Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Woman in Black is a Solid Ghost Story

Plus, Chronicle is Certified Fresh, and Big Miracle is a strong whale tale.

by | February 3, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a ghost story (The Woman in Black, starring Daniel Radcliffe and Ciarán Hinds), teenage superheroes (Chronicle, starring Dane DeHaan and Alex Russell), and a whale rescue (Big Miracle, starring John Krasinski and Drew Barrymore). What do the critics have to say?

The Woman in Black


Daniel Radcliffe tackles his first major post-Harry Potter role in The Woman in Black, and critics say this spooky, atmospheric ghost story conjures up some terrific old-fashioned thrills. Radcliffe stars as Arthur Kipps, a young lawyer who journeys to a small town to settle the estate of a recently-deceased, reclusive widow. However, the locals are reluctant to discuss the matter, and for good reason — a spectral presence casts a dark shadow over the community. The pundits say The Woman in Black sometimes relies too heavily on jump scares, but mostly it does the resurrected Hammer Films imprint proud by harkening back to the company’s Gothic glory days, and Radcliffe is rock-solid in the lead role. (Check out Radcliffe’s Five Favorite Films here.)



A found-footage mockumentary about teenagers with superpowers, Chronicle is also terrifically acted and endlessly imaginative, critics say. Andrew (Dane DeHaan) is a kid who’s being bullied at home and at school when he starts videotaping his daily activities. His footage gets exponentially more interesting when he and two of his friends develop telekinetic powers after visiting a mysterious gulch. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Chronicle is an action-packed sci-fi yarn that doesn’t skimp on character development, and the result is an exciting, emotionally resonant feature debut for director Josh Trank. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most unconventional superheroes.)

Big Miracle


Big Miracle is a mix of romance, realpolitik, and animal rescue that critics say makes for a surprisingly satisfying blend, thanks to excellent performances and an intelligent script. John Krasinski and Drew Barrymore star as a small town news reporter and a Greenpeace volunteer who campaign to save a trio of gray whales trapped by ice at the Arctic Circle; their efforts attract global attention and governmental response, and romance soon follows. The pundits say Big Miracle is smarter and more complex than its synopsis suggests, and if its plotting is occasionally uneven, the film earns its feel-good climax.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Splinters, a documentary about indigenous surfing in Papua New Guinea, is at 83 percent.
  • The Innkeepers, a horror film about ghost hunters searching for spirits in a haunted hotel, is Certified Fresh at 76 percent.
  • Kill List, a thriller about a mentally damaged hitman who undertakes a particularly disturbing assignment, is Certified Fresh at 76 percent.
  • Windfall, a documentary about the impact of a wind farm on an economically depressed small town, is at 58 percent.
  • W.E., starring Abbie Cornish and James D’Arcy in Madonna‘s biopic of American Duchess of Windsor Wallis Simpson, is at 18 percent.

And finally, mad props to Brian C for coming the closest to guessing One for the Money‘s three percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

directors Box Office LGBTQ PBS sports sopranos Infographic Anna Paquin Polls and Games politics Pride Month stop motion Hollywood Foreign Press Association Comedy ESPN HFPA Warner Bros. Esquire comic books Fox Searchlight mission: impossible TCA Awards 2021 cults SundanceTV PlayStation documentaries TV One Marvel mockumentary Disney Channel singing competition toy story Sundance Now Walt Disney Pictures Black History Month cancelled TV shows Universal Pictures sitcom BBC One History CBS films Exclusive Video children's TV docuseries batman Sony Pictures disaster Fall TV new star wars movies CNN strong female leads new zealand Broadway vs. godzilla Marathons space crime drama japan comics archives theme song police drama 2019 fast and furious Disney streaming service foreign NYCC Reality Competition Lifetime Christmas movies CBS All Access comic book movie trophy worst based on movie Wes Anderson DirecTV Video Games First Reviews satire Arrowverse lord of the rings casting TNT cancelled TCM Marvel Studios dogs A&E prank Mudbound BBC America zero dark thirty football crime Television Critics Association Starz Ellie Kemper high school true crime Cartoon Network Winners Acorn TV blockbusters Film Festival Amazon Prime romantic comedy genre miniseries diversity serial killer Tokyo Olympics saw james bond game of thrones Year in Review Spike sequel RT21 Shudder harry potter Television Academy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hispanic heritage month Lionsgate psycho 93rd Oscars TruTV video on demand mob Binge Guide Character Guide cancelled television Sundance TV 99% slashers E3 2017 Quiz PaleyFest First Look Trophy Talk Kids & Family black comedy trailers composers Women's History Month blockbuster french chucky Disney Plus BET stoner TV revenge Mary Tyler Moore Adult Swim scary movies Spring TV Cannes ITV CMT aapi king arthur Syfy OneApp olympics TV renewals Country 007 Nickelodeon Paramount Plus reboot Lifetime comedies Tags: Comedy DGA President finale Awards Tour Watching Series IFC Films GIFs nfl razzies Nat Geo HBO Go Lucasfilm ABC Family breaking bad comic book movies television king kong TIFF 45 Pop TV spanish language indie BAFTA WGN Creative Arts Emmys Toys El Rey crossover Red Carpet Film reviews Crunchyroll spider-man festivals Mindy Kaling social media Universal Mystery name the review Martial Arts remakes Schedule Rocketman rom-coms APB feel good hist Vudu BBC HBO Max monster movies romance TV Land doctor who SDCC art house Western VH1 Instagram Live Rock black Bravo Star Trek Fantasy dc political drama live action Mary poppins American Society of Cinematographers hispanic ID rt labs canceled TV shows Discovery Channel 71st Emmy Awards blaxploitation screen actors guild canceled telelvision Superheroes Epix medical drama X-Men Tubi See It Skip It basketball elevated horror Shondaland parents book adaptation Amazon Prime Video USA Network mutant indiana jones nature rt labs critics edition teaser E! Opinion MCU sequels The Academy VOD popular ABC Elton John SXSW Hallmark target Election festival Action 2018 Song of Ice and Fire Tumblr Ghostbusters LGBT Drama 2016 joker halloween comic Rom-Com NBC Freeform Reality kaiju young adult The Witch classics dragons Writers Guild of America documentary Emmy Nominations Food Network critic resources Superheroe supernatural die hard mcc comiccon Endgame royal family Comic Book jurassic park Amazon Studios golden globes TLC TBS spain biography versus YouTube hollywood Funimation new york Summer Apple TV+ dceu National Geographic latino A24 animated TCA Emmys Rocky Tomatazos spider-verse scorecard The Walking Dead YouTube Red spy thriller Teen VICE Paramount Network quibi Classic Film Chernobyl scene in color italian Musical Star Wars thriller psychological thriller Calendar Britbox biopic australia witnail tv talk kong stand-up comedy Fox News worst movies video nbcuniversal all-time Cosplay debate TV movies Hulu Fargo book ViacomCBS Sci-Fi 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards laika GoT Image Comics Animation Showtime kids Comic-Con@Home 2021 72 Emmy Awards 79th Golden Globes Awards Amazon Hear Us Out IFC Podcast DC Universe DC Comics gangster ABC Signature talk show Valentine's Day The Purge news BET Awards DC streaming service Certified Fresh justice league golden globe awards Awards werewolf Trailer marvel cinematic universe Alien halloween tv Hallmark Christmas movies cooking Baby Yoda MTV japanese what to watch Dark Horse Comics binge crime thriller vampires obituary live event FXX Holiday FOX Turner pirates of the caribbean Travel Channel Sundance cancelled TV series natural history ratings deadpool cars renewed TV shows anthology Sneak Peek Holidays Comics on TV know your critic scary venice jamie lee curtis criterion child's play Countdown Apple TV Plus San Diego Comic-Con Extras historical drama Family twilight Logo discovery movie heist movie adventure Music adenture Marvel Television aliens New York Comic Con Premiere Dates unscripted emmy awards Set visit Horror universal monsters Avengers Musicals Legendary Interview rotten series Masterpiece YA RT History international Netflix Christmas movies sag awards game show independent science fiction Ovation superman TCA 2017 Tarantino 20th Century Fox a nightmare on elm street anime AMC Plus 2020 Paramount dexter OWN 1990s YouTube Premium technology posters leaderboard period drama Pop concert Academy Awards Disney Heroines dramedy south america 4/20 movies war spanish ghosts Disney+ Disney Plus award winner boxoffice women 21st Century Fox Prime Video asian-american rotten movies we love critics TCA Winter 2020 robots wonder woman Captain marvel GLAAD CW Seed Pet Sematary Thanksgiving The CW rt archives green book The Walt Disney Company spinoff Black Mirror Nominations Columbia Pictures boxing zombie 24 frames Best and Worst free movies WarnerMedia Winter TV docudrama Pacific Islander Turner Classic Movies The Arrangement transformers slasher Peacock fresh Brie Larson cinemax screenings AMC Crackle cats marvel comics Christmas Comedy Central dreamworks richard e. Grant Pixar zombies HBO facebook hidden camera 2015 cartoon IMDb TV Stephen King Grammys FX on Hulu Biopics Trivia Photos travel NBA USA Neflix Apple Oscars Mary Poppins Returns streaming movies superhero suspense MSNBC Netflix cops Pirates franchise Super Bowl action-comedy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt adaptation 73rd Emmy Awards 90s dark toronto streaming christmas movies legend FX Spectrum Originals best