Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Three Stooges Is Sometimes Funny, Sometimes Un-Soiten

Plus, The Cabin in the Woods is Certified Fresh, and Lockout is mostly derivative.

by | April 12, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got two Howards and a Fine (The Three Stooges, starring Sean Hayes and Will Sasso), a spooky rural dwelling (The Cabin in the Woods, starring Chris Hemsworth and Kristen Connolly), and an outer space prison riot (Lockout, starring Guy Pearce and Maggie Grace). What do the critics have to say?

The Three Stooges


If anyone could update the Three Stooges’ brand of violently stoopid slapstick for the 21st century, it would be the Farrelly Brothers. And while critics say they’re helped immeasurably by the uncanny performances by Sean Hayes, Chris Diamantopoulos, and Will Sasso as Larry, Moe, and Curly, The Three Stooges is ultimately a not-bad comedy with some decent gags and a little too much filler. In their attempts to save the financially-strapped orphanage where they were raised, the Stooges get mixed up in a murder plot and find themselves involved in a reality show. The pundits say that The Three Stooges was obviously made with care, and though some of its laughs are riotous, it’s a little too long to sustain its comic momentum.

The Cabin in the Woods


Plenty of filmmakers have attempted to wring laughs out of horror clichés, but critics say few have pulled off that tricky balance with as much energy and aplomb as writer Joss Whedon and director Drew Goddard have in The Cabin in the Woods. As the title implies, the movie tells the tale of a group of teens who abscond to a rural retreat, where scary things happen. To say any more would ruin the surprise: the pundits say the Certified Fresh The Cabin in the Woods is a twisty, gory, funny, and thoroughly original horror hybrid that’s one of the smartest fright-fests to come along in quite some time.



Lockout‘s premise — Escape from New York in space — sounds pretty promising. Unfortunately, critics say while the movie has a few dumb thrills, it’s also silly and wildly illogical. Guy Pearce stars as a disgraced government agent who’s tasked with rescuing the president’s daughter from an outer space prison that’s engulfed by rioting. The pundits say Pearce lends gravitas to his clichéd role, but Lockout never fully transcends its B-movie trappings, and the result is derivative and occasionally cheesy. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Luc Besson’s best-reviewed films, and find out Maggie Grace’s Five Favorite Films here.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Monsieur Lazhar, a French dramedy about a substitute teacher who discovers a school system in crisis, is at 93 percent.
  • Post Mortem, a psychological thriller about a morgue clerk whose obsession with a cabaret dancer coincides with political turmoil in Chile, is at 89 percent.
  • Here, starring Ben Foster in a romantic drama about a brief romance in Armenia between a cartographer and a photographer, is at 83 percent.
  • How to Grow a Band, a documentary about the tumultuous formation of the bluegrass band the Punch Brothers, is at 60 percent.
  • Detention, starring Josh Hutcherson and Dane Cook in a horror/comedy about a group of high school seniors whose school is the target of a serial killer, is at 50 percent.
  • Late Bloomers, a comedy starring William Hurt and Isabella Rossellini as a married couple who react to aging in very different ways, is at 50 percent.
  • Hit So Hard: The Life and Near Death Story of Patty Schemel, a documentary about the hard times and miraculous recovery of the Hole drummer, is at 44 percent.
  • Blue Like Jazz, a dramedy about an young evangelical student whose horizons are broadened when he enrolls in an eccentric liberal arts college, is at 38 percent.
  • L!fe Happens, starring Krysten Ritter and Kate Bosworth in a comedy about a young woman who balances dating with single motherhood, is at 38 percent.
  • The Lady, starring Michelle Yeoh in a biopic of Burmese democracy activist and politician Aung San Suu Kyi, is at 36 percent.
  • Deadline, a murder mystery starring Eric Roberts as a newspaper reporter looking into a 20-year-old unsolved crime, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

comic A&E NBA Biopics Trailer Song of Ice and Fire Walt Disney Pictures SXSW Crackle sopranos biography young adult saw Stephen King children's TV WGN YouTube hispanic book franchise DC Universe international Spike comic book movies worst movies Video Games stand-up comedy CBS romantic comedy APB Winter TV Mary poppins Neflix television FOX Avengers Superheroe Ovation VOD dark sag awards 79th Golden Globes Awards Masterpiece Marvel Television Martial Arts The CW all-time The Witch political drama AMC action-comedy Opinion monster movies PlayStation obituary BBC America french scene in color fresh Writers Guild of America Pop TV Binge Guide Fall TV Photos Pacific Islander nfl revenge police drama Winners BBC Action San Diego Comic-Con Vudu Horror First Look remakes chucky DC Comics TCA Winter 2020 kids rt archives Holidays social media directors toy story Mystery festivals Best and Worst spanish language period drama YouTube Red Awards Tour crossover Rocketman mcc halloween tv Universal Pictures RT History reboot Paramount Network versus TCA 2017 popular Trophy Talk hispanic heritage month E! Emmys The Arrangement HBO Wes Anderson sitcom concert Mindy Kaling streaming book adaptation sequels legend satire BET dramedy thriller razzies Music New York Comic Con Star Wars Nickelodeon rotten binge prank talk show anthology comics Pop facebook latino Endgame MTV robots Funimation Certified Fresh trophy Sundance Now Country cancelled blockbuster parents E3 Marvel Studios 71st Emmy Awards USA Network adenture 2018 Food Network X-Men Western streaming movies Comedy Tomatazos Musicals werewolf Tags: Comedy TV renewals TIFF Amazon FXX American Society of Cinematographers elevated horror Grammys Academy Awards Bravo A24 Esquire 2020 emmy awards lord of the rings romance 2017 casting animated live action Interview jamie lee curtis cancelled TV series canceled TV shows king arthur dexter cops royal family Discovery Channel Pride Month Sneak Peek Pixar RT21 Polls and Games toronto crime drama science fiction batman BET Awards TLC GLAAD live event finale OWN golden globes Acorn TV unscripted reviews Hallmark Classic Film game of thrones Reality Competition biopic Paramount Plus canceled Freeform NBC Thanksgiving marvel cinematic universe 2021 free movies Apple jurassic park zombie zero dark thirty scary movies critics child's play sports scary Prime Video nature indie BAFTA PaleyFest Teen gangster Fox Searchlight DirecTV scorecard indiana jones IFC TBS screenings cancelled television discovery Christmas HFPA Hallmark Christmas movies TCA Awards NYCC diversity Crunchyroll Fargo movies japan President space Film Festival Film heist movie classics comedies Apple TV Plus SDCC documentary football telelvision independent strong female leads Shudder aliens cartoon documentaries new star wars movies Premiere Dates joker Podcast australia screen actors guild Red Carpet anime SundanceTV foreign best die hard trailers 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Disney streaming service Black History Month japanese VH1 asian-american black adventure 21st Century Fox doctor who Black Mirror Instagram Live psycho renewed TV shows CNN Set visit Tumblr BBC One Cartoon Network docuseries Turner Classic Movies CBS All Access olympics Pet Sematary mission: impossible Comics on TV hollywood Pirates Ellie Kemper king kong Cannes Disney Plus mockumentary Sony Pictures mob worst deadpool pirates of the caribbean Hulu blockbusters Comic Book video on demand Peacock Marathons criterion crime Netflix Christmas movies cancelled TV shows 4/20 breaking bad rt labs critics edition OneApp natural history docudrama ESPN fast and furious video Alien YouTube Premium Netflix GIFs Super Bowl singing competition Amazon Studios christmas movies Starz Captain marvel Rock disaster laika Fantasy nbcuniversal Ghostbusters hist Adult Swim ABC Family godzilla Infographic rotten movies we love Elton John basketball james bond technology Exclusive Video universal monsters 007 ratings CMT El Rey FX supernatural FX on Hulu theme song The Walt Disney Company superman genre cars Broadway Lifetime kaiju miniseries Holiday films women venice dc Emmy Nominations Anna Paquin cinemax spanish harry potter Syfy boxing See It Skip It cats Reality IMDb TV twilight slashers cooking VICE dogs vs. Spring TV Britbox Rocky series Television Critics Association Spectrum Originals Valentine's Day Paramount Tubi AMC Plus black comedy Comedy Central stop motion medical drama italian ViacomCBS PBS crime thriller know your critic movie comiccon 2015 Summer Warner Bros. spain Election dreamworks Trivia Travel Channel Heroines Rom-Com transformers travel Musical Shondaland Oscars zombies Women's History Month TV One ABC Signature witnail Hear Us Out Family Superheroes Countdown HBO Max DGA DC streaming service 24 frames halloween Lucasfilm Awards YA teaser WarnerMedia tv talk leaderboard comic books Television Academy Tarantino Lionsgate Toys psychological thriller Showtime vampires archives 99% wonder woman boxoffice Turner Brie Larson Amazon Prime Video Disney+ Disney Plus LGBT green book Marvel cults Year in Review adaptation The Purge game show 72 Emmy Awards Disney kong Quiz TCM TV movies TCA Legendary Box Office feel good Mudbound ABC justice league USA quibi new york Columbia Pictures rt labs Extras GoT superhero Watching Series MSNBC aapi spider-man Fox News marvel comics what to watch Disney Channel Dark Horse Comics spinoff Drama First Reviews Comic-Con@Home 2021 20th Century Fox Baby Yoda blaxploitation National Geographic rom-coms Hollywood Foreign Press Association History Image Comics TV Land based on movie Cosplay Universal Kids & Family Tokyo Olympics 45 Nominations Creative Arts Emmys Mary Poppins Returns Star Trek posters Sundance TV ITV Animation hidden camera ghosts debate Epix 1990s golden globe awards art house Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dragons 93rd Oscars sequel Schedule suspense composers LGBTQ slasher new zealand Amazon Prime TV mutant south america The Academy name the review comic book movie stoner 2016 IFC Films Sci-Fi Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CW Seed award winner richard e. Grant 90s MCU politics TNT critic resources Nat Geo Lifetime Christmas movies dceu target Chernobyl Apple TV+ 2019 war spider-verse ID Calendar 73rd Emmy Awards high school a nightmare on elm street true crime historical drama Mary Tyler Moore serial killer The Walking Dead Character Guide Arrowverse TruTV Sundance Logo spy thriller HBO Go festival news