Total Recall

Total Recall: Vince Vaughn's Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the Couples Retreat star.

by | October 7, 2009 | Comments

Vince Vaughn

Vegas, martinis, and the words “baby” and “money” helped launch Vince Vaughn‘s film career — and helped established him as an extraordinarily compelling cinematic scoundrel, a role he’s played repeatedly over the last decade and change. But that isn’t all Vaughn can do, as he’s proven while assembling an admirably eclectic filmography, moving from comedy to horror to action thrillers and back again, and sharing screens with everyone from Richard Attenborough to Jennifer Lopez in the process. This weekend, Vaughn reunites with his old partner Jon Favreau in Couples Retreat, and to celebrate, we decided to revisit his best-reviewed films, Total Recall style!

As always, we let the Tomatometer do the sorting for us, and although it did the easy work, tossing out the obvious rotten flicks (bye bye, The Break-Up), we still had to make a few judgment calls on roles that, though memorable, still amounted to cameos (adieu, Mr. & Mrs. Smith, Into the Wild, and Anchorman). What we were finally left with was a list that we think captures the breadth of Vaughn’s filmography while limiting it to the movies that gave him a healthy amount of screentime. And with that, let’s dispense with the formalities and get down to the films, shall we? Ladies and gents, the best of Vince Vaughn!


10. The Cell

Vaughn received second billing to Jennifer Lopez in Tarsem Singh’s directorial debut, but both of them (along with Vincent D’Onofrio) took a back seat to the incredible special effects in 2000’s The Cell — not to mention the stupendously grisly violence that alternately made critics think (Nick Davis called it “amazing, courageous, and thoroughly dark”) and run screaming for the aisles (ViewLondon’s Matthew Turner pronounced it “bad in so many ways that it’s difficult to know where to begin”). Ultimately, this tale of a child psychologist who has to enter the mind of a depraved serial killer to save the life of his latest victim wasn’t one of the year’s biggest critical winners, but it broke $100 million at the box office — and it gave Vaughn a chance to flex some dramatic muscle in an effects-heavy thriller completely devoid of dinosaurs.


9. The Lost World: Jurassic Park

Vaughn’s first major role came in Swingers, a film with a budget of $250,000. His next movie was a bit of a step up: 1997’s The Lost World: Jurassic Park boasted a $73 million bankroll, not to mention Steven Spielberg in the director’s chair and a cast including such famous names as Jeff Goldblum, Julianne Moore, and Lord Richard Attenborough. Of course, Lost World wasn’t greeted with quite the same critical reception enjoyed by Swingers, but on the other hand, it did make over $600 million at the box office — and it featured dozens of awesome-looking CGI dinosaurs, which makes up for any critical brickbats, or the fact that Vaughn’s character is a knuckleheaded environmentalist who’s more concerned about saving giant carnivores than his own traveling companions. Looking Closer’s Jeffrey Overstreet summed it all up succinctly when he wrote, “If you liked Jurassic Park, you’ll probably like this one a little less. What the first film did poorly, this film does worse.”


8. A Cool, Dry Place

Based on Michael Grant Jaffe’s novel Dance Real Slow, 1998’s A Cool, Dry Place broke Vaughn’s string of rapscallions and ne’er-do-wells and gave him the first thoroughly sympathetic role of his career: Russell Durrell, a young lawyer struggling through single fatherhood after his wife (Monica Potter) abandons him and their five-year-old son (Bobby Moat). Despite a cast that also included Joey Lauren Adams, Place barely squeaked its way into theaters, grossing a few thousand dollars during a one-week run — and though many critics rolled their eyes at the film’s leisurely pace and heavy melodrama (Filmcritic’s Christopher Null accused the plot of “just [sitting] there like a stuffed monkey”), they were matched by scribes such as Sandra Contreras of TV Guide, who wrote, “Its heart is in the right place, but this sweet drama just doesn’t build enough true drama from its slender premise. That said, it’s not bad enough to merit the kind of stealth release its studio has imposed on it.”


7. Old School

After 2000’s The Cell, Vaughn was relatively quiet for a few years; although he appeared in a pair of major releases (Domestic Disturbance and Made, both released in 2001), he spent much of his time in films whose appeal was more, uh, selective (The Prime Gig, I Love Your Work). It took another testosterone-heavy ensemble comedy to remind audiences what made the Swingers star famous — and okay, so Old School ended up being stolen by Will Ferrell, but Vaughn got his share of laughs, too, and it foreshadowed his funny bit parts in Anchorman and Starsky and Hutch. A not inconsiderable number of critics dismissed Old School‘s raunchy lowbrow humor, but the majority agreed with Cinerina’s Karina Montgomery, who gasped, “I can’t believe it, but I want to see it again.”


6. Clay Pigeons

After making a splash with Swingers, Vaughn hit the ground running, booking roles in several years’ worth of big-budget productions, including 1997’s Jurassic Park sequel, The Lost World, and the costly Jennifer Lopez flop The Cell. Between the tentpoles, however, Vaughn hadn’t lost his taste for the odd lower-profile project — like Clay Pigeons, a Ridley Scott-produced black comedy about a drifter (Vaughn) who uses his imagined friendship with a casual acquaintance (Joaquin Phoenix) as the impetus for a homicidal, Throw Momma from the Train-style “favor.” Playing a charming, murderous lunatic helped prep Vaughn for the starring role in Gus Van Sant’s Psycho remake — and while Pigeons didn’t make much of an impression at the box office, it earned the admiration of critics like the Palo Alto Weekly’s Jeanne Aufmuth, who wrote, “This is not your classic whodunit. It’s blacker,funnier, and edgier.”

Warning: NSFW — language.


5. Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story

Vaughn has an admirably varied resume, having done everything from thrillers to dramas to comedies, but if forced to choose, most people would probably say he works most successfully as half of a comic duo. It stands to reason, then, that 2004’s Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story — which pits Vaughn against a hilariously over-the-top Ben Stiller in a fight to the finish to be decided by bouncy rubber balls traveling at punishingly high speeds. The idea of a movie about grown men playing professional dodge ball is funny all by itself, and when you have the added benefit of a cast stuffed with funny supporting players (including Jason Bateman, Gary Cole, Stephen Root, and Rip Torn), you’re almost assured of a movie that’ll make at least two-thirds of its audience laugh — and, as it turns out, 70 percent of the world’s top critics. Of course, there were a few curmudgeons turned off by Dodgeball‘s broad humor, but most reviews echoed the sentiments of Rolling Stone’s Peter Travers, who wrote, “This masterpiece of modern cinema depends upon a single truism: A guy getting hit in the nuts a hundred times in a row is funny a hundred times.”


4. Return to Paradise

This Joseph Ruben-directed remake of the 1989 French movie Force majeure arrived during a period when American filmmakers were apparently pretty fascinated with the travails of reckless U.S. tourists in Southeast Asian prisons — Brokedown Palace was released a year later, and both films suffered comparisons with Alan Parker’s Midnight Express. Starring Vaughn, Joaquin Phoenix, and David Conrad as a trio of pot-puffing Malaysian tourists who inadvertently run afoul of the law, Paradise took a familiar plot device — innocent American awaiting death in a foreign prison — and added a new wrinkle: Vaughn and Conrad, safe on U.S. soil, are told they can save Phoenix from being hanged, but only if they return to Malaysia to do hard time. Though the script wasn’t without its fair share of contrivances, Paradise‘s thorny moral dilemma was enough to satisfy most critics, and even those who didn’t give the movie their stamp of approval tended to find positive aspects — like Luisa F. Ribeiro of Boxoffice Magazine, who wrote, “Vaughn labors mightily under the obviousness of the script, while managing to reveal a fragile but profound fear of being an aging frat boy who longs to realize a finer, better self, only to be petrified that quality isn’t within him.”


3. Made

Five years after they gave each other their big break in Swingers, Vaughn and Jon Favreau reunited — this time, with Favreau behind the camera in addition to writing the script — for the mob comedy Made. Starring Vaughn and Favreau as a pair of low-level Mafia knuckleheads, Made took their funny, fast-paced banter, surrounded it with a bigger budget, and added drugs, violence, and Sean “Diddy” Combs. Predictably, critics couldn’t help but compare Made to its surprise hit predecessor — and just as predictably, these comparisons didn’t do Made any favors. Still, even if Made didn’t reach Swingers‘ lofty critical heights (and barely made back its budget), Vaughn and Favreau’s chemistry remained potent enough to impress critics like’s Stacie Hougland, who wrote, “Vaughn hits the bullseye as a strident, volatile jerk who can’t keep his mouth shut. You never really like him, but you can’t wait to see what he’ll do next — his missteps and offenses are so unbelievable you wince, but you can’t look away.”


2. Wedding Crashers

Part of the recent R-rated comedy renaissance, Wedding Crashers may not have given Vaughn the opportunity to do anything new — here, he appears as Jeremy Grey, a lech with a heart of gold who isn’t terribly dissimilar from the character he played in Swingers — but it fell squarely in Vaughn’s comedic wheelhouse, had a solid Steve Faber/Bob Fisher script, and surrounded Vaughn and his co-star, Owen Wilson, with some terrific supporting talent, including Christopher Walken, Rachel McAdams, and Isla Fisher as the crazy nymphomaniac who thrills and torments Vaughn in equal measure. Though some critics had problems with Crashers‘ uneven tone — and the scads of gratuitous flesh on display in the movie’s opening montage — most found it too much fun to resist. “The likes of the sneakily subversive Wilson and Vaughn deserve better,” wrote MaryAnn Johnson of Flick Filosopher, “but this is darn close to a perfect showcase for what they can do, and how much better they do it together.”


1. Swingers

Somehow, we doubt many of you are surprised that this list ends where it all began for Vince Vaughn — specifically, with his scene-stealing turn as the appealingly smarmy Trent Walker, best bud to Jon Favreau’s sad sack Mike Peters. Favreau may have written the script, but it was Vaughn who ended up with many of Swingers‘ best lines — and although it’s true that those lines inspired countless wannabe hipsters to pronounce various persons and objects as “so money” for years to come, that’s just an unfortunate byproduct of the movie’s immense likability, and Vaughn’s seemingly effortless cool in the role, which showcased his gifts for comedy and drama. “Four guys hang out, kid one another, get into scuffles and flash their gonadal searchlight for available women,” wrote Time’s Richard Corliss. “Yikes, haven’t there been enough variations on the multiple-buddy movie? Actually, no.”

Take a look through Vaughn’s complete filmography, as well as the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for Couples Retreat.

Finally, here’s Vaughn in Fred Claus going off on Kris Kringle:

Tag Cloud

PBS social media cancelled IFC Films Image Comics classics marvel comics Countdown concert 2015 Disney obituary spain Quiz spanish scary movies MTV Valentine's Day WGN slasher medical drama king arthur 21st Century Fox Holiday Western Arrowverse The Witch cooking doctor who Anna Paquin TV One 45 documentaries leaderboard art house halloween tv Horror Tags: Comedy cartoon comiccon crime dceu Masterpiece 24 frames BET Awards Sundance TV name the review 90s The Arrangement parents CBS green book comic books TV renewals Disney Plus Amazon Prime Video SDCC golden globes Mudbound critics blaxploitation Oscars breaking bad quibi DGA 71st Emmy Awards Star Wars Song of Ice and Fire PlayStation boxing Prime Video supernatural Showtime foreign TCA Apple TV Plus gangster canceled olympics Television Academy franchise Alien scary versus Funimation Crackle spider-man aliens what to watch Sneak Peek twilight telelvision Universal IMDb TV Superheroes cops Opinion Rock live action Netflix Mary poppins 2020 international documentary Superheroe 2016 new zealand 79th Golden Globes Awards Black Mirror Schedule Adult Swim Disney streaming service james bond BBC One 93rd Oscars Biopics Drama spinoff Peacock YouTube Red anthology 4/20 venice blockbusters remakes Women's History Month finale movies ITV Fantasy biography Winter TV Marvel Comic-Con@Home 2021 DC Comics award winner Comic Book Music The Walt Disney Company APB slashers Ghostbusters 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards BBC revenge Interview Premiere Dates Winners rt labs YouTube Instagram Live El Rey TBS TNT 2021 adaptation Vudu Cosplay Paramount book SundanceTV Food Network Nat Geo Amazon Prime cults Fox News Trailer adventure Election emmy awards President Comedy Central Chernobyl television 73rd Emmy Awards Walt Disney Pictures reviews satire japan Discovery Channel reboot Podcast Syfy FOX Tomatazos TCA Winter 2020 OWN cancelled TV shows USA Starz nature The Academy OneApp Amazon Studios Emmys diversity japanese italian Rocky GLAAD Marathons composers cats VH1 best Animation comics political drama kids docuseries video Heroines Lionsgate Pirates Hulu MCU jamie lee curtis Apple TV+ Nominations universal monsters scorecard sequels DC Universe Disney Channel Endgame Ovation HFPA spanish language Baby Yoda Film Festival miniseries mockumentary TV movies Wes Anderson Awards Tour Rom-Com Comedy dreamworks Fall TV series screen actors guild football archives aapi singing competition black live event USA Network NBA Sony Pictures 2019 spy thriller scene in color hidden camera The Walking Dead 72 Emmy Awards New York Comic Con The CW Hollywood Foreign Press Association docudrama sopranos Classic Film pirates of the caribbean Tokyo Olympics lord of the rings TV ABC TCM independent rt archives black comedy Shudder Musical Holidays popular joker free movies batman HBO canceled TV shows Esquire E! directors Polls and Games mcc Avengers superman deadpool ID christmas movies king kong Christmas teaser NBC Martial Arts Character Guide stand-up comedy true crime heist movie Stephen King TCA 2017 disaster A24 streaming mutant south america San Diego Comic-Con zombie Red Carpet Tubi films GoT die hard 99% Nickelodeon Mystery latino period drama Exclusive Video royal family IFC Tarantino Cartoon Network Marvel Television VOD CBS All Access worst PaleyFest comic indiana jones children's TV Turner nbcuniversal know your critic YouTube Premium AMC game of thrones Dark Horse Comics Reality Competition harry potter legend ABC Signature Pop TV kaiju RT History strong female leads Legendary Spectrum Originals Disney+ Disney Plus Fargo hist Calendar anime Super Bowl Hallmark Christmas movies DirecTV Netflix Christmas movies dexter Star Trek politics war Watching Series a nightmare on elm street Country Acorn TV Paramount Plus hispanic HBO Go suspense robots Lucasfilm 20th Century Fox Rocketman dogs TCA Awards History spider-verse travel biopic Paramount Network laika discovery toronto X-Men Summer Elton John SXSW HBO Max CMT FXX Broadway posters Kids & Family Best and Worst American Society of Cinematographers french richard e. Grant new york saw psycho cinemax MSNBC Tumblr rt labs critics edition genre worst movies rotten 2018 elevated horror Spike Epix theme song fresh Infographic BET Apple godzilla sequel dark ratings BAFTA Creative Arts Emmys jurassic park young adult GIFs target screenings cars Extras romance superhero hollywood 1990s Pixar festivals boxoffice First Reviews action-comedy Hallmark tv talk sag awards talk show Spring TV AMC Plus criterion Pacific Islander sports stoner adenture Amazon video on demand ghosts WarnerMedia TLC trophy 007 streaming movies serial killer witnail Musicals vampires Lifetime National Geographic Freeform child's play comedies Mary Tyler Moore space Sundance Now DC streaming service animated TruTV Set visit women Photos Mindy Kaling Fox Searchlight Sci-Fi See It Skip It fast and furious nfl natural history vs. Writers Guild of America First Look Sundance Pop book adaptation Trivia Box Office Ellie Kemper marvel cinematic universe prank ViacomCBS ABC Family cancelled television ESPN facebook Action Mary Poppins Returns rotten movies we love Thanksgiving golden globe awards YA Warner Bros. 2017 dc LGBT Universal Pictures historical drama cancelled TV series zero dark thirty news wonder woman crime thriller Toys BBC America NYCC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime drama science fiction trailers unscripted police drama toy story based on movie Film Grammys comic book movie Britbox festival CNN FX feel good Crunchyroll Pride Month high school technology justice league Year in Review romantic comedy Bravo rom-coms debate Family Captain marvel E3 Turner Classic Movies Pet Sematary monster movies hispanic heritage month TV Land dragons Neflix Awards Binge Guide A&E casting Teen Video Games razzies Academy Awards Brie Larson Emmy Nominations Certified Fresh game show movie binge Trophy Talk Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt LGBTQ critic resources dramedy thriller werewolf mob kong Marvel Studios basketball Lifetime Christmas movies The Purge TIFF Columbia Pictures Hear Us Out new star wars movies comic book movies zombies Cannes mission: impossible transformers halloween all-time Shondaland VICE Black History Month Television Critics Association psychological thriller CW Seed chucky crossover Travel Channel FX on Hulu Logo indie australia sitcom Comics on TV asian-american RT21 renewed TV shows stop motion blockbuster Reality