Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Transformers 2 Is Less Than Meets The Eye

Plus, My Sister's Keeper is well-acted but manipulative, and The Hurt Locker is powerful and vital.

by | June 25, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got robots in disguise (Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen, starring Megan Fox and Shia LaBeouf) and an engagement of convenience (My Sister’s Keeper, starring Cameron Diaz and Abigail Breslin). What do the critics have to say?


Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen

Most folks like their blockbusters big, loud, and loaded with spectacle. However, the masses also tend to enjoy good characters and some semblance of a plot, two things the pundits say are sorely missing from Michael Bay‘s Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen. This follow up to 2007’s Transformers finds the Autobots waging a battle to destroy the evil forces of the Decepticons (with help from Megan Fox and Shia LaBeouf), since they have designs on obliterating Earth. Critics say Revenge has a lot of problems: it’s loud, it’s bombastic, it’s way to long, it contains few recognizable human emotions, and its plot is borderline incomprehensible. Worst of all, they say, it’s not particularly fun. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down the top 50 movie robots of all time, and our primer on Revenge of the Fallen‘s bots.)


My Sister’s Keeper

A lot of movies walk a fine line between being emotionally involving and seeming merely manipulative, and critics are essentially split on which side My Sister’s Keeper falls. Cameron Diaz stars as a woman whose daughter Anna (Abigail Breslin) is born as a genetic match with her leukemia-afflicted older sister Kate (Sofia Vassilieva). When, at 11, Anna is called upon to provide a kidney for Kate, she sues her parents for medical independence. Some critics say My Sister’s Keeper is bolstered by outstanding performances and a sense of moral complexity. However, others say this three-hankie weepie doesn’t fully earn its tears, resorting to unconvincing plot machinations..)


Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

independent Oscars Heroines HFPA Infographic docuseries razzies Drama films television Sci-Fi mission: impossible true crime biopic WGN free movies A&E spain Stephen King hollywood young adult biography golden globes king arthur Esquire ID festivals sequel Marvel Studios stand-up comedy halloween tv critics Wes Anderson robots TCA 2017 National Geographic Christmas japan Awards rom-coms 007 cars target BAFTA nfl Film criterion Mindy Kaling scary movies Elton John new zealand kids latino DirecTV The Walt Disney Company TNT Masterpiece Film Festival black comedy medical drama Disney dc know your critic USA Network Crunchyroll 79th Golden Globes Awards new york thriller chucky game show football genre slasher Star Wars Women's History Month Awards Tour movie Podcast tv talk scene in color name the review reviews cancelled MTV Arrowverse fast and furious SXSW Lucasfilm binge Endgame nbcuniversal Columbia Pictures Family romance LGBTQ MSNBC rt labs ViacomCBS parents comic stop motion political drama TV Disney Channel witnail Mystery Country Academy Awards Tubi Travel Channel Holiday Comedy Central 2020 obituary Polls and Games Shudder Comics on TV Marvel Television ESPN Summer CBS Nominations Vudu Thanksgiving werewolf Instagram Live TV movies video trailers rotten movies we love Ovation comic book movie Disney+ Disney Plus 21st Century Fox Sundance Now vs. king kong Turner 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards sports action-comedy Fox News art house Lifetime Christmas movies cinemax spanish language series olympics zombies RT21 Fall TV cults discovery dreamworks Acorn TV Neflix talk show Marvel justice league mutant elevated horror Extras cartoon Image Comics 2021 spider-man scary Comedy what to watch Discovery Channel child's play HBO Max Reality award winner twilight Election all-time anthology Netflix TCM Star Trek PaleyFest BBC facebook boxing dragons harry potter Pacific Islander ABC Signature blockbusters Best and Worst Musical Sony Pictures Apple TV Plus cancelled television toy story Showtime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt live action monster movies technology nature serial killer TCA Awards San Diego Comic-Con Certified Fresh Emmy Nominations Legendary crime thriller Tags: Comedy Black History Month comics spanish TruTV worst movies YouTube Red El Rey 2017 Mary poppins directors Emmys Amazon Studios 93rd Oscars HBO TCA children's TV Tomatazos supernatural Epix live event First Look Box Office Mary Tyler Moore Creative Arts Emmys green book reboot ITV 99% APB Reality Competition natural history adventure streaming italian mockumentary trophy psycho kong VICE Hear Us Out indiana jones travel Trailer Broadway crime drama Spectrum Originals suspense Cannes Superheroes Action Year in Review best Valentine's Day GoT Marathons unscripted Martial Arts Pride Month casting The Witch adenture TLC Pixar royal family Nat Geo heist movie 1990s USA high school movies Cosplay New York Comic Con asian-american BBC One 20th Century Fox batman YouTube space spinoff Chernobyl festival comic book movies Ellie Kemper rt archives superhero lord of the rings foreign Fargo popular FXX Tumblr 72 Emmy Awards politics sopranos Logo Holidays Prime Video Baby Yoda australia Apple TV+ Music venice TBS RT History golden globe awards comic books 71st Emmy Awards DGA Rock classics Rocketman Classic Film book adaptation blaxploitation Paramount Plus game of thrones 2019 transformers Pop NBA Apple aapi Comic-Con@Home 2021 2016 Horror Superheroe sag awards ratings pirates of the caribbean American Society of Cinematographers Spring TV mob strong female leads Hollywood Foreign Press Association jurassic park Lifetime book black Britbox marvel cinematic universe Trophy Talk Cartoon Network TCA Winter 2020 Fox Searchlight posters Countdown versus gangster See It Skip It Amazon Prime Video boxoffice stoner slashers FX critic resources documentaries Television Critics Association news TV One Universal DC Universe Writers Guild of America die hard Shondaland NYCC based on movie deadpool Song of Ice and Fire new star wars movies DC streaming service TV renewals doctor who Mudbound spy thriller Exclusive Video screenings CBS All Access telelvision Black Mirror period drama halloween OneApp SDCC Watching Series Crackle Super Bowl First Reviews toronto cats Netflix Christmas movies aliens godzilla hist Biopics 24 frames MCU jamie lee curtis Rom-Com AMC Plus Mary Poppins Returns zombie cancelled TV series basketball dexter Freeform finale comiccon Anna Paquin ghosts FX on Hulu rotten international psychological thriller Grammys A24 prank 45 indie HBO Go President james bond YA Quiz Teen OWN women Red Carpet Pet Sematary franchise VOD LGBT Universal Pictures a nightmare on elm street christmas movies Musicals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crossover laika legend GLAAD concert BBC America cancelled TV shows ABC diversity revenge french Trivia historical drama Schedule hidden camera ABC Family Alien disaster Bravo 73rd Emmy Awards Spike YouTube Premium wonder woman Hulu Amazon Prime Tarantino adaptation blockbuster BET satire mcc IFC docudrama video on demand hispanic hispanic heritage month singing competition Sundance Winter TV richard e. Grant Turner Classic Movies Fantasy zero dark thirty composers joker GIFs Paramount Pop TV superman Video Games Set visit Disney Plus documentary Tokyo Olympics crime breaking bad spider-verse saw Starz canceled TV shows VH1 The Walking Dead DC Comics The Academy Character Guide teaser streaming movies theme song police drama feel good sequels X-Men FOX south america marvel comics Walt Disney Pictures science fiction fresh Nickelodeon CW Seed leaderboard 90s 2015 E3 dceu remakes dogs rt labs critics edition canceled Western Warner Bros. Calendar 2018 cops TV Land Pirates screen actors guild comedies kaiju Disney streaming service Captain marvel quibi The CW Amazon BET Awards The Arrangement Interview animated worst Rocky IFC Films E! CNN universal monsters scorecard archives anime AMC Opinion Sundance TV WarnerMedia Sneak Peek Binge Guide Premiere Dates sitcom romantic comedy SundanceTV Hallmark emmy awards Photos Peacock PlayStation Kids & Family Adult Swim Brie Larson japanese PBS Avengers Lionsgate Hallmark Christmas movies Syfy The Purge Comic Book vampires debate miniseries IMDb TV Dark Horse Comics Toys war Food Network History CMT cooking Television Academy Animation Ghostbusters Paramount Network 4/20 dramedy Winners renewed TV shows NBC Funimation dark social media TIFF