Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Boxtrolls, The Equalizer, Fall TV

In limited release: Pride, The Two Faces of January, and Jimi: All Is by My Side.

by | September 26, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got misunderstood monsters (The Boxtrolls, featuring voice performances from Elle Fanning and Ben Kingsley) and an enigmatic vigilante (The Equalizer, starring Denzel Washington and Chloë Grace Moretz). What do the critics have to say?

The Boxtrolls

Witty, original, and darker than your average family fare, Coraline and ParaNorman proved that Laika was a force to be reckoned with in the animation world. Critics say the studio’s latest effort, The Boxtrolls, offers a less compelling story than those films, but it’s meticulously crafted and often delightfully weird. The titular creatures are kindly, goofy monsters that have raised a little boy named Eggs (voiced by Isaac Hempstead-Wright) as one of their own. But the nefarious Archibald Snatcher (Ben Kingsley) wants to wipe out the Boxtrolls for personal gain, so it’s up to Eggs and his new friend Winnie (Elle Fanning) to stop him. The pundits say The Boxtrolls is visually striking, but it lacks the charm and narrative pull of previous Laika features.(Check out our video interviews with Kingsley and Fanning.)

The Equalizer


The last time Denzel Washington and director Antoine Fuqua teamed up, the result was Training Day, a searing portrait of a crooked cop that earned Washington an Oscar. They’re back together for The Equalizer, but critics say the results are mixed this time; Washington is his usual compelling self, but the script often succumbs to thriller cliches. Washington stars as McCall, a man with a mysterious past who’s trying to keep a low profile. However, when he stumbles upon Teri (Chloë Grace Moretz) a troubled young woman under the thumb of heartless mobsters, McCall decides to take matters into his own hands. The pundits say The Equalizer is stylish and gritty, but the formulaic plot doesn’t always make the best use of Washington’s fine central performance. (Watch our video Q&A with Fuqua, as well as Washington’s best-reviewed films.)

Certified Fresh on TV this week:

Expanding upon the Batman universe, Gotham (90 percent), which stars Ben Mckenzie and Jada Pinkett Smith, delves into the history of the key players of the Dark Knight saga. The critics say Gotham features high production values, a talented cast, and an appealingly stylized approach to the Batman mythos.

black-ish (86 percent) stars Anthony Anderson and Laurence Fishburne in a comedy series about a father who’s concerned that raising his his kids in the suburbs will force them to lose touch with their African American roots. The critics say black-ish is smart, ingratiating, and often very funny.

Viola Davis is an exceptional talent, and critics say she’s the best reason to watch How to Get Away With Murder (84 percent). The pundits say this legal thriller is slick and exciting, which helps it to overcome its sometimes shaky plotting.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

women Pet Sematary Election Captain marvel Superheroe emmy awards stoner DGA IMDb TV talk show golden globe awards TIFF ABC Nat Geo social media biography Comic Book Action FXX teaser RT History universal monsters Masterpiece scorecard 73rd Emmy Awards Spike tv talk The Arrangement Lucasfilm sitcom Hallmark E! Amazon sag awards thriller cartoon Mary poppins composers TNT politics action-comedy El Rey space zero dark thirty docuseries streaming movies President Sneak Peek Hallmark Christmas movies Lionsgate what to watch films animated blaxploitation Ovation Oscars trailers The Witch comics revenge dragons Brie Larson HBO Go Marathons Tubi Writers Guild of America Disney Plus Awards Hollywood Foreign Press Association justice league PBS The Purge Toys TV based on movie japan APB Reality criterion ratings international LGBTQ kids VH1 nature TLC Ghostbusters dceu streaming DC Comics DirecTV Stephen King Epix rom-coms Musicals Spectrum Originals movies chucky dc Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt elevated horror worst movies hispanic heritage month all-time 2021 dreamworks Extras child's play canceled Emmy Nominations Certified Fresh aliens a nightmare on elm street Crackle PaleyFest Box Office canceled TV shows name the review Red Carpet genre series Image Comics AMC Crunchyroll leaderboard asian-american Star Trek harry potter Animation cancelled TV shows archives GoT 90s Emmys NYCC 93rd Oscars robots psychological thriller Music Fall TV die hard italian Discovery Channel Video Games Marvel concert rt labs spanish language rotten movies we love WarnerMedia mcc Year in Review discovery trophy Universal Pictures medical drama screen actors guild ghosts Comic-Con@Home 2021 Calendar Dark Horse Comics Teen Infographic book adaptation mob ABC Family batman Cartoon Network Rock BET live action anthology Winners Sundance TV casting Biopics kaiju richard e. Grant posters romance Chernobyl documentaries 2019 Fox Searchlight cooking christmas movies theme song VOD IFC A&E ESPN The Walt Disney Company Marvel Television live event Spring TV critic resources Christmas 4/20 Apple Turner FX 45 romantic comedy high school kong directors E3 movie Endgame werewolf stand-up comedy olympics TruTV TBS gangster Bravo football versus New York Comic Con wonder woman USA young adult Tarantino Television Critics Association Apple TV+ 2020 rt labs critics edition golden globes video on demand Acorn TV miniseries Podcast ID jamie lee curtis worst singing competition NBA mission: impossible BBC One CMT indie crossover Warner Bros. cancelled television ITV spanish dexter art house blockbuster Polls and Games Paramount Plus Arrowverse mockumentary Song of Ice and Fire Ellie Kemper Tomatazos Rom-Com dramedy supernatural mutant zombies heist movie halloween tv Marvel Studios 2015 TCA 2017 sequels Alien comic book movies new york strong female leads Cannes critics 007 TCA technology jurassic park dark AMC Plus sequel australia quibi Black Mirror spy thriller Avengers Grammys scary 1990s docudrama Universal target YA Rocketman nfl Sundance Now video Cosplay Prime Video Britbox travel GIFs godzilla stop motion Columbia Pictures Horror Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 99% game of thrones Netflix Christmas movies Musical science fiction HFPA Showtime doctor who reboot legend hispanic Country Disney SXSW festivals 24 frames TCM Shudder Lifetime adenture Holiday Opinion Sundance Comedy Central Western Comedy natural history finale Nominations cinemax Mudbound Thanksgiving children's TV Freeform Elton John Film saw new zealand sports 2018 Best and Worst news french National Geographic Mystery 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards FX on Hulu comedies Rocky joker Interview monster movies ViacomCBS cancelled MTV cops Broadway true crime anime Tags: Comedy Syfy vampires satire biopic Trivia slasher zombie superman YouTube Red screenings CW Seed CNN Set visit History game show Drama transformers CBS Disney streaming service OneApp Lifetime Christmas movies 72 Emmy Awards Character Guide reviews renewed TV shows Mindy Kaling CBS All Access cults foreign hist Watching Series Wes Anderson Academy Awards hollywood Pride Month TCA Winter 2020 Hulu adaptation USA Network royal family TV Land suspense spider-verse unscripted Fargo Women's History Month Pixar Comics on TV telelvision 21st Century Fox Sony Pictures Heroines south america Martial Arts ABC Signature rotten Photos TV movies NBC LGBT BBC America classics The Academy documentary pirates of the caribbean witnail Pirates toronto Starz 71st Emmy Awards Winter TV Star Wars Countdown toy story king kong black Amazon Prime Video Peacock free movies boxoffice 2017 Creative Arts Emmys black comedy comic DC streaming service police drama Apple TV Plus Valentine's Day Pop Premiere Dates Hear Us Out BAFTA Tokyo Olympics TV renewals obituary TCA Awards marvel comics Awards Tour DC Universe binge First Look green book facebook king arthur twilight sopranos superhero First Reviews disaster vs. 20th Century Fox X-Men blockbusters scary movies feel good basketball Food Network Esquire diversity Exclusive Video dogs serial killer Nickelodeon Paramount The CW spinoff indiana jones hidden camera Baby Yoda comic book movie nbcuniversal 2016 deadpool book Kids & Family remakes spider-man festival scene in color Superheroes American Society of Cinematographers IFC Films OWN Instagram Live political drama Mary Tyler Moore Super Bowl Vudu Black History Month aapi comic books 79th Golden Globes Awards Fantasy franchise Adult Swim YouTube breaking bad Holidays spain halloween Walt Disney Pictures A24 Binge Guide venice Trophy Talk prank rt archives crime drama laika HBO BET Awards fresh lord of the rings Sci-Fi james bond television Television Academy Film Festival Pop TV MSNBC latino Tumblr WGN SDCC new star wars movies VICE Schedule See It Skip It Disney Channel HBO Max TV One Classic Film razzies parents cars adventure MCU psycho crime thriller Pacific Islander marvel cinematic universe Amazon Studios period drama YouTube Premium japanese fast and furious Family debate Trailer Funimation SundanceTV Paramount Network Shondaland PlayStation Legendary San Diego Comic-Con Turner Classic Movies Netflix boxing Quiz Logo Neflix The Walking Dead cancelled TV series Summer GLAAD cats BBC independent Disney+ Disney Plus Amazon Prime Reality Competition comiccon RT21 Fox News popular FOX award winner best Mary Poppins Returns historical drama know your critic Anna Paquin war slashers Travel Channel crime