Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: WALL-E Is the Best-Reviewed Film of 2008

Plus, Wanted delivers the adrenaline-fueled goods.

by | June 30, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got lonely robots (Pixar’s WALL-E, directed by Andrew Stanton) and kinetic killers (Wanted, starring Angelina Jolie, James McAvoy, and Morgan Freeman). What do the critics have to say?

It’s rare that a picture earns comparisons with Chaplin‘s City Lights and Kubrick‘s 2001. It’s rarer still that said picture is also praised as intelligent, visually remarkable, darkly funny, and ultimately, heartwarming family fare. However, critics say the good folks at Pixar have done just that with WALL-E, perhaps the studio’s most audacious film yet. Set in a dystopian future, WALL-E is the tale of a garbage-collecting robot navigating an unpopulated Earth. Soon he’s joined by EVE, a female bot searching for vegetation, and falls head-over-treads in love. Critics have been heaping praise on Pixar for years, but there’s a reason for that: The studio re-invents the rules of CG animation each time out. The pundits say WALL-E deftly blends slapstick, political satire, heartbreaking romance, and masterful storytelling into a one-of-a-kind movie experience. At 96 percent on the Tomatometer, WALL-E is not just Certified Fresh. It’s not just one of the best-reviewed films of the year. It’s one of the best-reviewed films in Pixar’s history.

“Now where can we get some Brawndo?”

If you’re looking for realism and well-developed characters, you can safely skip Wanted. However, if visceral, kicky popcorn fun is what you crave, critics say this Angelina Jolie-toplined flick should largely satisfy. Directed by Timur (Night Watch) Bekmambetov, Wanted is the story of an average Joe (James McAvoy) who finds himself recruited into a secret society by the enigmatic Fox (Jolie), in which he learns how to be an efficient assassin before getting in over his head. The pundits say Wanted is ultra-violent and artificial, but also sharply-paced and loaded with visual flair. At 72 percent, Wanted is more alive than dead. (Check out our video interview with Jolie here, and our breakdown of McAvoy’s best-reviewed films here.)

“Clean up on aisle five!”

Also opening this week in limited release:

Louise Bourgeois: The Spider, The Mistress and The Tangerine, a documentary about the iconoclastic artist, is at 89 percent;

Beastie Boy Adam Yauch‘s Gunnin’ for That #1 Spot, a doc about street-hoops Mecca Rucker Park, is at 82 percent;

Catherine Breillat’s The Last Mistress, adapted from a novel by Jules Barbey d’Aurevilly and starring Asia Argento, is at 71 percent;

Trumbo, a doc about the blacklisted screenwriter of Roman Holiday, is at 64 percent;

Elsa & Fred, a romantic comedy about a wild love affair between two seniors in Madrid, is at 50 percent;

Finding Amanda, starring Matthew Broderick and Brittany Snow, a comedy about a compulsive gambler’s search for his drug-addicted niece, is at 46 percent;

Full Grown Men, a dark comedy about arrested emotional development starring Matt McGrath and Judah Friedlander, is at 44 percent;

And Hannari: Geisha Modern, a doc about the Japanese performance tradition, is at zero percent.

“I’m taking my Tomatometer with a grain of salt.”

Recent Pixar Movies:
95% — Ratatouille (2007)
75% — Cars (2006)
97% — The Incredibles (2004)
98% — Finding Nemo (2003)
95% — Monsters, Inc. (2001)

Tag Cloud

blaxploitation trophy Marvel Studios period drama king arthur book adaptation werewolf rt labs critics edition target based on movie Martial Arts slasher hispanic heritage month Paramount Plus Crunchyroll Comic Book hispanic Bravo singing competition TCA 2017 mission: impossible remakes BET debate cults spy thriller scene in color spain Red Carpet batman gangster free movies Rocky dark name the review Epix dragons parents Holidays Set visit Drama Columbia Pictures Apple TV+ NBC justice league transformers Interview Shondaland Stephen King Universal Pictures screen actors guild Horror IMDb TV news venice Fargo Schedule Pirates 79th Golden Globes Awards japanese saw PlayStation MCU medical drama scary movies OWN new star wars movies jamie lee curtis fresh Exclusive Video disaster sequels golden globe awards Sci-Fi all-time The Purge child's play Comics on TV Amazon Studios movies Lucasfilm Fox News RT History SDCC award winner king kong canceled TV shows Best and Worst blockbuster composers Polls and Games game show TBS ABC Peacock LGBT mutant Teen Disney Channel Valentine's Day worst movies war President nature comic book movies Wes Anderson spider-man Chilling Adventures of Sabrina true crime Sneak Peek TCM spanish adenture 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Year in Review live event screenings Lifetime Christmas movies Crackle serial killer CMT olympics Musical children's TV FX Toys docuseries USA facebook Mindy Kaling Turner Classic Movies jurassic park international vs. new zealand NYCC Spectrum Originals sag awards Lifetime tv talk 2015 Superheroe Sony Pictures SXSW Netflix 73rd Emmy Awards 24 frames popular Alien high school Emmy Nominations 007 The Witch video El Rey Film films game of thrones GoT kids DirecTV zombie posters canceled royal family Opinion Cannes Tags: Comedy book Comedy Central thriller Rock scorecard TCA Awards Trailer Adult Swim The CW History vampires 71st Emmy Awards FOX cancelled Walt Disney Pictures Anna Paquin Amazon Prime Video zero dark thirty BET Awards Cosplay halloween 2021 Western Writers Guild of America cinemax 93rd Oscars Amazon First Reviews Women's History Month christmas movies comic Nat Geo green book ABC Family joker rom-coms Music Marvel Television Tokyo Olympics criterion comic books biography Syfy harry potter AMC adaptation Certified Fresh Sundance TV OneApp Star Trek festivals CNN Countdown 2018 Amazon Prime know your critic A24 Food Network ABC Signature Fantasy Prime Video Ellie Kemper Tomatazos Captain marvel Trophy Talk renewed TV shows best TCA trailers BBC archives rt labs Masterpiece 2017 DC Comics football Nickelodeon Instagram Live deadpool Paramount Showtime Awards Awards Tour HFPA sports docudrama marvel cinematic universe Britbox new york space VH1 Spike National Geographic police drama TLC lord of the rings Lionsgate Rocketman dexter hist kaiju suspense American Society of Cinematographers Extras cats HBO Go Rom-Com nfl SundanceTV MSNBC Warner Bros. The Academy wonder woman crime thriller supernatural 4/20 FXX Funimation Starz Quiz basketball toy story Television Academy nbcuniversal Acorn TV Country technology Video Games witnail LGBTQ video on demand chucky USA Network Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt HBO Max The Walking Dead TV renewals YA Grammys Mystery 1990s biopic cancelled TV shows Fox Searchlight Esquire halloween tv satire Black Mirror psycho revenge 20th Century Fox breaking bad travel Reality Broadway Turner Ovation stop motion marvel comics Paramount Network black comedy politics Baby Yoda CW Seed Thanksgiving Emmys YouTube Comedy spider-verse animated Winners CBS All Access anthology documentaries BBC One First Look anime blockbusters slashers heist movie Action scary japan ESPN NBA teaser Disney Plus crime drama feel good Binge Guide BAFTA die hard aapi E! A&E Mary Tyler Moore Nominations Vudu Mudbound directors Holiday Podcast crime Cartoon Network Tubi 72 Emmy Awards cooking Watching Series dreamworks prank Endgame worst hollywood french Song of Ice and Fire obituary political drama Family young adult Classic Film psychological thriller television Oscars IFC Films boxing comedies Pop TV 45 mcc IFC spanish language historical drama dogs Trivia stand-up comedy Christmas Film Festival latino cancelled television Apple TV Plus streaming movies genre Pride Month aliens 2019 HBO sopranos Arrowverse golden globes TNT WarnerMedia kong what to watch Creative Arts Emmys Disney streaming service ghosts Spring TV BBC America classics casting ID Hulu Mary poppins E3 discovery stoner miniseries PBS festival australia superhero 2016 TCA Winter 2020 WGN Disney+ Disney Plus Superheroes Winter TV Netflix Christmas movies Discovery Channel a nightmare on elm street science fiction black dc romantic comedy women comiccon Heroines Summer natural history Biopics zombies Freeform GIFs elevated horror Travel Channel TV action-comedy 90s X-Men rotten superman Television Critics Association dramedy live action Logo romance leaderboard pirates of the caribbean cops TruTV Super Bowl See It Skip It FX on Hulu finale talk show Legendary foreign toronto independent The Walt Disney Company Shudder critic resources dceu TV One ITV laika mob sequel Hollywood Foreign Press Association legend documentary versus robots Dark Horse Comics AMC Plus DC Universe VOD Avengers Star Wars concert comics universal monsters fast and furious Ghostbusters rotten movies we love Sundance critics theme song crossover The Arrangement Infographic emmy awards indie Chernobyl quibi james bond Reality Competition richard e. Grant diversity rt archives razzies Comic-Con@Home 2021 99% cars Pet Sematary south america godzilla MTV Image Comics CBS spinoff San Diego Comic-Con movie streaming Apple Character Guide ViacomCBS strong female leads Hallmark Christmas movies DC streaming service Fall TV Calendar RT21 twilight series TV movies unscripted Election reviews social media monster movies Box Office Sundance Now hidden camera Tumblr DGA Marvel cartoon indiana jones Hallmark Tarantino Pacific Islander VICE Black History Month TV Land PaleyFest Elton John Disney ratings Pop Premiere Dates Mary Poppins Returns Musicals Neflix telelvision 21st Century Fox GLAAD YouTube Premium comic book movie Brie Larson sitcom binge TIFF reboot YouTube Red boxoffice Pixar Academy Awards cancelled TV series adventure New York Comic Con mockumentary asian-american Photos Marathons APB Kids & Family Universal Animation 2020 doctor who art house franchise Hear Us Out italian