Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Season of the Witch Doesn't Cast a Spell

Plus, Country Strong hits some sour notes.

by | January 7, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got courageous Crusaders (Season of the Witch, starring Nicolas Cage and Ron Perlman) and a country comeback (Country Strong, starring Gwyneth Paltrow and Tim McGraw ). What do the critics have to say?


Season of the Witch

Say what you will about Nicolas Cage, but give the man credit: at a time when too many movie stars studiously protect their images, he’s unafraid to look ridiculous. Sometimes, his devil-may-care attitude pays off (see Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans), and sometimes, well, we get stuff like Season of the Witch, a Medieval action flick that critics say is too dull to qualify as so-bad-it’s-good kitsch. Cage and Ron Perlman star as former Crusaders who are tasked with protecting and transporting a woman accused of being witch to a remote monastery; on their arduous journey, they must contend with wolves, zombies, and the black plague. The pundits say Season of the Witch is bottom-of-the barrel fantasy fare, with cheesy dialogue, so-so special effects, and a general air of silliness. (Check out Cage’s Five Favorite Films, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Perlman’s best-reviewed movies.)


Country Strong

A lot of country songs are great not for their originality, but because they’re infused with passion and craftsmanship. The same holds true for plenty of movies, but unfortunately for Country Strong, it can’t transcend its clichés, devolving into a showbiz melodrama despite good performances and heart-on-its-sleeve sincerity. Gwyneth Paltrow stars as Kelly Canter, a country superstar fresh from rehab; still shaky, she embarks on a tour, with hot young singer Beau Hutton (Garrett Hedlund), overseen by her manager/ex-husband James (Tim McGraw). Can our heroine overcome romantic entanglements and the bottle to reclaim her place atop the charts? The pundits say the leads give it their all, and the music is toe-tapping, but Country Strong is undone by meandering pacing and a slavish adherence to soapy formula.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

sequel Paramount Network target comic book movie Fox News unscripted versus superhero Best and Worst TV One game of thrones films chucky miniseries Reality Competition Star Wars television Pacific Islander boxoffice emmy awards kaiju OneApp Legendary Family halloween Pop TV toronto cartoon Amazon Prime CW Seed Mystery Emmy Nominations Western Song of Ice and Fire comic rotten movies we love technology french joker christmas movies Emmys APB TIFF movie reboot zero dark thirty Arrowverse supernatural Comedy cats hidden camera criterion Fantasy vs. Apple TV+ HBO Polls and Games New York Comic Con cancelled television festival olympics gangster E! obituary BBC One harry potter news venice Comedy Central green book spider-man ITV action-comedy a nightmare on elm street discovery Ghostbusters Universal Pictures Pride Month composers Neflix 21st Century Fox children's TV book Nat Geo kids video on demand spy thriller hist Image Comics comics Film Festival Superheroe 2015 Nickelodeon worst international werewolf ratings Instagram Live ViacomCBS BBC Photos 007 TNT toy story royal family Grammys Broadway Certified Fresh Watching Series Crunchyroll pirates of the caribbean crossover 72 Emmy Awards award winner NYCC Trailer hispanic historical drama game show Rocketman Peacock Infographic breaking bad Horror ABC Signature ABC 73rd Emmy Awards cops Calendar Funimation basketball Sneak Peek black new star wars movies quibi Epix Ellie Kemper 2021 Premiere Dates Pixar comedies Turner Classic Movies BBC America football NBA true crime SXSW SundanceTV IFC YouTube Red Comic Book Action History Columbia Pictures die hard Writers Guild of America directors 1990s Red Carpet ABC Family stand-up comedy Sci-Fi Superheroes cars 71st Emmy Awards Prime Video Turner Apple docuseries VOD Marvel Television Bravo Holidays Holiday Biopics binge justice league GIFs Captain marvel Mary Poppins Returns finale Mudbound debate jamie lee curtis San Diego Comic-Con cancelled TV shows blaxploitation thriller TV art house TCM latino stop motion SDCC Binge Guide archives tv talk canceled TV shows A24 golden globe awards free movies foreign Teen vampires saw doctor who indiana jones Amazon Cosplay new zealand AMC Plus TBS Oscars legend Tags: Comedy live event Thanksgiving The Witch HBO Max what to watch Martial Arts VH1 PBS mutant Character Guide rom-coms Hallmark spain Amazon Studios godzilla Classic Film AMC medical drama cooking Star Trek political drama Trivia FX on Hulu Dark Horse Comics rt labs YouTube Premium rotten king arthur Cartoon Network ID Box Office BAFTA south america Television Academy Exclusive Video genre Comics on TV El Rey animated stoner boxing Rock Drama rt archives Netflix Christmas movies young adult Musicals blockbuster batman IMDb TV richard e. Grant Spectrum Originals MSNBC Endgame Heroines Academy Awards Music posters Film Animation DC streaming service satire reviews Stephen King adenture japan travel razzies independent comic book movies Country Lifetime 90s dc E3 20th Century Fox Christmas telelvision ESPN First Look scene in color 2019 sopranos Tumblr series canceled RT History The Walking Dead docudrama Marvel Studios documentaries Wes Anderson Paramount Plus Hulu italian Rocky PaleyFest CBS All Access twilight halloween tv book adaptation laika james bond documentary renewed TV shows OWN Mary Tyler Moore elevated horror critics concert streaming hollywood Winners Pirates Podcast FXX Rom-Com spinoff black comedy Tubi MCU facebook talk show name the review zombie based on movie scorecard dexter Video Games VICE Walt Disney Pictures prank 2020 Brie Larson Tokyo Olympics President australia aliens TCA 2017 TCA TCA Awards YA Avengers adventure theme song leaderboard nbcuniversal 93rd Oscars BET Awards sitcom sag awards mockumentary See It Skip It 2016 99% Disney Channel Musical movies serial killer Freeform 79th Golden Globes Awards dramedy Discovery Channel slasher spider-verse parents Extras dceu Syfy TruTV crime drama strong female leads Summer sequels know your critic social media Television Critics Association mob Netflix new york heist movie CBS Year in Review CMT romantic comedy blockbusters crime thriller Awards Hear Us Out Food Network marvel cinematic universe golden globes MTV 2017 Fall TV feel good Paramount DC Comics Nominations all-time festivals cancelled 24 frames First Reviews war GoT 2018 cancelled TV series American Society of Cinematographers Ovation Black History Month Marvel DirecTV FOX A&E PlayStation video DGA suspense women TCA Winter 2020 comic books Showtime singing competition Mary poppins Schedule Disney Plus worst movies National Geographic witnail Countdown TV renewals deadpool Toys casting nfl zombies teaser Lifetime Christmas movies streaming movies Universal Adult Swim The Arrangement LGBT CNN Election Black Mirror Disney streaming service TLC The Academy Travel Channel Super Bowl Logo Fargo The Walt Disney Company spanish dark Reality Vudu jurassic park USA Network Lucasfilm romance dreamworks Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trophy Talk Masterpiece Disney+ Disney Plus franchise hispanic heritage month The CW robots fast and furious Chernobyl disaster WGN Pop science fiction high school Crackle Amazon Prime Video slashers king kong Comic-Con@Home 2021 best politics nature dogs Esquire child's play Women's History Month superman anime Valentine's Day aapi Spike lord of the rings YouTube psychological thriller cults IFC Films 45 Awards Tour Pet Sematary DC Universe Tomatazos Lionsgate marvel comics Quiz crime Baby Yoda diversity indie kong revenge BET Apple TV Plus Anna Paquin japanese rt labs critics edition The Purge Britbox Acorn TV screenings Interview RT21 live action trailers Winter TV scary movies space remakes wonder woman Kids & Family psycho biopic adaptation period drama dragons monster movies HBO Go Hollywood Foreign Press Association classics TV Land LGBTQ mcc 4/20 Opinion screen actors guild popular HFPA universal monsters spanish language Creative Arts Emmys mission: impossible Sony Pictures police drama TV movies ghosts comiccon natural history Fox Searchlight Set visit Elton John biography FX Hallmark Christmas movies fresh X-Men cinemax Sundance TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sundance Now Alien critic resources Tarantino transformers Shudder Disney Sundance Shondaland anthology scary GLAAD NBC Warner Bros. trophy Starz Mindy Kaling 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Marathons WarnerMedia sports Cannes asian-american USA Spring TV