Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is on Solid Ground

Plus, Tyler Perry's A Madea Christmas wasn't screened for critics, and American Hustle and Saving Mr. Banks are Certified Fresh.

by | December 13, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a journey through Middle-earth (The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug, starring Martin Freeman and Ian McKellen) and some yuletide shenanigans (Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas, starring Tyler Perry and Kathy Najimy). What do the critics have to say?

The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug


OK, so here’s the bad news: critics say The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug is overlong and overstuffed with characters and subplots that are likely to mean little to all but the most devoted of Tolkien fans. The good news? They also say it’s a step up from An Unexpected Journey, in that it’s better paced and more action-packed. This time, our heroes Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) and Gandalf (Ian McKellen) are on a journey to Lonely Mountain, encountering giant spiders, elves, and a human/bear hybrid as part of their mission to wrest control of a lost Dwarf kingdom from Smaug, a terrifying dragon. The pundits say the first two Hobbit movies have yet to approach the depth and sweep of the Lord of the Rings films, but Smaug mostly succeeds as both a middle chapter and a rousing fantasy adventure in its own right. (For lots more on The Desolation Of Smaug and the LOTR films, check out Hobbit Headquarters.)

Tyler Perry’s A Madea Christmas


A Madea Christmas, like most of Tyler Perry’s output, was not screened for critics prior to its release in theaters. When an old friend decides to pay a surprise visit to her daughter, she talks Madea (Perry) into tagging along; soon our irrepressible heroine is shaking up a small town’s Christmas carnival. Time to guess the Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Fantasy Sundance Now Video Games ITV laika Quiz adaptation MSNBC ID Trophy Talk critics jurassic park Sneak Peek Holidays Musical Infographic TV Adult Swim women Polls and Games TV renewals A24 live action Action spinoff italian toronto Discovery Channel Disney streaming service Black Mirror Nat Geo Emmys indiana jones prank golden globes comedies Biopics RT History hist Mary Tyler Moore royal family Opinion science fiction sitcom Fall TV concert Toys razzies Food Network black comedy spanish language doctor who police drama scary psycho game show TCA Winter 2020 sequels critic resources deadpool discovery Disney Channel true crime Marvel Studios blockbuster Baby Yoda reboot TCA Awards Interview rt labs critics edition cats NYCC films Music genre blaxploitation leaderboard festivals Chernobyl blockbusters diversity Arrowverse zombies Mudbound Warner Bros. Comedy Spring TV 93rd Oscars cancelled TV series Super Bowl BBC rt archives Comics on TV nfl all-time TNT 2017 marvel comics Funimation Valentine's Day Reality feel good IFC Martial Arts ESPN Apple TV+ Superheroes Horror foreign rotten harry potter Binge Guide Bravo trailers Mary Poppins Returns Pop new zealand free movies tv talk WGN mockumentary target Anna Paquin boxoffice Disney HBO Max CBS trophy rt labs high school comiccon Britbox talk show Tubi slashers screen actors guild USA Network HFPA scorecard telelvision classics disaster comic book movie Watching Series Disney+ Disney Plus GIFs Set visit casting Rocky psychological thriller facebook Classic Film AMC 1990s comic Alien TV movies festival renewed TV shows strong female leads supernatural Marvel Lifetime Christmas movies Pixar ghosts composers 99% book adaptation Ovation BET Awards FOX Fox News TIFF monster movies witnail worst movies kids cults 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards period drama LGBT 73rd Emmy Awards best Hear Us Out dogs Pop TV parents cars dexter Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TLC quibi french Writers Guild of America Tarantino 2020 war New York Comic Con cooking FX on Hulu OWN cancelled CMT Box Office Year in Review 72 Emmy Awards PlayStation Amazon Prime Video Amazon Prime NBA NBC singing competition San Diego Comic-Con spanish LGBTQ Elton John james bond politics fresh Disney Plus Winter TV art house independent Travel Channel slasher reviews Peacock legend Brie Larson historical drama Starz serial killer BAFTA christmas movies CNN Grammys marvel cinematic universe Trivia transformers Awards Tour History book spider-verse cancelled TV shows Rocketman Countdown Kids & Family Freeform animated kong Neflix Creative Arts Emmys Premiere Dates zombie Christmas aapi mob cinemax Drama black crime drama justice league game of thrones sequel movie Universal Lifetime 45 posters king arthur young adult scene in color PBS biography thriller 007 TBS VICE Hulu The Arrangement TCM 2019 fast and furious Prime Video 71st Emmy Awards series sports award winner miniseries anthology E3 Cartoon Network RT21 Heroines American Society of Cinematographers Dark Horse Comics comic books Netflix Christmas movies WarnerMedia aliens Animation TCA Avengers superman Turner Classic Movies Thanksgiving Summer nbcuniversal rotten movies we love Paramount Plus SundanceTV CBS All Access Masterpiece wonder woman Esquire Paramount Stephen King Sundance TV video child's play adventure Mary poppins name the review vampires international CW Seed Hallmark Christmas movies green book werewolf sag awards crossover south america 2021 revenge Family binge APB comic book movies Western Television Critics Association Winners President 2015 Nickelodeon ABC Family DirecTV anime news Netflix streaming Lionsgate Nominations ViacomCBS teaser cartoon Superheroe rom-coms finale Crunchyroll documentaries travel Syfy See It Skip It stoner halloween tv Comic-Con@Home 2021 Black History Month breaking bad TCA 2017 Vudu E! screenings dramedy 90s lord of the rings GoT hollywood Holiday adenture PaleyFest pirates of the caribbean docuseries hidden camera crime YouTube Premium emmy awards docudrama Best and Worst dreamworks Lucasfilm action-comedy canceled TV shows Universal Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Character Guide Film Tokyo Olympics IMDb TV 24 frames Podcast Image Comics latino batman Mindy Kaling basketball medical drama Pet Sematary twilight DGA Star Trek Ghostbusters dceu TV One GLAAD A&E DC Comics 4/20 new york 2016 gangster Apple TV Plus ABC Signature movies dc richard e. Grant The Witch YouTube Pacific Islander FX ABC Certified Fresh Tumblr Emmy Nominations boxing SDCC IFC Films Extras stop motion 79th Golden Globes Awards The Purge Comic Book hispanic VH1 worst Showtime BBC One mcc sopranos Shondaland The Walt Disney Company Tags: Comedy MCU australia Trailer Musicals TV Land king kong Academy Awards children's TV Wes Anderson football japan AMC Plus Hollywood Foreign Press Association die hard venice asian-american comics technology Logo Endgame First Look Oscars saw Pride Month television Hallmark live event OneApp Exclusive Video X-Men streaming movies space debate Comedy Central The Academy HBO BBC America godzilla HBO Go 2018 Sci-Fi Women's History Month joker Acorn TV Turner based on movie 20th Century Fox hispanic heritage month Columbia Pictures Sony Pictures Instagram Live YA kaiju National Geographic obituary MTV halloween SXSW El Rey natural history directors a nightmare on elm street indie Pirates FXX scary movies Marvel Television First Reviews Red Carpet cancelled television Mystery DC Universe Walt Disney Pictures 21st Century Fox stand-up comedy VOD Broadway Film Festival mutant archives Marathons spy thriller vs. BET ratings nature Captain marvel Television Academy dragons The CW toy story Election Ellie Kemper canceled japanese olympics golden globe awards Photos criterion mission: impossible DC streaming service what to watch heist movie spain YouTube Red Fargo universal monsters Paramount Network TruTV USA popular superhero chucky know your critic Epix romantic comedy Fox Searchlight Schedule franchise elevated horror Apple Awards Song of Ice and Fire documentary Amazon Studios new star wars movies Reality Competition Country crime thriller theme song video on demand Cosplay romance unscripted biopic The Walking Dead satire Spectrum Originals Spike Rom-Com Rock Calendar suspense spider-man dark Crackle Legendary Star Wars cops Amazon Shudder versus Teen robots political drama Sundance zero dark thirty remakes social media Cannes jamie lee curtis Tomatazos