Showdowns

Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher: Who Makes Better Mindbending Blockbusters?

Is it the director who gave us Fight Club, The Game, Seven, and Zodiac? Or the one who gave us Memento, Inception, Interstellar, and the upcoming Tenet?

by | July 9, 2020 | Comments

OK, fanboys, we’re getting ready to dodge and duck and block your furious comments as we pit favorites Christopher Nolan and David Fincher against each other in our second director-focused episode of VS. Who is the better mind-bending auteur: The man who delivered the big WTFs with Memento and redefined the superhero movie with the Dark Knight Trilogy? Or the man who laid Mark Zuckerberg out on the table in one of the smartest and most enjoyable dramas of the last 20 years – and also gave us the iconic Fight Club? We’re comparing their performance on the Tomatometer and at the box office, and looking at their characters and biggest moments to decide who comes out on top of the modern directors’ heap.

Of course, if you don’t agree with our choice of winner, let us have it in the comments.


Thumbnail images by ©20th Century Fox Film Corp., Stephen Vaughan/©Warner Bros courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Trailer Acorn TV witnail parents spy thriller sag awards Holidays PaleyFest robots Ellie Kemper Disney Plus Winter TV south america Arrowverse renewed TV shows game show Horror spanish language Ovation Song of Ice and Fire Marvel Television unscripted OWN Character Guide true crime comic books Hallmark Christmas movies Baby Yoda Paramount batman Epix TV adventure Paramount Network screen actors guild children's TV australia The Academy period drama Shondaland Year in Review spider-man Kids & Family Infographic laika worst movies video Toys japanese Photos series Heroines APB italian 2020 nfl Ghostbusters discovery TruTV festivals OneApp Family LGBT quibi Marvel Studios anime Freeform award winner versus The Walking Dead Chernobyl Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mudbound Classic Film CBS All Access Funimation Tumblr 45 Star Trek twilight Travel Channel ABC BAFTA Spectrum Originals dark Stephen King VICE Mary Tyler Moore space game of thrones Teen LGBTQ PBS Calendar cooking festival social media streaming New York Comic Con Rock stand-up comedy Rocketman james bond chucky See It Skip It E! Schedule Comics on TV Binge Guide Masterpiece Lucasfilm San Diego Comic-Con Disney cancelled television Hallmark rt archives Disney Channel Sundance TV name the review blockbuster Tubi Oscars Election black Biopics comic hollywood comedies psycho reboot 2015 Pixar mockumentary MCU Amazon Prime GoT dceu Captain marvel A24 MSNBC franchise nature romantic comedy VH1 Music AMC 99% Comic Book 2018 critics Mary Poppins Returns Watching Series Marvel Television Academy Super Bowl DC Comics disaster Endgame TBS asian-american Awards E3 technology Sundance Now Pirates Certified Fresh sequels FX YouTube Premium The Purge TCM rotten movies we love Cannes Superheroe CMT talk show slashers crime drama CW Seed The CW political drama foreign harry potter Discovery Channel TV renewals golden globes Christmas TNT tv talk medical drama Pop Netflix Christmas movies YouTube docudrama richard e. Grant Apple TV Plus sequel FXX news USA Network Sci-Fi scary movies mutant Turner Classic Movies what to watch transformers revenge cartoon classics BBC One spanish boxing fresh cults Adult Swim Writers Guild of America travel Animation President all-time CNN GLAAD ITV book universal monsters Syfy BET Awards supernatural Dark Horse Comics Box Office Apple TV+ hispanic Amazon Summer police drama biography Disney+ Disney Plus NYCC RT History HBO Go ID Western PlayStation FOX hist Action BBC Set visit Women's History Month best Sneak Peek canceled Shudder Universal HBO Max Extras 21st Century Fox mission: impossible dogs Lifetime Superheroes YouTube Red Hear Us Out Pride Month miniseries remakes video on demand diversity Spring TV TLC boxoffice IFC Films Best and Worst screenings superhero History concert stop motion Fox Searchlight venice theme song Academy Awards ESPN TCA Awards emmy awards Brie Larson thriller RT21 TIFF Martial Arts American Society of Cinematographers halloween tv television obituary cars Hulu Creative Arts Emmys aliens Trivia scorecard spain football Valentine's Day Holiday Amazon Studios cancelled serial killer WarnerMedia casting criterion Fall TV halloween independent zombies Avengers NBC DC Universe Television Critics Association canceled TV shows Musicals Warner Bros. SDCC spinoff anthology worst Interview WGN war deadpool french Walt Disney Pictures fast and furious elevated horror latino facebook Sony Pictures The Arrangement Pop TV Lionsgate Vudu Drama Pet Sematary TCA Winter 2020 free movies 2017 Mary poppins breaking bad Britbox crossover National Geographic Trophy Talk indie Spike directors BET Awards Tour Starz stoner composers dramedy Showtime Fantasy Polls and Games politics Cartoon Network jamie lee curtis 24 frames dragons zombie cats crime Reality Competition adaptation dc nbcuniversal Disney streaming service movies historical drama Elton John archives Black Mirror cops Food Network Fox News Cosplay toy story ghosts TCA Tarantino a nightmare on elm street Grammys toronto cancelled TV shows 72 Emmy Awards based on movie X-Men DC streaming service animated kids Tomatazos Anna Paquin Peacock green book romance YA christmas movies justice league child's play Emmy Nominations First Reviews psychological thriller finale Crackle rotten Country FX on Hulu El Rey Opinion First Look CBS vampires Red Carpet natural history 71st Emmy Awards Comedy 007 doctor who Lifetime Christmas movies Columbia Pictures Comedy Central SundanceTV Netflix science fiction Winners Rom-Com blaxploitation Black History Month DGA ABC Family reviews Reality documentaries strong female leads werewolf Crunchyroll singing competition Esquire Film Nominations Film Festival GIFs Alien Amazon Prime Video Thanksgiving SXSW comics Sundance TCA 2017 sitcom die hard teaser Musical Quiz Marathons comiccon satire Premiere Dates Emmys Podcast 4/20 indiana jones Mystery 2016 joker zero dark thirty documentary crime thriller Apple DirecTV MTV Countdown Turner USA Logo Mindy Kaling IFC HBO sports TV Land BBC America movie VOD The Witch ratings films binge Rocky 20th Century Fox Nickelodeon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cancelled TV series A&E Nat Geo 2019 cinemax Bravo Star Wars Video Games