Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Shutter Island Is Solid But Minor Scorsese

Plus, critics have plenty of love for Lourdes and Ghost Writer.

by | February 18, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies brings just one new wide release: Martin Scorsese‘s Shutter Island, a psychological thriller starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Ben Kingsley. What do the critics have to say?


Shutter Island

It’s inevitable that a new Martin Scorsese movie will be greeted rapturously by film buffs — and will be compared, fairly or not, to his past triumphs. Critics say Shutter Island is unquestionably the work of a cinematic maestro, but it’s also a second-tier effort in the man’s career. Leonardo DiCaprio stars as a U.S. marshal investigating a patient’s disappearance from a remote hospital for the criminally insane; however, it quickly becomes clear that things aren’t quite as they seem. Most pundits say Shutter Island is masterfully crafted and atmospherically creepy; however, others find it somewhat bloodless, a solid B-movie that lacks the master’s touch. (Check out our feature, Great Directors: Martin Scorsese, on the director’s brilliant body of work, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down DiCaprio’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Lourdes, a drama about a physically disabled woman who seeks a miracle in the titular city, is at 91 percent.

  • Roman Polanski’s The Ghost Writer, starring Ewan McGregor and Pierce Brosnan in a thriller about an author who discovers his subject may have engaged in some ominous deeds, is at 80 percent.

  • Phyllis and Harold, a documentary about 59-year marriage with a dark secret, is at 71 percent.
  • Blood Done Sign My Name, a drama based upon a real-life murder that sparked social change in 1970s North Carolina, is at 44 percent.
  • The Good Guy, starring Alexis Bledel and Andrew McCarthy in a dramedy about a young idealist and her romantic pratfalls with Wall Street types, is at 38 percent.
  • Happy Tears, starring Demi Moore and Parker Posey in an indie comedy about a pair of squabbling sisters and their irascible father, is at 37 percent.

Tag Cloud

ITV cops golden globes foreign zombie summer TV preview robots The Walt Disney Company Image Comics Marvel Television Film Festival universal monsters Hollywood Foreign Press Association Black Mirror Sneak Peek children's TV Hallmark Quiz Britbox aapi Oscars Thanksgiving spanish Tarantino Marathons Spring TV HBO Go miniseries game show dogs Lucasfilm cooking serial killer Emmy Nominations Mary Poppins Returns spy thriller The Arrangement saw talk show El Rey USA Network political drama video on demand best scene in color diversity hidden camera comic book movie harry potter NBA elevated horror critic resources natural history italian sag awards TCA Television Critics Association BET nfl Set visit Funimation TCA Winter 2020 Mary Tyler Moore TBS 2021 Tubi indie Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cults The Academy WGN movie Shudder Epix debate renewed TV shows comic books ESPN halloween Wes Anderson wonder woman Video Games The CW classics LGBTQ The Walking Dead Comic Book NYCC Marvel 21st Century Fox sopranos Comic-Con@Home 2021 Lifetime Arrowverse comiccon Crunchyroll MSNBC Lifetime Christmas movies politics Disney Television Academy sequels book FX rotten movies we love TV Land godzilla 72 Emmy Awards fast and furious ID Pride Month YouTube Red HFPA Musicals television RT21 unscripted Turner Classic Movies cancelled TV shows Avengers Food Network casting Premiere Dates Mystery SXSW Podcast IMDb TV Film Travel Channel 2017 zero dark thirty Kids & Family The Purge boxing Action Crackle adaptation 20th Century Fox kids crime zombies Apple TV Plus scary movies Pop TV Superheroes japanese dragons Dark Horse Comics Interview 71st Emmy Awards Hulu TruTV SDCC king arthur tv talk Tags: Comedy asian-american cancelled technology Best and Worst CNN toronto adventure boxoffice canceled TV shows E! worst movies CW Seed Cartoon Network HBO rotten Acorn TV National Geographic ViacomCBS joker 2015 criterion lord of the rings Valentine's Day mcc dark doctor who Certified Fresh Geeked Week Drama Photos Rom-Com witnail Ellie Kemper Song of Ice and Fire Universal Pictures mob reviews independent TCA 2017 A&E Fargo spinoff Apple TV+ Ovation Peacock versus 45 AMC Plus space legend ABC MGM Pirates stoner Year in Review indiana jones PlayStation quibi documentary MTV Instagram Live The Witch monster movies satire all-time jamie lee curtis AMC jurassic park adenture prank Reality USA laika Mary poppins PBS revenge anime Netflix Christmas movies Trailer ghosts disaster scene in color film series Starz kong child's play die hard Reality Competition Winter TV Creative Arts Emmys Paramount Pictures Anna Paquin LGBT animated MCU south america festival Star Wars Celebration blaxploitation anthology Binge Guide dc scene in color series young adult theme song Lionsgate CMT ABC Signature new zealand remakes DC Comics Oscar Animation Awards justice league french news TCM Brie Larson BAFTA Prime Video travel summer preview parents Alien japan romantic comedy broadcast VICE new star wars movies See It Skip It Trophy Talk Hallmark Christmas movies Paramount Network obi wan Grammys based on movie popular Fall TV superhero gangster blockbusters Star Wars San Diego Comic-Con Netflix richard e. Grant Nominations golden globe awards Women's History Month award winner Captain marvel feel good ratings spider-verse Holidays medical drama docuseries werewolf Disney streaming service target scene in color 007 series kaiju RT History Trivia WarnerMedia composers Sundance TV spider-man singing competition comic psychological thriller Winners Western Best Director superman YouTube Premium rt archives SXSW 2022 rt labs critics edition Showtime Sci-Fi 94th Oscars interviews emmy awards 2016 hist TCA Awards comedies TV BBC One Polls and Games Native vampires Schedule Extras crime drama Nat Geo BBC America sports james bond deadpool Turner Infographic OWN christmas movies Comedy Amazon Studios DC streaming service telelvision Endgame Martial Arts streaming CBS DC Universe facebook Sony Pictures Sony New York Comic Con Biopics blockbuster Fox Searchlight reboot social media teaser PaleyFest 90s discovery Summer cats Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BET Awards IFC X-Men transformers international thriller Vudu Tumblr History cartoon Academy Awards summer TV stand-up comedy Horror YouTube venice GoT Sundance Now mission: impossible Masterpiece latino Syfy Amazon Prime Video APB historical drama war new york Calendar stop motion Sundance razzies South by Southwest Film Festival Holiday aliens video TV One royal family Tomatazos Mindy Kaling ABC Family Writers Guild of America Paramount biopic genre book adaptation DGA cancelled television Heroines Indigenous Pacific Islander Musical Pixar Star Trek GLAAD olympics scary Fox News supernatural Super Bowl Hear Us Out obituary TLC Emmys scorecard marvel cinematic universe First Reviews Neflix high school Comics on TV TIFF 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Family DirecTV women rom-coms OneApp Country Walt Disney Pictures halloween tv Legendary dramedy FX on Hulu 93rd Oscars American Society of Cinematographers finale Discovery Channel rt labs Stephen King comics know your critic Fantasy Music YA HBO Max trailers Paramount Plus VH1 FOX king kong Freeform IFC Films docudrama Apple 4/20 pirates of the caribbean cars Teen free movies 73rd Emmy Awards what to watch binge black comedy 99% TNT Spectrum Originals dreamworks worst nature 79th Golden Globes Awards FXX VOD 1990s dceu australia streamig leaderboard Christmas psycho Elton John Broadway art house football CBS All Access Rocketman live action spain critics movies basketball Shondaland romance batman Exclusive Video Focus Features TV movies Esquire films TV renewals hispanic Cannes archives chucky First Look Box Office Disney Channel crime thriller suspense canceled Baby Yoda dexter comic book movies Warner Bros. a nightmare on elm street Amazon Prime period drama Superheroe game of thrones A24 sequel Universal Ghostbusters E3 Mudbound streaming movies Disney Plus posters festivals Disney+ Disney Plus Rock franchise biography Election cinemax 2020 mutant live event true crime hollywood nbcuniversal Red Carpet strong female leads Classic Film Watching Series Pop GIFs Rocky trophy Cosplay documentaries Columbia Pictures Tokyo Olympics screen actors guild slasher sitcom Pet Sematary Countdown slashers Toys crossover 24 frames Awards Tour Spike Best Actress toy story 2018 Marvel Studios Comedy Central fresh Best Actor science fiction screenings Nickelodeon marvel comics hispanic heritage month 2019 BBC police drama Chernobyl SundanceTV heist movie mockumentary black cancelled TV series Bravo green book Logo twilight NBC directors Adult Swim target Best Picture Opinion action-comedy name the review Black History Month Amazon concert vs. President Character Guide breaking bad spanish language