Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Season of the Witch Doesn't Cast a Spell

Plus, Country Strong hits some sour notes.

by | January 7, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got courageous Crusaders (Season of the Witch, starring Nicolas Cage and Ron Perlman) and a country comeback (Country Strong, starring Gwyneth Paltrow and Tim McGraw ). What do the critics have to say?


Season of the Witch

Say what you will about Nicolas Cage, but give the man credit: at a time when too many movie stars studiously protect their images, he’s unafraid to look ridiculous. Sometimes, his devil-may-care attitude pays off (see Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans), and sometimes, well, we get stuff like Season of the Witch, a Medieval action flick that critics say is too dull to qualify as so-bad-it’s-good kitsch. Cage and Ron Perlman star as former Crusaders who are tasked with protecting and transporting a woman accused of being witch to a remote monastery; on their arduous journey, they must contend with wolves, zombies, and the black plague. The pundits say Season of the Witch is bottom-of-the barrel fantasy fare, with cheesy dialogue, so-so special effects, and a general air of silliness. (Check out Cage’s Five Favorite Films, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Perlman’s best-reviewed movies.)


Country Strong

A lot of country songs are great not for their originality, but because they’re infused with passion and craftsmanship. The same holds true for plenty of movies, but unfortunately for Country Strong, it can’t transcend its clichés, devolving into a showbiz melodrama despite good performances and heart-on-its-sleeve sincerity. Gwyneth Paltrow stars as Kelly Canter, a country superstar fresh from rehab; still shaky, she embarks on a tour, with hot young singer Beau Hutton (Garrett Hedlund), overseen by her manager/ex-husband James (Tim McGraw). Can our heroine overcome romantic entanglements and the bottle to reclaim her place atop the charts? The pundits say the leads give it their all, and the music is toe-tapping, but Country Strong is undone by meandering pacing and a slavish adherence to soapy formula.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Fantasy Film Festival Kids & Family black IMDb TV Disney+ Disney Plus Turner Classic Movies series TCA Winter 2020 new york ratings GLAAD Mary Tyler Moore high school DC Universe TCA 2017 composers sports Discovery Channel PaleyFest french christmas movies blockbusters Teen comic book movie History Quiz The Academy Country true crime chucky USA natural history teaser broadcast mcc Walt Disney Pictures ABC Family Year in Review Video Games casting hispanic Winter TV new star wars movies PBS nfl Best Actor TLC halloween tv ESPN Hollywood Foreign Press Association The Walt Disney Company mockumentary elevated horror Sundance harry potter obituary cancelled television Lifetime Superheroe Sundance TV summer TV preview police drama Sneak Peek docudrama spinoff BET Awards rt labs critics edition king arthur The Witch cartoon satire game of thrones latino action-comedy Star Wars scene in color film series marvel cinematic universe Freeform Image Comics Holidays cars Amazon Prime Video Tarantino rt labs news Tumblr screen actors guild TIFF Biopics Election indiana jones young adult miniseries TruTV zombies Elton John A24 theme song crime drama archives worst movies historical drama finale richard e. Grant summer TV Thanksgiving Writers Guild of America SDCC rt archives Horror singing competition cults independent cinemax Apple streaming Classic Film superhero VOD remakes IFC Films superman fresh 2018 Marathons blockbuster Podcast rotten movies we love cooking Paramount Plus Set visit AMC Plus supernatural Best Picture Toys trophy genre Peacock 99% TBS sequels space video on demand lord of the rings unscripted spanish language The Arrangement stand-up comedy ID breaking bad YouTube a nightmare on elm street Super Bowl joker know your critic live action Nominations trailers 1990s werewolf Sci-Fi romance critic resources Stephen King Apple TV Plus Academy Awards Women's History Month National Geographic italian Geeked Week Pixar Pop japan Pirates Rom-Com Star Wars Celebration foreign Netflix Christmas movies halloween Drama SundanceTV Pacific Islander versus canceled TV shows 4/20 Amazon Studios scene in color series WarnerMedia biopic jamie lee curtis festival Captain marvel Christmas CW Seed sag awards emmy awards social media First Look razzies franchise Broadway Mudbound comic Comics on TV Photos Disney Plus Song of Ice and Fire award winner TV renewals Starz wonder woman Disney movies zombie Certified Fresh cancelled TV shows DirecTV politics TCM Watching Series zero dark thirty First Reviews crime Avengers monster movies 72 Emmy Awards hidden camera CNN comiccon documentaries Action ITV scorecard Sundance Now kids royal family cops transformers Ellie Kemper leaderboard Hallmark Christmas movies name the review MGM king kong Pet Sematary Musicals sopranos biography Nat Geo Infographic Spike Television Academy Apple TV+ stoner Sony Anna Paquin Valentine's Day CBS 73rd Emmy Awards nature Star Trek international Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt video NYCC OWN Marvel children's TV Food Network X-Men Tomatazos Ghostbusters interviews game show Television Critics Association saw crossover dramedy Emmy Nominations Emmys YouTube Red indie Indigenous television dexter spy thriller Turner CBS All Access 24 frames Endgame Premiere Dates YA fast and furious cats TNT BAFTA 2020 reboot mob sitcom godzilla 45 worst south america vs. doctor who Showtime E3 directors prank asian-american book adaptation Focus Features ViacomCBS Best Actress romantic comedy SXSW documentary talk show green book Character Guide laika Lionsgate LGBTQ Tags: Comedy black comedy Mary poppins kong popular Marvel Television Superheroes AMC Vudu Extras criterion TCA anthology Mystery Hear Us Out anime cancelled TV series dceu based on movie Columbia Pictures 2017 japanese target American Society of Cinematographers nbcuniversal hist target scene in color Prime Video Summer DC Comics Reality concert deadpool Hulu streamig free movies debate pirates of the caribbean boxoffice universal monsters Esquire crime thriller sequel Fargo Trophy Talk scary slasher MTV Exclusive Video GoT animated parents spanish BBC Comic-Con@Home 2021 The Purge Baby Yoda Cannes comic book movies Marvel Studios WGN LGBT Comic Book 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards comic books Family San Diego Comic-Con Lifetime Christmas movies scene in color psycho dogs boxing Creative Arts Emmys blaxploitation cancelled Amazon Amazon Prime reviews Native RT21 TV Land El Rey serial killer art house The CW rotten Comedy Rock VH1 Dark Horse Comics MCU suspense Polls and Games toy story A&E Paramount Pictures golden globe awards films facebook Sony Pictures screenings jurassic park VICE Best Director streaming movies Trivia travel Binge Guide women Musical See It Skip It Reality Competition movie disaster marvel comics ABC book strong female leads Oscar critics Wes Anderson Oscars 2016 hollywood ABC Signature comics Rocky psychological thriller GIFs classics Black History Month thriller discovery Pride Month TV movies dragons rom-coms Western Opinion festivals robots Spring TV MSNBC Ovation FX on Hulu Awards Tour best Crunchyroll RT History technology all-time olympics Universal Rocketman Alien Hallmark live event Masterpiece USA Network spain NBC Mindy Kaling 94th Oscars Animation 2021 BET Holiday FXX dreamworks kaiju adenture Mary Poppins Returns Comedy Central PlayStation science fiction mutant TCA Awards comedies period drama Awards justice league 93rd Oscars spider-verse South by Southwest Film Festival Heroines venice CMT aliens Disney Channel toronto new zealand Martial Arts Fox Searchlight gangster NBA Funimation Neflix YouTube Premium vampires Fall TV Winners Arrowverse Britbox witnail HBO Max Grammys 2015 Calendar legend Cartoon Network Travel Channel HBO Netflix basketball Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FX feel good IFC dark binge Warner Bros. APB Spectrum Originals posters child's play docuseries Film war australia TV football Best and Worst Schedule Box Office slashers Paramount Epix diversity OneApp spider-man Trailer Syfy Paramount Network E! dc Nickelodeon Universal Pictures Red Carpet heist movie TV One mission: impossible Crackle Acorn TV adventure aapi stop motion Disney streaming service Interview Countdown hispanic heritage month FOX DC streaming service 2019 ghosts 21st Century Fox quibi telelvision medical drama The Walking Dead 007 batman golden globes renewed TV shows Black Mirror adaptation Adult Swim BBC America HFPA 90s Legendary summer preview Shudder President Brie Larson Fox News Music Chernobyl Instagram Live New York Comic Con james bond 20th Century Fox Logo twilight Pop TV revenge 79th Golden Globes Awards die hard Cosplay SXSW 2022 tv talk Tubi HBO Go political drama Bravo 71st Emmy Awards DGA Lucasfilm BBC One scary movies Tokyo Olympics Shondaland what to watch canceled obi wan