Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Identical Won't Leave You All Shook Up

Plus, No No: A Dockumentary is a fascinating portrait of a trailblazing ballplayer, and Wetlands is wild and transgressive.

by | September 5, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got just one wide release: The Identical, starring Blake Rayne, Ashley Judd, and Ray Liotta in the fictional story of an Elvis-esque rocker and his twin brother. What do the critics have to say?

The Identical


It’s a heartbreaking — and undeniably intriguing — bit of trivia that every Elvis Presley fan knows: the King had an identical twin brother who was stillborn. What would have happened had Jesse Presley survived? Unfortunately, critics say The Identical takes this premise and squanders it on a schmaltzy, unintentionally funny plot sprinkled with bland tunes and uneven performances. Blake Rayne plays a dual role as brothers separated by birth. One grows up to become a rock ‘n’ roll pioneer, and the other is expected to join the ministry — though he finds the lure of music hard to resist. The pundits say The Identical is well-meaning but surprisingly ham-fisted; it’s a movie about a rock star that’s short on edge or memorable music.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • No No: A Dockumentary, a portrait of Pittsburgh Pirates pitcher Dock Ellis and the no-hitter he threw while on acid, is at 100 percent.

  • Wetlands, a transgressive dramedy about a teenager who acts out while dealing with her parents’ divorce, is at 94 percent.

  • Last Days in Vietnam, a documentary about the evacuation of South Vietnamese collaborators from Saigon, is at 92 percent.

  • Memphis, a drama about a few days in the life of a troubled soul singer, is at 75 percent.

  • God Help the Girl, starring Emily Browning in a coming-of-age comedy directed by Belle and Sebastian’s Stuart Murdoch, is at 71 percent.

  • Thunder and the House of Magic, an animated adventure about a cat who moves into a magician’s house, is at 68 percent.

  • Kelly & Cal, starring Juliette Lewis in a drama about an alienated suburban mom who befirends a teen from the neighborhood, is at 64 percent.

  • Trailer Park Boys: Don’t Legalize It, featuring the Canadian goofballs in a mockumentary about keeping marijuana illegal so as not to hurt their thriving business, is at 57 percent.

  • Frontera, starring Ed Harris and Michael Peña in a drama about a murder investigation along the Mexico-Arizona border, is at 55 percent.

  • The Longest Week, starring Jason Bateman and Olivia Wilde in a comedy about a writer who moves in with his best friend and falls in love with his girlfriend, is at 22 percent.

  • Innocence, a dark drama about a troubled girl at a sinister boarding school, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

biography disaster Exclusive Video monster movies blockbuster cartoon Columbia Pictures TCA Awards Martial Arts Marvel Studios superhero HBO Max art house Nat Geo festivals sequel Premiere Dates 20th Century Fox BBC One razzies ABC Best Picture IMDb TV Star Trek El Rey Indigenous anthology live event Discovery Channel Epix remakes Sundance 73rd Emmy Awards Watching Series Acorn TV See It Skip It slashers Television Academy Spike gangster Brie Larson chucky rt archives films summer TV preview Kids & Family comiccon Mudbound Amazon Studios archives new star wars movies Cartoon Network women canceled Best Director Certified Fresh children's TV marvel comics TIFF know your critic heist movie Music dceu rt labs Oscar screen actors guild MTV Mindy Kaling BAFTA Star Wars Celebration adaptation Starz Box Office FX The CW tv talk feel good Creative Arts Emmys supernatural japan franchise comics deadpool Rom-Com scorecard Arrowverse romantic comedy Song of Ice and Fire Legendary Adult Swim Animation 79th Golden Globes Awards spider-man halloween Alien CNN serial killer Spectrum Originals Film pirates of the caribbean animated medical drama Trophy Talk young adult Paramount Prime Video Drama toronto A&E golden globes scary summer preview Nominations VH1 police drama halloween tv Sci-Fi Trailer adventure Walt Disney Pictures ghosts The Academy Binge Guide cancelled television 2018 adenture BET Comedy Central name the review vampires Focus Features Holiday australia television NYCC Super Bowl fast and furious worst AMC aliens ABC Signature french Anna Paquin WGN posters based on movie Pixar cancelled singing competition SDCC award winner debate mob spider-verse comic books interviews LGBTQ AMC Plus series spy thriller dc mission: impossible suspense facebook Bravo trophy a nightmare on elm street Sundance Now nature cooking E3 Pirates DC streaming service Opinion South by Southwest Film Festival zombies Country NBA Travel Channel festival Family Photos Christmas ABC Family Crackle Election 45 Sundance TV Western Syfy slasher GLAAD Biopics Turner Classic Movies japanese 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards First Reviews President best christmas movies doctor who Disney Channel Pop Apple TV Plus composers mockumentary Best Actress crime drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt RT21 2016 Amazon Prime Video war Classic Film SXSW football target zero dark thirty First Look Elton John discovery Nickelodeon international Rock Oscars dramedy die hard Hear Us Out Vudu HFPA cops cars ratings VOD Video Games 90s Marvel video on demand Shudder jurassic park Trivia reboot blaxploitation period drama king arthur Geeked Week sopranos movie scene in color film series kaiju TLC ITV scene in color series twilight concert unscripted Disney MSNBC emmy awards Writers Guild of America cinemax Peacock Comic Book witnail Holidays new york obi wan stoner SundanceTV OWN Tomatazos Calendar 99% aapi Universal Paramount Pictures marvel cinematic universe movies indie Lionsgate strong female leads what to watch Best and Worst Heroines live action classics TV One Character Guide Cannes DGA Netflix TV Black History Month politics 2019 royal family TCA 2017 jamie lee curtis Cosplay quibi FXX Paramount Network Shondaland superman Pride Month Awards Amazon DC Universe Fargo Hollywood Foreign Press Association Rocky james bond Funimation Lifetime Podcast Esquire travel crossover Neflix hist streaming movies natural history WarnerMedia Image Comics transformers Dark Horse Comics cults Apple TV+ kids Musical Stephen King National Geographic new zealand 71st Emmy Awards golden globe awards Emmy Nominations rotten movies we love Sneak Peek 21st Century Fox social media BBC America Superheroe harry potter Musicals Television Critics Association justice league streamig Infographic Fantasy Amazon Prime MGM Winter TV Academy Awards IFC Films sports Netflix Christmas movies Fox News Schedule Wes Anderson LGBT prank Best Actor green book foreign 72 Emmy Awards genre miniseries NBC game of thrones USA Paramount Plus ID Avengers HBO rotten robots finale TCM nfl spanish streaming Emmys Grammys Chilling Adventures of Sabrina critic resources Pop TV History Summer asian-american dexter GoT boxoffice Thanksgiving kong Comics on TV CMT mcc criterion technology crime Toys CW Seed E! broadcast dark PBS werewolf HBO Go 1990s science fiction versus elevated horror PaleyFest Instagram Live documentary TCA Winter 2020 Reality Competition rt labs critics edition Crunchyroll sitcom SXSW 2022 Tubi RT History dogs Set visit comic olympics toy story Warner Bros. X-Men space talk show Red Carpet 007 Sony Pictures south america Film Festival richard e. Grant 2017 Tokyo Olympics basketball Star Wars breaking bad parents political drama The Purge Comic-Con@Home 2021 PlayStation lord of the rings stop motion Food Network wonder woman Freeform Ovation Interview Pet Sematary Year in Review blockbusters TV movies true crime video TBS Action Awards Tour saw Turner Tumblr Logo black comedy Lucasfilm Comedy Fall TV YA Apple Black Mirror laika Mary poppins all-time mutant king kong thriller Chernobyl The Walt Disney Company diversity game show latino Marathons BET Awards legend venice Women's History Month psychological thriller binge 4/20 MCU Broadway joker Disney streaming service ESPN 24 frames VICE comedies The Arrangement YouTube Ellie Kemper comic book movies godzilla obituary Disney Plus OneApp comic book movie Baby Yoda free movies high school hidden camera theme song book TNT Mary Tyler Moore Mystery telelvision YouTube Premium New York Comic Con Extras Hallmark hollywood Britbox 2020 dreamworks sequels ViacomCBS spanish language docuseries 94th Oscars Superheroes satire romance black Marvel Television Spring TV critics APB cancelled TV series screenings historical drama dragons cancelled TV shows YouTube Red 2021 boxing spain Rocketman summer TV TV Land crime thriller casting batman Teen GIFs Fox Searchlight Disney+ Disney Plus canceled TV shows news fresh hispanic vs. reviews BBC Ghostbusters DirecTV TCA indiana jones trailers Showtime Sony Countdown worst movies hispanic heritage month Pacific Islander child's play Universal Pictures Hulu Reality Horror CBS All Access anime A24 Lifetime Christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns Native independent Masterpiece action-comedy FOX documentaries book adaptation docudrama FX on Hulu Valentine's Day USA Network Hallmark Christmas movies stand-up comedy universal monsters Polls and Games italian renewed TV shows Tarantino TV renewals Tags: Comedy target scene in color scene in color Winners revenge biopic zombie IFC The Witch Quiz CBS Endgame Captain marvel San Diego Comic-Con popular The Walking Dead directors nbcuniversal spinoff teaser cats American Society of Cinematographers DC Comics scary movies sag awards TruTV psycho 93rd Oscars rom-coms leaderboard 2015