Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Taken Is A Near Miss

Plus, The Uninvited is so-so, and New in Town is unwelcome.

by | January 29, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a kidnapping plot (Taken, starring Liam Neeson and Famke Janssen); haunted teens (The Uninvited, starring Emily Browning and Elizabeth Banks); and cold comfort (New in Town, starring Renee Zellweger and Harry Connick Jr.). What do the critics have to say?



Taken is an action flick that’s both efficient and absurd, critics say, and so it’s often entertaining — but only up to a point. The film stars Liam Neeson as a retired CIA agent who learns his daughter has been abducted in Paris; upon receiving a frantic phone call from her, he tracks her down — and finds himself on the trail of a massive criminal enterprise. The pundits say Taken is a sprightly piece of work, and Neeson is compelling in the lead role, but the film is weighted down by contrivances and leaps in logic.


The Uninvited

Another Asian horror remake getting released in January? While the critics say The Uninvited may not live up to the standard set by its source material (2003’s A Tale of Two Sisters), it’s a reasonably involving thriller– though not an entirely successful one. Emily Browning plays a young woman with a history of mental problems who, upon meeting her father’s new fiancée (Elizabeth Banks), is immediately suspicious; creepy goings-on ensue. The pundits say The Uninvited is moody and well acted, but it also contains plenty of haunted house conventions and telegraphed plot twists.


New in Town

It may be cold in Minnesota this time of year, but that’s nothing compared to the chilly reception the critics have given New in Town. In this fish-out-of-water romantic comedy, Renee Zellweger stars as a hotshot executive who’s sent to the Land of 10,000 Lakes to oversee layoffs at one of her company’s factories; there, she falls for the local union rep (Harry Connick Jr.) and learns about the strange customs of small-town Americans. The pundits say New in Town‘s timely premise and winning leads are no match for the film’s weather-beaten, clichéd script, which tries way too hard to be uplifting.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Medicine for Melancholy, a stylish, nuanced tale of two Bay Area hipsters in love, is at 94 percent.
  • The Filipino import Serbis, a documentary that examines at the root causes of the long-running gang war, is at 90 percent.
  • Shadows, about a young man who survives a car crash only to be confronted by ghostly visions, is at 57 percent.
  • Blessed Is the Match: The Life and Death of Hannah Senesh, a documentary about the famed poet and resistance fighter who attempted to free imprisoned Jews in World War II, is at 50 percent.
  • The Toe Tactic, a live action/animated hybrid about a young woman dealing with the death of her father, is at 43 percent.

Finally, props to AnthonyDidge, who came the closest to guessing Underworld: Rise of the Lycans‘ 34 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

SXSW 2022 documentaries posters know your critic reboot A24 ABC Amazon Prime Paramount Plus natural history FXX Paramount Pictures Image Comics Turner Classic Movies Cartoon Network marvel cinematic universe GIFs Holiday zombies scene in color Warner Bros. football comic book movie Spectrum Originals TCA Awards Black Mirror Rom-Com archives Bravo DC Universe Turner Focus Features Musical ABC Family kaiju news Starz blockbuster YA scene in color series BBC America Academy Awards Fox Searchlight animated Song of Ice and Fire Pet Sematary target scene in color travel mob BBC Red Carpet Crackle TCM Apple TV+ screen actors guild VH1 Certified Fresh films TCA Funimation TLC Star Wars Esquire Alien documentary Logo Television Academy TruTV summer TV preview Horror Television Critics Association FX on Hulu new star wars movies Peacock ratings sopranos satire singing competition women Marvel Television A&E trailers Britbox robots psychological thriller jurassic park TCA Winter 2020 olympics Interview Classic Film miniseries Spring TV 2015 slashers aapi transformers pirates of the caribbean based on movie period drama godzilla Writers Guild of America HBO fast and furious Comics on TV joker quibi video crime thriller classics japanese Drama TV One BBC One scary all-time Binge Guide SXSW Exclusive Video Netflix Christmas movies Anna Paquin President blockbusters halloween Columbia Pictures free movies 94th Oscars Box Office anime spain die hard Biopics MGM Star Trek Tubi unscripted The Arrangement Acorn TV SDCC renewed TV shows Awards hollywood Fantasy deadpool true crime Disney Plus science fiction Comic-Con@Home 2021 live event james bond Ellie Kemper AMC Plus Sony Mary poppins finale hispanic heritage month venice Hulu New York Comic Con adventure rotten movies we love 72 Emmy Awards festivals El Rey directors Black History Month Best and Worst interviews Cannes GoT 2018 Amazon biopic MSNBC teaser composers 2021 Native halloween tv Food Network Action HFPA Universal Pictures Showtime Rocky Mary Poppins Returns NYCC Character Guide south america king kong cancelled TV series politics Chernobyl CBS All Access chucky critic resources movie feel good Winners saw Hallmark Christmas movies book adaptation ABC Signature USA Pop TV diversity USA Network young adult movies cars dramedy leaderboard Western 79th Golden Globes Awards Quiz elevated horror Netflix DGA streaming movies 45 Opinion Family sitcom Disney+ Disney Plus independent PaleyFest canceled TV shows Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt what to watch Best Actor romantic comedy Pride Month marvel comics kids E3 canceled Captain marvel Hear Us Out nbcuniversal Awards Tour Dark Horse Comics a nightmare on elm street kong Lionsgate sequel crime drama Paramount Network mission: impossible 007 Wes Anderson 24 frames Walt Disney Pictures child's play Toys The CW stand-up comedy CBS Travel Channel San Diego Comic-Con E! lord of the rings Valentine's Day Prime Video Nat Geo OWN game of thrones IFC Films comics dogs WarnerMedia Nickelodeon broadcast zombie italian ViacomCBS anthology Extras dragons superman Disney Channel hispanic war dexter batman LGBT black comedy Comedy Central streamig Neflix harry potter cancelled television Thanksgiving jamie lee curtis justice league Pixar Premiere Dates Paramount Elton John 2020 art house Pop VICE APB psycho screenings TIFF game show OneApp Trophy Talk disaster Lifetime Christmas movies Shudder IFC Sci-Fi Christmas Emmys docudrama royal family adaptation theme song X-Men mockumentary international TBS binge South by Southwest Film Festival VOD live action new york criterion dc Kids & Family dark PlayStation American Society of Cinematographers Trailer First Look reviews YouTube Red toy story spanish Schedule Summer Apple TV Plus cooking obituary Pacific Islander trophy nfl christmas movies Reality Competition 1990s PBS See It Skip It NBC rt labs critics edition DC streaming service rom-coms cops indie Disney streaming service Vudu comic book movies Winter TV Animation high school vs. TV Land laika Holidays Set visit HBO Go Hollywood Foreign Press Association Tokyo Olympics Election Superheroe Marvel Studios Film Festival sag awards spider-verse space Masterpiece Video Games Reality 71st Emmy Awards universal monsters remakes Discovery Channel worst 93rd Oscars target Geeked Week Mary Tyler Moore Best Actress cats franchise debate BET comic books cancelled french cinemax 2019 biography Pirates Cosplay Calendar rt labs foreign docuseries nature ESPN obi wan 21st Century Fox BET Awards Mudbound Baby Yoda crossover crime sports 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards prank Watching Series Instagram Live Star Wars Celebration ITV CMT Mystery new zealand mutant stop motion golden globes richard e. Grant SundanceTV romance YouTube Sneak Peek twilight Infographic technology Broadway First Reviews NBA Marvel Rock legend Ghostbusters revenge scene in color film series 99% Tumblr Amazon Prime Video action-comedy Tags: Comedy summer TV Apple Emmy Nominations wonder woman YouTube Premium Super Bowl Stephen King TCA 2017 parents versus Comedy spinoff hidden camera MTV Lucasfilm FX Sundance Now Teen Grammys Fall TV Countdown superhero Comic Book medical drama monster movies spy thriller Universal Adult Swim casting IMDb TV 2017 facebook History Heroines television zero dark thirty Hallmark cults dceu Freeform comedies blaxploitation GLAAD razzies spanish language serial killer Ovation green book CW Seed book Rocketman Marathons Year in Review thriller dreamworks National Geographic Endgame heist movie Superheroes breaking bad Mindy Kaling Musicals basketball telelvision boxoffice series TNT video on demand Oscars Sundance talk show AMC streaming Lifetime name the review ghosts doctor who aliens genre 20th Century Fox Martial Arts FOX Syfy Creative Arts Emmys TV suspense fresh mcc Tarantino Trivia concert discovery historical drama Legendary slasher Arrowverse RT History Chilling Adventures of Sabrina critics adenture cartoon king arthur rotten TV renewals black CNN australia The Purge The Walking Dead MCU Shondaland popular indiana jones Photos WGN Indigenous scary movies LGBTQ Avengers Epix latino 73rd Emmy Awards gangster Women's History Month boxing werewolf The Academy best police drama golden globe awards tv talk vampires 90s Tomatazos ID Music Fargo Amazon Studios Best Picture worst movies sequels TV movies The Walt Disney Company comiccon cancelled TV shows comic HBO Max asian-american Polls and Games stoner DC Comics strong female leads Crunchyroll supernatural hist award winner spider-man Oscar Brie Larson emmy awards children's TV japan Sony Pictures Country Spike witnail political drama scorecard rt archives 4/20 toronto DirecTV Disney Podcast Nominations RT21 summer preview BAFTA 2016 Film social media Best Director Sundance TV Fox News festival The Witch