Critics Say Certified Fresh Animaniacs Revival Is Nostalgic, Self-Aware Fun

Filled with classic characters, zany comedy, and catchy musical numbers, Hulu's latest animated offering is sure to please fans old and new.

by | December 1, 2020 | Comments

It’s been 22 years since the series finale of Animaniacs hit the air. Much has changed in the world of cartoon entertainment. But nostalgia never goes out of style. Hulu execs understood this when they announced the highly-anticipated reboot, now considered a Hulu Original, back in 2018. As an added bonus, all 99 episodes of the original series, which premiered back in 1993, were added to Hulu’s streaming library.

The original Animaniacs had an anthology format, but the program was generally centered on three zany characters: The Warner brothers Yakko (Rob Paulsen), Wakko (Jess Harnell), and the Warner sister, Dot (Tress MacNeille). In each episode, these three troublemakers would escape their water tower prison on the Warner Bros. lot and wreak havoc as they went, interacting with celebrities and iconic characters from the big screen while delivering hilarious riffs on pop culture and some catchy songs along the way. And of course, there was Pinky (Paulsen) and The Brain (Maurice LaMarche) — the mouse duo hell-bent on world domination were so popular, they even got their own spinoff.

And now, Hulu has gotten the band back together. Most of the original voice cast has returned, along with Steven Spielberg, who is once again the executive producer on the series. All 13 episodes are now streaming. But is the return of the animated classic as satisfying as fans are hoping? Here’s what critics say about the now–Certified Fresh first season of Hulu’s Animaniacs.

How Does the Animation Compare to the Original?

(Photo by Amblin Television/Warner Bros. Animation)

One thing that’s clear from the start is that the production paid close attention to how the animation of the original worked when it was at its best. Yakko, Wakko, and Dot have been updated to 2020 without losing any of the zany stretching and wacky expressions that made them endearing in the first place. It’s by no means the same show (and the updated Acme Labs building and Pinky and the Brain intro should make that immediately apparent), but it pays all due respect to its delightfully disrespectful past. — Rollin Bishop,

It has an updated digital, vectored look. Much like the original series, seven different animation studios across the globe worked on this, but it manages to stay consistent. For starters, all the character designs have thinner outlines. There’s no shadowing and it leans more towards flat designs. The backgrounds, updated to resemble something like a watercolor painting, and the art direction are gorgeous. — Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

It copies the animation style of the original, though the now-digital format gives the human characters an uncanny valley feel. The clean lines and brighter tones clash with the show’s purposefully ugly moments—like watching a toddler scream or the new Warner Bros. CEO laugh maniacally at the idea she’d ever eat refined sugar. (It reminded me a bit of Tom and Jerry: Willy Wonky and the Chocolate Factory, which is something I never want to say again.) — Beth Elderkin,

What Other Characters Show Up?

(Photo by Amblin Television/Warner Bros. Animation)

It’s also worth noting that while several segments from the previous version didn’t make the jump — so long Slappy Squirrel and Rita and Runt — there do appear to be entirely new segments in the mix this time around.— Rollin Bishop,

We don’t have all the secondary characters back — yet. I am really hoping to see the Goodfeathers and Buttons and… well… everyone! We did get Pinky and the Brain though and that is something I cannot complain about. It was so great to see them still trying to take over the world 22 years later. — Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Only one of the new episodes included a brand-new short in a similar vein, called Starbox and Cindy, that featured an alien trying to escape a little girl’s house. It had the most interesting animation choices by far and I loved how it featured an actual child’s voice, but it wasn’t an instant classic. It did leave me hoping to see more original shorts, though, as the episodes felt kind of repetitive without them. — Beth Elderkin,

You can’t have “Animaniacs” without “Pinky and the Brain,” and the series returns the saga of the two mice seeking world domination despite their “Of Mice and Men” dynamic. Even more than the Warner siblings sketches, these segments certainly feel like unabashed continuations of the same series. And even with some peppering of jokes about memes, or references to the movie “Ex Machina,” it’s easy for the show to feel like it’s on autopilot. It’s the same thing they do every night, but it’s still a segment that pales compared to Dot, Wakko, and Yakko’s antics. — Nick Allen,

Do the Jokes Still Land?

(Photo by Amblin Television/Warner Bros. Animation)

The same kind of humour found within the 90s series can be found in the new Animaniacs. It was both brilliant and nostalgic. — Britany Murphy, Geeks of Color

The series is as topical as things can get for writing the new episodes in 2018. Only five episodes were available for review and I quickly devoured all of them just before Election Day. There’s no shortage of material when it comes to jokes about Russia. The series even has an election special that is on the money–it’s a basic bit that satires what we see on cable news.— Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

The series fails in part because it didn’t update its nostalgia to make sense for fans who were kids then but are adults now. Instead, it’s stuck in the ’90s. This presents itself in dated references to things like Seinfeld’s “The dingo ate your baby” and a Cold War-esque view of Russia. During times Animaniacs skews more modern, the satire is not “biting,”—as Dot herself claims in an early episode—it’s weak. — Beth Elderkin,

Instead of going to the rich well of entertainment industry nonsense and historical larks that kept Ruegger’s “Animaniacs” afloat, Wild’s “Animaniacs,” relishes the opportunity to take shots at Politics Today in a way that has kept “Family Guy” running for years, but rarely fits the Animaniacs themselves. Yakko, Wakko and Dot are shrewd, sure, but they’ve always rather been agents of chaos accidentally on purpose upending the world than just snarky pundits commenting on its flaws. — Caroline Framke, Variety

Any Final Thoughts?

(Photo by Amblin Television/Warner Bros. Animation)

Some bits are far better than others, but thanks to the brief runtime for any given segment, nothing ever truly overstays its welcome. If the gang being extremely gross, then extremely cute, then extremely gross again doesn’t sit right with you, all you need to do is wait another eight minutes for something else to come along. — Rollin Bishop,

The show’s spirit is still completely intact. It hits all the beats that captured what the original was all about: the self-aware meta-humor, catchy music, unapologetic bashing of modern celebrities and figures, and satirical commentary on the state of the world that will fly over kids’ heads but that adults will immediately comprehend, all while being targeted towards a general family audience. — Rendy Jones, Rendy Reviews

So while the 1993 “Animaniacs” was aggressively self-aware, this 2020 version feels aggressively so, even defiant, as it constantly works to justify its existence. — Caroline Framke, Variety

Filled with hilarious songs, self aware main characters, and of course current event humor, the Animaniacs 2020 reboot is something that everyone can enjoy! If you like the original show, you are sure to love this one! — Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Hulu’s Animaniacs is fun, outlandish, nostalgic, and manages to bring a fresh modern perspective. — Daniel Hart, Ready Steady Cut

Animaniacs season 1 is now available on Hulu.

Tag Cloud

Fox Searchlight historical drama comic book movie Emmys reviews anthology comic book movies finale prank Character Guide Syfy adaptation unscripted foreign elevated horror romantic comedy Sundance TV dogs Crunchyroll PBS DGA dramedy what to watch Animation Shudder Drama biography 2015 Apple TV+ Marathons laika Comic-Con@Home 2021 universal monsters Hallmark Tubi crime thriller Ovation theme song WarnerMedia Year in Review 1990s Bravo Stephen King Legendary GoT TV One Television Academy Nat Geo rt labs monster movies asian-american natural history See It Skip It Peacock spider-man ABC Signature critic resources Captain marvel parents Masterpiece book Film Festival DC Comics Premiere Dates BBC America Rocky scene in color Amazon Marvel Chernobyl Comedy Central joker 90s spanish comic werewolf ViacomCBS Heroines BBC One award winner Travel Channel Mudbound revenge Marvel Television YouTube Premium The Witch lord of the rings teaser zombie video strong female leads USA Network cinemax posters Cartoon Network Reality ghosts Spring TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt MCU NBC Women's History Month MTV Tomatazos HBO Go halloween sequels dceu independent 45 james bond olympics GIFs Disney Plus First Reviews free movies quibi Turner Classic Movies 72 Emmy Awards remakes golden globe awards live action disaster boxing ID vampires IFC Pride Month streaming movies Red Carpet renewed TV shows science fiction TCA saw Classic Film die hard thriller Alien Paramount Plus American Society of Cinematographers royal family critics aapi adenture History dark women football El Rey Binge Guide Rock Valentine's Day children's TV CMT Netflix Christmas movies Biopics Holidays Mindy Kaling batman OneApp blockbusters criterion BET TV Land high school south america venice cancelled TV series BAFTA Creative Arts Emmys Best and Worst Hear Us Out Mary Tyler Moore mcc Apple french crime Western toy story blaxploitation series action-comedy dexter toronto X-Men legend Esquire worst movies screen actors guild young adult screenings harry potter Image Comics popular Star Wars Schedule indie Black Mirror talk show Disney+ Disney Plus Rom-Com kong black Winter TV Marvel Studios know your critic casting YouTube Teen Universal Apple TV Plus canceled TV shows comics spinoff tv talk spy thriller Cannes Superheroes Walt Disney Pictures rotten supernatural romance USA Spectrum Originals DC Universe Logo 2019 2016 cars Certified Fresh hidden camera cancelled TV shows Film BBC rt archives CNN Endgame aliens 2021 godzilla Music docudrama king kong debate game of thrones Comics on TV E! basketball Musical Paramount Network 4/20 heist movie FXX Podcast Sundance Now Acorn TV king arthur YouTube Red Wes Anderson book adaptation documentaries diversity The Academy concert Reality Competition 99% DC streaming service Election kaiju indiana jones space chucky video on demand WGN HBO Max TV movies directors Emmy Nominations Trivia sag awards Anna Paquin police drama political drama Food Network Dark Horse Comics archives 2018 2020 rotten movies we love 2017 documentary war Disney nature 20th Century Fox FX stand-up comedy Lifetime Sundance cults dc Discovery Channel SundanceTV halloween tv CW Seed Baby Yoda Countdown Sneak Peek wonder woman Mary Poppins Returns films Pop TV Thanksgiving SXSW Set visit based on movie travel Paramount Kids & Family Video Games 24 frames Exclusive Video zombies japan ABC Family name the review best Sci-Fi FOX rt labs critics edition TCA Awards Pacific Islander The Walking Dead Oscars E3 richard e. Grant movie rom-coms scorecard Musicals San Diego Comic-Con Disney streaming service Avengers TV slasher ITV international singing competition robots Tarantino trailers Watching Series Fantasy Epix feel good hollywood Vudu marvel comics satire Family cooking biopic 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pirates Broadway Columbia Pictures Toys Hallmark Christmas movies MSNBC Opinion Rocketman Extras Mystery Awards Tour japanese Interview sequel Starz mission: impossible Polls and Games transformers psychological thriller reboot Adult Swim crime drama festivals Britbox australia VH1 President spanish language Awards streaming ABC AMC Trailer New York Comic Con jurassic park Martial Arts deadpool stop motion sitcom a nightmare on elm street 93rd Oscars all-time Winners Ellie Kemper boxoffice kids The Arrangement Brie Larson National Geographic Superheroe worst TIFF fast and furious VOD Spike Comic Book Star Trek mutant Arrowverse RT21 hispanic heritage month A&E Freeform PaleyFest Warner Bros. APB superman CBS canceled LGBTQ marvel cinematic universe franchise blockbuster spain GLAAD LGBT Netflix Disney Channel Lucasfilm docuseries movies Holiday scary movies target festival doctor who Calendar TCA Winter 2020 Showtime sports Tokyo Olympics superhero technology DirecTV TV renewals comiccon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cartoon cancelled television CBS All Access new star wars movies classics psycho pirates of the caribbean YA Box Office obituary Writers Guild of America true crime VICE anime miniseries news TCM Action OWN cancelled Amazon Prime Video 73rd Emmy Awards Country slashers Amazon Studios Crackle Grammys 71st Emmy Awards FX on Hulu politics twilight ESPN Pixar Photos television fresh golden globes period drama cats nbcuniversal Ghostbusters Cosplay crossover latino social media hispanic Funimation composers new zealand NYCC Mary poppins breaking bad zero dark thirty razzies mockumentary telelvision HBO 007 jamie lee curtis Lifetime Christmas movies TBS Song of Ice and Fire Fox News Tumblr Infographic IFC Films Pop Shondaland comedies adventure Sony Pictures child's play serial killer Lionsgate ratings Trophy Talk TruTV versus Comedy nfl Black History Month Academy Awards Turner SDCC The Purge stoner suspense The Walt Disney Company Pet Sematary witnail TLC gangster Christmas justice league Amazon Prime Elton John emmy awards Nominations italian BET Awards RT History binge green book Quiz Horror TCA 2017 PlayStation comic books NBA new york christmas movies Hulu 21st Century Fox Nickelodeon A24 discovery cops dragons First Look TNT Television Critics Association animated hist Summer Super Bowl The CW Fall TV facebook medical drama game show