Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Shutter Island Is Solid But Minor Scorsese

Plus, critics have plenty of love for Lourdes and Ghost Writer.

by | February 18, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies brings just one new wide release: Martin Scorsese‘s Shutter Island, a psychological thriller starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Ben Kingsley. What do the critics have to say?


Shutter Island

It’s inevitable that a new Martin Scorsese movie will be greeted rapturously by film buffs — and will be compared, fairly or not, to his past triumphs. Critics say Shutter Island is unquestionably the work of a cinematic maestro, but it’s also a second-tier effort in the man’s career. Leonardo DiCaprio stars as a U.S. marshal investigating a patient’s disappearance from a remote hospital for the criminally insane; however, it quickly becomes clear that things aren’t quite as they seem. Most pundits say Shutter Island is masterfully crafted and atmospherically creepy; however, others find it somewhat bloodless, a solid B-movie that lacks the master’s touch. (Check out our feature, Great Directors: Martin Scorsese, on the director’s brilliant body of work, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down DiCaprio’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Lourdes, a drama about a physically disabled woman who seeks a miracle in the titular city, is at 91 percent.

  • Roman Polanski’s The Ghost Writer, starring Ewan McGregor and Pierce Brosnan in a thriller about an author who discovers his subject may have engaged in some ominous deeds, is at 80 percent.

  • Phyllis and Harold, a documentary about 59-year marriage with a dark secret, is at 71 percent.
  • Blood Done Sign My Name, a drama based upon a real-life murder that sparked social change in 1970s North Carolina, is at 44 percent.
  • The Good Guy, starring Alexis Bledel and Andrew McCarthy in a dramedy about a young idealist and her romantic pratfalls with Wall Street types, is at 38 percent.
  • Happy Tears, starring Demi Moore and Parker Posey in an indie comedy about a pair of squabbling sisters and their irascible father, is at 37 percent.

Tag Cloud

adventure independent Broadway BET Avengers Emmys Captain marvel news Creative Arts Emmys Apple BAFTA animated movies TLC Elton John streaming movies Masterpiece El Rey ABC criterion heist movie TV Land 2018 007 Martial Arts Disney Channel HBO 2021 A24 Rocky Reality Competition Lucasfilm high school MCU The Walking Dead diversity YouTube 72 Emmy Awards legend Disney Sundance TV emmy awards NBA cats Summer aapi Kids & Family Tarantino Acorn TV 2019 E! Turner science fiction Classic Film Oscars Comedy Central AMC Plus franchise Pirates Trailer dreamworks social media SundanceTV 73rd Emmy Awards Set visit spider-man Binge Guide festival Black History Month Universal CMT Academy Awards DC Universe Universal Pictures Disney+ Disney Plus vampires Netflix Christmas movies Certified Fresh Paramount Plus TV renewals spy thriller DGA First Look Hulu Marathons documentaries zombie docuseries witnail hispanic Ghostbusters Apple TV+ Star Trek 93rd Oscars asian-american archives mutant king arthur black comedy Ellie Kemper Pet Sematary trailers video on demand child's play hist comic books Film 71st Emmy Awards italian ratings black Photos Ovation Opinion Amazon Prime Video rotten movies we love Rock toronto Freeform breaking bad reviews slashers Awards Tour godzilla french USA talk show olympics Pop TV YouTube Red Infographic book crossover kids target 2016 DC streaming service political drama Television Academy young adult hidden camera Stephen King Syfy FX on Hulu teaser scary movies Spectrum Originals satire blockbusters OWN Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Sony Pictures Rocketman Family Countdown spider-verse Tomatazos 2015 spanish language Crackle Drama renewed TV shows Action Election razzies chucky Bravo LGBTQ Trophy Talk Polls and Games die hard latino Extras TIFF superman twilight Logo doctor who IMDb TV spinoff jamie lee curtis kaiju ID GIFs The Academy best miniseries Holiday new york new zealand universal monsters HFPA crime indiana jones basketball Baby Yoda know your critic binge Mary poppins golden globe awards sag awards TV dexter Marvel The Purge SDCC supernatural dc Epix batman medical drama Pixar CBS All Access Cartoon Network Hallmark Christmas movies Comic-Con@Home 2021 NBC Amazon strong female leads sequel debate critic resources Pop NYCC Winter TV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards suspense action-comedy facebook international Country Marvel Television Musicals obituary stand-up comedy technology screen actors guild WarnerMedia hispanic heritage month genre TCA Winter 2020 Travel Channel children's TV Holidays documentary 79th Golden Globes Awards Nickelodeon ITV 2020 sports Fantasy Nominations Women's History Month Box Office Black Mirror Hallmark Marvel Studios space comic book movies Super Bowl politics 21st Century Fox posters cancelled television MSNBC anime cartoon marvel cinematic universe trophy Music TCA 2017 Musical FX APB cooking richard e. Grant spanish quibi The Witch mockumentary game show Best and Worst Esquire anthology Podcast sopranos Schedule award winner lord of the rings rotten Fall TV PBS American Society of Cinematographers mob 99% Mary Tyler Moore Character Guide superhero slasher period drama Food Network adaptation Fox Searchlight kong singing competition History DC Comics Reality book adaptation ghosts remakes streaming police drama theme song IFC Films Fargo Film Festival Western pirates of the caribbean cancelled TV series Nat Geo art house free movies a nightmare on elm street Mudbound Fox News travel E3 Shudder sequels Teen video AMC Emmy Nominations rt labs critics edition TCA Superheroe canceled serial killer adenture halloween nbcuniversal football Star Wars BET Awards YA FXX Endgame Cosplay ESPN ABC Signature rom-coms Showtime indie Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comic book movie romantic comedy scorecard foreign screenings PaleyFest 20th Century Fox deadpool war Adult Swim Valentine's Day wonder woman casting Netflix toy story Heroines Legendary based on movie spain GoT San Diego Comic-Con hollywood boxing Pride Month crime thriller jurassic park monster movies harry potter composers rt archives disaster VOD fast and furious boxoffice south america 90s Spring TV RT History Tubi dragons Interview BBC America comic 4/20 festivals psycho dark Awards concert Tokyo Olympics docudrama halloween tv worst movies Paramount Network ABC Family canceled TV shows nature dogs The Arrangement fresh Amazon Prime discovery PlayStation Television Critics Association Lifetime Christmas movies TV One FOX Biopics TBS cinemax Arrowverse nfl dceu comiccon royal family BBC One live action ViacomCBS cars WGN popular Apple TV Plus green book CBS cults VICE Hear Us Out The Walt Disney Company mcc USA Network japanese DirecTV 2017 christmas movies comics cancelled TV shows Anna Paquin stop motion mission: impossible thriller BBC japan justice league aliens tv talk CNN Year in Review elevated horror what to watch romance werewolf scary all-time Tumblr saw Trivia Writers Guild of America parents Spike RT21 women Sci-Fi Dark Horse Comics Pacific Islander revenge vs. See It Skip It National Geographic OneApp Cannes Mystery dramedy Watching Series GLAAD 45 telelvision Video Games sitcom Toys Brie Larson golden globes CW Seed Walt Disney Pictures joker Neflix rt labs live event HBO Go SXSW cops Hollywood Foreign Press Association Mindy Kaling Lifetime television prank classics Quiz reboot Sundance Red Carpet Sundance Now VH1 TNT venice Calendar Rom-Com TruTV psychological thriller Columbia Pictures Amazon Studios YouTube Premium king kong unscripted Christmas Peacock stoner crime drama Mary Poppins Returns films Funimation TCA Awards HBO Max critics Lionsgate Song of Ice and Fire worst New York Comic Con Thanksgiving Prime Video series President Starz MTV Comedy scene in color Premiere Dates zombies Shondaland game of thrones blaxploitation Disney streaming service IFC Warner Bros. new star wars movies james bond 24 frames feel good comedies historical drama Turner Classic Movies Superheroes X-Men directors Chernobyl The CW australia transformers Animation Winners 1990s marvel comics Comics on TV biopic finale versus zero dark thirty blockbuster Tags: Comedy Discovery Channel First Reviews A&E Vudu TCM leaderboard cancelled Sneak Peek Comic Book Horror Exclusive Video Crunchyroll Instagram Live Alien Grammys Wes Anderson true crime name the review Disney Plus Image Comics Paramount Britbox gangster natural history LGBT laika biography robots TV movies movie