Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Lorax is Good, But Not Tree-mendous

Plus, Project X is a bummer of a party.

by | March 1, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an animated eco-parable (The Lorax, with voice work from Zac Efron and Taylor Swift) and a wild party (Project X, starring Thomas Mann and Oliver Cooper). What do the critics have to say?



The Lorax

54%

Delightful as Dr. Seuss’ books are, they aren’t all that long, so it can’t be easy to adapt them to the big screen. The critics say The Lorax sometimes feels padded with action and musical numbers, but on the whole, it’s bright and colorful, and it delivers a solid message about protecting the planet. Ted (Zac Efron) is a youngster who ventures beyond the seemingly idyllic confines of Thneedville and discovers that greed has led to deforestation, despite the warnings of the diminutive orange tree defender the Lorax (Danny DeVito). The pundits say The Lorax does a nice job of capturing the visual style of Seuss’ book, and it contains some solid gags, but it’s also so busy and action-packed that it mostly forgoes the whimsy (and the message) of its source. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down DeVito’s best-reviewed movies).



Project X

28%

Just when you think every idea for a teen party comedy has been exhausted, along comes the mockumetary Project X, which purports to capture the wild goings-on of a particularly raging kegger. Unfortunately, critics say the film is mostly a mean-spirited wallow into areas better explored in Animal House and Superbad. A trio of nerds decides to throw a birthday party in order to increase their social standing; bedlam (and would-be hilarity) ensues. The pundits say Project X might have merited some laughs if it bothered developing its characters, but as it stands, it’s essentially just a string of “outrageous” incidents that test the bounds of good taste.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Zach K for guessing Tyler Perry’s Good Deeds‘ 31 percent Tomatometer, and to Ben C for guessing Gone‘s 11 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Cannes richard e. Grant DirecTV spinoff cinemax VICE TLC DC Universe singing competition worst movies dexter LGBT Star Trek foreign crossover Tokyo Olympics PaleyFest remakes spain know your critic comic NYCC psychological thriller BBC 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Trophy Talk Elton John WarnerMedia Chernobyl dreamworks black comedy FXX Super Bowl satire Universal MTV 2017 monster movies critic resources stoner Disney Channel anthology spider-man facebook japanese Drama spider-verse Shudder cars quibi TV Land TNT ABC Signature Travel Channel kong MCU black directors SundanceTV comic books space Binge Guide prank Film Festival The Walking Dead TCM 79th Golden Globes Awards hist Set visit Masterpiece james bond HBO Max spy thriller Turner A24 football casting GLAAD nfl canceled TV shows finale Black Mirror Summer NBC San Diego Comic-Con worst Certified Fresh DC streaming service hispanic hollywood independent miniseries ViacomCBS Spike Action Holidays franchise FOX 2015 Bravo zombie heist movie Hallmark Christmas movies Starz dc new zealand versus Captain marvel king kong jurassic park series docudrama Country Pride Month political drama cancelled TV shows Television Critics Association HBO Go best hispanic heritage month live action Superheroe adventure FX on Hulu batman Mystery travel Endgame supernatural Podcast movie Apple TV+ vampires legend die hard sopranos breaking bad Valentine's Day Image Comics debate IFC Films See It Skip It Teen stand-up comedy thriller concert TCA Awards TBS FX Thanksgiving adenture Winter TV comedies royal family news 2016 marvel cinematic universe GIFs kids scary pirates of the caribbean teaser green book Amazon Prime Video WGN Pirates Women's History Month lord of the rings The Witch saw unscripted Heroines 99% Sundance Now ESPN Awards Syfy Watching Series mission: impossible spanish language Tarantino classics rt archives natural history cops CBS All Access child's play History USA crime critics Tumblr 2020 APB women cancelled dceu movies New York Comic Con Hollywood Foreign Press Association YA chucky slasher Warner Bros. olympics action-comedy Broadway Reality Competition young adult Biopics Comedy Britbox australia binge Sneak Peek deadpool all-time TV renewals scorecard TV One Crunchyroll live event composers Best and Worst BBC America Western The Arrangement reviews free movies Black History Month Amazon romantic comedy CW Seed fresh blockbuster strong female leads Star Wars The Walt Disney Company Creative Arts Emmys zombies talk show YouTube Red Trivia 90s TV international IMDb TV emmy awards period drama Interview Polls and Games latino cartoon NBA Disney Plus revenge halloween Calendar Sony Pictures Marvel Television Food Network what to watch 2021 razzies SXSW First Look cancelled television sequels technology Fantasy high school crime drama sag awards rom-coms social media Schedule true crime blaxploitation rt labs critics edition aapi MSNBC french Baby Yoda Extras renewed TV shows toy story south america Turner Classic Movies venice Lucasfilm Hulu basketball HBO comiccon 71st Emmy Awards Holiday video Netflix new york Grammys Video Games Netflix Christmas movies CMT AMC Musical LGBTQ Cartoon Network Emmy Nominations blockbusters docuseries boxing Nominations Mudbound Adult Swim Pet Sematary dogs genre Universal Pictures werewolf Showtime Tags: Comedy biopic feel good Arrowverse Mary Tyler Moore cats documentary Reality universal monsters leaderboard medical drama ABC Family boxoffice new star wars movies cancelled TV series First Reviews Television Academy Emmys Paramount Network BET sequel Dark Horse Comics streaming movies disaster Ellie Kemper aliens police drama Disney streaming service Rocketman RT21 Horror 007 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina YouTube Premium Toys 20th Century Fox 2019 Nickelodeon rotten movies we love President criterion zero dark thirty comic book movies Writers Guild of America SDCC Crackle Epix tv talk festival Wes Anderson ghosts ID godzilla elevated horror spanish 45 Pop TV Logo screen actors guild Prime Video Shondaland Exclusive Video Premiere Dates Hallmark Freeform justice league National Geographic PlayStation cooking cults Walt Disney Pictures romance Apple Animation indiana jones USA Network award winner 24 frames 73rd Emmy Awards documentaries Cosplay sitcom YouTube Fall TV Character Guide Infographic rotten wonder woman Fox Searchlight Photos transformers game show HFPA Rom-Com The CW Lionsgate ratings Classic Film Rock BBC One Fox News marvel comics IFC Rocky A&E book Christmas superhero Sundance TV witnail Lifetime Christmas movies fast and furious Discovery Channel psycho trophy screenings mcc science fiction diversity Peacock Pop CBS Countdown name the review American Society of Cinematographers BAFTA canceled mob Anna Paquin golden globe awards jamie lee curtis serial killer Avengers italian target laika Academy Awards Apple TV Plus Winners rt labs Stephen King 4/20 Ovation streaming Song of Ice and Fire Vudu popular posters a nightmare on elm street mutant Sundance Spring TV Comics on TV Marvel parents Trailer AMC Plus Mary Poppins Returns slashers 72 Emmy Awards superman Paramount crime thriller Sci-Fi Music Musicals Amazon Studios Mary poppins Columbia Pictures TCA nature indie TV movies war TCA 2017 The Purge films discovery doctor who VH1 biography E3 Brie Larson Opinion twilight 93rd Oscars scary movies historical drama 21st Century Fox Nat Geo anime comic book movie dark Esquire Ghostbusters DC Comics Spectrum Originals Comic-Con@Home 2021 The Academy Superheroes book adaptation DGA TCA Winter 2020 Tubi Comic Book based on movie CNN asian-american trailers Election scene in color PBS christmas movies kaiju stop motion adaptation halloween tv TruTV toronto nbcuniversal festivals king arthur Quiz joker Mindy Kaling sports E! Disney+ Disney Plus telelvision Tomatazos golden globes OneApp ABC 2018 Year in Review Legendary Kids & Family dragons theme song animated archives hidden camera Oscars Box Office Hear Us Out 1990s Paramount Plus japan reboot OWN obituary El Rey Lifetime video on demand Instagram Live mockumentary GoT art house Martial Arts robots game of thrones VOD Red Carpet Neflix Awards Tour BET Awards harry potter Disney children's TV Marathons Fargo Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Family Marvel Studios politics Pixar Amazon Prime comics ITV television gangster TIFF RT History Film dramedy X-Men Comedy Central Pacific Islander Funimation vs. suspense Alien Acorn TV