Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Watch Watchmen, But Caveat Emptor

The big-screen adaptation of Alan Moore's work is visually stunning but very, very long.

by | March 5, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Watchmen, the long-awaited adaptation of Alan Moore’s classic graphic novel directed by Zack Snyder and starring Billy Crudup and Carla Gugino. What do the critics have to say?



After years of speculation, negotiations, lawsuits, and geek anticipation, Alan Moore’s classic graphic novel Watchmen is finally hitting the big screen. So, is it worth watching? The answer, say critics, is a qualified yes. The film is set in a dystopian 1985, in which Richard Nixon is still president and the future looks bleak. A group of retired superheroes is forced back into action when one of their colleagues is murdered and suspicions of an anti-hero conspiracy arise. A number of critics find Watchmen to be excessively reverent to Moore’s book, as well as overlong and dark bordering on dour. However, others say this ambitious, sprawling superhero epic is emotionally weighty and visually stunning. (Check out Watchmen Headquarters for all of RT’s Watchmen-related news and features.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Fados, a documentary about the haunting Portuguese musical genre, is at 100 percent.
  • The Oscar-nominated 12, a Russian spin on 12 Angry Men, is at 88 percent.
  • Explicit Ills , starring Rosario Dawson and Paul Dano and featuring four interconnected stories involving low-income Philly residents, is at 82 percent.
  • Tokyo!, an omnibus film that focuses on Japan’s largest city and features a segment from Michel Gondry, is at 71 percent.
  • Phoebe in Wonderland, starring Elle Fanning and Bill Pullman in a drama about a family coping with a child with Tourette’s Syndrome, is at 46 percent.
  • Sherman’s Way, a quirky indie road comedy in which an Ivy Leaguer and a washed-up ex-jock hit the highway, is at 22 percent.

Tag Cloud

suspense MSNBC diversity independent DC streaming service Shondaland discovery asian-american name the review theme song RT History IMDb TV Marvel adaptation Instagram Live canceled new star wars movies hispanic heritage month The Walking Dead blockbusters hidden camera DC Universe king arthur Hear Us Out versus sequels 73rd Emmy Awards Television Academy Universal Mudbound Mystery war Mary Tyler Moore scene in color Pop TV YouTube Premium GLAAD Freeform Lifetime cults Star Trek HFPA Marvel Television Logo stand-up comedy Endgame young adult Esquire OWN quibi Rom-Com cats Emmys Action Pet Sematary 2021 71st Emmy Awards political drama Amazon Studios VH1 Mary poppins Rocketman TV Land CW Seed Classic Film Lifetime Christmas movies Walt Disney Pictures Crunchyroll BBC America natural history Awards television Video Games ghosts mockumentary GoT revenge 4/20 video Paramount Network godzilla christmas movies TLC Kids & Family comic books TV live event MCU kaiju YouTube Red Apple TV+ breaking bad BBC Superheroe Exclusive Video LGBT Wes Anderson Discovery Channel SXSW game show singing competition heist movie 20th Century Fox boxing spider-man SDCC DGA Holidays blaxploitation mutant marvel cinematic universe The Witch TV movies APB streaming movies Black Mirror Martial Arts Nominations james bond Awards Tour Comics on TV Marathons Paramount space justice league HBO biopic Christmas Election period drama Turner ViacomCBS dark pirates of the caribbean Podcast Country medical drama crime films Infographic SundanceTV saw olympics Elton John finale Paramount Plus historical drama basketball Ovation best italian nature politics mob cancelled TV shows child's play toy story gangster comic book movies mission: impossible romantic comedy BET Awards lord of the rings elevated horror Warner Bros. Disney Certified Fresh The CW witnail joker 2016 BET San Diego Comic-Con cops toronto mcc teaser supernatural jamie lee curtis Tumblr trophy Sundance Now NYCC 1990s Universal Pictures ID disaster Opinion Animation Red Carpet Family superman Trophy Talk police drama crossover green book New York Comic Con rt archives TIFF movie cooking robots MTV 2017 sitcom BAFTA Bravo laika Disney+ Disney Plus 90s ABC Reality Competition nbcuniversal Hallmark Christmas movies miniseries psychological thriller telelvision Tags: Comedy Interview technology RT21 Mindy Kaling wonder woman Apple TV Plus TBS golden globes Black History Month debate golden globe awards 2020 YA adventure streaming Spike social media foreign what to watch TruTV docuseries unscripted TV renewals Horror Acorn TV 24 frames Sony Pictures Netflix book Baby Yoda Captain marvel Neflix 99% Pride Month dramedy Disney Plus deadpool cancelled TV series GIFs posters trailers Schedule Set visit art house TV One slasher dc CNN docudrama Prime Video Pacific Islander Calendar Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt WGN Extras Britbox critics science fiction National Geographic Amazon japanese richard e. Grant Image Comics Spring TV screenings Broadway emmy awards indie WarnerMedia zombie See It Skip It CBS All Access Chilling Adventures of Sabrina thriller TCA 2017 Comic-Con@Home 2021 NBA video on demand rt labs latino know your critic Masterpiece series Winter TV genre archives Dark Horse Comics TCA Awards Epix Peacock japan renewed TV shows Film Amazon Prime Video Best and Worst Heroines Holiday royal family prank HBO Go Tubi Arrowverse Funimation indiana jones award winner VICE worst VOD CMT Starz children's TV spy thriller comics crime thriller Showtime President spanish language Fall TV zombies vs. Tomatazos Countdown composers black true crime hispanic Star Wars USA American Society of Cinematographers razzies feel good jurassic park rt labs critics edition DC Comics TCM new york Fox Searchlight scary First Reviews PlayStation Nickelodeon sag awards anime FX new zealand superhero french documentary Columbia Pictures spanish biography A&E travel Syfy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards game of thrones Valentine's Day E! Box Office Turner Classic Movies 79th Golden Globes Awards chucky 2019 Mary Poppins Returns Super Bowl Brie Larson women TCA Winter 2020 free movies Comedy Central fresh Fox News El Rey Anna Paquin The Purge hollywood cancelled vampires Polls and Games Legendary spain cartoon Adult Swim Reality strong female leads AMC doctor who canceled TV shows Song of Ice and Fire binge Sundance festivals First Look universal monsters AMC Plus Fargo parents Drama Pixar cancelled television fast and furious OneApp PaleyFest The Walt Disney Company Trailer blockbuster Cosplay Comic Book 45 movies international animated action-comedy 2015 Binge Guide popular Academy Awards 21st Century Fox Pirates Cartoon Network facebook HBO Max DirecTV romance Amazon Prime Sneak Peek dragons zero dark thirty YouTube dreamworks ESPN critic resources monster movies IFC Films Crackle sports adenture ratings psycho documentaries A24 Oscars live action Stephen King cinemax serial killer Apple tv talk target Hulu die hard IFC anthology australia Travel Channel spider-verse werewolf directors scary movies Ellie Kemper Rock Netflix Christmas movies Winners dceu franchise stop motion based on movie Hollywood Foreign Press Association Toys Lucasfilm satire nfl a nightmare on elm street TCA Quiz slashers halloween tv Premiere Dates History Television Critics Association concert Nat Geo sopranos rom-coms Pop reboot E3 PBS kong Writers Guild of America dogs Comedy king kong FX on Hulu BBC One comiccon Shudder leaderboard Superheroes Cannes Creative Arts Emmys Lionsgate TNT USA Network The Arrangement Chernobyl high school spinoff crime drama Ghostbusters dexter rotten movies we love talk show Musical X-Men Music batman all-time legend Character Guide sequel 93rd Oscars obituary ABC Signature halloween Musicals book adaptation Marvel Studios Emmy Nominations harry potter CBS 007 Year in Review Tokyo Olympics cars Sci-Fi news Disney streaming service boxoffice Thanksgiving Sundance TV Alien comedies FXX Spectrum Originals The Academy criterion comic Western Vudu aapi reviews Hallmark Disney Channel Teen stoner remakes Fantasy classics football black comedy Trivia FOX transformers twilight Biopics worst movies Watching Series LGBTQ hist comic book movie scorecard rotten Rocky kids ABC Family Food Network Grammys Women's History Month 2018 aliens screen actors guild Photos festival NBC 72 Emmy Awards ITV marvel comics casting Film Festival venice Summer Avengers south america Tarantino