Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Dark Knight Is One Of The Year's Best-Reviewed

Plus, Mamma Mia! is not a super trouper; Chimps is lost in Space.

by | July 17, 2008 | Comments

This week, we’ve got the Caped Crusader (The Dark Knight, starring
Christian Bale and
Heath Ledger), ABBA aficionados (Mamma Mia!, starring
Meryl Streep and
Amanda Seyfried), and space-bound simians (Space Chimps, with voice work by
Andy Samberg and
Jeff Daniels). What do the critics have to say?

The wait is over, Batfans. And the word is good. Critics are calling The Dark Knight one of the year’s best, a brooding, complex, emotionally wrenching film that plumbs the emotional depths of the Batman mythos. The sequel to the series reboot
Batman Begins, TDK finds Bruce Wayne/ Batman (Christian Bale) tangling with his most iconic archenemy, the Joker (Heath Ledger) — while finding the two have more in common than they’d like to admit. The pundits give kudos all around, from
Christopher Nolan‘s white-knuckle direction and provocative script to the able cast that includes
Michael Caine,
Maggie Gyllenhaal, and
Aaron Eckhart. But much of the critical gushing is reserved for the late Ledger, who plays the Joker like a man possessed (some suggest the Academy should take notice of his performance). At 93 percent on the Tomatometer, The Dark Knight isn’t just Certified Fresh. It’s also the best-reviewed Batman movie of all time, and the third best-reviewed wide release of the year, trailing only
WALL-E at (97 percent) and
Iron Man (at 93 percent). (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we revisit all the Batman movies.)

“If only getting the Time Warner cable guy were this easy.”

It is a fact that you can dance. It is also true that you can jive. However, will you have the time of your life at Mamma Mia? Critics aren’t quite going that far. Meryl Streep stars as a single mother whose daughter (Amanda Seyfried) is about to get married, and has invited three men to her wedding in Greece, trying to determine which is her real father; romance and renditions of “S.O.S.” and “Waterloo” ensue. Nobody denies ABBA’s tunes are darned infections (noted fans include
Sid Vicious and
John McCain), and some pundits concede Mamma Mia! has moments of frothy fun. However, others say the movie is ultimately way too sugary, sentimental, and lightweight to truly satisfy, and though Streep is in fine form, others in the cast don’t fare as well with the musical numbers. At 47 percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes aren’t falling “Head Over Heels” for Mamma Mia!

“Let me show you a fast way to wax the banister.”

Monkeys and chimps were some of the earliest space travelers, so an animated take on their exploits would seem like a sure bet for the kiddies, right? Well, critics aren’t going bananas for the CGI feature
Space Chimps
. Ham III (voiced by Andy Samberg) is the good-for-nothing grandson of a space pioneer who finds himself part of team of chimps who have been blasted through a black hole, where they find a planet ruled by and evil monarch. The pundits say Space Chimps is bland and dull, featuring indifferent animation and a tired storyline that may please really little kids but virtually no one else. At
21 percent on the Tomatometer, these Chimps are lost in space.

The mission: Research the effects of zero gravity on the Tomatometer.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Batman Movies:
84% — Batman Begins (2005)
12% — Batman & Robin (1997)
43% — Batman Forever (1995)
87% — Batman: Mask of the Phantasm (1993)
79% — Batman Returns (1992)
69% — Batman (1989)
80% — Batman: The Movie (1966)

Tag Cloud

Toys zombies WGN Comedy Tomatazos godzilla Universal Pictures Paramount Network HBO Go stand-up comedy Lionsgate Discovery Channel 99% target Quiz chucky dogs ABC Signature indie RT21 Sundance Mindy Kaling TCM Hallmark Christmas movies hidden camera miniseries Winter TV marvel cinematic universe archives Chilling Adventures of Sabrina casting festival Star Wars green book 72 Emmy Awards feel good ghosts DGA superhero 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cancelled SXSW international trophy Captain marvel Premiere Dates Tarantino NBA zero dark thirty Exclusive Video Teen pirates of the caribbean slashers ratings olympics video on demand revenge romance die hard nature Lifetime Christmas movies Summer science fiction Shudder Spring TV true crime Shondaland cancelled TV series Writers Guild of America USA concert Watching Series blockbuster MCU OWN Oscars Pet Sematary critics Thanksgiving The Arrangement ViacomCBS Baby Yoda teaser Trivia Disney streaming service mob transformers Reality Competition harry potter Trophy Talk Cartoon Network PaleyFest TV Land a nightmare on elm street Marvel Studios free movies SundanceTV hist YouTube Red werewolf Logo richard e. Grant comedies comic spy thriller blaxploitation FX Pop TV Syfy Musical Grammys The Academy boxoffice award winner psycho YouTube Premium dark TNT 1990s Family ABC 90s witnail stoner TruTV Epix quibi IFC trailers Marvel Bravo Amazon Prime television Arrowverse TCA Awards comics Rom-Com FXX biography binge Fargo IMDb TV SDCC nbcuniversal kong child's play mockumentary Pirates name the review versus Character Guide Black Mirror scorecard Mystery 73rd Emmy Awards YA indiana jones Tubi RT History USA Network Rock unscripted comic book movie Pacific Islander Creative Arts Emmys rt labs critics edition know your critic Crunchyroll franchise technology American Society of Cinematographers mission: impossible toy story toronto Columbia Pictures TV renewals black Prime Video Acorn TV cinemax razzies live action cooking MTV biopic Endgame NBC Polls and Games BBC streaming Warner Bros. tv talk LGBTQ Adult Swim Apple TV+ legend politics new york theme song prank Rocketman documentaries foreign black comedy all-time Action Trailer news 2019 strong female leads WarnerMedia monster movies christmas movies superman Universal The Purge National Geographic aliens vs. Photos Holidays Avengers halloween Interview comic book movies Ovation movie Comics on TV halloween tv 007 discovery First Reviews venice crime spider-man Year in Review Legendary BBC America adaptation Song of Ice and Fire criterion VH1 scary women joker Women's History Month Mary Tyler Moore mcc Awards telelvision psychological thriller worst dexter Drama Hallmark TLC facebook italian elevated horror thriller docuseries heist movie Sci-Fi Anna Paquin Cosplay The Witch doctor who screen actors guild jurassic park Binge Guide Nominations Country Sundance TV NYCC Spike Winners Tokyo Olympics TV One Lifetime TCA Winter 2020 new star wars movies Star Trek mutant Calendar TBS Spectrum Originals critic resources 2018 Election best Television Critics Association crime drama Paramount Plus Hear Us Out Esquire 4/20 Western dragons Turner Classic Movies animated San Diego Comic-Con gangster game show classics Amazon Studios action-comedy Apple ABC Family documentary south america 20th Century Fox independent game of thrones rt labs 2016 parents Valentine's Day deadpool james bond VOD TIFF GIFs war Fox Searchlight screenings Horror cartoon hispanic laika remakes art house docudrama obituary Comic Book space spinoff Comedy Central breaking bad New York Comic Con jamie lee curtis sag awards suspense fast and furious disaster Box Office Music Food Network cops zombie Nickelodeon GoT period drama political drama HBO Max adenture Turner wonder woman First Look king kong spider-verse social media Tags: Comedy Funimation History Awards Tour japanese Classic Film travel sequels 79th Golden Globes Awards MSNBC Apple TV Plus Rocky dramedy ESPN cancelled TV shows sports 71st Emmy Awards nfl Masterpiece high school Christmas The CW cats aapi Cannes Image Comics Extras canceled TV shows rt archives BBC One spanish DC Universe leaderboard video X-Men Amazon diversity emmy awards 2015 asian-american Holiday rotten Ghostbusters Showtime A&E Wes Anderson football FOX stop motion Instagram Live lord of the rings singing competition Peacock fresh AMC Plus popular BAFTA Musicals debate 2021 PBS dceu DC Comics Fantasy justice league Vudu kaiju royal family Schedule TCA 2017 satire Opinion Disney Channel series comiccon DC streaming service See It Skip It universal monsters japan crossover E3 CNN kids Disney Plus comic books HFPA Martial Arts blockbusters worst movies cars 93rd Oscars CBS All Access Super Bowl Travel Channel serial killer Hulu cancelled television A24 batman what to watch renewed TV shows Certified Fresh slasher scary movies BET films book rom-coms Alien Crackle Neflix TV live event Emmy Nominations Mary poppins 2020 Infographic genre Netflix reviews Academy Awards rotten movies we love Emmys Podcast Superheroe spain Stephen King Tumblr Set visit 21st Century Fox Sundance Now dc 24 frames romantic comedy Freeform Television Academy LGBT BET Awards Red Carpet HBO TV movies spanish language YouTube Animation Black History Month Netflix Christmas movies movies Marathons Nat Geo Reality streaming movies dreamworks festivals ITV DirecTV GLAAD Fox News hollywood Sneak Peek Amazon Prime Video Video Games Chernobyl Hollywood Foreign Press Association Pride Month Fall TV Britbox CBS golden globe awards adventure historical drama ID Film Heroines golden globes FX on Hulu Disney new zealand Sony Pictures Mary Poppins Returns Mudbound children's TV Best and Worst canceled latino composers supernatural anime Film Festival The Walt Disney Company OneApp Dark Horse Comics Comic-Con@Home 2021 Disney+ Disney Plus VICE Countdown based on movie book adaptation APB reboot finale Kids & Family scene in color Superheroes E! saw king arthur 45 directors Pixar police drama french crime thriller sitcom Walt Disney Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Broadway young adult Elton John CMT natural history talk show medical drama CW Seed twilight posters Brie Larson basketball sopranos El Rey cults marvel comics vampires AMC Pop IFC Films sequel Ellie Kemper australia robots Lucasfilm boxing Paramount TCA Starz President hispanic heritage month PlayStation anthology 2017 The Walking Dead Marvel Television Biopics