Total Recall

Total Recall: Best Live-Action Disney Movies

Which of the Mouse House's family-friendly romps comes out on top?

by | March 12, 2009 | Comments

We tend to think of Walt Disney Pictures as chiefly an animation studio — and with good reason — but the house Uncle Walt built has been churning out quality (and often highly profitable) live-action entertainment since the 1950s, something we were reminded of when we noticed that the latest chapter in the Witch Mountain franchise (and the Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson’s latest bid for the undisputed heavyweight champion of kid-friendly cinema), Race to Witch Mountain, was landing in theaters this Friday. What better time, then, for your pals here at Rotten Tomatoes to devote a Total Recall list to the 10 best-reviewed live-action entries in the Disney canon?

Of course, not all of Disney’s live-action efforts have been critical winners — we’re guessing Condorman is discussed as infrequently as possible at the Mouse House — but not everything that missed the list was a dud: You’ll find plenty of the classics you remember (yes, Old Yeller is present and accounted for), but you’re bound to take umbrage with a few omissions. Some movies missed the cut on technicalities — we limited our scope to films without animation (so long, Bedknobs and Broomsticks) and crossed any co-productions off the list, too (thus sparing Operation Dumbo Drop the embarrassment of being disqualified on critical grounds). Others, however, simply didn’t have the reviews — something we think says a lot about the strength of the competition. So let’s see what we ended up with, shall we? The live-action world of Disney awaits!


10. Escape to Witch Mountain

Well, well, well. How’s this for perfect? Not only did it provide a starting point for this week’s Total Recall honoree, 1975’s Escape to Witch Mountain wound up making the list itself. While not the best-remembered of Disney’s 1970s properties, this adaptation of the Alexander Key novel helped kickstart a mini-franchise that eventually extended to 1978’s Return from Witch Mountain, a 1982 TV movie and 1995 made-for-TV remake, and, of course, 2009’s Race to Witch Mountain. Placing extraordinary kids in situations of nail-biting, grown-up peril is something Disney has always done well, and Escape is no exception; psychic alien twins Tony and Tia are literally running for their lives from creepy millionaire Aristotle Bolt (Ray Milland). Though not all critics were susceptible to its charm — Vincent Canby of the New York Times called it “a Walt Disney production for children who will watch absolutely anything that moves” — most scribes took its popcorn-flavored blend of action, sci-fi, and family drama at face value, including Roger Ebert, who called it “a sci-fi thriller that’s fun, that’s cheerfully implausible, that’s scary but not too scary, and it works.”


9. The Absent-Minded Professor

No list of the Disney live-action oeuvre would be complete without a mention of Fred MacMurray’s work for the studio. Although he’d been a major film star for decades before making his Disney debut with 1960’s The Shaggy Dog, it’s MacMurray’s late-period string of pipe-puffing father types that he’s arguably best remembered for, particularly among younger film fans. The most critically successful of these movies, 1961’s The Absent-Minded Professor, casts MacMurray in the title role as Ned Brainard, the accidental inventor of an incredible energy-producing substance known as Flubber. Over the course of the film, Brainerd uses Flubber to make himself look like a talented dancer and helps an entire basketball team cheat during the big game, but thanks to MacMurray’s Everyman charm, you still believe he’s the good guy. It’s goofy, and light as a feather, but Disney has always known how to make the most of those two ingredients; as TV Guide put it, “This is a zanily inventive piece of work, with delightful special effects, which set the style for a long series of live-action Disney films.”


8. Swiss Family Robinson

Even in the context of the other classic films in the Disney vaults, 1960’s Swiss Family Robinson was a huge success — its $40 million gross is equivalent to $367 million in today’s money, placing it proudly among the ranks of the most successful G-rated films of all time. Johann David Wyss’ 1812 novel has been adapted on numerous occasions, for film and television, but Disney’s Ken Annakin-directed treatment is the most well-known; although it doesn’t skimp on the cheesy dialogue and cornpone wholesomeness that came prepackaged with many of the studio’s live-action efforts, Lowell S. Hawley’s screenplay does a fine job of drawing enough swashbuckling action and tropical derring-do out of the source material to guarantee a good time for viewers of all (okay, most) ages. Channel 4 Film’s Alistair Harkness spoke for many of his peers when he wrote, “It’s no Pirates Of The Caribbean, but the spirit of adventure, and Disney’s high production values, means that there’s still some fun to be had watching this wholesome family adapt to island life.”


7. Pollyanna

Hayley Mills, like Tommy Kirk before her (and countless fresh-faced Disney teen starlets after her), became a household name thanks to a string of starring roles in Disney live-action films. Mills’ six-movie run got off to a pretty good start with 1960’s Pollyanna; although its box office performance was initially something of a disappointment for the studio, Mills won a special Academy Award for her performance. For many, the film is now considered one of Disney’s earliest live-action classics; though Disney was far from the first to adapt Eleanor Porter’s novel, it’s Mills that people usually think of when they hear the name “Pollyanna” — and for good reason, as even critics who overdosed on the movie’s relentless optimism, like the Time critic who called it “a Niagara of drivel and a masterpiece of smarm,” were often swayed by her performance. Variety, for instance, said her presence “more than compensates for the film’s lack of tautness and, at certain points, what seems to be an uncertain sense of direction.”


6. The Rookie

By 2002, the “inspirational sports movie” genre was seen as well past its prime — and so was Dennis Quaid: one of the more bankable matinee idols of the 1980s, Quaid was suffering through a dry spell when he signed on for Disney’s John Lee Hancock-directed dramatization of the brief-yet-noteworthy Major League Baseball career of high school teacher-turned-Tampa Bay Devil Ray pitcher Jimmy Morris. Like Morris himself, The Rookie was initially written off by many as an amiable relic of a bygone era — but try as they might, most critics were too charmed by its true-life inspirational story, and Quaid’s refreshingly low-key performance, to be cynical about the film. The Rookie earned a healthy return on Disney’s $22 million investment, kick-started a new chapter in Quaid’s career, and earned a surprising number of endorsements from critics like Looking Closer’s Jeffrey Overstreet, who called it “one of those rare, wonderful ‘formula’ films that … favors understatement over exaggeration, subtlety over sentimentality.”


5. The Parent Trap

For a relatively lightweight rom-com, The Parent Trap has enjoyed an incredibly long life; not only was the original film re-released to theaters seven years after its theatrical debut, but Hayley Mills ended up reprising her dual roles for a trio of made-for-TV sequels more than 20 years later — and the career-boosting power of the story of matchmaking twins who play Cupid for their divorced parents proved every bit as potent in 1998, when Lindsay Lohan starred in a remake. Part of Trap‘s appeal no doubt came from its pioneering use of the trick photography that made it appear as though Mills was actually her own twin — a technique later used to notable effect on The Patty Duke Show two years later — but even without special effects, The Parent Trap is a solid, albeit proudly corny, film that benefits from a strong performance by its winsome star. Mills’ charms were even sufficient to win over more “serious” publications, such as Time, whose reviewer wrote, “Surprisingly, the film is delightful — mostly because of 15-year-old Hayley Mills, the blonde button nose who played the endearing delinquent in Tiger Bay.”


4. 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea

Whether you attribute it to beginner’s luck or the steady hand of one of Hollywood’s most quality-conscious studios, it’s worth noting that Richard Fleischer’s adaptation of Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea is both one of Disney’s most highly regarded live-action efforts and its first foray into science fiction. Proving he had an eye for giant squid battles to match his knack for animating adorable fauna, Walt Disney personally produced 20,000 Leagues, helping Fleischer blend an attentive eye to period detail with a rip-roaring action yarn that just happened to have strong Cold War parallels (right down to the mushroom cloud witnessed after the climactic battle). Enlisting the talents of A-list stars like Kirk Douglas, James Mason, and Peter Lorre certainly didn’t hurt Leagues‘ box-office prospects — nor did glowingly positive reviews from the likes of the New York Times’ Bosley Crowther, who called it “as fabulous and fantastic as anything [Disney] has ever done in cartoons.”


3. That Darn Cat!

Younger filmgoers may be more familiar with the 1997 remake, starring Christina Ricci and Doug E. Doug — which, as illustrated by that film’s woeful seven percent Tomatometer rating, is a shame. The 1965 original, starring Hayley Mills as the owner of a robbery-foiling feline (and the immortal Frank Gorshin as the robber), was a perfect example of the sort of goofy, animal-assisted middlebrow flick that Disney’s live-action arm became known for in the 1960s — but if it’s silly stuff, it’s at least eminently well-crafted, thanks to the steady hand of director Robert Stevenson and charming performances from a cast that included Disney vets Mills and Dean Jones. Critics were kind, if not exactly effusive (Rob Thomas of Madison’s Capital Times waved it off as “lightweight, forgettable family fun”) — but it was the titular cat that earned some of the movie’s highest warmest praise, including high marks from the New York Times’ Bosley Crowther, who said, “The feline that plays the informant, as the F.B.I. puts it, is superb. Clark Gable at the peak of his performing never played a tom cat more winningly.”


2. Old Yeller

A movie so successful that it spawned a sequel, Tommy Kirk’s career, and the heartbreaking on-screen deaths of dozens of beloved critters, Old Yeller is mostly remembered today for its tearjerking final act and cornpone dialogue — and although this Robert Stevenson-directed adaptation of Fred Gipson’s popular novel certainly doesn’t skimp on the familiar plot points and gooey nostalgia so often identified with the Disney films of the era, it also tries to impart some useful lessons about the tough choices that come with growing up. Those lessons were imparted to a huge audience, too — watching Old Yeller was a rite of passage for multiple generations of filmgoers, among them DVDTalk’s Scott Weinberg, who called it “every bit the warm, comfortable, and tragically bittersweet classic that had you sobbing like a infant the first time you saw it.”


1. Never Cry Wolf

The best-reviewed of Disney’s late 1970s/early 1980s string of family-friendly live-action flicks, Never Cry Wolf offers a surprisingly mature, unflinching adaptation of Farley Mowat’s memoir detailing the years he spent studying the hunting habits of wolves in the Canadian wilderness. One year later, Disney would spin off Touchstone, an imprint which would eventually be responsible for some fairly racy fare, but in 1983, Wolf director Carroll Ballard’s decision to afford audiences a glimpse of Charles Martin Smith’s bare buttocks was a major step for the Mouse House. Though the film wasn’t a giant hit, it did manage an impressive 27-week theatrical run — all the more notable considering its small cast, exceedingly minimal dialogue, and deliberate pace. Critics were suitably impressed, sending Never Cry Wolf all the way to a 100 percent Tomatometer rating on the strength of reviews from scribes like Time’s Richard Schickel, who raved, “Ballard and his masterly crew of film makers have reimagined a corner of the natural world…They leave us awed.”

Check out the rest of our Total Recall archives here.

Finally, we leave you with a clip from one of Disney’s trippiest live-action offerings. It’s a close encouter of the feline kind: The Cat from Outer Space.

Tag Cloud

Endgame spy thriller boxoffice serial killer Superheroes supernatural slasher 90s Stephen King DC Comics sequels IMDb TV Best Picture Sundance italian Mary Tyler Moore ratings 72 Emmy Awards universal monsters Mary poppins OWN Podcast witnail new star wars movies Rocketman NBA screen actors guild talk show chucky canceled feel good richard e. Grant TV renewals 20th Century Fox Ellie Kemper Marvel Television harry potter Elton John sag awards comic book movies police drama sports DGA nature Netflix Christmas movies Extras Premiere Dates Tokyo Olympics 73rd Emmy Awards Lifetime Christmas movies Ghostbusters know your critic art house Sci-Fi TLC FX on Hulu streamig Sundance Now deadpool Awards medical drama saw Lionsgate psycho Paramount Pictures Reality Competition FX marvel cinematic universe cinemax best quibi films Film Festival VOD rt labs critics edition rt labs X-Men anthology olympics Animation Winners comic books The Arrangement foreign prank Captain marvel hollywood TBS Hollywood Foreign Press Association summer TV disaster discovery ESPN monster movies Red Carpet Schedule parents romance Action mutant Starz mockumentary comic book movie FXX nfl MCU space NBC GLAAD a nightmare on elm street romantic comedy Sneak Peek screenings blockbuster science fiction TIFF children's TV documentary spanish language Apple TV Plus debate golden globe awards Shondaland Avengers versus crossover anime james bond Freeform sitcom fresh psychological thriller Emmys Music adenture asian-american A24 streaming movies Warner Bros. superman Tumblr hist ABC worst biography TCA Winter 2020 Sony Pictures Masterpiece Funimation news Peacock Disney Channel period drama Geeked Week The Walt Disney Company dark target green book crime Image Comics video on demand television broadcast Best Actor 24 frames superhero DC Universe Best Director Fargo MSNBC Best and Worst YA critics Nat Geo live event dceu Rom-Com 94th Oscars Interview DirecTV New York Comic Con YouTube Premium 007 99% stop motion BBC One PlayStation Mary Poppins Returns posters name the review Adult Swim Quiz singing competition unscripted Certified Fresh Turner Classic Movies Trophy Talk biopic dreamworks Pop festival nbcuniversal war comiccon Comic-Con@Home 2021 cats Infographic Tags: Comedy Writers Guild of America spider-verse Women's History Month 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Marvel spinoff Tarantino Oscars dogs vampires Family National Geographic Alien historical drama wonder woman ABC Signature Nickelodeon SXSW 2022 DC streaming service Hulu Musicals zero dark thirty obituary book adaptation Marvel Studios BET Awards renewed TV shows Polls and Games breaking bad Christmas 2018 Heroines rt archives Amazon obi wan Set visit Focus Features werewolf award winner scary movies strong female leads jurassic park based on movie lord of the rings halloween tv HBO Go cooking gangster Acorn TV sequel Marathons Food Network christmas movies Ovation transformers book diversity Star Trek Countdown Britbox remakes TV movies docuseries BBC USA movies Grammys latino AMC Plus jamie lee curtis fast and furious action-comedy OneApp E! The Witch Lucasfilm HBO Max godzilla king kong indiana jones 71st Emmy Awards venice Kids & Family BBC America french Binge Guide heist movie Amazon Prime all-time Box Office PaleyFest CMT VICE Pet Sematary Walt Disney Pictures tv talk Netflix composers travel adventure HBO trailers toronto ABC Family ghosts Comedy Disney+ Disney Plus international cars finale YouTube Holiday summer TV preview cancelled TV shows satire dc dramedy The Academy toy story series high school genre Mystery Travel Channel Disney Plus legend criterion hispanic heritage month Black Mirror golden globes spanish NYCC movie Fox Searchlight trophy LGBTQ ViacomCBS comics CBS All Access franchise TNT WGN cults El Rey social media Apple Winter TV Calendar San Diego Comic-Con basketball Sundance TV reviews aapi Election IFC Films Fall TV zombie CW Seed 4/20 45 critic resources Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crime drama BAFTA PBS SXSW adaptation Paramount Network slashers Exclusive Video Turner Hear Us Out Syfy sopranos what to watch classics Awards Tour die hard Columbia Pictures theme song Bravo black FOX RT21 Martial Arts free movies young adult Oscar hidden camera king arthur true crime Spring TV History TruTV Star Wars Celebration Logo Comics on TV cartoon The CW scene in color series crime thriller canceled TV shows documentaries cancelled black comedy Mudbound USA Network Indigenous child's play Watching Series E3 directors Esquire WarnerMedia comedies worst movies Amazon Studios rotten movies we love 21st Century Fox 2020 mission: impossible scene in color MTV vs. 2019 mcc archives Instagram Live facebook Pop TV cops Amazon Prime Video The Walking Dead royal family australia First Reviews Drama binge Pacific Islander robots new york Paramount Plus docudrama Holidays razzies miniseries Song of Ice and Fire independent japan Comedy Central new zealand live action Neflix Baby Yoda GoT Spectrum Originals American Society of Cinematographers doctor who ITV CNN Black History Month Universal Pictures Brie Larson Universal Classic Film batman TCA Awards President Hallmark Christmas movies Trivia twilight Arrowverse Character Guide Pride Month Paramount laika Fox News scary technology Rock Year in Review kaiju HFPA marvel comics 2015 women GIFs Crunchyroll Nominations Toys Thanksgiving Musical thriller blaxploitation boxing south america elevated horror leaderboard interviews TCA 2021 streaming reboot The Purge video Rocky Dark Horse Comics Crackle MGM pirates of the caribbean TV Land Creative Arts Emmys natural history Mindy Kaling Cannes stoner Television Critics Association Emmy Nominations IFC Trailer Sony Best Actress Biopics kids Star Wars spain 2017 summer preview VH1 japanese Showtime Reality 79th Golden Globes Awards First Look Apple TV+ Anna Paquin indie Academy Awards Broadway Opinion dragons political drama Cosplay emmy awards zombies BET Photos Film LGBT festivals spider-man YouTube Red TV Hallmark Vudu rotten mob RT History cancelled television AMC Fantasy Lifetime SundanceTV Valentine's Day Cartoon Network TCA 2017 Horror revenge comic A&E aliens suspense Legendary kong halloween animated casting Western Native cancelled TV series hispanic dexter stand-up comedy telelvision Epix Super Bowl ID Discovery Channel football Summer 2016 93rd Oscars Prime Video Video Games Pirates Spike Disney South by Southwest Film Festival Teen rom-coms justice league Shudder Country TCM game show target scene in color Tubi Superheroe CBS joker Wes Anderson popular Chernobyl concert Pixar game of thrones 1990s APB Television Academy teaser scene in color film series TV One politics Comic Book scorecard Disney streaming service blockbusters See It Skip It Chilling Adventures of Sabrina SDCC Tomatazos