Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Watch Watchmen, But Caveat Emptor

The big-screen adaptation of Alan Moore's work is visually stunning but very, very long.

by | March 5, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Watchmen, the long-awaited adaptation of Alan Moore’s classic graphic novel directed by Zack Snyder and starring Billy Crudup and Carla Gugino. What do the critics have to say?



After years of speculation, negotiations, lawsuits, and geek anticipation, Alan Moore’s classic graphic novel Watchmen is finally hitting the big screen. So, is it worth watching? The answer, say critics, is a qualified yes. The film is set in a dystopian 1985, in which Richard Nixon is still president and the future looks bleak. A group of retired superheroes is forced back into action when one of their colleagues is murdered and suspicions of an anti-hero conspiracy arise. A number of critics find Watchmen to be excessively reverent to Moore’s book, as well as overlong and dark bordering on dour. However, others say this ambitious, sprawling superhero epic is emotionally weighty and visually stunning. (Check out Watchmen Headquarters for all of RT’s Watchmen-related news and features.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Fados, a documentary about the haunting Portuguese musical genre, is at 100 percent.
  • The Oscar-nominated 12, a Russian spin on 12 Angry Men, is at 88 percent.
  • Explicit Ills , starring Rosario Dawson and Paul Dano and featuring four interconnected stories involving low-income Philly residents, is at 82 percent.
  • Tokyo!, an omnibus film that focuses on Japan’s largest city and features a segment from Michel Gondry, is at 71 percent.
  • Phoebe in Wonderland, starring Elle Fanning and Bill Pullman in a drama about a family coping with a child with Tourette’s Syndrome, is at 46 percent.
  • Sherman’s Way, a quirky indie road comedy in which an Ivy Leaguer and a washed-up ex-jock hit the highway, is at 22 percent.

Tag Cloud

breaking bad Endgame Brie Larson 93rd Oscars Baby Yoda Acorn TV Drama FX on Hulu IMDb TV debate natural history godzilla TV movies Tubi werewolf BBC America medical drama Sundance TV king arthur GIFs CW Seed YouTube Premium Amazon Studios Music mockumentary Grammys Indigenous 94th Oscars elevated horror razzies summer TV preview Christmas The Arrangement binge Trailer foreign dceu canceled TV shows halloween tv Shudder Teen Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hear Us Out Video Games Legendary Country kids sports renewed TV shows films cinemax prank ViacomCBS LGBTQ WGN south america Mudbound book adaptation Classic Film deadpool aliens criterion streaming movies RT21 crime drama Premiere Dates biopic casting movies Awards indiana jones game show Best and Worst cats festivals Tarantino 73rd Emmy Awards Pride Month doctor who Starz Logo richard e. Grant CMT documentary romantic comedy Pop TV video on demand Disney streaming service NBA The Walt Disney Company CBS All Access cartoon Comic Book South by Southwest Film Festival A24 Superheroe Marvel First Look social media scorecard Hallmark mcc war Winners Discovery Channel TruTV Vudu sequels Marathons concert rt labs critics edition Alien Horror heist movie Exclusive Video twilight Certified Fresh leaderboard new zealand series summer TV BBC Rock biography cops LGBT hispanic ESPN screen actors guild Rocky french trailers SXSW 2022 cancelled TV shows feel good comedies 2020 Universal basketball nbcuniversal what to watch TCM japanese GoT Winter TV Podcast YouTube Red children's TV broadcast GLAAD DirecTV Pet Sematary ABC remakes Marvel Studios 1990s American Society of Cinematographers nature latino scene in color series comic HFPA gangster cancelled TV series Anna Paquin The Academy suspense Best Actress teaser toronto hidden camera Film sag awards legend Sci-Fi PBS directors FXX emmy awards Comics on TV Disney Plus Captain marvel sopranos Showtime E3 mutant saw El Rey SDCC ghosts Tokyo Olympics Britbox politics Film Festival Mary poppins toy story MGM dreamworks joker Mary Tyler Moore Super Bowl spanish language 99% Family italian Election VOD Amazon Prime worst Best Picture psycho archives zombies boxing aapi scary movies dark San Diego Comic-Con dramedy science fiction Hollywood Foreign Press Association cooking Apple parents canceled vs. Ovation Awards Tour international crime critics satire a nightmare on elm street Nominations YA police drama Freeform Elton John 2016 critic resources fresh wonder woman obi wan king kong 90s revenge Broadway Epix Fantasy DC Universe political drama Rom-Com trophy marvel cinematic universe ABC Signature young adult dexter Sundance Adult Swim NBC lord of the rings universal monsters black comedy rt labs superman ITV genre Quiz Creative Arts Emmys singing competition Crackle live event Opinion game of thrones Black Mirror Valentine's Day Bravo BET stoner Fargo Lionsgate women anthology versus comic book movies live action Interview child's play name the review Fox Searchlight DGA kaiju Emmys ratings free movies Calendar Food Network Reality Competition Western PaleyFest Arrowverse hist Disney comics USA Network Syfy harry potter Dark Horse Comics DC streaming service Television Academy Sneak Peek Paramount Pictures 79th Golden Globes Awards crime thriller know your critic period drama Infographic Universal Pictures video Disney Channel cars Paramount Plus Binge Guide olympics Musical worst movies spider-verse TIFF TCA Awards The CW Schedule Fox News romance vampires zero dark thirty boxoffice Martial Arts WarnerMedia interviews summer preview Holidays TBS Disney+ Disney Plus black Watching Series Holiday Fall TV 2018 crossover popular Native Shondaland Summer SundanceTV X-Men spy thriller Sundance Now pirates of the caribbean monster movies Cartoon Network stand-up comedy independent MCU blockbuster discovery Character Guide TCA Winter 2020 chucky Hallmark Christmas movies 2019 zombie Cosplay TCA 2017 Turner TCA anime IFC witnail Pixar award winner BET Awards comic books scary Comedy Best Actor cancelled blockbusters AMC Plus A&E supernatural Turner Classic Movies HBO Go Mindy Kaling Star Wars golden globe awards National Geographic Trophy Talk thriller Pirates new star wars movies quibi Masterpiece sequel AMC Set visit First Reviews Comic-Con@Home 2021 Television Critics Association VH1 History Writers Guild of America Academy Awards The Purge FX scene in color technology Nickelodeon jamie lee curtis rotten Comedy Central space 2015 MSNBC Oscars mission: impossible streamig Image Comics comic book movie cults Song of Ice and Fire spain Chilling Adventures of Sabrina indie strong female leads Biopics franchise asian-american reboot HBO Max ID Neflix Spike golden globes news superhero nfl travel Box Office OWN 2021 SXSW transformers hispanic heritage month spider-man Reality Lifetime Christmas movies art house Lucasfilm Rocketman Avengers President laika Apple TV+ Thanksgiving best Lifetime Star Wars Celebration Amazon Prime Video Ghostbusters marvel comics Tomatazos 24 frames 71st Emmy Awards royal family die hard Crunchyroll TV Hulu documentaries E! psychological thriller 007 hollywood Kids & Family Best Director TV renewals Year in Review Pacific Islander book Heroines spinoff Pop Polls and Games CNN dogs Action high school 20th Century Fox Musicals Paramount Red Carpet MTV serial killer fast and furious disaster NYCC BAFTA Netflix streaming australia Extras Paramount Network Countdown comiccon Photos ABC Family Columbia Pictures BBC One docudrama The Walking Dead slashers VICE dc animated Toys Spring TV Trivia Black History Month CBS YouTube 72 Emmy Awards HBO robots Chernobyl scene in color film series target james bond TV One Apple TV Plus Sony Tumblr Women's History Month OneApp APB adventure reviews christmas movies batman Spectrum Originals Travel Channel Cannes Oscar docuseries slasher Walt Disney Pictures action-comedy tv talk Geeked Week finale green book Mary Poppins Returns sitcom miniseries TLC rt archives DC Comics Ellie Kemper Esquire Star Trek See It Skip It 2017 adaptation movie festival USA TNT adenture unscripted Emmy Nominations obituary composers rom-coms IFC Films Sony Pictures all-time facebook screenings venice dragons new york TV Land Tags: Comedy theme song PlayStation jurassic park football 4/20 Focus Features Prime Video Amazon telelvision Stephen King stop motion classics Mystery kong Animation Marvel Television diversity Netflix Christmas movies Funimation mob true crime Instagram Live Warner Bros. Nat Geo talk show RT History halloween based on movie cancelled television target scene in color Peacock television New York Comic Con 21st Century Fox japan justice league blaxploitation 45 posters FOX Superheroes historical drama The Witch Wes Anderson 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards rotten movies we love spanish