Total Recall

Total Recall: Beowulf and Ye Olde Tradition of Animation

Humans and animation mix and match in this week's Total Recall.

by | November 14, 2007 | Comments

These are heady times for live-action/animation hybrids.
This week, Robert Zemeckis updates the Old English poem
with some
help from Ray Winstone,
Angelina Jolie, and a whole mess of technology. Next
week, Enchanted, starring
Amy Adams and
, also adds a heavy
dose of animation to its fantasy world. With these flicks in mind, it’s a good time to
take a look at some other flicks that combine live-action and animation in
unconventional ways.

The blending of live-action and animation is nothing new, as
evinced by silent cartoons like Gertie the Dinosaur and
Max Fleischer‘s rotoscoped shorts featuring Koko the Clown. Now technology has advanced to the
point where some films, like the
Lord of the Rings
movies, blend
technology and live-action so seamlessly it’s sometimes hard to tell the
difference. What was once a novelty is now relatively commonplace. But before then, rotoscoped animation hit its turning point in the 1970s when director Ralph Bakshi established it as an artistic technique (and not just a trifle or cost-cutting measure) through a series of racially charged, frequently explicit animated movies.

By the mid-1970s,
Bakshi was
the American king of urbanely ribald animation with features like
Fritz the Cat

(53 percent), Heavy
(91 percent), and
. With 1977’s
Wizards (53
percent), he attempted something a little different. Conceptually, Wizards is a movie Walt Disney could get behind:
soulful, beautiful animation (as Bakshi described it) with bright colors,
fairies, and even a princess or two. In execution, he delivered post-apocalyptic
psychedelia, a bizarre fable about two brothers set millions of years in the
future. One brother is healthy and is nice to his mother, the other a mutant who
reconstructs 21st century weapon technology and breeds an army with
Nazi propaganda. A.H. Weiler of the New York Times calls it "a melange of
animation and live footage that [features] mystical, slightly scary and,
occasionally, comic tones." Contrasted with its Disney-esque color palette and
voice acting, this movie is like
the UNICEF Smurfs ad gone feature-length.

Bakshi used rotoscoping for a majority of the large-scale
battle sequences, a technique that requires an animator to paint and color live
footage. (Beowulf is a sophisticated variation on rotoscopes.) Elegant creatures
such as Snow White or Gollum can spring out of rotoscoping, but Bakshi had a
unique approach in films like Wizards and 1978’s
The Lord of the Rings

(50 percent): applying
just the right amount of detail and fluid motion, he turned objects into
grotesque apparitions. Perfect when you feel like animating the monstrosity of

The Wizards trailer.
(67 percent) was a commercial disappointment for Disney in 1982 and
it’s been a notoriously long and arduous journey to get a sequel greenlit. But
it’s hard not to think that there wouldn’t be all those troubles if the movie were just a teeny bit better. The premise is intriguing (Jeff Bridges gets zapped into a
computer, where programs have to gladiate against each other in neon suits) if
half-formed, while the pacing is beyond plodding. But it was the
special effects Disney was really banking on. Considering TRON can be
seen as the
progenitor of computer graphics-driven studio flicks, some of its effects hold
up remarkably well. "The movie’s innovative digital special effects were jaw-dropping
at the time and still seem pretty cool," writes Jeffrey Anderson of
Combustible Celluloid
. Indeed, there’s an elemental thrill in
seeing a digital airship gliding over a mountain range or light cycles speeding
around on grids.

TRON demonstrated that computer-generated scenes could
propel a narrative, a lesson that countless blockbusters have taken to heart.
Two years after TRON, Pixar released their first short (The Adventures of
Andre and Wally B.
) and people slowly began realizing that, goodness, these cumbersome computers can also make things funny, expanding even more upon the
future potential of the machine.

The light cycle scene from TRON.

‘s Waking Life (2001, 79 percent)
utilized rotoscoping for more philosophically-minded purposes. The movie tells
the story of a young man wandering around Austin, listening to a variety of
points of view about the nature of existence — all the while wondering if he’s
in the midst of an extended dream, or alive at all. Human actors were shot on
digital video, and different artists then overlaid the footage with a variety
of styles via computer (Linklater used a similar technique on
A Scanner
[67 percent]). The result has a textural beauty unlike virtually
anything else — sometimes impressionistic, sometimes cartoonish, Waking
‘s visuals add a sense of hyper-reality to its musings on the nature of

Despite its fascinating technique, Waking Life has
its detractors; some find the nearly non-stop philosophizing unbearable. But
within the expanse of talk, there is an overall air of optimism and wonder that
makes Waking Life hypnotic for those willing to plunge into it. And the
final monologue, in which Linklater himself tells our sleepy protagonist a story
about Philip K. Dick, is a knockout.
The Chicago Tribune‘s Michael Wilmington
called it "truly special, truly different — a wondrous talky roundelay about
and for people who love life."

A clip from Waking Life.

By no means are these films’ methods the only approaches pioneering animators have taken. If hyper-real meditations on war, reality, and existence prove too harsh, you can always opt for lighter fare: Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (100 percent), Pete’s Dragon (60 percent) and Who Framed Roger Rabbit? (100 percent) all represent disparate attempts to meld live-action and animation.

Tag Cloud

Epix australia E3 2021 Cosplay dark CBS All Access worst Animation Netflix royal family Hollywood Foreign Press Association prank stop motion worst movies Set visit movie suspense olympics based on movie HBO Max Comics on TV Academy Awards The Purge screen actors guild Paramount Plus Opinion USA Network Sneak Peek diversity 72 Emmy Awards ABC Signature San Diego Comic-Con docuseries First Reviews Bravo comic book movie 2017 NBA Television Critics Association critic resources Tags: Comedy 2019 Fantasy crossover pirates of the caribbean aliens dc ABC canceled YouTube docudrama E! Avengers miniseries Ghostbusters japanese Comedy Central marvel comics cats strong female leads Crackle comics debate spider-verse 73rd Emmy Awards christmas movies HFPA comic books movies Hallmark BET Election cancelled canceled TV shows black comedy political drama Spring TV Turner Classic Movies discovery mutant biography green book Rocky transformers Syfy Star Wars Baby Yoda superman stoner Video Games golden globes MTV Interview festival dexter Sundance genre The Arrangement Warner Bros. anime WarnerMedia Mary Poppins Returns Thanksgiving Stephen King ABC Family justice league Lifetime X-Men japan MSNBC Trailer ID james bond ITV WGN Pride Month Holiday popular indiana jones Drama Awards Tour comedies Quiz Biopics binge screenings medical drama saw archives Year in Review NBC Sony Pictures documentary festivals anthology Family Mary poppins obituary nbcuniversal stand-up comedy BBC America basketball social media rom-coms composers women Exclusive Video PaleyFest CNN Cannes Lionsgate Lifetime Christmas movies harry potter Spectrum Originals werewolf book superhero TCA Winter 2020 Martial Arts children's TV mob video on demand Teen PlayStation cars CMT Fox News telelvision TruTV Turner richard e. Grant GoT comic Apple Tumblr Photos live action cooking zero dark thirty psychological thriller BBC Superheroe Disney streaming service American Society of Cinematographers hispanic heritage month robots YA streaming Sundance TV Watching Series 1990s Best and Worst psycho Superheroes revenge period drama VH1 Comic Book blockbusters Kids & Family Extras Grammys Paramount target universal monsters rt labs A&E FX on Hulu versus 4/20 DC Comics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards dogs Hear Us Out Marvel hollywood Star Trek boxing zombie HBO zombies Mary Tyler Moore Rock Pop TV action-comedy toy story Netflix Christmas movies HBO Go Premiere Dates ESPN spy thriller Black History Month Pirates Amazon Prime Video Columbia Pictures Ovation Valentine's Day latino Instagram Live Television Academy die hard Fall TV TV One RT21 hist SXSW DC streaming service fast and furious slashers Oscars dreamworks supernatural joker thriller asian-american DGA Pacific Islander travel toronto rt labs critics edition Hulu Esquire news streaming movies monster movies TV renewals AMC Plus Mudbound Song of Ice and Fire TIFF Showtime 20th Century Fox Ellie Kemper Universal blaxploitation italian Calendar new york french Disney Plus VOD Super Bowl tv talk Tokyo Olympics hispanic 24 frames gangster Travel Channel sequel Writers Guild of America Dark Horse Comics new star wars movies Prime Video police drama football Neflix Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Film Infographic Marvel Studios 2018 Disney vs. reviews Acorn TV Amazon Reality Competition indie singing competition Food Network crime TV movies game show History romantic comedy crime thriller films Peacock A24 Apple TV+ adventure Sci-Fi dramedy nature Legendary kong cults Horror romance Marathons rt archives FX comic book movies black Marvel Television slasher Emmys Tarantino 71st Emmy Awards Pixar international Universal Pictures laika Nickelodeon First Look sports VICE Elton John Toys golden globe awards feel good true crime spanish kids cancelled TV series remakes ViacomCBS teaser elevated horror satire Tomatazos Spike spain scorecard TNT 93rd Oscars video Paramount Network 007 BET Awards TBS television lord of the rings SDCC renewed TV shows posters king arthur adaptation disaster Logo ratings Alien cartoon TV concert Britbox spanish language The Academy Character Guide TCA game of thrones Freeform halloween tv Box Office scary movies criterion 45 Vudu venice trailers 79th Golden Globes Awards FXX GIFs Classic Film YouTube Premium rotten movies we love name the review CBS serial killer PBS 90s Shondaland Podcast what to watch dragons breaking bad RT History MCU Western Brie Larson know your critic TV Land Lucasfilm GLAAD Starz OWN The Walking Dead LGBT jurassic park aapi IFC Films Holidays halloween Hallmark Christmas movies dceu El Rey 2016 boxoffice art house President APB foreign cinemax casting sitcom emmy awards child's play Broadway 2020 kaiju blockbuster chucky National Geographic scary Musicals BAFTA YouTube Red Walt Disney Pictures NYCC independent TCM mcc Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Comedy crime drama Nat Geo Christmas Captain marvel sequels mission: impossible series TLC Countdown Disney+ Disney Plus 2015 LGBTQ historical drama rotten Funimation 21st Century Fox science fiction award winner Tubi animated directors ghosts Shudder Black Mirror Rom-Com SundanceTV Adult Swim Nominations talk show IMDb TV wonder woman adenture Emmy Nominations Endgame FOX Fargo politics deadpool marvel cinematic universe vampires Red Carpet Summer free movies witnail Pop Trivia Rocketman Disney Channel Binge Guide theme song finale cancelled TV shows sag awards Wes Anderson Discovery Channel fresh cancelled television doctor who best book adaptation OneApp south america natural history Awards New York Comic Con mockumentary USA Winter TV TCA Awards Chernobyl The CW spider-man cops jamie lee curtis comiccon critics facebook Anna Paquin Pet Sematary new zealand technology Country scene in color young adult Amazon Prime AMC razzies sopranos trophy Sundance Now spinoff Heroines hidden camera Musical Film Festival nfl Amazon Studios Trophy Talk Certified Fresh DirecTV documentaries leaderboard godzilla Mystery a nightmare on elm street Action Cartoon Network twilight Arrowverse unscripted high school Music parents biopic 99% Reality heist movie Apple TV Plus reboot quibi Women's History Month franchise See It Skip It Schedule war The Witch Mindy Kaling DC Universe CW Seed king kong classics Image Comics The Walt Disney Company legend Winners live event Fox Searchlight space BBC One batman Comic-Con@Home 2021 Masterpiece Polls and Games all-time IFC TCA 2017 Creative Arts Emmys Crunchyroll