News

Aquaman First Reviews: The DCEU Gets Its Second Fresh Film... At Least For Now

Early reviews for James Wan's origin story for the Justice League's Atlanean hero say it's an unapologetically over-the-top spectacle with a perfectly cast Jason Momoa.

by | December 11, 2018 | Comments

DC movies continue to turn the tide with the release of Aquaman, the first solo feature for the maritime member of the Justice League. While it won’t be brandishing as high a Tomatometer score as Wonder Woman, reviews for the James Wan-helmed superhero adventure are mostly positive out of the gate. Aquaman certainly sounds ridiculous, even from the raves, as this is a whole lot of movie (and maybe more). If you just take in the ambitious spectacle and enjoy Jason Momoa’s swagger, you’re in for a wild treat, my man.

Here’s what the critics are saying about Aquaman:


Is it actually any good?

If you’ve ever wondered what pure joy looks like on screen, look no further than the latest film in the DC Universe.
Germain Lussier, io9

It’s a film for everyone.
Catalina Combs, Black Girl Nerds

It’s kind of a shock that it doesn’t suck.
Peter Debruge, Variety

Were it not for Black Panther and Into the Spider-VerseAquaman would easily clinch the title for best superhero movie of the year.
Karen Han, Polygon

It’s a weird and wonderful superhero adventure that strives — and almost succeeds — to be the most epic superhero movie ever made.
William Bibbiani, The Wrap


What about its place in the DC Universe?

This is the movie Green Lantern was too reluctant to be. It’s the most unabashedly DC Comics-embracing movie in the current shared universe.
Jim Vejvoda, IGN

Aquaman seems too afraid of falling into the much derided gravity of Snyder’s [DC movies], and does not have the courage to take any of its stakes seriously.
Elena Lazic, Little White Lies

As with much about the DC universe, the whole thing is hobbled by carelessness.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire


Warner Bros.

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

And when compared to Marvel?

Comes closest to nailing that particular brand of self-aware humor and save-the-world earnestness that has been working so well over at Marvel.
Anne Cohen, Refinery29

When it gets trippy, it floats within hailing distance of Doctor Strange.
– Joshua Rothkopf, Time Out

Change a few names and locations in the plot synopsis, and Aquaman could have been a Thor reboot.
– Eric Kohn, IndieWire


How crazy is it?

Wan’s Aquaman is pulp, through and through, and it’s as broad and outlandish as you could possibly hope for.
William Bibbiani, The Wrap

It’s bonkers. It’s bananas. It doesn’t always work but when it does, oh wow is it fun.
– Germain Lussier, io9

Its unapologetic ridiculousness is exactly why it’s so delightful, bucking so many of the rules set for the genre in the last decade.
Karen Han, Polygon

There’s always some form of insane nonsense on the screen to keep you bewildered and entertained so you don’t really have the time or energy to focus on its more underwhelming aspects.
– Sean Mulvihill, FanboyNation.com


Does it go overboard?

Wan’s film pushes too far sometimes, but that’s because it’s pushing as hard as it can.
William Bibbiani, The Wrap

What seems like fifteen different subgenres are crammed into a submarine ready to burst…no scene ever contemplates the phrase ‘too much.’
Matt Donato, We Got This Covered

Instead of making one Aquaman movie, Wan has made three or four, spinning the wheel and changing modes whenever one idea dries up.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

It’s as if someone told Wan and team that Aquaman would be the title character’s one and only shot at a solo movie, and they made sure to go for broke.
Alex Abad-Santos, Vox

This is a movie that wants to kill you with sensory overload. (It may have even succeeded. I’m fairly sure I am writing this as a ghost. Boo.)
Mike Ryan, Uproxx


Warner Bros.

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

How does Aquaman look?

The production designers have outdone themselves here imagining an elaborate other world beneath the ocean’s surface.
Peter Debruge, Variety

Dubbing Aquaman one of the year’s most accomplished visual achievements is no hyperbole… Atlantis’ sunken megacity stuns on par with Black Panther‘s unveiling of Wakanda.
Matt Donato, We Got This Covered

Aquaman’s greatest strength is its visual style. Even when it borders on bioluminescent whimsy, it’s so distinctly and ceaselessly its own.
Alex Abad-Santos, Vox

Aquaman’s visuals are less Jungle Book photo-realism, more Lisa Frank razzle-dazzle.
Angie Han, Mashable


Does it deliver on the action?

Imagine if someone cut together all the biggest action sequences from the last few decades of Hollywood.
Helen O’Hara, Empire Magazine

There are moments when the action is just so wildly absurd that you can’t help but just stare at the screen in awe of Wan’s audacity.
Sean Mulvihill, FanboyNation.com

The majority of the time the action set pieces seem quite arbitrary… this saddles the overlong film with a ponderous, grinding feel.
Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

It’s confusing but not quite incoherent.
Peter Debruge, Variety


Warner Bros.

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

How is Jason Momoa?

What a perfectly cast superhero…take away Momoa’s steady presence, and you’re looking at an overstuffed mess.
Mara Reinstein, US Weekly

Aquaman hinges on Momoa’s natural swarthy charisma and charm, and Wan’s willingness to let those things shine makes the movie enjoyable.
Alex Abad-Santos, Vox

This movie doesn’t work without Jason Momoa.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx

He leans into the absurdity of his appearance. He knows he’s ripped and superhuman, so why pretend otherwise? But none of that really qualifies as acting.
Anne Cohen, Refinery29


Do the other characters shine?

Watching Kidman kick ass for a few minutes makes a good enough case for an Atlanna standalone movie.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Heard sleepwalks through her part and has zero chemistry with Momoa.
Mara Reinstein, US Weekly

[Heard] fails to really connect, and big part of that is just how indifferent the script for Aquaman is towards its women characters – of which there are only two.
Sean Mulvihill, FanboyNation.com

If there’s one thing to like about Aquaman, it’s that the film allows women such as Mera and Atlanna to kick some ass.
Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

Dolph Lundgren brings a gruff gravitas to his supporting role…Between this and Creed II, we are in the midst of a Lundgrenaissance – and I’m totally fine with that.
Jim Vejvoda, IGN


Warner Bros. Pictures

(Photo by Warner Bros. Pictures)

How are the villains?

I love Yahya Abdul-Mateen II’s Black Manta.
– Mike Ryan, Uproxx

Abdul-Mateen II brings a ferociousness and intensity that works for that character’s specific arc, but feels out of place as it only matches some of the tones that Aquaman is juggling.
Spencer Perry, ComingSoon.net

Black Manta starts out strong but feels increasingly superfluous… Meanwhile, Orm feels curiously underdeveloped — it’s only Wilson’s performance that keeps him from being a total snooze.
Angie Han, Mashable

Black Manta could have been saved for the sequel and this movie wouldn’t have suffered for it.
Jim Vejvoda, IGN


So we should look forward to more Aquaman?

If it stays in the water a bit too long — well, I’d still come back for a sequel.
Angie Han, Mashable

An Aquaman sequel is reportedly in the works.The filmmakers just need to find the heart of their ocean.
Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post


Aquaman opens everywhere on December 21.

#1

Aquaman (2018)
65%

#1
Adjusted Score: 82.592%
Critics Consensus: Aquaman swims with its entertainingly ludicrous tide, offering up CGI superhero spectacle that delivers energetic action with an emphasis on good old-fashioned fun.
Synopsis: From Warner Bros. Pictures and director James Wan comes an action-packed adventure that spans the vast, visually breathtaking underwater world... [More]
Directed By: James Wan

Tag Cloud

2019 New York Comic Con Sundance Extras TV Land sag awards YouTube game of thrones supernatural Trailer unscripted SundanceTV FX Television Critics Association Bravo boxing Grammys Election Cosplay IFC Films space Martial Arts romantic comedy satire best comics CMT venice Year in Review cancelled TV shows festivals anthology 21st Century Fox Comic Book HBO Go TNT History Comedy Central facebook Travel Channel First Look LGBTQ cults Food Network TruTV Nominations Superheroe Spring TV harry potter mutant finale PaleyFest Reality Competition Funimation Marvel Studios Awards Tour TV renewals cars Pet Sematary Star Wars latino Anna Paquin Holiday Lifetime Discovery Channel singing competition Schedule Shondaland Women's History Month cartoon mockumentary Hear Us Out Rocky Toys cancelled television HBO 45 Crackle Ovation Adult Swim hist remakes joker dark biography criterion nature serial killer james bond GoT historical drama PlayStation Amazon Prime Video TCA theme song technology GLAAD Pixar Star Trek Lionsgate discovery A&E Hallmark scary movies 2016 A24 CBS All Access award winner Warner Bros. Premiere Dates streaming TIFF Drama strong female leads E3 Crunchyroll Musicals El Rey cops SDCC cancelled TV series police drama Rocketman spanish comedies transformers adventure Cannes australia Thanksgiving fast and furious Character Guide Rock Marvel Trophy Talk San Diego Comic-Con animated crossover comic books casting Disney Plus teaser Captain marvel Stephen King news festival American Society of Cinematographers VICE doctor who Apple TV Plus child's play vampires Mystery Universal Countdown ESPN hispanic 4/20 thriller ABC nfl deadpool BET Awards Disney+ Disney Plus mission: impossible BBC Set visit classics french Academy Awards Music VH1 The Walking Dead screen actors guild Mary Tyler Moore die hard dragons Arrowverse witnail The Arrangement Winter TV Ellie Kemper black universal monsters adaptation FXX Masterpiece boxoffice BBC One YouTube Premium Film chucky PBS Song of Ice and Fire Logo travel name the review elevated horror Animation Netflix renewed TV shows scorecard archives Nickelodeon Awards independent south america See It Skip It DGA 007 ghosts cooking Calendar tv talk natural history talk show DC Comics The Purge DC streaming service 72 Emmy Awards Disney streaming service war Writers Guild of America what to watch Tomatazos Rom-Com CW Seed nbcuniversal GIFs Turner Valentine's Day jamie lee curtis Fall TV Polls and Games Binge Guide Disney Channel The CW TCA 2017 politics Mudbound Summer USA Esquire indiana jones HBO Max Action BBC America ABC Family diversity RT History composers rotten movies we love zero dark thirty IFC dc Pride Month stoner Podcast Pop FX on Hulu First Reviews Red Carpet franchise sequel period drama green book reviews parents YA 2015 BET Turner Classic Movies 99% critics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FOX Mindy Kaling werewolf AMC Super Bowl 2020 Black History Month spy thriller Musical TLC free movies Cartoon Network hollywood japanese 2017 Tumblr comiccon Apple Avengers asian-american Marathons cats ratings zombie Superheroes a nightmare on elm street obituary Fantasy Lifetime Christmas movies 20th Century Fox Classic Film movies halloween tv game show Christmas indie Paramount Network 71st Emmy Awards Kids & Family science fiction Country Spectrum Originals CBS 24 frames Amazon Prime X-Men cancelled Hallmark Christmas movies Alien laika dceu Pop TV dramedy Pirates Television Academy breaking bad video TCA Awards foreign Chernobyl canceled romance ID dogs screenings documentary Sneak Peek The Witch kids WGN BAFTA NBC Epix medical drama E! OneApp Netflix Christmas movies canceled TV shows toronto films Walt Disney Pictures 2018 Columbia Pictures MSNBC Sundance TV cinemax golden globes Acorn TV comic MTV all-time Amazon Studios justice league blaxploitation TBS Sci-Fi Comedy WarnerMedia LGBT christmas movies Hulu zombies NYCC revenge Best and Worst halloween spinoff APB Fox News documentaries The Academy based on movie political drama toy story richard e. Grant Starz Syfy Box Office true crime Family spider-man Freeform anime concert Heroines emmy awards spanish language slashers disaster Holidays Quiz MCU crime drama italian President Oscars directors aliens Horror sports Showtime miniseries worst movies Spike sitcom quibi Shudder docudrama Emmy Nominations VOD Photos Infographic Emmys TV Interview worst Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt robots Western Creative Arts Emmys television crime thriller psycho DC Universe ITV National Geographic Winners movie Trivia YouTube Red crime versus Apple TV+ Baby Yoda Video Games Britbox Elton John Watching Series Tarantino book superhero Fox Searchlight Lucasfilm TCM Black Mirror Ghostbusters Mary Poppins Returns TCA Winter 2020 series batman Marvel Television children's TV psychological thriller Opinion Certified Fresh Sundance Now SXSW rt archives twilight social media DirecTV reboot Comics on TV spain sequels Disney Mary poppins Endgame video on demand Amazon Teen Dark Horse Comics stand-up comedy rotten fresh Brie Larson Film Festival blockbuster stop motion CNN Vudu OWN Paramount USA Network RT21 Biopics Sony Pictures Nat Geo Peacock football Reality Tubi binge