Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Unknown's Plot Twists Too Much

Plus, I Am Number Four is so-so, and Big Mommas is dire stuff.

by | February 17, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a mystery man (Unknown, starring Liam Neeson and January Jones), a teenage alien (I Am Number Four, starring Alex Pettyfer and Timothy Olyphant), and a cross-dressing fed (Big Mommas: Like Father, Like Son, starring Martin Lawrence and Brandon T. Jackson). What do the critics have to say?

Unknown

55%

Lately, Liam Neeson has a thing for European intrigue. He journeyed to Paris to rescue his daughter in 2009’s Taken, and now he heads to Berlin for Unknown, a twisty thriller that critics say undermines its strong premise with implausible plotting. Neeson stars as a man who falls into a coma after a car accident; when he awakens, he discovers his wife (January Jones) doesn’t recognize him, and he’s being targeted by shadowy forces. The pundits say Neeson and an expert supporting cast help keep Unknown watchable, but ultimately, the unlikely story and excessive action set pieces keep it from truly soaring.

I Am Number Four

19%

Another week, another tale of a teenager with supernatural powers. In I Am Number Four, our hero is neither a vampire nor a wizard, but an alien — which matters little to critics, who say the movie has some decent action scenes, but little in the way of memorable characters or original plotting. Alex Pettyfer stars as a teenage alien with extraordinary powers who wants to settle down and enjoy high school life in a sleepy Ohio town; unfortunately, some evil aliens have already killed three of his associates. The pundits say Four rips off just about every other film of its ilk, from Twilight to Harry Potter, without adding much to the formula, though there are a few exciting moments here and there.

Big Mommas: Like Father, Like Son

5%

Some cinematic stories are so sprawling or emotionally overwhelming that it takes a trilogy to tell them — think Lord of the Rings or the Apu trilogy. But the Big Momma movies? If the first two installments didn’t exactly set the critical world afire, the pundits are especially unamused by Big Mommas: Like Father, Like Son, calling it a particularly slim assemblage of crass gags that furthers the franchise’s one-joke premise without, ahem, expanding upon it. Once again, Martin Lawrence plays an FBI agent who must go undercover in the most counterintuitive of disguises — this time in an all-girls school after his nephew witnesses a killing. The pundits say Big Mommas is tired stuff – clichéd, dull, and shrill, with little reason to exist. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we present a brief history of movies with dudes in drag.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Reality Competition ViacomCBS 73rd Emmy Awards genre discovery Writers Guild of America Holiday PlayStation new york Disney VOD comic book movie name the review blockbusters biopic dexter Women's History Month Masterpiece 2016 2015 venice unscripted facebook Action pirates of the caribbean Tags: Comedy Film interviews Apple Neflix ratings royal family Hollywood Foreign Press Association crime TV renewals aliens high school criterion serial killer critic resources free movies die hard Tumblr Cosplay robots E! comiccon fresh DC Comics period drama 21st Century Fox Food Network zombie Academy Awards YA Video Games cancelled television a nightmare on elm street sag awards FOX DGA RT History MSNBC Best Actress series Ghostbusters international HBO Go telelvision Exclusive Video movies TV TV One Showtime heist movie Superheroe Sundance jurassic park Spring TV WarnerMedia canceled ABC Signature obi wan critics hispanic heritage month adaptation romantic comedy 94th Oscars CBS crime thriller Fall TV Logo travel Ellie Kemper Netflix Christmas movies WGN scorecard directors LGBTQ slasher GLAAD spanish Music Quiz italian art house sequels comic Hallmark DirecTV tv talk dc popular Classic Film australia natural history kaiju lord of the rings Instagram Live golden globes National Geographic hidden camera archives adenture indie cops movie satire harry potter 90s Image Comics screen actors guild asian-american news Marvel Television rt archives Broadway TCA 2017 Comics on TV TIFF New York Comic Con The Purge 007 Trailer BBC America CBS All Access classics Nickelodeon Alien stoner FXX Crackle Film Festival parents Indigenous TCA Winter 2020 romance scene in color docudrama franchise trophy social media A&E scary APB spain justice league Sony Pictures Travel Channel 99% Marathons toronto television worst blaxploitation anthology sopranos Nominations OWN halloween tv canceled TV shows 20th Century Fox IFC joker Spectrum Originals Vudu trailers streaming book adaptation SundanceTV hollywood NYCC The Witch cancelled VICE President Lifetime Christmas movies Nat Geo spider-man comic book movies prank binge Star Trek Paramount Plus mcc video nfl sitcom BBC One Best and Worst Comedy Central young adult animated renewed TV shows Fargo Calendar miniseries Star Wars Celebration streamig Podcast Brie Larson Opinion San Diego Comic-Con BBC Marvel know your critic war Pixar space Heroines vampires cats reviews Wes Anderson LGBT Oscar toy story vs. American Society of Cinematographers E3 dragons Paramount video on demand teaser true crime Sneak Peek Acorn TV chucky hist docuseries Captain marvel zero dark thirty Reality Amazon Stephen King cartoon Cannes Emmy Nominations South by Southwest Film Festival Bravo sequel MTV Shondaland Walt Disney Pictures Turner slashers 2019 book football mutant Premiere Dates christmas movies Disney Channel TV Land supernatural Disney+ Disney Plus stop motion nature aapi Geeked Week science fiction 2018 child's play Turner Classic Movies Comic Book PBS Pop Hear Us Out thriller Shudder gangster Country Television Academy king kong south america mission: impossible Netflix Rocky Musical HBO Universal Pictures Song of Ice and Fire dreamworks police drama Amazon Prime Video Awards target witnail Mindy Kaling live action Rock remakes Lifetime Britbox festivals dogs Crunchyroll Teen dramedy Sci-Fi Rom-Com legend ghosts Comic-Con@Home 2021 History The Academy what to watch BAFTA Lionsgate Sundance TV The Walt Disney Company Esquire political drama posters debate versus Mystery NBC Native summer TV preview casting TBS ABC Family children's TV Amazon Studios Thanksgiving scene in color film series Interview based on movie screenings See It Skip It USA Network comedies Winter TV TCA Awards IMDb TV Comedy psycho Television Critics Association Epix X-Men Best Actor kong blockbuster ABC green book TNT transformers Photos Emmys godzilla Red Carpet NBA Apple TV Plus french Starz worst movies cars Trophy Talk Lucasfilm Pirates basketball spider-verse composers Endgame IFC Films Funimation Super Bowl crossover Sundance Now revenge Discovery Channel documentary biography black CW Seed disaster talk show olympics foreign japan summer preview latino DC streaming service The Walking Dead Schedule theme song Awards Tour Hulu 2017 batman Black Mirror scary movies Mary Poppins Returns cinemax A24 Watching Series Tokyo Olympics Disney Plus Universal GoT Toys dceu Ovation japanese jamie lee curtis Elton John concert breaking bad Martial Arts SXSW 2022 kids Valentine's Day Trivia Pride Month suspense comic books broadcast Spike target scene in color Columbia Pictures Dark Horse Comics festival SXSW Amazon Prime Extras all-time YouTube Red Box Office comics new zealand Election historical drama anime elevated horror films doctor who streaming movies 24 frames strong female leads saw Kids & Family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt obituary Prime Video 72 Emmy Awards rt labs critics edition razzies Avengers Mary Tyler Moore marvel cinematic universe Binge Guide cults scene in color series Paramount Network FX on Hulu Countdown spy thriller game show ESPN TCA Syfy BET Disney streaming service Superheroes The Arrangement TLC Musicals fast and furious cooking Arrowverse Cartoon Network universal monsters Star Wars Fox News Pop TV Peacock First Reviews Warner Bros. hispanic GIFs The CW Horror rom-coms Polls and Games singing competition Focus Features deadpool Freeform El Rey superman summer TV FX politics DC Universe Fox Searchlight quibi Infographic Summer sports SDCC YouTube Premium ITV documentaries CNN RT21 mob women ID boxing Tarantino OneApp Year in Review Black History Month adventure 79th Golden Globes Awards Paramount Pictures MGM Fantasy Family HFPA Tubi Marvel Studios marvel comics First Look best independent Best Director action-comedy Rocketman stand-up comedy TruTV Set visit twilight wonder woman 45 mockumentary Creative Arts Emmys game of thrones live event Character Guide rotten movies we love boxoffice award winner 71st Emmy Awards werewolf golden globe awards Sony PaleyFest Hallmark Christmas movies laika MCU black comedy TV movies Best Picture Winners HBO Max cancelled TV series new star wars movies TCM VH1 93rd Oscars james bond CMT technology zombies AMC Apple TV+ spanish language 1990s Animation Pet Sematary Anna Paquin Holidays dark Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 4/20 nbcuniversal rotten Mudbound king arthur emmy awards superhero Certified Fresh monster movies spinoff cancelled TV shows BET Awards Oscars feel good Christmas Adult Swim Biopics 2021 diversity rt labs crime drama 2020 indiana jones AMC Plus Chernobyl richard e. Grant Western medical drama psychological thriller Pacific Islander YouTube Drama USA Tomatazos finale Legendary Baby Yoda leaderboard halloween reboot 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Grammys Mary poppins