Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Vampires Suck Bites

Plus, yay to Nanny McPhee Returns and Piranha 3-D, nay to The Switch and Lottery Ticket

by | August 20, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a Twilight spoof (Vampires Suck, starring Jenn Proske and Matt Lanter); a magical childminder (Nanny McPhee Returns, starring Emma Thompson and Maggie Gyllenhaal); bloodthirsty fish (Piranha 3D, starring Elisabeth Shue and Jerry O’Connell); a baby mixup (The Switch, starring Jennifer Aniston and Jason Bateman); and powerball pratfalls (Lottery Ticket, starring Bow Wow and Ice Cube). What do the critics have to say?


Vampires Suck

The critically-reviled spoof-meisters Jason Friedberg and Aaron Seltzer make Uwe Boll look like Akira Kurosawa; for those keeping score at home, their best-reviewed directorial effort thus far is Date Movie, which garnered a robust six percent on the Tomatometer. And critics say their latest, the witless Twilight parody, Vampires Suck, lives down to its title. Jenn Proske stars as Becca Crane (geddit? It’s just like Bella Swan!), who falls for a vampire named Edward Sullen (sounds like Edward Cullen! And he’s mopey!) and an oft-shirtless werewolf; hilarity, in the form of pratfalls and Jersey Shore impersonators, ensues. The pundits say Vampires Suck represents something of an advance for Friedberg and Seltzer — a couple gags are mildly amusing — but otherwise, it’s more of the same, with lame, lazy pop-culture references substituting for actual laughs.


Nanny McPhee Returns

Nanny McPhee is back, and better than ever! At least, so say the critics, who are once again charmed by the snaggletoothed, magic-dispensing domestic savior in Nanny McPhee Returns. Emma Thompson reprises the title role, this time bringing her services to the put-upon Isabel Green (Maggie Gyllenhaal), who is trying to keep her family intact while her husband serves in a far-away war. Naturally, Ms. McPhee restores order to the household, but outside forces still threaten the Greens. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Nanny McPhee Returns is better than its predecessor, thanks to its fine cast and a willfully eccentric, whimsical, intelligent script.


Piranha 3-D

Back in the day, 3D wasn’t employed in the service of big-budget prestige pictures but delightfully disreputable B-movies. And for those of you who’ve been pining for a 3D flick in the tradition of William Castle, wait no more: critics say the giddy, gory Piranha 3-D is a whale of fish tale. This third installment of Roger Corman’s Jaws ripoff stars Elisabeth Shue as a sheriff who must protect her community after a school of prehistoric fish lay waste to spring break revelers partying at the local lake. The pundits say Piranha 3-D is a lot of fun: it’s tongue-in-cheek without succumbing to self parody, and its kills are energetic and inventive.


The Switch

Apparently, artificial insemination and comedy go together like babies and pacifiers — in recent months, we’ve been treated to the Certified Fresh The Kids Are All Right and the less warmly-received The Back-Up Plan. Now comes The Switch, and critics say this mix of raunch and sentiment leaves, ahem, womb for improvement. Jennifer Aniston and Jason Bateman star as a pair of close friends; seven years ago, after an accident, he replaced the sperm sample she planned to use to get pregnant with his own seed. How will they face the revelation that her kid is really his, too? The pundits say The Switch‘s premise is questionable to begin with, and although the performers do their best, they’re saddled with a surprise-free script that adheres too closely to the romantic comedy playbook.


Lottery Ticket

We’ve all fantasized about winning the lottery, but we tend to avoid thinking about the downside — false friends and tenuous connections looking for a piece of the pie. Unfortunately, critics say Lottery Ticket takes that delicious premise and doesn’t do much with it — despite good intentions and occasional charm, it’s an uneven piece of work. Bow Wow stars as Kevin, an affable Foot Locker employee who buys a lottery ticket that turns out to be worth $370 million. Pretty soon the word gets out, and Kevin must avoid greedy neighbors and local tough guys in order to collect the prize. The pundits say Lottery Ticket has moments of warmth and humor, but it’s ultimately haphazard and devoid of tension. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Ice Cube’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Army of Crime, a thriller about the early days of the French Resistance in World War II, is at 90 percent.

  • A Film Unfinished, which resurrects (and provides insight into) a long-lost Nazi propaganda film, is at 89 percent.

  • The Tillman Story, a documentary about the inspiring life and untimely death of the footballer-turned-Army Ranger, is at 89 percent.

  • Soul Kitchen, a comedy about a idiosyncratic restaurateur and the eccentrics drawn into his orbit, is at 80 percent.

  • Mao’s Last Dancer, based on the true rags-to-riches tale of a dancer who rose from humble origins, is at 59 percent.

  • Calvin Marshall, a drama about a junior college ballplayer determined to make the majors despite a lack of talent, is at 50 percent.

  • Making Plans for Lena, a drama about a gathering of dysfunctional family members, is at 43 percent.

Tag Cloud

adaptation Sneak Peek razzies 21st Century Fox dreamworks Heroines Paramount Network comedies AMC crime The Purge OneApp Creative Arts Emmys docuseries chucky laika hidden camera Academy Awards Marvel Musical elevated horror Hulu Trivia NYCC Teen Universal TCA Awards rt labs Box Office GLAAD Nat Geo MSNBC Fantasy latino nbcuniversal teaser debate psycho FX Logo sag awards Country streaming movies action-comedy Quiz spanish First Reviews TCM BAFTA genre facebook free movies prank Tomatazos emmy awards slasher Lionsgate cinemax Esquire doctor who posters ratings movie psychological thriller Avengers high school VOD Fargo Crunchyroll Hollywood Foreign Press Association boxing worst police drama Television Critics Association YouTube Best Actress Musicals batman APB SDCC 73rd Emmy Awards basketball superman Exclusive Video 2018 Marathons Mystery Emmy Nominations ID Anna Paquin venice scene in color Certified Fresh anime Paramount technology comic books kong movies disaster dceu obi wan stand-up comedy godzilla rotten 1990s adenture Stephen King comiccon 2015 indie Netflix Christmas movies hist casting USA Network Best Actor serial killer ViacomCBS GoT Food Network olympics dark quibi Arrowverse stop motion Legendary Extras parents criterion talk show animated Election Winners pirates of the caribbean biography Britbox superhero IFC Films 99% Disney+ Disney Plus TNT PaleyFest screen actors guild Video Games jamie lee curtis twilight LGBT Best Director christmas movies natural history james bond interviews 2016 Sundance Now name the review Adult Swim nfl Indigenous rotten movies we love young adult singing competition Amazon Prime Spring TV women die hard Walt Disney Pictures YouTube Red feel good Mary poppins reboot Martial Arts Disney IFC cancelled TV shows Sundance TV a nightmare on elm street Spike ghosts Podcast mutant Neflix Women's History Month zombies Turner Classic Movies Acorn TV summer preview zombie Dark Horse Comics fresh New York Comic Con Apple TV+ Pop TV comic book movies universal monsters 72 Emmy Awards Pixar MTV transformers Lifetime Christmas movies golden globes space El Rey Mary Poppins Returns Trophy Talk ESPN justice league Kids & Family Black Mirror Star Wars lord of the rings wonder woman MCU Paramount Pictures miniseries political drama HBO films 90s cats Awards Comics on TV Premiere Dates Epix romance all-time composers spy thriller supernatural tv talk leaderboard japan black blaxploitation Photos video on demand cults dc FOX American Society of Cinematographers Marvel Television ITV book adaptation breaking bad joker series rom-coms stoner Vudu award winner Instagram Live Valentine's Day Ghostbusters FXX anthology Rock target RT21 Action Western HBO Max diversity game show Superheroes Drama Apple TV Plus Superheroe target scene in color Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Countdown GIFs legend Biopics australia nature versus science fiction crossover Grammys Geeked Week BBC America Travel Channel TV One social media comics comic book movie Opinion unscripted The CW A&E CBS new star wars movies Interview The Academy summer TV summer TV preview satire Disney Channel hispanic BET Awards Alien Best and Worst slashers zero dark thirty Character Guide E3 game of thrones BBC true crime revenge streamig Christmas Endgame sequel Rocketman RT History new york Turner TV movies DC streaming service Animation mission: impossible Nominations aliens art house royal family gangster Rocky italian USA critic resources trailers crime drama SXSW 2022 Star Wars Celebration HFPA Sony marvel comics PBS Calendar broadcast Paramount Plus Tokyo Olympics TCA 2017 Lifetime Summer international E! President 93rd Oscars Family DC Comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina japanese blockbusters The Arrangement YouTube Premium 007 SXSW Reality robots scorecard popular toronto TV renewals Lucasfilm LGBTQ Schedule OWN remakes finale Wes Anderson spider-man best crime thriller documentaries Crackle Comic Book TruTV CW Seed Disney streaming service heist movie telelvision Oscar Prime Video TV Land Peacock archives boxoffice marvel cinematic universe Television Academy indiana jones vs. Funimation Mary Tyler Moore asian-american TIFF live action discovery hollywood Writers Guild of America Syfy renewed TV shows Pacific Islander Netflix Year in Review Tags: Comedy dramedy Watching Series what to watch video Emmys biopic Winter TV Sci-Fi Trailer child's play 2017 blockbuster Reality Competition dexter toy story harry potter 2020 Song of Ice and Fire mockumentary CNN deadpool foreign french VH1 Broadway Awards Tour See It Skip It Fox News FX on Hulu witnail BBC One cancelled television Warner Bros. Discovery Channel Starz DirecTV travel Holidays Showtime vampires Shondaland adventure Columbia Pictures franchise rt archives ABC Family canceled TV shows Apple aapi live event NBC Spectrum Originals ABC AMC Plus comic VICE 2021 WarnerMedia reviews richard e. Grant Hallmark Christmas movies dragons 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Nickelodeon IMDb TV news jurassic park scary cooking The Walking Dead concert spider-verse 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Prime Video WGN Fox Searchlight suspense directors TCA Oscars NBA Sony Pictures History scary movies 79th Golden Globes Awards Universal Pictures halloween scene in color film series Black History Month Comedy Film docudrama werewolf Pet Sematary Ellie Kemper spinoff sequels classics Infographic based on movie 4/20 rt labs critics edition kaiju hispanic heritage month Image Comics binge 2019 know your critic South by Southwest Film Festival Focus Features CBS All Access Best Picture TCA Winter 2020 period drama Comic-Con@Home 2021 Tumblr Elton John Marvel Studios Bravo Super Bowl SundanceTV spain Fall TV Amazon Rom-Com DC Universe TLC strong female leads black comedy CMT monster movies sitcom war Music Cartoon Network scene in color series kids canceled fast and furious cancelled halloween tv children's TV Baby Yoda king arthur Tarantino San Diego Comic-Con Comedy Central trophy YA Masterpiece 45 BET Tubi football Hallmark book Mudbound ABC Signature golden globe awards Captain marvel south america festival Red Carpet Pirates worst movies Binge Guide new zealand cops Disney Plus cars HBO Go TBS Toys The Witch 24 frames thriller Cannes PlayStation spanish language romantic comedy Cosplay streaming Brie Larson Pride Month Amazon Studios television Sundance TV sopranos Hear Us Out 94th Oscars DGA Classic Film Pop The Walt Disney Company A24 Freeform Film Festival medical drama Thanksgiving cancelled TV series cartoon festivals Mindy Kaling politics Holiday mcc MGM mob Ovation Horror sports dogs Polls and Games screenings saw independent First Look historical drama documentary critics X-Men Chernobyl 20th Century Fox National Geographic green book Set visit Star Trek obituary Shudder king kong Native theme song