Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Race to Witch Mountain Doesn't Cast A Spell

Plus, Last House on the Left falls short of the original, and Miss March is largely laugh-free.

by | March 12, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a supernatural quest (Race to Witch Mountain, starring Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson and AnnaSophia Robb), a vengeance thriller ( Last House on the Left, starring Sara Paxton and Garret Dillahunt), and playmate pratfalls (Miss March starring Zach Cregger and Trevor Moore). What do the critics have to say?


Race to Witch Mountain

Race to Witch Mountain finds Disney attempting to resurrect a franchise that delivered some sizable hits for the studio in the 1970s. However, critics say the reboot is only sporadically successful, despite the best efforts of a talented cast. Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson stars as an ex-con cabbie who picks up two teens with supernatural powers; together, they attempt to elude government officials and ominous forces. The pundits say the cast is just fine, especially the Rock, who mixes toughness and good humor with panache. But the rest of the film is alternately too noisy and not exciting enough to maintain interest throughout. (Check out star Carla Gugino‘s five favorite films, and our rundown of the finest live-action Disney films.)


The Last House on the Left

Wes Craven‘s original The Last House on the Left was a horror movie touchstone, a film so violent in its time that even its poster had to reassure audience members that it was only a movie. Critics say the remake (which Craven produced) is stylishly crafted and effective in spots, but it misses the spirit of the original by miles, lacking Craven’s bleak artistry and his sense of social commentary. Sara Paxton stars as a young woman who is brutally attacked by a prison escapee and his flunkies. She flees to the supposed safety of her house, but when her parents discover that they’re harboring the very thugs who attacked their daughter, they exact their own brand of revenge. The pundits say the film is better-made than most, but it’s ultimately pretty generic, substituting the dark subtleties of Craven’s landmark film with oodles of gratuitous gore.


Miss March

Unless your taste runs toward the bottom-of-the-barrel lowest common denominator, the critics say you may want to scratch Miss March off your calendar. The film stars Zach Cregger (who also directed with co-star Trevor Moore, both part of the the Whitest Kids U’ Know comedy troupe) as a young man who awakens from a coma to discover his once-chaste high school significant other is now a Playboy centerfold. The pundits say Miss March is crass, unfunny, and poorly made, a gross-out comedy with little beyond scene-stealer Craig Robinson to recommend it.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

docudrama satire FXX die hard Nickelodeon 2017 HBO biopic game of thrones 79th Golden Globes Awards comic Wes Anderson Acorn TV TCA halloween USA Shudder Paramount Plus Broadway Best and Worst Apple TV Plus parents DC Comics 2020 MSNBC docuseries Drama anthology heist movie Image Comics The Purge biography aliens deadpool Universal Pictures Mary poppins Interview Stephen King sequel Winter TV Apple TV+ Food Network Tokyo Olympics Video Games leaderboard finale Martial Arts Universal 1990s aapi SXSW genre The Arrangement Esquire harry potter Holiday Character Guide LGBTQ elevated horror Star Wars dark james bond TV movies Pacific Islander Columbia Pictures legend talk show jamie lee curtis Apple TV Land universal monsters Polls and Games young adult American Society of Cinematographers action-comedy Family Trophy Talk doctor who Avengers zombie Comic Book USA Network zero dark thirty 99% marvel cinematic universe mockumentary Podcast Pop BBC America 007 SDCC fresh spy thriller Turner Classic Movies Reality medical drama mcc Endgame sag awards Extras Freeform superhero Western period drama Quiz Vudu batman facebook Disney Plus See It Skip It Mindy Kaling sitcom dogs DC Universe disaster 2018 TBS Lifetime Warner Bros. war DC streaming service Film Disney+ Disney Plus singing competition adenture Cannes trailers MCU science fiction Marvel Comics on TV asian-american OWN Exclusive Video ITV Music Tumblr APB Tomatazos nbcuniversal justice league book vampires TV movies AMC Plus BAFTA Hulu critic resources streaming movies 2021 PaleyFest Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt President rt labs robots cartoon ESPN Netflix Christmas movies 4/20 diversity anime Schedule Prime Video Pet Sematary Rock Superheroe Star Trek Election Red Carpet italian Creative Arts Emmys nfl crossover Awards romance kids Fantasy scary Spectrum Originals french Comic-Con@Home 2021 mob debate halloween tv spinoff king arthur OneApp godzilla 20th Century Fox golden globes comic book movies The Walt Disney Company HBO Go Discovery Channel Disney Channel travel dc TCA Awards social media best Fox Searchlight Spike indie emmy awards Netflix target TCM Amazon Studios Comedy Central vs. Walt Disney Pictures IFC child's play 21st Century Fox YouTube TruTV Amazon Prime teaser Countdown trophy comiccon mission: impossible NBC hollywood werewolf YouTube Red 2015 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina theme song book adaptation foreign popular Animation Television Academy based on movie CNN cancelled television spider-man festival razzies Rocky SundanceTV Disney streaming service Ovation Opinion The Academy Mary Tyler Moore YA Shondaland Peacock Song of Ice and Fire spanish hidden camera Paramount screenings richard e. Grant DGA Musicals Teen Nominations Neflix quibi directors joker TCA 2017 films fast and furious boxing police drama saw live action HFPA Box Office crime Set visit casting black comedy television true crime franchise kong mutant Anna Paquin movie ABC Signature golden globe awards hispanic heritage month dramedy transformers Hallmark Christmas movies children's TV Tags: Comedy Christmas Premiere Dates binge Writers Guild of America The Witch adventure 24 frames prank Hollywood Foreign Press Association PBS Pride Month game show E3 Trailer Pixar obituary comic books monster movies cinemax japanese TCA Winter 2020 Oscars MTV Mystery Brie Larson reviews psycho kaiju rom-coms romantic comedy Awards Tour 73rd Emmy Awards Television Critics Association Fargo dreamworks Summer toy story dragons sopranos RT21 comics toronto cancelled Heroines ABC supernatural Showtime FOX space technology RT History IMDb TV Elton John Rocketman Starz cancelled TV series Dark Horse Comics stand-up comedy NBA historical drama award winner art house rt archives japan Travel Channel Pop TV Arrowverse The CW GLAAD Thanksgiving political drama Cosplay streaming scene in color Alien History classics breaking bad Marvel Television Ellie Kemper what to watch Year in Review basketball critics AMC versus Amazon rotten boxoffice blaxploitation 90s adaptation Sundance Now screen actors guild ABC Family FX 72 Emmy Awards remakes video on demand First Reviews HBO Max laika Nat Geo Lucasfilm free movies dexter archives Tarantino A24 rt labs critics edition Musical video 45 worst movies 2019 black IFC Films cops latino WGN BET Awards cooking international ID Britbox TIFF CBS All Access TNT documentary stoner LGBT Academy Awards festivals slasher TV One 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards blockbusters Classic Film worst serial killer spanish language chucky GIFs women Cartoon Network gangster Fall TV Emmys Lifetime Christmas movies Lionsgate cults news Instagram Live cancelled TV shows suspense spider-verse Sundance Infographic blockbuster zombies 2016 psychological thriller New York Comic Con Baby Yoda Marvel Studios live event cats canceled new york Holidays A&E natural history ratings Sci-Fi pirates of the caribbean Super Bowl series E! green book christmas movies comedies Sony Pictures Sundance TV scorecard X-Men Grammys jurassic park independent Amazon Prime Video The Walking Dead TV renewals Marathons Reality Competition documentaries Syfy Black Mirror witnail sequels VOD San Diego Comic-Con Country high school venice Winners south america wonder woman ghosts Calendar Toys Binge Guide politics all-time royal family YouTube Premium National Geographic Mary Poppins Returns GoT marvel comics spain Watching Series Women's History Month know your critic Chernobyl Black History Month criterion lord of the rings 71st Emmy Awards TLC cars PlayStation telelvision Epix Crackle Mudbound crime drama Fox News unscripted WarnerMedia football scary movies hist El Rey slashers Biopics Trivia Pirates feel good crime thriller Emmy Nominations Disney Comedy king kong Action renewed TV shows CW Seed stop motion Certified Fresh nature strong female leads olympics tv talk Sneak Peek DirecTV Film Festival sports revenge NYCC First Look posters Horror VH1 new zealand reboot VICE Spring TV Superheroes twilight thriller Crunchyroll comic book movie indiana jones Turner Funimation a nightmare on elm street Tubi new star wars movies Hear Us Out dceu BET CMT Logo canceled TV shows superman Adult Swim australia miniseries concert BBC One rotten movies we love ViacomCBS discovery Captain marvel Bravo name the review Ghostbusters 93rd Oscars hispanic Rom-Com CBS composers animated Kids & Family Masterpiece FX on Hulu Valentine's Day Paramount Network Legendary Photos BBC Hallmark