Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Green Hornet Recieves Bad Buzz

Plus, The Dilemma misfires as a comedy and a drama.

by | January 14, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an unlikely crime fighter (The Green Hornet, starring Seth Rogen and Jay Chou) and some shaky relationships (The Dilemma, starring Vince Vaughn and Kevin James). What do the critics have to say?


The Green Hornet

The Green Hornet, who began life as the star of a 1930s radio serial, is a little late to the gritty superhero reboot club. And the critics say despite the direction of the oft-whimsical Michel Gondry and the presence of likeable everyman Seth Rogen in the title role, The Green Hornet doesn’t quite succeed as a superhero flick or as a subversive send-up of the genre. Rogen plays the famed vigilante, who teams up with Kato (Jay Chou) to take on the mob after the death of a friend. The pundits say The Green Hornet has moments of inspiration, and that Chou is excellent, but that Gondry’s typical good humor is mostly missing here, resulting in a strange mix of wisecracking and ultra-violence that never quite gels.


The Dilemma

There’s nothing wrong with a comedy that explores the dark side of modern romance – as long as it can make us laugh. Critics say that’s the main problem with Ron Howard’s The Dilemma: it’s not particularly insightful or funny, mucking around in dispiriting territory before bailing out with shopworn slapstick. Vince Vaughn and Kevin James star as a pair of old buds and business partners whose friendship is about to be tested by a big business deal — and the fact that Vaughn has inadvertently learned that James’s wife (played by Winona Ryder) may be having an affair. The pundits say it’s a decent setup, and the cast (particularly Vaughn) is game, but what transpires is more sour than satisfying; The Dilemma‘s pacing problems and tonal shifts undermine both the comedic and dramatic elements of the script. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Ryder’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Petition, a documentary about Chinese citizens patiently seeking justice for government abuses, is at 100 percent.

  • Barney’s Version, a dramedy starring Paul Giamatti as a boorish TV producer, is at 77 percent.

  • A Somewhat Gentle Man, a dark comedy about a gangster who reluctantly takes on a new job, is at 71 percent.

  • Plastic Planet, a doc about the environmental impact of plastic, is at 60 percent.

  • Every Day, starring Liev Schreiber and Helen Hunt in the tale of a family that’s upended when a woman’s father moves in with her, is at 44 percent.

Tag Cloud

target scene in color Baby Yoda hispanic feel good Marvel Television historical drama Image Comics cults all-time summer TV preview screenings Turner Classic Movies 21st Century Fox Hear Us Out action-comedy Adult Swim Tarantino spanish language indiana jones 2018 cancelled television scene in color Chilling Adventures of Sabrina scene in color film series SXSW 2022 Anna Paquin YA Creative Arts Emmys Tubi slashers blaxploitation mockumentary remakes Disney+ Disney Plus Amazon Studios aapi live event festival Neflix Travel Channel golden globes Awards Tour spain game of thrones Lionsgate green book Dark Horse Comics GoT crossover boxing Star Wars Celebration ViacomCBS USA TCA 2017 hollywood comic books suspense politics Holiday japan Disney Plus ghosts independent twilight TV One king arthur video on demand kaiju E3 Polls and Games legend streaming live action broadcast superhero Reality Competition christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con fresh ABC discovery adenture Showtime war Endgame VOD Shondaland rom-coms psychological thriller Funimation know your critic Watching Series dramedy VH1 teaser Sony TLC kids VICE Marathons Superheroes parents justice league YouTube Premium Disney comics scorecard Mary poppins streamig black comedy BBC Mindy Kaling Kids & Family 2017 NYCC Interview elevated horror target natural history Focus Features blockbusters Paramount Plus RT21 festivals breaking bad The CW Nickelodeon Country Pet Sematary Horror heist movie TCA Awards deadpool Western Holidays cinemax king kong Podcast Fargo Pop based on movie emmy awards USA Network Best Actor summer TV Universal Cosplay dc Classic Film Film Festival romance Election Fox Searchlight Disney streaming service FOX foreign cancelled TV series Sundance TV National Geographic Pride Month black IFC Films mob Television Academy The Academy WGN Acorn TV The Purge facebook Legendary Logo Disney Channel Fox News fast and furious toronto rt labs critics edition 2019 Apple TV Plus venice dragons interviews Marvel Winter TV zombies Christmas true crime slasher Comedy Central Cartoon Network news PBS political drama Freeform young adult Syfy critic resources Tags: Comedy technology BBC America Amazon Prime 1990s strong female leads Star Trek Drama 20th Century Fox TV Geeked Week stop motion aliens Mary Poppins Returns MSNBC leaderboard documentaries Toys 73rd Emmy Awards dexter Crunchyroll Marvel Studios TV Land saw boxoffice movies sequel sports Hollywood Foreign Press Association mcc 71st Emmy Awards Britbox A&E TNT Super Bowl video MCU Indigenous children's TV canceled Chernobyl MGM biography critics HBO Go Wes Anderson South by Southwest Film Festival rt archives Valentine's Day Spectrum Originals 4/20 NBC royal family Trophy Talk A24 comic Extras Quiz Arrowverse reviews animated Best Actress Cannes anthology ITV reboot Comic Book Tumblr werewolf obituary 24 frames comic book movie Television Critics Association high school spy thriller archives Pacific Islander halloween Binge Guide nature Year in Review OWN spider-verse crime Ovation godzilla sag awards Reality Mudbound japanese disaster scary docuseries Animation Thanksgiving spanish Alien Musicals Opinion international Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 94th Oscars Summer Best and Worst robots Brie Larson Lucasfilm medical drama Certified Fresh Fall TV summer preview laika vampires GIFs casting rotten movies we love Black History Month science fiction Hallmark Heroines Turner 90s Action New York Comic Con gangster new zealand women lord of the rings PaleyFest Martial Arts Instagram Live Shudder richard e. Grant Premiere Dates streaming movies HFPA theme song The Arrangement harry potter CMT Rock SDCC First Reviews batman die hard worst blockbuster talk show documentary Starz Ellie Kemper space Hulu FXX Awards criterion Schedule jurassic park award winner Tomatazos 72 Emmy Awards 93rd Oscars HBO Max olympics DGA MTV Hallmark Christmas movies zombie ratings Trivia IMDb TV CNN AMC Plus Character Guide 2015 Spike Best Picture BET Awards scary movies 99% Ghostbusters Academy Awards DC streaming service Avengers 007 stoner Discovery Channel adventure basketball HBO comedies universal monsters 45 television History new star wars movies Spring TV Nat Geo APB OneApp spider-man Biopics 79th Golden Globes Awards superman Lifetime Christmas movies Writers Guild of America concert sequels Prime Video sopranos romantic comedy E! The Walking Dead Columbia Pictures 2016 Lifetime Musical zero dark thirty halloween tv RT History popular sitcom TIFF Stephen King Paramount screen actors guild travel Paramount Network Winners BET binge dogs BAFTA LGBTQ south america doctor who Vudu Rom-Com indie police drama Broadway adaptation james bond CBS All Access quibi diversity ABC Family Black Mirror Sci-Fi The Witch DC Universe TV movies Grammys book Walt Disney Pictures films Nominations what to watch crime drama Video Games classics Set visit directors cancelled art house witnail Exclusive Video TBS docudrama period drama WarnerMedia joker Elton John cops FX Box Office Bravo anime composers Mary Tyler Moore movie monster movies YouTube debate Netflix President revenge child's play Comics on TV Epix supernatural miniseries serial killer asian-american golden globe awards Star Wars Amazon Prime Video AMC TCA Winter 2020 hispanic heritage month Sony Pictures Comic-Con@Home 2021 chucky singing competition nbcuniversal PlayStation biopic australia social media kong DirecTV cats Paramount Pictures Universal Pictures french cars 2020 mutant Fantasy Emmy Nominations NBA unscripted new york best Comedy razzies hist Peacock Warner Bros. Native spinoff Masterpiece genre franchise marvel cinematic universe SundanceTV trophy rt labs Rocky Crackle renewed TV shows ID TruTV LGBT game show Superheroe First Look wonder woman trailers Music Infographic comiccon CW Seed psycho TV renewals Pop TV dreamworks cooking Teen DC Comics toy story telelvision free movies Pirates transformers pirates of the caribbean jamie lee curtis BBC One latino a nightmare on elm street GLAAD prank tv talk satire Mystery CBS cartoon rotten hidden camera posters book adaptation finale Oscars Women's History Month Esquire ABC Signature Captain marvel Trailer IFC American Society of Cinematographers thriller Photos versus Sundance canceled TV shows stand-up comedy Netflix Christmas movies El Rey YouTube Red mission: impossible Film Best Director nfl scene in color series Song of Ice and Fire Family Sundance Now crime thriller name the review See It Skip It Countdown Amazon Red Carpet SXSW vs. Food Network worst movies Calendar comic book movies The Walt Disney Company X-Men cancelled TV shows Emmys dark marvel comics italian Apple football Sneak Peek ESPN TCA series Rocketman TCM Oscar Pixar 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 2021 dceu FX on Hulu Tokyo Olympics Apple TV+ obi wan