Total Recall

Total Recall: And the Oscar Goes To...

We try predicting the Best Picture winner based on Tomatometer and box office.

by | February 20, 2008 | Comments

Instead of focusing on one hot movie for Total Recall, this
week you’ll get five. They’re a little old now, but I think you’ll forgive me —
after all, they’re
, Juno,
Michael Clayton,
No Country
for Old Men
, and
There Will Be

I’ve never been good at predicting the Oscars. Last year, for
example, I thought
Pan’s Labyrinth
was going to win Best Foreign. Silly me! So this year,
I’m ditching gut feelings and going the experimental route: the Tomatometer. The
average Best Picture nominee’s Tomatometer hovers in the upper-80 percentile, so
critical reception and Best Picture nomination go hand in hand. My
mini-experiment: can an ad hoc formula using Tomatometer and box office
numbers be used to predict the winner?

To begin with, here are this year’s Best Picture nominees:

Movie title


Box office so far
(in mil.)

No Country for Old Men






There Will Be Blood



Michael Clayton






I’m going to predict an upset and say either Juno or
Michael Clayton will take Best Picture. I’m probably wrong. And I hope
I’m wrong — I want There Will Be Blood to win. No Country has
also deserved all of its momentum. But going on purely Tomatometer and box
office statistics, the numbers are against both NCFOM and TWBB.
But more on that later.

First, let’s talk Atonement. What happened here? It
has strong performances, a rousing score, gorgeous panoramas, and a love story
that transcends both time and large bodies of water. In other words, the perfect
Oscar movie. And director
Joe Wright
skillfully avoided preening for the award throughout his movie. But, suddenly,
it’s Atonement, not Juno, that should be happy to have gotten this far.

This week’s issue of Entertainment Weekly pegs Atonement
with a 10 percent chance of victory, writing, "Aren’t the days of the typical ‘Oscar
movie’ over?" Indeed, the smear-and-sneer campaigns the last historical, epic
Best Pictures (The
English Patient
[85 percent] and
[82 percent])
have endured after their wins reveal audiences have had their fill. Plus, Wright
wasn’t even nominated for Best Director. There’s only been three instances that
a movie has won Best Picture under those circumstances (Wings
[100 percent], Grand
[84 percent], and
Driving Miss Daisy

[78 percent]), and two of those came at a time when
Private Snafu

seemed like cutting-edge animation.

I can’t decide if either Michael Clayton and Juno will win.
They both exist in the now, even as they embody specific eras: Clayton recalls
meaty American dramas like
(90 percent)
and On the
(100 percent), and Juno, with its precious music and
Gen Y jive, is a movie with its head in the clouds, leaning ever-so-slightly
into the future. If I had a gun to my nose, I’ll say Juno will pull the
upset. It’s been a while since a movie mainly identified as a comedy has won Best
Picture. And Juno has much in common with
Annie Hall
percent): they’re both culture-driven products of their time, but their
ruminations on love and relationships have universality.

So what does the Tomatometer have against a movie like
No Country for Old Men
, with its

virtual lock
on the Best Picture race? Get this: my cursory peek into
criticism history shows that in the past 36 years, only twice has the nominee
with the highest Tomatometer won Best Picture: Annie Hall in 1977, and

(96 percent) in 1992.

Why is that? Ideally, a year’s Best Picture is a
meeting point between art and commerce: a movie of deep thoughts with the sweet charm
to pass them on to whomever’s around. Critics, thirsty for something to wow them
after watching several hundred movies a year, are likely more wont to praise
movies of extreme novelty and subtlety before audiences (and the Oscars) can
fully latch onto them.

No Country for Old Men is the only Best Picture
nominee that has virtually no backlash against it. The movie is challenging and
deliberately obscure, but the Coens’ mastery of their medium has kept audiences
electrified. I still feel jolts and chills thinking about it. But
Tomatometer-wise, NCFOM has a 5.5 percent chance of winning. So if we are
heading for an upset, I would normally picture There Will Be Blood
sneaking up to take home the statue.

And that would be a remarkable feat for reasons beyond the fact that
There Will Be Blood is a sprawling, shapeless movie about an ugly misanthrope. TWBB
has grossed the least of all the nominees. And from what I can guess, the
lowest-grossing nominee has never,
ever won
. The reason’s fairly obvious: even though There Will Be Blood
has been drawing strong per-theater averages, the less a country feels compelled
to watch a movie, the less likely they are to vote for it.

The Oscars have suffered a number of embarrassments this
year. Snubs for Zodiac
(89 percent) and
The Simpsons Movie
(89 percent). The sheer presence of
(9 percent).
And on the rejection of
percent), The Band’s
(98 percent), and
4 Months,
3 Weeks, and 2 Days
(97 percent), foreign Oscar chairman Mark Johnson

this to say
: "It’s just inconceivable to me that they weren’t included." But
public humiliations aside, this year’s Best Pictures selections are among the
most thoughtful, well-rounded crew to represent cinema in decades.

In last month’s "The
Downsizing of Oscar
," Richard Corliss wondered, "Why not just change the
name, from the Oscars to the Independent Spirit Awards?" But I don’t think it’s
a matter of the academy out of touch with what the public watches. In fact, it’s
the opposite: not only do these movies represent the still-smoldering hope of
indie fare connecting with audiences, it demonstrates the Academy is finally
catching up with the rest of us.

After giving Best Picture to the lazy, self-congratulatory
pap of Crash
(75 percent), the Academy atoned by giving
his Oscar last year. And now they’re recognizing five movies each
relevant in its unique way.  I haven’t seen as much online discourse sparked
as the complexities of deceit in Atonement and Michael Clayton
have, or of the annoying/endearing personality of Juno, the mystique of Anton
Chigurh, and the general WTFness of Daniel Plainview. Their stories may
not always make a mint at the box office, but they are exactly the thing to rile
up the modern community — the bloggers, the users, the podcasters, the budding
scholars and filmmakers. Choose the movies that get us talking. We will be the
ones who make them last.

Tag Cloud

DGA Holidays aapi Bravo Image Comics name the review TBS posters Shudder Hulu 73rd Emmy Awards critic resources Fantasy The Walking Dead canceled TV shows Crackle marvel comics canceled President Rocky cooking new york Turner biography First Look Hallmark Amazon Studios ratings SDCC 79th Golden Globes Awards debate 71st Emmy Awards Heroines golden globes strong female leads Sneak Peek miniseries Marvel Television Fall TV Rock parents new star wars movies Columbia Pictures San Diego Comic-Con Crunchyroll GLAAD comic book movie independent golden globe awards kaiju mutant Nat Geo jamie lee curtis Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt RT21 festival 007 Ghostbusters BBC One DC Comics green book 2021 black comedy Winners 99% Pride Month Superheroe Britbox Song of Ice and Fire FXX blockbuster zombies hollywood historical drama Television Academy dark italian Discovery Channel best Drama Toys Pop Neflix 45 composers adventure cats Shondaland Universal indiana jones Masterpiece Wes Anderson See It Skip It RT History Opinion kong OneApp sports fresh slashers theme song Quiz cars Spring TV Teen book Academy Awards Western mission: impossible serial killer CW Seed jurassic park Rocketman Tokyo Olympics Christmas feel good Travel Channel WarnerMedia PaleyFest nbcuniversal binge superhero docudrama BET Awards 2016 basketball Adult Swim dramedy Summer Disney+ Disney Plus The Walt Disney Company The CW USA Network adaptation WGN richard e. Grant facebook 21st Century Fox legend superman telelvision Netflix monster movies Universal Pictures blaxploitation versus BAFTA Showtime Mary poppins Nickelodeon razzies Film breaking bad Trivia Captain marvel Chernobyl Comedy Central History TNT laika streaming comedies Valentine's Day doctor who Red Carpet YouTube Red olympics Horror TV Land Podcast Avengers criterion comics Broadway die hard war El Rey directors boxoffice godzilla werewolf Marvel Studios Rom-Com movie Comic Book Martial Arts Apple TV+ high school Sci-Fi ABC Family 20th Century Fox GIFs Black Mirror Kids & Family true crime Black History Month screen actors guild chucky crime Mary Poppins Returns SXSW christmas movies nature indie Animation foreign Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 2018 ABC Signature sequel Action comic book movies GoT MTV asian-american japan LGBT Grammys crime drama harry potter scary movies vampires Nominations zombie tv talk Comic-Con@Home 2021 hispanic heritage month IFC Films Spectrum Originals Syfy Best and Worst YouTube Premium Sundance Now Polls and Games BBC a nightmare on elm street period drama OWN toronto Disney First Reviews crossover Apple Pacific Islander TCM festivals psychological thriller travel Dark Horse Comics Hallmark Christmas movies Disney streaming service diversity australia Box Office boxing Certified Fresh movies romance documentary 2020 romantic comedy batman E3 animated Hear Us Out game of thrones 90s saw wonder woman screenings rt labs critics edition VOD dexter free movies Acorn TV elevated horror TCA Awards MSNBC Turner Classic Movies Emmy Nominations new zealand Hollywood Foreign Press Association Alien spain Awards Biopics target witnail heist movie nfl Star Wars cancelled adenture Instagram Live Character Guide sag awards disaster CNN scene in color MCU james bond NBA 2015 Ovation Film Festival halloween Photos Election king arthur hist Schedule comic mcc psycho Pirates classics Food Network IFC Logo Thanksgiving Ellie Kemper women Peacock TLC ghosts Creative Arts Emmys dc satire Country Video Games films Tags: Comedy justice league Mudbound Elton John Trophy Talk TV One aliens Disney Plus Endgame worst movies quibi Pixar teaser marvel cinematic universe fast and furious Anna Paquin TV Cannes Brie Larson police drama Fox News Television Critics Association scary twilight discovery NBC japanese Star Trek Emmys Marvel Infographic blockbusters Tumblr unscripted hidden camera Holiday transformers FOX franchise CBS APB biopic Amazon Prime Video LGBTQ lord of the rings archives SundanceTV HBO zero dark thirty Baby Yoda Tarantino American Society of Cinematographers The Academy TV movies dceu rotten political drama ID action-comedy comiccon Funimation halloween tv revenge IMDb TV Binge Guide universal monsters medical drama science fiction natural history Warner Bros. USA New York Comic Con Awards Tour TCA popular worst The Arrangement cops dragons HBO Max rt archives DC Universe Tubi comic books live action cancelled television all-time spanish Comedy Fox Searchlight series 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Amazon documentaries Super Bowl 2019 Exclusive Video PlayStation TruTV BET Music space trophy cartoon Marathons based on movie finale Countdown Legendary Extras Arrowverse 24 frames politics Musical know your critic spider-verse what to watch TCA Winter 2020 thriller trailers Freeform Stephen King Walt Disney Pictures Amazon Prime AMC Plus Sony Pictures latino leaderboard child's play game show hispanic Musicals Lifetime Christmas movies spinoff Paramount Network anthology Classic Film Fargo talk show Sundance TV video on demand reviews The Witch spider-man Sundance DC streaming service TIFF Premiere Dates spy thriller singing competition mob TCA 2017 Epix football black Paramount Netflix Christmas movies CBS All Access The Purge CMT suspense Disney Channel social media television cancelled TV series Oscars PBS Esquire YouTube FX Reality Competition dogs Lifetime joker Lionsgate 93rd Oscars Watching Series DirecTV Mary Tyler Moore National Geographic ViacomCBS art house 1990s Calendar dreamworks reboot BBC America renewed TV shows Mystery Pop TV Paramount Plus NYCC deadpool stoner VH1 young adult A24 AMC anime video live event rotten movies we love emmy awards Cosplay Comics on TV remakes Starz 2017 crime thriller sopranos stand-up comedy ABC venice Reality docuseries E! genre pirates of the caribbean gangster HFPA obituary 72 Emmy Awards award winner Prime Video cults 4/20 scorecard FX on Hulu Women's History Month rom-coms stop motion rt labs casting Writers Guild of America Tomatazos streaming movies cinemax cancelled TV shows king kong Mindy Kaling Year in Review international Family Pet Sematary technology Spike X-Men news critics concert mockumentary TV renewals Lucasfilm Superheroes Set visit ESPN kids slasher A&E toy story prank french Vudu VICE vs. robots Trailer supernatural HBO Go sequels Cartoon Network spanish language ITV Winter TV south america sitcom children's TV Interview book adaptation royal family YA Apple TV Plus