Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Positive Role Models, So-So Soul Men

Plus, Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa tops the original.

by | November 6, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Big Brothers (Role Models, starring Paul Rudd and Seann William Scott), wild animals (Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa, with voice work by Ben Stiller and Chris Rock), and R&B vets (Soul Men, starring Bernie Mac and Samuel L. Jackson). What do the critics have to say?

Films that are at once raucously stupid and genuinely funny are a rarity. However, critics say Role Models fits the bill with aplomb. The film stars Paul Rudd and Seann William Scott as a pair of energy drink pitchmen with a proclivity for bad behavior and law-breaking; assigned to community service, they act as Big Brothers to a pair of troublemakers — and learn something in the process. It may sound like pure formula, but the pundits say this is a worthy entry in the Judd Apatow-inspired subgenre of gross-out comedy with heart, featuring well-paced, spectacularly dumb (in a good way) gags and engaging performances. At 75 percent on the Tomatometer, Role Models may be worth following.

“I’d like to dedicate this next number to McLovin.”

Speaking of rarities, how many sequels top the original? Madagascar
made a ton of money but disappointed critics unimpressed with its string of pop culture references and flatulence jokes. The scribes say Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa is better in almost every regard, with sharper animation, funnier jokes, and a better story. Alex the Lion (Ben Stiller), Gloria the Hippo (Jada Pinkett Smith), Marty the Zebra (Chris Rock) and Melman the Giraffe (David Schwimmer) are relocated from captivity in New York to a savannah in Africa. Once there, they rediscover their roots, but pine for the friendly confines of the zoo. It may not be the edgiest animation out there, but pundits say Madagascar is bright and cheerful, with a good deal of energy and some smart laughs. At 68 percent on the Tomatometer, Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa may be worth a trip.

“They call me the Hiphopapotamus, my lyrics are bottomless…..”

The script of Soul Men may be coarse and shopworn, but critics say it’s an ok sendoff for the great comic Bernie Mac, who passed away earlier this year. The film stars Mac and Samuel L. Jackson as a pair of R&B backup singers who reluctantly agree to perform at a tribute concert for a soul legend despite mutual acrimony; their cross-country journey to the show is filled with wacky hostility. The critics say Soul Men isn’t particularly original, borrowing from a number of road-buddy flicks, and the jokes are pretty blue. Still, they also note it’s a worthy final performance for Bernie Mac, an actor who stole many scenes in supporting roles and is in fine form as a lead here (and the late soul great Isaac Hayes also turns in a sharp supporting performance). At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, Soul Men hits some decent notes.

One of these men is in no hurry to take it to the bridge, to the consternation of the other.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Captain Abu Raed, a tale of a janitor in Jordan who inspires a goup of children who believe he’s a pilot, is at 100 percent.

  • A revival of Francois Truffaut‘s classic The Wild Child, based on the true story of a boy who survived alone in the wild, is at 100 percent.

  • Pray the Devil Back to Hell, a documentary about a group of Liberian women’s political activism in the midst of civil war, is at 100 percent.

  • JCVD, starring Jean-Claude Van Damme as a version of himself fighting to escape a hostage situation in a bank, is at 85 percent (check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down the Muscles from Brussels’ best-reviewed films).

  • The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, a Holocaust drama about the son of a Nazi officer who forms a friendship with a boy in a concentration camp, is at 71 percent.

  • The World Unseen, a drama about two South African women who form a tight bond during the Apartheid era, is at 29 percent.

  • Repo! The Genetic Opera, a futuristic musical about a biotech company that harvests human organs, is at 25 percent.

Finally, props to indiefilmfan2, Mary R., and rockclimbr6 for coming the closest to guessing The Haunting Of Molly Hartley‘s three percent Tomatometer.

Best-Reviewed Bernie Mac Movies:

Tag Cloud

halloween tv critic resources Heroines sports foreign Tokyo Olympics GIFs SDCC Quiz halloween A24 Holidays 1990s boxing Song of Ice and Fire BET historical drama Mary Poppins Returns best History joker politics Country justice league 24 frames TCM YouTube Premium Oscar rotten zombie comiccon spanish Showtime Television Critics Association australia 72 Emmy Awards Reality Competition mockumentary The Purge Binge Guide Mary Tyler Moore Fargo Awards Tour Tumblr Columbia Pictures Focus Features YouTube 73rd Emmy Awards tv talk Biopics festivals X-Men slashers American Society of Cinematographers green book indie Dark Horse Comics Rocky Netflix Winners HFPA olympics films documentary comics serial killer travel Musicals DC streaming service animated james bond Marathons talk show rt labs critics edition VICE New York Comic Con Mudbound gangster Drama Comic Book USA franchise Captain marvel Thanksgiving Polls and Games Tomatazos crime directors sitcom Disney+ Disney Plus crossover Paramount Pictures dramedy television wonder woman Best Picture Travel Channel Hear Us Out Amazon Prime scary movies jurassic park 79th Golden Globes Awards Music YouTube Red Television Academy Stephen King A&E comic aliens Nominations Amazon Prime Video FXX criterion Comic-Con@Home 2021 romantic comedy Emmys Endgame vs. based on movie Prime Video zero dark thirty women trophy Kids & Family blockbusters Superheroes rom-coms WGN latino cancelled TV shows sopranos action-comedy harry potter DirecTV live action Trivia christmas movies Nat Geo war popular strong female leads hispanic heritage month BBC Pacific Islander Watching Series Lifetime Super Bowl Creative Arts Emmys Pop TV nbcuniversal South by Southwest Film Festival posters new zealand GLAAD crime drama mutant french 45 Cartoon Network cancelled TV series Sony Pictures Comedy Central ABC Family Starz Instagram Live 4/20 Oscars Universal comedies Rom-Com TCA what to watch Disney Tubi anime cancelled television laika elevated horror Best Actor Shudder mcc MSNBC SundanceTV NYCC 93rd Oscars fresh FOX deadpool Best and Worst 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Nickelodeon facebook SXSW 2022 all-time Holiday obi wan RT21 Trailer AMC Plus Cannes The CW science fiction sequels composers black Writers Guild of America remakes feel good Esquire VH1 movies pirates of the caribbean Epix Podcast The Academy YA 2016 cinemax Superheroe Christmas blockbuster Tarantino Lucasfilm binge Image Comics jamie lee curtis medical drama japan monster movies PBS reboot Baby Yoda WarnerMedia Anna Paquin versus adventure ITV Film Festival Best Director Paramount Plus TIFF streamig ghosts ID Winter TV finale docuseries scorecard Hulu TCA Winter 2020 BAFTA child's play disaster godzilla GoT Netflix Christmas movies Photos NBA ESPN TV One Cosplay Hollywood Foreign Press Association casting kaiju superman rt archives HBO PaleyFest black comedy king arthur unscripted CW Seed Apple Reality 2020 docudrama Rock concert CNN Exclusive Video RT History robots The Witch Western Legendary Adult Swim superhero MGM dc discovery award winner Disney Plus live event Toys TruTV Marvel Television football streaming Walt Disney Pictures police drama screen actors guild book boxoffice Musical Crackle Apple TV Plus 007 IFC teaser Academy Awards Freeform prank DC Comics SXSW miniseries toy story hist Valentine's Day blaxploitation Fox Searchlight anthology documentaries Extras canceled universal monsters ratings dark stoner Pop dragons 2015 international Black History Month 2017 spider-verse free movies news Bravo TCA Awards twilight sequel crime thriller CBS All Access Ellie Kemper Chernobyl Turner trailers Turner Classic Movies Vudu ViacomCBS stop motion BBC America Marvel VOD Premiere Dates Sundance Now ABC IMDb TV Logo TBS spinoff debate 20th Century Fox summer TV aapi Martial Arts video Countdown 90s social media game show Paramount Character Guide worst movies witnail spider-man marvel comics biography children's TV Pixar romance batman Mary poppins Election Horror dexter political drama Spring TV a nightmare on elm street HBO Go Year in Review Syfy zombies Schedule BET Awards The Arrangement Women's History Month National Geographic Family Peacock cults Summer Box Office kids First Reviews TCA 2017 First Look ABC Signature theme song space transformers screenings Emmy Nominations game of thrones golden globe awards Disney Channel art house San Diego Comic-Con OneApp sag awards Hallmark Christmas movies The Walking Dead golden globes Set visit Star Trek true crime Black Mirror Alien archives indiana jones Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt nfl natural history TV thriller book adaptation Video Games genre breaking bad Red Carpet hollywood Crunchyroll mission: impossible USA Network BBC One FX on Hulu Teen diversity Calendar streaming movies Animation cartoon summer preview scene in color LGBTQ Shondaland Pirates chucky leaderboard dceu Tags: Comedy Disney streaming service canceled TV shows Sundance supernatural Spectrum Originals LGBT singing competition Britbox E! quibi E3 Amazon Studios worst mob cats vampires royal family legend rt labs dreamworks Wes Anderson revenge APB Avengers Arrowverse dogs Fall TV TLC Discovery Channel fast and furious independent Brie Larson adaptation festival doctor who comic book movies Rocketman Comics on TV lord of the rings Fox News HBO Max cancelled FX Lifetime Christmas movies Broadway Neflix psycho Masterpiece DGA 94th Oscars high school 21st Century Fox Grammys psychological thriller El Rey spanish language TV movies Amazon Interview Sci-Fi Hallmark OWN new york asian-american PlayStation movie emmy awards See It Skip It technology rotten movies we love telelvision Sneak Peek parents adenture Acorn TV Pride Month IFC Films period drama Mystery Universal Pictures Infographic hispanic south america Ovation Funimation name the review 71st Emmy Awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina king kong Mindy Kaling saw video on demand critics Ghostbusters Certified Fresh young adult spy thriller Film AMC hidden camera Elton John cooking DC Universe venice TNT know your critic suspense japanese summer TV preview renewed TV shows 2021 President richard e. Grant stand-up comedy Star Wars biopic NBC Best Actress obituary Lionsgate Paramount Network nature comic books classics heist movie Opinion TV Land 99% Classic Film werewolf MTV Apple TV+ series die hard Food Network razzies kong Action cars slasher CBS 2018 TV renewals Warner Bros. MCU new star wars movies marvel cinematic universe Comedy scary basketball comic book movie Fantasy Trophy Talk The Walt Disney Company Awards cops reviews Marvel Studios italian toronto Spike Sundance TV CMT 2019 spain target satire Pet Sematary