Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is on Solid Ground

Plus, Tyler Perry's A Madea Christmas wasn't screened for critics, and American Hustle and Saving Mr. Banks are Certified Fresh.

by | December 13, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a journey through Middle-earth (The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug, starring Martin Freeman and Ian McKellen) and some yuletide shenanigans (Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas, starring Tyler Perry and Kathy Najimy). What do the critics have to say?

The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug


OK, so here’s the bad news: critics say The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is overlong and overstuffed with characters and subplots that are likely to mean little to all but the most devoted of Tolkien fans. The good news? They also say it’s a step up from An Unexpected Journey, in that it’s better paced and more action-packed. This time, our heroes Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) and Gandalf (Ian McKellen) are on a journey to Lonely Mountain, encountering giant spiders, elves, and a human/bear hybrid as part of their mission to wrest control of a lost Dwarf kingdom from Smaug, a terrifying dragon. The pundits say the first two Hobbit movies have yet to approach the depth and sweep of the Lord of the Rings films, but Smaug mostly succeeds as both a middle chapter and a rousing fantasy adventure in its own right. (For lots more on The Desolation Of Smaug and the LOTR films, check out Hobbit Headquarters.)

Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas


A Madea Christmas, like most of Tyler Perry’s output, was not screened for critics prior to its release in theaters. When an old friend decides to pay a surprise visit to her daughter, she talks Madea (Perry) into tagging along; soon our irrepressible heroine is shaking up a small town’s Christmas carnival. Time to guess the Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

ID debate Prime Video composers Tubi YouTube Travel Channel BBC Best Actor Hollywood Foreign Press Association jurassic park Chernobyl BET Awards slasher A&E docudrama Universal HBO Go facebook Freeform scene in color film series concert The Academy MGM christmas movies Musical zombies ViacomCBS television Acorn TV Brie Larson cooking spanish book adaptation scorecard discovery Sundance Now scary movies Marvel TNT Family Fantasy Apple Disney streaming service OneApp 90s Avengers target scene in color toronto spain natural history heist movie broadcast thriller travel dark romance 2020 Interview docuseries WarnerMedia slashers 72 Emmy Awards football singing competition strong female leads Nat Geo Sony Pictures psychological thriller pirates of the caribbean Writers Guild of America new york Rom-Com Toys Calendar Ellie Kemper HFPA archives serial killer witnail Box Office revenge streamig FX WGN doctor who Arrowverse ABC Epix Election Columbia Pictures high school rotten movies we love Comics on TV Elton John 21st Century Fox Kids & Family Sneak Peek worst medical drama sag awards indiana jones franchise Instagram Live Anna Paquin documentaries basketball TruTV best chucky TCA Winter 2020 crime thriller Esquire 2019 canceled Hallmark elevated horror superhero art house Women's History Month Warner Bros. Marvel Television The Arrangement all-time indie YouTube Premium versus anthology Lionsgate screen actors guild legend The Walt Disney Company Nominations Mary poppins Sundance mockumentary 73rd Emmy Awards Comedy Captain marvel movies golden globe awards Holidays Grammys Biopics The Walking Dead The CW Valentine's Day mob Hear Us Out Sundance TV Broadway Binge Guide reboot halloween animated die hard feel good Crunchyroll Tarantino japanese scene in color Pixar laika king arthur Pop TV Starz Tomatazos rt labs critics edition hist Summer 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards MSNBC trophy Reality Competition golden globes Paramount Pictures 93rd Oscars streaming movies disaster APB Classic Film police drama Mary Tyler Moore social media CW Seed HBO Max science fiction Amazon Studios Photos IFC History Marvel Studios Sony Stephen King YouTube Red Extras First Reviews Black Mirror live event rt labs superman VICE biopic award winner BBC America YA Exclusive Video stand-up comedy Year in Review OWN Food Network Comedy Central 2017 Ovation Syfy Thanksgiving action-comedy IMDb TV reviews interviews Holiday TCM biography children's TV PBS DC Universe Oscar cults boxing 79th Golden Globes Awards TIFF scary ITV comiccon Paramount Network Certified Fresh TV renewals Pride Month Mary Poppins Returns Turner Classic Movies joker fresh TV One parents GLAAD kids USA Network Premiere Dates directors adenture boxoffice live action monster movies 99% crime drama game of thrones Crackle Pirates VOD rom-coms Countdown Winter TV NYCC popular Tumblr young adult renewed TV shows emmy awards deadpool king kong critics Wes Anderson posters telelvision know your critic Hulu Walt Disney Pictures Showtime comic teaser 94th Oscars werewolf Film Festival BBC One comic books french TV Watching Series FX on Hulu Mystery GoT rt archives TCA 2017 technology cats unscripted Focus Features satire HBO Shondaland Sci-Fi kong ABC Signature Paramount 2015 A24 twilight trailers cars true crime independent Mudbound LGBTQ critic resources Best and Worst Star Trek vs. mcc ghosts crime Tokyo Olympics Amazon RT21 cancelled TV series dramedy video Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt based on movie summer TV 71st Emmy Awards Superheroe vampires romantic comedy Indigenous E! dragons universal monsters a nightmare on elm street The Purge binge rotten Turner transformers Lucasfilm 20th Century Fox 2016 Dark Horse Comics dc Baby Yoda wonder woman Apple TV+ classics comedies MTV Rock Endgame Oscars Hallmark Christmas movies hidden camera Marathons 4/20 jamie lee curtis 45 series leaderboard foreign international Television Academy spider-verse justice league Legendary venice richard e. Grant free movies australia Country historical drama adventure book Reality period drama Rocky VH1 hispanic heritage month Western 2021 Lifetime Pet Sematary toy story documentary TLC south america 007 Musicals ratings cancelled TV shows mutant genre Best Director finale tv talk American Society of Cinematographers black comedy SundanceTV obituary BAFTA comic book movies festivals green book Comic Book The Witch See It Skip It BET LGBT 24 frames sports SDCC Christmas breaking bad Fox News criterion nbcuniversal theme song National Geographic razzies james bond Vudu Native DirecTV new star wars movies Netflix crossover TCA GIFs batman Winners robots Geeked Week Fall TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Drama Image Comics Adult Swim Song of Ice and Fire nfl game show New York Comic Con miniseries Masterpiece Action Paramount Plus black blockbuster casting Star Wars CNN CBS All Access sequel Red Carpet italian TCA Awards Video Games godzilla Comic-Con@Home 2021 Spike Netflix Christmas movies Spectrum Originals new zealand suspense Film worst movies women comics gangster political drama summer preview Creative Arts Emmys movie spanish language festival TBS cops films Academy Awards 1990s Trailer Britbox adaptation Trophy Talk Animation harry potter PlayStation Rocketman Heroines Television Critics Association royal family Cartoon Network NBC AMC Plus South by Southwest Film Festival diversity X-Men Disney+ Disney Plus stoner ESPN RT History Podcast hispanic zero dark thirty child's play marvel cinematic universe zombie Mindy Kaling scene in color series DC Comics Quiz Horror Emmys MCU El Rey Best Actress dreamworks remakes marvel comics hollywood kaiju dceu FXX screenings Awards news nature target Fox Searchlight aliens dexter E3 Opinion talk show SXSW 2022 video on demand quibi Trivia Music Super Bowl Shudder 2018 Infographic TV movies Pacific Islander Pop saw Polls and Games name the review Tags: Comedy Funimation blaxploitation Peacock lord of the rings Amazon Prime Video CBS cartoon Spring TV fast and furious canceled TV shows President Disney First Look aapi Emmy Nominations politics Awards Tour USA sitcom latino olympics CMT supernatural ABC Family sequels streaming San Diego Comic-Con Character Guide Logo spy thriller spider-man Schedule what to watch Martial Arts spinoff FOX japan Set visit NBA cancelled television DC streaming service prank Star Wars Celebration Lifetime Christmas movies dogs Universal Pictures comic book movie Fargo Bravo anime DGA asian-american Neflix Black History Month Superheroes space summer TV preview SXSW Ghostbusters Disney Plus halloween tv cinemax mission: impossible Disney Channel Amazon Prime stop motion blockbusters Nickelodeon AMC Discovery Channel Cosplay Apple TV Plus Alien IFC Films sopranos Best Picture PaleyFest war Teen obi wan psycho TV Land Cannes cancelled