Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Puss in Boots is the Cat's Meow

Plus, The Rum Diary is sporadically compelling, and In Time takes a great idea and does a so-so job with it.

by | October 28, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a swashbuckling feline (Puss in Boots, with voice work from Antonio Banderas and Salma Hayek), a gonzo journalist (The Rum Diary, starring Johnny Depp and Aaron Eckhart), and monetary mortality (In Time, starring Justin Timberlake and Amanda Seyfried). What do the critics have to say?

Puss in Boots


The Shrek franchise keeps rolling along, this time ogre-free, with Puss in Boots, which critics find to be a witty, action-packed romp in its own right. In this prequel, ever-daring Puss (voiced by Antonio Banderas) teams up with the tough, alluring Kitty Softpaws (Salma Hayek) to protect the world from a pair of villains named Jack and Jill. The pundits say Puss in Boots is smart and funny, a clever send-up of fairy tale conventions with vibrant animation and inspired vocal performances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Banderas’ best-reviewed films.)

The Rum Diary


Johnny Depp steps back into Hunter S. Thompson’s shoes for The Rum Diary, but critics say that, like its predecessor Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, its sporadic moments of colorful madness are undercut by an uneven script. The Run Diary chronicles one of the gonzo reporter’s memorable early assignments: a wild trek to Puerto Rico in which our hero uncovers a shady business plot and drinks a ton of booze. The pundits say the film is a mostly agreeable mix of picturesque settings and eccentric characters, but it lacks the focus needed to be a truly cohesive head trip. (Check out director Bruce Robinson’s Five Favorite Films.)

In Time


It’s a high concept cross between Logan’s Run and Occupy Wall Street, but critics say gaping plot holes and excessive action sequences keep In Time from measuring up to its intriguing premise. Set in a world where everyone is genetically engineered to die shortly after they turn 25 (except for the rich folks, who can purchase more time), Justin Timberlake stars as a man of modest means on the run from the cops after he’s been gifted a life-extension. The pundits say In Time has a sleek look and some interesting ideas, but it runs out of steam pretty quickly.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

NBC ABC TCA Winter 2020 all-time Oscars versus dogs Turner Classic Movies 20th Century Fox TCA 2017 comedies Film Musical Interview spider-verse rotten movies we love Discovery Channel FX on Hulu cars DirecTV Neflix olympics Writers Guild of America MCU Comics on TV Pet Sematary TV movies classics APB Christmas CBS All Access independent international BET stand-up comedy Reality reboot Turner GLAAD scary movies Tokyo Olympics harry potter superman Television Critics Association Acorn TV worst movies anime See It Skip It scary remakes mission: impossible cartoon football telelvision HBO political drama First Look Fargo Disney Sneak Peek Martial Arts archives Syfy Tarantino rotten Endgame werewolf franchise slasher nfl Tumblr CMT IMDb TV finale 2019 Sci-Fi monster movies sitcom 2018 worst NYCC films disaster canceled TV shows ITV dark obituary ESPN Crunchyroll mockumentary sequel kaiju superhero comic Cartoon Network zombie Ovation comiccon police drama comic book movies critic resources revenge Set visit social media Exclusive Video New York Comic Con composers renewed TV shows Amazon Studios adaptation Character Guide Brie Larson series National Geographic boxoffice Wes Anderson game of thrones FOX Nickelodeon cancelled TV series The Academy Women's History Month E3 basketball mob transformers Alien The Arrangement cancelled television Countdown blockbuster vs. suspense spain Disney streaming service aliens VH1 psychological thriller Binge Guide Country scorecard kong Box Office Food Network IFC Films criterion Apple TV+ Hallmark Christmas movies Valentine's Day Marvel Reality Competition Tubi Drama Summer DC streaming service The Witch spanish christmas movies Tags: Comedy psycho video on demand spinoff natural history History new star wars movies wonder woman hist TCA Awards Watching Series Arrowverse streaming hollywood Mudbound action-comedy WarnerMedia TIFF australia quibi a nightmare on elm street Amazon Prime reviews TruTV Comic-Con@Home 2021 adventure gangster diversity 2016 live action dragons X-Men Premiere Dates politics unscripted NBA 2017 Ellie Kemper name the review docudrama Rock SXSW emmy awards Dark Horse Comics doctor who Fall TV technology feel good joker Star Wars prank comic book movie video child's play leaderboard DC Comics Awards Tour medical drama Song of Ice and Fire Rocky Hulu breaking bad Certified Fresh 2020 Broadway Mary Poppins Returns 4/20 Fox News directors Disney+ Disney Plus 45 YA 79th Golden Globes Awards AMC Universal TCA art house Grammys dexter 73rd Emmy Awards cats Classic Film A&E movie Columbia Pictures Family San Diego Comic-Con Walt Disney Pictures Baby Yoda Freeform dc Schedule free movies USA Network period drama Emmy Nominations The Walking Dead 93rd Oscars HBO Max Creative Arts Emmys razzies south america royal family CW Seed chucky new york indiana jones Paramount venice crossover cinemax Disney Channel halloween tv Chernobyl Chilling Adventures of Sabrina zero dark thirty Bravo 1990s golden globes Infographic BAFTA movies live event ID richard e. Grant pirates of the caribbean Disney Plus Spectrum Originals 24 frames james bond Spike travel facebook LGBTQ ghosts fast and furious TV One 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pride Month Apple GIFs sag awards Animation critics documentaries Teen jamie lee curtis rt archives book Ghostbusters parents Photos green book LGBT Television Academy king kong Legendary festival Britbox foreign 2021 aapi Calendar Western deadpool mcc Funimation genre black Mystery President Black History Month asian-american jurassic park Horror cancelled game show crime drama Shudder Pop MTV Superheroes E! El Rey Mary poppins nature biopic supernatural fresh Netflix Christmas movies Heroines TV Land Nat Geo comic books Winter TV Trivia cops Spring TV FXX Quiz italian true crime high school mutant Pirates Hear Us Out Marvel Studios Lionsgate Pop TV best Lifetime Christmas movies marvel cinematic universe children's TV book adaptation talk show stoner Mindy Kaling Image Comics robots indie Lucasfilm Adult Swim hidden camera ABC Signature comics spider-man Academy Awards women Rom-Com miniseries Kids & Family Stephen King DC Universe Epix MSNBC sports RT History saw Biopics what to watch dramedy animated anthology Paramount Plus Fantasy PlayStation Hollywood Foreign Press Association Sundance WGN Pixar Paramount Network satire American Society of Cinematographers YouTube Red PBS japanese war ABC Family SDCC Best and Worst young adult canceled festivals Starz Awards scene in color streaming movies Toys Extras adenture IFC biography Marvel Television docuseries elevated horror OneApp Prime Video TV renewals Cosplay dreamworks spy thriller BBC One Showtime Vudu PaleyFest Red Carpet rom-coms TLC strong female leads 72 Emmy Awards Rocketman Peacock HFPA Tomatazos The Walt Disney Company historical drama Comic Book Emmys Film Festival rt labs justice league teaser Super Bowl Comedy Music popular nbcuniversal VICE blaxploitation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt laika posters Captain marvel Netflix trophy TV CNN binge vampires Hallmark Sundance Now singing competition HBO Go documentary sopranos french Anna Paquin space screen actors guild twilight DGA dceu BET Awards Holiday Podcast toy story Action new zealand japan Nominations Pacific Islander Trailer Comedy Central blockbusters zombies television cancelled TV shows crime Warner Bros. know your critic science fiction ratings concert ViacomCBS cults batman based on movie Esquire TNT target 71st Emmy Awards 21st Century Fox YouTube debate witnail slashers OWN CBS Avengers toronto theme song The CW godzilla Election screenings spanish language Thanksgiving Star Trek 99% TCM Elton John Video Games Masterpiece The Purge Sundance TV GoT legend TBS hispanic heritage month Amazon discovery romance BBC heist movie Trophy Talk YouTube Premium Instagram Live award winner king arthur serial killer latino VOD Year in Review Crackle Lifetime hispanic SundanceTV Polls and Games tv talk A24 2015 kids halloween Fox Searchlight casting thriller trailers news universal monsters USA 007 Cannes Apple TV Plus marvel comics 90s Travel Channel Universal Pictures Shondaland BBC America FX stop motion Musicals Holidays Black Mirror Logo RT21 Sony Pictures Marathons AMC Plus black comedy Mary Tyler Moore golden globe awards First Reviews crime thriller rt labs critics edition romantic comedy Amazon Prime Video sequels Superheroe boxing cooking Winners Opinion lord of the rings die hard