/©Warner Bros courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Universal Box Office dceu IFC Films Columbia Pictures PaleyFest TLC ghosts video Reality binge slashers TCA Showtime Disney Plus Masterpiece Pride Month SundanceTV WGN Marvel Television Dark Horse Comics renewed TV shows zero dark thirty hispanic Amazon obituary indie singing competition spinoff National Geographic free movies Black History Month Biopics rotten game of thrones Super Bowl Drama Year in Review Set visit Tomatazos concert stand-up comedy sitcom RT History Trophy Talk festivals GoT cats kids movies aliens all-time WarnerMedia natural history Discovery Channel crime YouTube worst movies CBS worst Superheroes Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FOX romantic comedy Comics on TV HBO TV renewals Britbox 24 frames Nickelodeon Country The Walking Dead miniseries Paramount Network comedies Mary poppins Musicals HBO Go independent sequel casting documentaries Awards Tour BBC One Mindy Kaling Vudu Pirates Hallmark canceled SXSW diversity Shondaland Starz The CW animated politics Travel Channel E3 Spike 45 Rock archives HBO Max FXX Amazon Prime Video indiana jones superhero boxoffice versus Marvel Studios transformers what to watch LGBTQ USA Network directors 2016 facebook Lionsgate Esquire psychological thriller Family cancelled TV series classics Turner Classic Movies sports Disney video on demand Pop TV Logo Marvel laika sag awards First Reviews zombie The Academy Paramount BET Awards doctor who children's TV Film Festival parents History Premiere Dates remakes CNN Christmas chucky Lifetime witnail series Funimation halloween adventure richard e. Grant Netflix cartoon Valentine's Day historical drama quibi comic festival 2020 cinemax science fiction ratings Amazon Studios ESPN psycho YouTube Red stop motion 2018 Fantasy Emmy Nominations television Red Carpet FX on Hulu ABC Toys NBC YouTube Premium scary movies Holidays San Diego Comic-Con RT21 AMC Women's History Month Action cults Academy Awards ABC Family Extras news Disney+ Disney Plus Walt Disney Pictures elevated horror The Arrangement Best and Worst Character Guide The Purge Stephen King south america documentary Teen spy thriller Kids & Family Winter TV Mudbound PBS mockumentary Countdown Ghostbusters cars Polls and Games Warner Bros. Summer Pixar Musical Rocketman Creative Arts Emmys TCA Winter 2020 book Mary Tyler Moore screen actors guild Sundance TV joker french revenge Television Critics Association cops twilight Arrowverse Infographic Superheroe Grammys Lifetime Christmas movies 2015 hollywood emmy awards dc 2017 Star Wars Hallmark Christmas movies Captain marvel foreign YA cancelled BAFTA Shudder golden globes latino Apple TV Plus supernatural crime drama DC Comics TCA Awards rotten movies we love DGA MCU teaser crime thriller CMT Brie Larson police drama Fox Searchlight nfl halloween tv X-Men A24 dragons Hear Us Out award winner The Witch Rocky travel breaking bad spain Sci-Fi ITV Crackle screenings technology Reality Competition Nat Geo theme song critics war movie IFC Schedule biography DC streaming service spider-man toy story Spectrum Originals BET Rom-Com CW Seed christmas movies GLAAD Binge Guide Animation films CBS All Access blockbuster APB President reboot disaster Peacock jamie lee curtis social media SDCC werewolf Trailer Certified Fresh See It Skip It fast and furious TIFF Tarantino cooking Fox News romance Pet Sematary harry potter Film Opinion Music venice Fall TV Disney streaming service GIFs discovery Trivia mutant unscripted Cannes Chernobyl cancelled TV shows streaming space criterion Hulu strong female leads toronto best Heroines Food Network a nightmare on elm street Cosplay Cartoon Network dramedy TNT VOD Emmys VH1 Holiday blaxploitation Television Academy MTV talk show Baby Yoda dogs PlayStation Song of Ice and Fire OWN 2019 20th Century Fox Spring TV zombies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crossover Freeform Pop TV Mary Poppins Returns period drama Tubi American Society of Cinematographers Writers Guild of America name the review Endgame thriller Sony Pictures canceled TV shows OneApp Lucasfilm LGBT anime nature Turner Disney Channel 007 El Rey spanish language Apple 72 Emmy Awards Photos TCA 2017 nbcuniversal Ovation Winners Acorn TV DirecTV Anna Paquin Interview justice league spanish Martial Arts Sundance Now Sneak Peek Horror New York Comic Con game show BBC America BBC Western franchise Awards Syfy TCM USA composers 71st Emmy Awards Election cancelled television die hard 4/20 scorecard medical drama Comedy Crunchyroll Amazon Prime 21st Century Fox Thanksgiving Quiz sequels Tumblr Black Mirror green book child's play VICE dark Video Games football Star Trek Netflix Christmas movies anthology Podcast asian-american comiccon Oscars Classic Film DC Universe NYCC mission: impossible docudrama robots Marathons Apple TV+ Bravo adaptation Comedy Central First Look stoner tv talk Sundance true crime Calendar political drama comics Ellie Kemper serial killer reviews Avengers MSNBC FX TV Land vampires Epix universal monsters Watching Series TruTV Mystery Adult Swim A&E TBS satire italian batman Elton John Comic Book finale Nominations E! based on movie hist