Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Taken Is A Near Miss

Plus, The Uninvited is so-so, and New in Town is unwelcome.

by | January 29, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a kidnapping plot (Taken, starring Liam Neeson and Famke Janssen); haunted teens (The Uninvited, starring Emily Browning and Elizabeth Banks); and cold comfort (New in Town, starring Renee Zellweger and Harry Connick Jr.). What do the critics have to say?



Taken is an action flick that’s both efficient and absurd, critics say, and so it’s often entertaining — but only up to a point. The film stars Liam Neeson as a retired CIA agent who learns his daughter has been abducted in Paris; upon receiving a frantic phone call from her, he tracks her down — and finds himself on the trail of a massive criminal enterprise. The pundits say Taken is a sprightly piece of work, and Neeson is compelling in the lead role, but the film is weighted down by contrivances and leaps in logic.


The Uninvited

Another Asian horror remake getting released in January? While the critics say The Uninvited may not live up to the standard set by its source material (2003’s A Tale of Two Sisters), it’s a reasonably involving thriller– though not an entirely successful one. Emily Browning plays a young woman with a history of mental problems who, upon meeting her father’s new fiancée (Elizabeth Banks), is immediately suspicious; creepy goings-on ensue. The pundits say The Uninvited is moody and well acted, but it also contains plenty of haunted house conventions and telegraphed plot twists.


New in Town

It may be cold in Minnesota this time of year, but that’s nothing compared to the chilly reception the critics have given New in Town. In this fish-out-of-water romantic comedy, Renee Zellweger stars as a hotshot executive who’s sent to the Land of 10,000 Lakes to oversee layoffs at one of her company’s factories; there, she falls for the local union rep (Harry Connick Jr.) and learns about the strange customs of small-town Americans. The pundits say New in Town‘s timely premise and winning leads are no match for the film’s weather-beaten, clichéd script, which tries way too hard to be uplifting.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Medicine for Melancholy, a stylish, nuanced tale of two Bay Area hipsters in love, is at 94 percent.
  • The Filipino import Serbis, a documentary that examines at the root causes of the long-running gang war, is at 90 percent.
  • Shadows, about a young man who survives a car crash only to be confronted by ghostly visions, is at 57 percent.
  • Blessed Is the Match: The Life and Death of Hannah Senesh, a documentary about the famed poet and resistance fighter who attempted to free imprisoned Jews in World War II, is at 50 percent.
  • The Toe Tactic, a live action/animated hybrid about a young woman dealing with the death of her father, is at 43 percent.

Finally, props to AnthonyDidge, who came the closest to guessing Underworld: Rise of the Lycans‘ 34 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

historical drama IMDb TV Musical cancelled TV series docudrama Mindy Kaling Interview President PaleyFest Mary poppins justice league worst Trailer YA Sundance aliens Alien Disney Anna Paquin VH1 spy thriller zombies DC streaming service south america romantic comedy medical drama latino feel good rt archives foreign sequel GLAAD spinoff Legendary festivals Black History Month halloween CW Seed cats hollywood Apple rotten CMT Crackle high school Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Endgame Food Network basketball golden globes black comedy child's play leaderboard facebook Warner Bros. Fox News El Rey nature mcc Captain marvel independent miniseries video on demand twilight BBC America telelvision Discovery Channel Set visit adenture CNN stop motion Disney streaming service LGBT Adult Swim ratings cinemax 72 Emmy Awards richard e. Grant Arrowverse dark cars Best and Worst Grammys Binge Guide Marvel Studios Cartoon Network blockbusters slasher GIFs 2016 NBC toy story Pacific Islander Winter TV nbcuniversal crossover mockumentary Stephen King true crime Freeform FX Black Mirror 2018 Amazon Prime DirecTV documentaries live action kids Rocketman Schedule Pop TV dc harry potter Sundance Now FOX TCA Winter 2020 Marvel Infographic criterion psycho crime thriller Peacock NYCC Creative Arts Emmys comic book movie Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Fall TV cancelled TV shows james bond ESPN marvel comics Year in Review genre Superheroe movie casting Ellie Kemper Masterpiece live event police drama Amazon Studios The CW Countdown Fargo godzilla classics Pixar technology Animation saw Watching Series Hear Us Out Photos target spain christmas movies game of thrones new star wars movies Western Polls and Games Pet Sematary hist scary movies talk show AMC Plus Amazon animated reviews Netflix kaiju Showtime TV One TruTV finale superhero Star Trek zombie japan boxoffice films Turner Classic Movies doctor who laika 007 Film Festival Baby Yoda ITV Logo women Reality 24 frames BAFTA japanese X-Men Instagram Live SundanceTV name the review Holiday festival royal family blaxploitation french 4/20 tv talk dogs award winner Awards Tour olympics TLC action-comedy PBS HBO pirates of the caribbean Universal Pictures The Purge screenings sag awards anthology 21st Century Fox DC Comics Country critics chucky Horror franchise Rock Nat Geo documentary Hulu comic books The Walt Disney Company Film composers Winners reboot sports 73rd Emmy Awards comic cops Trophy Talk binge MCU dramedy Classic Film australia BBC Premiere Dates LGBTQ OWN scary APB teaser RT21 Apple TV Plus Family spider-man Super Bowl FXX MTV Hollywood Foreign Press Association Funimation marvel cinematic universe scene in color The Arrangement 79th Golden Globes Awards E3 Prime Video Television Critics Association Podcast science fiction halloween tv Shondaland green book TCM Sneak Peek The Academy Image Comics Syfy Mystery Fantasy Christmas quibi CBS All Access TV renewals Television Academy Rom-Com MSNBC international docuseries Disney Channel concert Cannes zero dark thirty crime drama 2019 nfl art house Brie Larson Ovation First Reviews A24 Crunchyroll aapi anime Red Carpet rotten movies we love biopic IFC Films SXSW canceled Spectrum Originals italian television politics Marvel Television deadpool serial killer Box Office Writers Guild of America Universal war Teen robots satire HBO Go political drama The Witch TBS vampires Apple TV+ spanish PlayStation superman stoner emmy awards diversity video Extras asian-american Hallmark Heroines Elton John Avengers Paramount Plus AMC movies vs. Lifetime parents TNT space rom-coms TV movies travel theme song toronto Tokyo Olympics 90s biography scorecard DC Universe black Pop Chernobyl ghosts Sony Pictures ABC Signature 93rd Oscars indie Music Kids & Family Nominations period drama spanish language wonder woman Netflix Christmas movies Amazon Prime Video Comedy Hallmark Christmas movies book adaptation Mary Tyler Moore werewolf Britbox FX on Hulu Opinion Epix First Look adventure free movies venice SDCC Wes Anderson dexter cooking popular Character Guide disaster unscripted Paramount Network ABC Family new york GoT streaming movies all-time Lionsgate a nightmare on elm street Drama Women's History Month hispanic heritage month new zealand Tubi heist movie TCA Awards RT History Broadway Disney+ Disney Plus cults archives Mudbound TV Land Comics on TV comedies hispanic Toys Spike king kong monster movies IFC Tumblr crime Starz TV Travel Channel Action debate renewed TV shows rt labs 2021 Tags: Comedy cartoon Sundance TV Video Games dreamworks sequels 71st Emmy Awards Election hidden camera Trivia Bravo Emmys WGN The Walking Dead New York Comic Con HFPA Quiz rt labs critics edition screen actors guild Exclusive Video VICE Musicals 2017 football jamie lee curtis game show book TCA gangster news Star Wars discovery spider-verse canceled TV shows Comic Book YouTube Red romance ViacomCBS obituary boxing Song of Ice and Fire BBC One kong thriller Turner breaking bad best stand-up comedy dragons Esquire History remakes social media Biopics Columbia Pictures strong female leads Pride Month National Geographic Cosplay Ghostbusters streaming young adult Awards series trailers 1990s indiana jones A&E witnail E! Sci-Fi die hard Dark Horse Comics Marathons OneApp natural history mob 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards versus ID Paramount Lucasfilm Academy Awards Vudu comiccon Rocky Oscars cancelled king arthur 2020 comics joker critic resources BET Awards See It Skip It Thanksgiving WarnerMedia sitcom Summer USA Network Nickelodeon 45 Superheroes NBA Martial Arts supernatural razzies Tomatazos Comedy Central worst movies VOD jurassic park trophy 2015 Walt Disney Pictures fresh Comic-Con@Home 2021 blockbuster mission: impossible Calendar prank Pirates golden globe awards HBO Max adaptation suspense slashers transformers elevated horror Certified Fresh comic book movies 99% ABC BET TIFF Holidays TCA 2017 universal monsters Valentine's Day batman DGA Emmy Nominations know your critic Lifetime Christmas movies dceu Disney Plus YouTube Premium San Diego Comic-Con what to watch sopranos posters legend USA fast and furious cancelled television Shudder revenge Reality Competition Spring TV lord of the rings Acorn TV Mary Poppins Returns directors CBS Fox Searchlight based on movie mutant children's TV Tarantino 20th Century Fox YouTube Neflix psychological thriller American Society of Cinematographers singing competition