News

Black Is King First Reviews: Queen Bey Drops A Masterpiece

Critics say Beyoncé's musical film is a timely, visually stunning feast for the senses that reaffirms her status as pop culture royalty.

by | July 31, 2020 | Comments

Barely one month after announcing the project, Beyoncé has dropped her latest visual album, titled Black Is King, on the streaming service Disney+. The surprise new release stems from her involvement with last year’s live-action reimagining of The Lion King and is a complimentary work to her 2019 record The Lion King: The Gift. The first reviews of the musical film, which wasn’t screened early for critics, are unanimously positive, recognizing its visual craftsmanship, timeliness, and how it progresses both its material and Beyoncé’s own career as an artist.

Here’s what critics are saying about Beyoncé’s Black Is King:


How does this project fit into Beyoncé’s artistic reign?

Beyoncé, the master of the visual album, just keeps getting better with each release.
– Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen, Sydney Morning Herald

The greatest success of Black Is King, with all its ambitions, purposeful revelations and nods by Beyoncé, may be the conformation of its creator and star as the cultural Queen of our time.
– Dominic Patten, Deadline

[It] is a particularly genius sleight of hand only she could pull off.
– Jude Dry, IndieWire

It’s a remarkable addition to the pop world and tribute to her artistry.
– Anne Brodie, What She Said

The product feels like a natural progression in her evolution as an artist… and truly, the outfits are just fabulous — possibly her best to date.
– Anna Menta, Decider

Black Is King doesn’t exactly stand with the best of her previous work — it’s a pleasure but not a landmark — but the Queen Bey goes through it with her head up and her crown intact.
– Steve Pond, The Wrap


Beyonce in Black Is King

(Photo by Disney+)

Is it only for Beyoncé fans?

With appearances from Jay-Z, Kelly Rowland, Pharrell and Naomi Campbell, this star-studded film has something for everyone.
Chanté Joseph, Guardian

The Queen Bey orchestrated visual album is… well, rather excellent and exciting on various fronts.
Dominic Patten, Deadline


How does it honor the legacy of The Lion King?

It bears little resemblance to the Disney film.
Anna Menta, Decider

Beyoncé, who lent her voice to Nala in said remake, is here to offer a corrective… a bold and unique offering that’s brimming with Black pride.
Amon Warmann, Empire Magazine

The Lion King always was and should have been an African-told story. And while Beyoncé’s lens is certainly an American one, her inclusion of Nigerian, Ghanaian, and Cameroonian collaborators drives home this necessity.
Jude Dry, IndieWire

The ties to The Lion King occasionally ground the story in that familiar coming-of-age story, but they just as often feel beside the point.
Steve Pond, The Wrap

Though some sections incorporating dialogue feel a little clunky, the parallel generally works well.
Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen, Sydney Morning Herald

If the public is tiring of Disney doggedly remaking all of its old animations in live action format, finally some original content is coming out of the project as well.
David Smyth, London Evening Standard


Beyonce in Black Is King

(Photo by Disney+)

What else is Black Is King reminiscent of?

Similar in stature and design to Michael Jackson’s Moonwalker film from 1988, Black Is King is clearly structured to be an event release in this time of essentially endless options.
Dominic Patten, Deadline

At times, it feels like Terence Malick’s Tree of Life meets Ryan Coogler’s Black Panther.
Jeremy Helligar, Variety


How are the visuals of this visual album?

Black Is King is a visual masterpiece. It’s almost overwhelming.
Anna Menta, Decider

If there is one thing to be said about Black Is King, it’s that it is visually stunning — from beginning to end. The whole thing.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Each scene somehow more spectacular than its predecessor, Black Is King is a feast for the eyes.
Amon Warmann, Empire Magazine

It’s a sumptuous visual feast, from detailed costuming to choreography.
Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen, Sydney Morning Herald

Black Is King is a visual feast; it provides several slow-panning scenes of stillness where we absorb the striking beauty and duality of bright colors against deep brown tones.
Chanté Joseph, Guardian

This visual feast… finds its moments of glory in the strength of its images, which are more arresting than the story or the subtext.
Steve Pond, The Wrap


Black Is King

(Photo by Disney+)

Who else deserves recognition for the artistry on display?

Beyoncé’s fashion is next-level throughout Black Is King… Shout-out to costume designer Zerina Akers for making Bey look fierce, flawless and Afro-fabulous.
Chuck Arnold, New York Post

Every single outfit that Beyoncé wears is just absolutely beautiful.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

The real star of the visual film, however, is the raw, untapped talent from performers around the world showcasing their rich tradition and culture, history and lineage.
Cydney Henderson, USA Today


What’s the best musical number?

When supermodel Naomi Campbell, Oscar winner Lupita Nyong’o, and Beyoncé’s fellow former Destiny’s Child Kelly Rowland pop up during “Brown Skin Girl,” a tribute to Black women, it feels transcendent.
Jeremy Helligar, Variety

“Brown Skin Girl” is especially moving, showing Beyoncé, Rowland and Blue Ivy together in a strong visual affirmation of generational black womanhood.
Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen, Sydney Morning Herald


Will Black Is King move you?

I’ll admit, I got emotional when Beyoncé and former Destiny Child’s member Kelly Rowland were singing praises to each other.
Anna Menta, Decider

It is impossible to watch the emotive story unfold, accompanied by Warsan Shire’s poetry, Yrsa Daley-Ward’s writing and warm images of west Africa, without feeling emotional.
Chanté Joseph, Guardian


Black Is King

(Photo by Disney+)

Are there any imperfections?

The uneven music of the original soundtrack, though enhanced by the visual accompaniment, can still be hit or miss.
Jeremy Helligar, Variety

There is one part that I would totally skip if I were to watch it again. The celestial stuff… For me, it felt a little weird and out of place.
Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

It’s mildly disappointing that more inspiration isn’t drawn from East Africa given that’s where The Lion King is set.
Amon Warmann, Empire Magazine


How important is Black Is King to young Black people in particular?

Black Is King, if nothing else, will perhaps inspire them to learn about the history of their race and the ways in which it has shaped the world.
Jeremy Helligar, Variety

There’s an urgency in the way that Beyoncé is addressing the “black kings,” as if she feels like she’s running out of time.
Anna Menta, Decider

Black Is King is both her gift and her hope for humanity.
Jude Dry, IndieWire


Beyonce in Black Is King

Ryan Fujitani

Is this another masterpiece for our time?

Black Is King [is] vital to the current conversation in a way that no one could have foreseen, but is most welcome.
Amon Warmann, Empire Magazine

Her visual album has taken on new meaning following the reemergence of the Black Lives Matter movement and the fight against police brutality and racism.
Cydney Henderson, USA Today

With the resurgence of the Black Lives Matter movement this year, Black Is King is a timely, powerful declaration of pride.
Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen, Sydney Morning Herald

With this vivid celebration, she goes way beyond saying Black Lives Matter to showing the dazzling inspiration of her ancestry.
David Smyth, London Evening Standard

The film is being released at a time when Disney is coming to terms with some of its own racist past.
Steve Pond, The Wrap

What the world needs now is love, sweet, love, and this colorful reminder of the power and glory of Black, here in America but even more so in Africa.
Jeremy Helligar, Variety


Black Is King premieres on Disney+ on Friday, July 31.

#1

Black Is King (2020)
94%

#1
Adjusted Score: 95.898%
Critics Consensus: Beyoncé is King.
Synopsis: The voyages of Black families, throughout time, are honored in a tale about a young king's transcendent journey through betrayal,... [More]
Directed By: Beyoncé Knowles

Tag Cloud

television natural history political drama TBS what to watch 2016 indie Disney Mudbound criterion cancelled TV series crime thriller crime laika Lifetime spanish Crunchyroll trailers Tomatazos razzies Comic Book Arrowverse blockbuster reboot The Arrangement Nickelodeon animated Winter TV Sundance CNN Shudder sequels HBO Go Marathons See It Skip It Mystery Horror TV Calendar Spring TV directors cancelled television Paramount IFC Fox Searchlight SXSW movie Funimation golden globe awards Best and Worst Columbia Pictures cancelled TV shows know your critic Certified Fresh BBC Walt Disney Pictures 2019 PBS sag awards TCA Awards adventure 21st Century Fox Nominations Winners Epix children's TV RT History LGBT binge 2017 Oscars YouTube Premium Pacific Islander news USA Network Western transformers psychological thriller Disney Channel Masterpiece italian spy thriller spain award winner Crackle Election singing competition new york popular RT21 Comedy Apple TV Plus FOX superhero Holidays historical drama 2015 A&E documentaries TV movies dragons Baby Yoda festival MTV Ghostbusters Women's History Month elevated horror target The Academy international Musicals new star wars movies FX on Hulu Starz Quiz E! anime cartoon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt concert dc batman scary movies Alien Sundance Now Action GLAAD Sony Pictures Netflix Christmas movies screen actors guild VOD GoT japanese book adaptation spinoff Interview Chilling Adventures of Sabrina prank Fox News Black Mirror Film Festival thriller Family south america YA USA universal monsters Cannes Disney+ Disney Plus Star Trek game show Paramount Network justice league Nat Geo Toys Chernobyl reviews Comics on TV NBC Creative Arts Emmys AMC SundanceTV satire Superheroes witnail 2021 TruTV Lucasfilm nbcuniversal Dark Horse Comics renewed TV shows Esquire History golden globes Classic Film mutant spanish language superman Pop TV Apple documentary Awards HBO marvel cinematic universe 20th Century Fox high school cars casting 4/20 Superheroe deadpool halloween tv Reality mockumentary spider-man NYCC Rocketman Fall TV Reality Competition Comedy Central Summer Acorn TV versus unscripted TCM VH1 all-time asian-american BBC America hidden camera travel discovery Elton John Red Carpet rotten kids politics Academy Awards Travel Channel Trivia sequel king kong Hallmark Christmas movies LGBTQ MCU latino 007 comiccon Ellie Kemper based on movie Bravo dceu revenge 99% boxoffice The Walking Dead Video Games nature BBC One game of thrones worst movies DC streaming service Kids & Family supernatural harry potter Infographic cults BET Awards joker Christmas classics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards PlayStation obituary psycho BAFTA Drama sitcom Spike 24 frames New York Comic Con mission: impossible heist movie Box Office christmas movies Hallmark First Reviews Holiday richard e. Grant Countdown Ovation jurassic park CMT sports theme song Trophy Talk lord of the rings YouTube Red GIFs serial killer medical drama Warner Bros. Mary Tyler Moore The Purge Pop ViacomCBS fast and furious First Look Awards Tour Pixar Avengers telelvision social media Pirates Set visit venice hollywood live action boxing Opinion Polls and Games disaster franchise Amazon Studios stoner PaleyFest Adult Swim 2020 Amazon Prime scene in color fresh Image Comics Trailer finale cops critics facebook zombies Lifetime Christmas movies Year in Review Tarantino Star Wars Marvel The Witch dogs Television Critics Association die hard Schedule ratings cooking Disney Plus Sneak Peek comic Legendary X-Men Mary poppins Freeform true crime toronto National Geographic jamie lee curtis twilight period drama Stephen King emmy awards streaming miniseries Cosplay best police drama Photos Pride Month independent ghosts Super Bowl WGN child's play DC Comics Podcast zombie Character Guide TV Land indiana jones video on demand Emmys rt archives strong female leads monster movies blaxploitation robots OWN scorecard Binge Guide Music parents dramedy Rom-Com Shondaland saw godzilla toy story aliens Watching Series President remakes 2018 a nightmare on elm street Vudu Peacock quibi Britbox diversity Biopics adaptation doctor who war comedies james bond comic books movies crossover Television Academy OneApp stop motion Rocky IFC Films Hulu streaming movies french 93rd Oscars Tumblr FXX Mary Poppins Returns Marvel Television DC Universe TV renewals vampires hispanic TLC screenings rotten movies we love tv talk ABC Showtime ID archives Film video TV One Turner Classic Movies talk show breaking bad Turner halloween El Rey TCA Hear Us Out free movies romantic comedy Musical TNT composers CBS Syfy Amazon 72 Emmy Awards Sundance TV crime drama MSNBC American Society of Cinematographers Marvel Studios ITV HBO Max docuseries dark nfl Lionsgate Emmy Nominations Brie Larson Martial Arts Heroines TCA Winter 2020 green book Broadway book series stand-up comedy Disney streaming service canceled TV shows Discovery Channel Cartoon Network science fiction Mindy Kaling football Valentine's Day Captain marvel Logo docudrama Anna Paquin Writers Guild of America hist pirates of the caribbean DGA anthology CW Seed Teen slashers cats festivals ABC Family ABC Signature Black History Month Paramount Plus Animation Apple TV+ Grammys ESPN San Diego Comic-Con The CW cancelled 71st Emmy Awards werewolf Food Network Exclusive Video canceled blockbusters Thanksgiving technology kaiju Fantasy CBS All Access cinemax Sci-Fi BET romance WarnerMedia Amazon Prime Video APB The Walt Disney Company VICE FX aapi Extras rom-coms A24 E3 Rock new zealand 45 Universal teaser TCA 2017 zero dark thirty Premiere Dates kong Country biography Pet Sematary Endgame Song of Ice and Fire Netflix space Spectrum Originals australia SDCC DirecTV YouTube comics Tubi women worst films TIFF name the review foreign black chucky